8 ms·
I guess if you don’t have prowler or package theft problems, they aren’t really necessary. I personally have found my Nest cameras indispensable. Ironically, if
by seanmcdirmid 4y ago
I guess if you don’t have prowler or package theft problems, they aren’t really necessary. I personally have found my Nest cameras indispensable. Ironically, if police would just do their job on property crime, they wouldn’t be so needed.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ensignavenger 4y agoThere are alternative cameras that don't have the same privacy concerns.
- lijogdfljk 4y agoYup. I absolutely love my cameras. I wouldn't have set them up without a home server to isolate them, though.
- archon810 4y agoThe problem with those is they're easily stolen during a home invasion.
- RNAlfons 4y agoCan you recommend some?
- sebazzz 4y agoEufy, which records locally. Doesn't have as much "AI" though.
- archon810 4y agoI have several Eufy cams and while their hardware is excellent, the software leaves much to be desired. My biggest gripe right now is when you get a notification and tap it on Android, you get such a cut down UI, it doesn't even have a scrubber and you can't fast forward or rewind. Just a completely barebones player you can't control. Once you exit that and go to the camera history, you get a normal player with controls. Makes no sense to me whatsoever.
- wheelie_boy 4y agoThe logitech circle view ones are pretty good Anything the integrates with homekit secure video will be e2e encrypted
- KevinGlass 4y agoUniFi cameras are amazing. Superb video quality (better then so called "professional" cameras from the regular security companies), easy to setup (but still an order of magnitude more work then a Ring), self hostable, and from my experience highly reliable.
- zrail 4y agoAgreed. I have a UniFi Protect setup and almost all of the equipment is top notch. I don't appreciate the lock-in inherent in the system (Protect NVR only works with Protect cameras, cameras only work with their NVR, and you can't self-host the NVR on your own hardware), but I'll gladly take it in trade for excellent spousal-approval-factor. The one exception I've found so far is that the UNVR-4 system software in older models is stored on a very cheap USB flash drive, and I believe they write logs to it too. Mine failed a few months before warranty expired so I just replaced it with an SSD and SATA->USB 3 adapter I had laying around. Works great, is snappy, and should hopefully last quite a bit longer.
- KevinGlass 4y agoFor what it's worth you can use RSTP streams from the cameras in most open source NVRs but you can only enabled it from the UniFi NVR thus requiring UniFi NVR hardware to begin with.
- zrail 4y agoThe streams don't come from the cameras in that scenario either, they get proxied by the NVR.
- horsawlarway 4y agoSynology has some fairly strong products in this space. A fairly cheap NAS from them for local storage, and then basically any ip camera you can find will mostly just work. (NAS I'm using: https://www.amazon.com/Synology-Bay-DiskStation-DS220-Diskless/dp/B087ZCBWFH/ref=sr_1_2?crid=3CJFK9DH67GS2&keywords=ds220%2B&qid=1657731166&s=electronics&smid=ATVPDKIKX0DER&sprefix=ds220%2B%2Celectronics%2C100&sr=1-2 https://www.amazon.com/Synology-Bay-DiskStation-DS220-Diskle...) They offer surveillance station (https://www.synology.com/en-us/surveillance https://www.synology.com/en-us/surveillance) as a free app for most of their models. My entire setup (3 cameras, NAS, hdds, POE switch) cost me under $1000, and I get pretty much every feature that most of these cloud camera services offer. - Remote viewing on my phone (https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.synology.DScam&hl=en_US&gl=US https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.synology.D...) - Activity alerts and optional triggers for recording - Viewing through any browser - Multiple user accounts Plus if I want it, Surveillance station has a whole host of other features that I currently don't need, but are nice to have (ex: automated cloud backups, offsite storage, CMS, Action rules, etc) As a nice little bonus - I pay zero in monthly costs for this outside of the power to run the cameras & NAS My initial setup cost ran slightly higher than something like Nest or Google Home (ex: I paid 1k vs the roughly 400 it would have cost to buy the cameras from a cloud service) but 4 years in I'm now in the positive on the investment, since I don't have a recurring 14/month subscription charge. So long story short - It's still my data, it's costing me less over time, and I get feature parity. The downside is it requires a little more configuration and setup.
- RNAlfons 4y agoI actually own a Synology NAS. Weird. Never cared about the app but is sounds really nice. Thank you. I'll check it out.
- CalRobert 4y agoReolink have cameras which keep the video local, but support RTSP and can upload video to an FTP server (old school, I know) of your choice. I run my own FTP server and keep the video streams in DigitalOcean spaces with a 24 hours object expiration policy, fairly cheap NVR.
- archon810 4y agoReolink can work with Synology, I believe.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoNest has the best experience as far as I can tell. The person recognition works fairly well, so I’m not getting alerts for every rabbit or blown tree branch that wanders into view.
- archon810 4y agoNest is also my favorite. I just wish they didn't completely abandon the main Nest app and didn't force the inferior and convoluted Google Home app as the mandatory app necessary for the latest gen cameras. Such a squandered opportunity.
- giraffe_lady 4y agowhat is a prowler. how does a camera prevent package theft? you get information about who took it but it doesn't prevent them from taking it, or get it back. deterrence only?
