10 ms·
Decompiler Explorer
- ykl 4y agoLove the joke in the URL. :) (For anyone that doesn't get it; it's a play on Godbolt)
- jraph 4y agoWhat is really funny about this is that Godbolt is the last name of the Compiler Explorer's author. But it seems like it is a brand, a word now. Being able to swap two letters from a name and get something nice like this is lucky. Godbolt is quite a name.
- psifertex 4y agoThanks! We debated it some internally and I'm glad it won out, I think it's worth it. Plus, it has a nice logo that goes with it.
- jiggawatts 4y agoHugged to death...
- meibo 4y agoI feel like the decompiler space is a little stuck? I mostly go with Hex-Rays out of habit and because I'm used to IDA, but I haven't really seen x64 decompiler output noticeably improve in recent releases. A lot of my colleagues use Ghidra a lot now and complain about its decompiler regularly. Is there any new approach in the works? Maybe something ML-based for optimization? Would be sad if Hex-Rays output is "as good as it's gonna get".
- develatio 4y agoI hear good things about Binary Ninja!
- ishitatsuyuki 4y agoRellic [1] implements an algorithm that generates goto-free control flows (citation in README), which would be a significant improvement against what Ghidra/IDA generates currently. Unfortunately it looks like the maintenance state of the pieces around Rellic isn't very good, and it's quite rocket science to get it building. It doesn't have as much UI/GUI as Ghidra either so it's a bit far from accessible right now. [1]: https://github.com/lifting-bits/rellic https://github.com/lifting-bits/rellic
- dataflow 4y ago> that generates goto-free control flows ...note: from LLVM bitcode.
- zozbot234 4y ago> Rellic [1] implements an algorithm that generates goto-free control flows Doesn't WebAssembly implement that already, via Relooper?
- FrozenVoid 4y agoWhat happens with code that uses lots of gotos(incl. computed gotos)?
- smcl 4y agoIncredible name
- spaintech 4y agoHa! that was funny, I wonder though, getting fed tons of code, couldn’t Godbolt leverage code—-> Compiler Obj —-> Assembly as a mean to train an AI decompiler ? Food for thought.
- tralarpa 4y agoI think it would be easier and faster to just take the millions of open source projects on github for that :)
- unsafecast 4y ago...which don't have binaries. It's easier for Godbolt, since the whole purpose of the website is to compile and show output. If you crawl GitHub you need to compile the projects yourself, much more difficult.
- yjftsjthsd-h 4y agoSome projects do publish binaries with releases.
- ComputerGuru 4y agoBinaries are freely available from package management repos, with the benefit of having a known toolchain you can tag your ML inputs with. All the package managers I've worked with have a strongly structured "upstream" or "repo" field or similar that you can use to get to the source.
- unsafecast 4y agoFair enough!
- planede 4y agoJust take all of Debian packages, or something like that.
- sargun 4y ago
- unnouinceput 4y agoHN crowd decompiled the website
- psifertex 4y agoYeah, sorry about that. We're working on getting it up again but no promises. I'm on vacation in Europe while the rest of the team is about to head to sleep so might be a bit before we have it more stable.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- thesz 4y agoMaximal size of executable is 2MB. So, it is not possible to torture it with the ghc-compiled Haskell program.
- mikewarot 4y agoLong, long ago a friend lost the source to a CP/M program, and wrote ReSource to help re-create the 8080 assembler source from the executable. I ported it as Com2Asm, back in the MS-DOS days... I wonder how good things are now. How long should I give this thing to run? My upload was 250k.
- psifertex 4y agoSorry for the outages, friends. We're actively working on getting it able to handle higher load but we knew that if we hit HN we'd be swamped no matter what we did. We're spinning up more workers and fixing obvious perf issues as we see them, but if it's not available when you try it make sure to check back later!
- T3RMINATED 4y ago
- athrowaway3z 4y agoI really appreciate these kinds of websites. But i wonder if we eventually go full circle and it becomes easier and cheaper to send a wasm linux kernel with virtual disk access over websockets instead of processing stuff server side.
- rfoo 4y agoIDA Pro and Binary Ninja listed here is proprietary and require expensive licenses to run.
- psifertex 4y agoAnd both companies behind those licenses (hi, I'm one of them!) donated licenses to support this. That said, you're right. It's unlikely we'd ship our entire binaries plus code to live in-browser though the amount wasm stuff people are doing lately is fascinating.
- kangalioo 4y agoHilarious name and fascinating concept haha I like it
- no_time 4y agoIDA license sponsored by "Yiang Ling Personal License"? EDIT: Site has changed in multiple ways in the last 30minutes I've been trying to submit my sample. Best of luck in keeping up with demand.