- dylan604 4y agofrom your comment, it doesn't sound like anyone was deterred.
- giraffe_lady 4y agoyeah my personal view is that these cameras do nothing except widen police surveillance capacity but I'm somewhat interested in what the people who buy them think they are doing.
- corrral 4y agoI expect people who buy them haven't personally witnessed what it looks like to report property crime—even fairly major property crime—to the police. Which is to say, they don't realize that there's almost no chance they'll do anything about it at all except issue a report for insurance (if you want one, and probably for a fee just to add insult to injury) even if you come to them with all kinds of evidence, up to and including clear video of faces and license plates. They probably imagine it going very differently from how it actually goes.
- dylan604 4y agoMy personal experience from a home invasion where the individual caused a not insignificant amount of damage to the home resulted in nothing more than the police merely filing in a form and handing me a receipt. My personal experience from coming home to a burgled also ended with the same situation. The police came, waited from crime lab to take prints, prints were not recoverable, no follow up. This was even after several attempts at providing the assigned detective detailed information from the bank on how the criminal's attempted to use a stolen checkbook to withdraw money from a bank account. The detective later explained that he's too busy to look at information provided via email.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoWhere the hell do you all live where this is a common problem? Out of all of my friend and relatives, 100s of people, none of them have ever complained about vandalism/theft.
- giraffe_lady 4y agoI live in a big city and package theft is fairly common here, happens to me a few times a year. The shipping company always replaces though, this has never cost me anything and so there's not much pressure on me to contribute to the police surveillance apparatus over it.
- BitwiseFool 4y agoI was in a similar situation until a rash of thefts began happening around my apartment complex a little over 10 months ago. Something changed, whether some porch pirates moved in to the complex, or some crime ring decided to start exploiting our area. The police and apartment management had no answer, and it turns out their security cameras are absolutely useless.
- thewebcount 4y agoYeah a similar thing happened at a rental property we own. Someone in the neighborhood learned the code to get into the building and started stealing packages. Changing the code would help for a few days and then it would happen again. I haven't heard about the issue in a few months, so it seems like they've fixed whatever the problem was. My guess is someone was watching people input the code and then using it later to get in. Another owner recently moved out, so maybe they were the weak link? Who knows.
- xeromal 4y agoProbably any large metropolis.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoI have friends in NYC, Boston, Houston, Dallas, and Seattle and they have never mentioned package theft or vandalism. Maybe I'm wrong in assuming that since they don't mention it that it must not be a problem for them.
- rdtwo 4y agoWhat’s the point? Even if you have a great video of a dude stealing your packages nobody will arrest or do anything about it.
- adastra22 4y agoI used to have things stolen off my porch frequently. After installing a Ring camera, that ended immediately and never happened again. It did seem to work as a deterrent.
- parkingrift 4y agoYou don’t have to pick a dystopian spyware camera to deter porch theft. This attitude is why we can’t have nice things.
- adastra22 4y agoWhat is the issue with a porch camera looking out into a low traffic public space like my own personal driveway? I seriously don't understand the complaint here, and I say this as someone who has a Faraday pouch for my phone and a policy of no AI "assistants" WITHIN the house.
- parkingrift 4y agoThere isn’t any issue with a camera. The issue is that you lazily picked the spyware camera from Amazon.
- adastra22 4y ago…and? I’m paying them for a service if handling recording and integration with the app, etc. What is the problem here?
- deltree7 4y agoI will have my own definition of dystopia and not rely on some privileged HNers definition. Thank you very much
- tomcam 4y ago> Ironically, if police would just do their job on property crime, they wouldn’t be so needed. A girl can dream, can’t she
- smegger001 4y ago>Ironically, if police would just do their job on property crime, they wouldn’t be so needed. if the last several years have taught us anything its that police only do there jobs when they feel like it. whether that processing rape kits, stopping gunmen, stopping property theft, doesn't matter that wont do it.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoWhen police are incredibly understaffed, they don’t do their job because they don’t have many to do it. Granted, everyone is understaffed these days, so it’s not just a police problem, and prosecutor/judges in my county make things harder for them by auto releasing the property-crime offenders they do catch (doesn’t matter if they have 10 warrants for times they didn’t return to court after being released from previous arrests). It’s not just the police’s fault that they are ineffective, the politicians (that appoint judges and prosecutors) and the people that vote for the politicians take a lot of the blame also. And even after that it’s just a bad time for labor and crime.
- justin66 4y ago> incredibly understaffed That's adorable.
- KennyBlanken 4y agoYeah, our court system is vastly underfunded...police generally aren't, though some departments are having enormous difficulty finding qualified people who want to work for them. Ironically and sadly, it becoming such a hated profession means we really don't want the people who are willing to do it. It's a grave they dug themselves, though.
- smegger001 4y agoThese problems predate the pandemic and fallowing recession, trying to blame it on the immediate labor shortage is unreasonable. And since when has being weak on crime every gotten a judge of prosecutor elected in this country? Politicians go out of their way as a mater of course to look tough on crime to the point that it a problem of its own. no offense intended, (maybe you have some inside knowledge and perspective that I don't) but this seems to be a little disingenuous to say the least.