- saagarjha 4y agoApparently legitimate: https://twitter.com/psifertex/status/1546745992925642759 https://twitter.com/psifertex/status/1546745992925642759
- psifertex 4y agoNope, Ilfak gave us a license for it and as Binary Ninja devs we're using a legitimate licensed copy of Binary Ninja as well. All above board and we're hoping to add more commercial decompilers in the future as well as we can integrate them and the companies behind them are willing. RE: Demand. We just got 2x the workers but as the easy coast wakes up I'm not confident it'll hold up too well, several of the decompilers are... VERY resource intensive so there's really no good way without an exorbitant amount of compute to scale to heavy demand. Eventually a better queue system with better pre-processing to filter invalid things is on our todo list
- rfoo 4y agoUnrelated, but it's amazing that over the years I have seen all of misspells of "Jiang Ying" and the "ang ing" part is always right. :P
- WiSaGaN 4y agoSome nice symmetry there: Decompiler Explorer: dogbolt.org Compiler Explorer: godbolt.org
- lpcvoid 4y agoDoesn't this violate (at least) the Hex-Rays license? Fun project, but how is this legal?
- cinntaile 4y agoThat probably means they received permission ;)
- psifertex 4y agoNope, not when you ask them and they provide the license. This is being run with the permission of all the commercial products. In fact, we (Binary Ninja) and Hex-Rays (once I figure out the exact mechanism with Ilfak) are the ones actually paying hosting costs! It's both good for the community and hopefully shows off the value in commercial decompilers. :-)
- 1wd 4y agoAre there any decompilers for old x86 DOS com files?
- MattKimber 4y agoThe commercial versions of IDA still do COM and MZ executables as far as I'm aware, although it's been dropped from the free versions since 5. (Which is still available from ScummVM's reverse engineering page, but is only a disassembler and doesn't come with the decompiler) Ghidra does a vaguely OK job with MZ executables, providing they've been unpacked first. It really struggles to represent DOS function calls properly, you'll find arguments go missing from the decompiled code. There are some third-party plugins which improve things a bit. And it doesn't have signatures for any of the libraries so the output will just be a lot of `if ((var26 & 0xFEEE) && var42 > 0xE0) { ... }` and it's up to you to work out when one of the variables is actually a pointer to video memory or whatever. Reko can also decompile this era of code, it does have a tendency to crash on any more complex program but will be fine for simple files. Similar problem that the decompiled pseudo-C code doesn't really illuminate what's going on any more than just reading the disassembled x86 assembly language and walking through any tricky sections in the DOSBox debugger does. Without all of the Win32 API calls modern programs make there's a lot more work needed to figure out what's going on. Personally I find I also end up needing to use a vintage tool like Sourcer alongside the modern ones, because the newer stuff doesn't annotate things which were common in the era like directly referencing the BIOS data area or reading the interrupt table from memory rather than using the DOS calls for it. It's that or spending a lot of your reverse-engineering time discovering how things were done in the DOS days.
- 1wd 4y agoThanks. I had tried Reko and your description matches my impression. I hoped to try hunt down the DOS Tetris easter egg described on the original authors website. https://vadim.oversigma.com/Tetris.htm https://vadim.oversigma.com/Tetris.htm The executable is linked in the image. I managed to decipher some functions (video memory pointers were actually kind of helpful) but didn't get far.
- mobilio 4y ago
- mwcampbell 4y agoCan any of these decompilers make effective use of a Microsoft PDB file, if I have one, to include original symbols in the decompiled output? What I'd really like to do with a decompiler is feed it a final compiled EXE or DLL of my own code and see what it looks like after it's been run through whole-program optimization. In that case, of course, I have a PDB file.
- enragedcacti 4y agoGhidra is able to: https://github.com/NationalSecurityAgency/ghidra/blob/master/Ghidra/Features/PDB/src/global/docs/README_PDB.html https://github.com/NationalSecurityAgency/ghidra/blob/master...
- ok123456 4y agoIDA does.
- psifertex 4y agoBinary Ninja can as well (sorry for the delay, been on vacation this week) though none of the tools will download and use PDBs that might be available via public servers or otherwise by default in the configuration we're using on dogbolt. It would potentially be possible but our goal isn't to provide a test of all tools in all possible configurations as much as it is to get a good overview. Once you start tweaking each tool differently you're better off running that sort of analysis locally.
- chazeon 4y agoA few years ago have tried Hex-Rays/IDA, and it gives me reasonable information in terms of program control flow, and help me with doing hot reverse-engineering without source code. A few years later, Hex-Rays/IDA seems to still be the one to give the most useful information out there, even for hello-world examples. I remember one of the project came up on my GitHub homepage, but never tried it. Probably this is the only space where I don't feel left out without having to constant following the update, comparing it to JS space, etc..
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Terry_Roll 4y agoBinaryNinja: Error decompiling: Traceback (most recent call last): File "decompile_bn.py", line 66, in <module> main() File "decompile_bn.py", line 13, in main t = tempfile.NamedTemporaryFile() File "/usr/local/lib/python3.8/tempfile.py", line 531, in NamedTemporaryFile prefix, suffix, dir, output_type = _sanitize_params(prefix, suffix, dir) File "/usr/local/lib/python3.8/tempfile.py", line 117, in _sanitize_params dir = gettempdir() File "/usr/local/lib/python3.8/tempfile.py", line 286, in gettempdir tempdir = _get_default_tempdir() File "/usr/local/lib/python3.8/tempfile.py", line 218, in _get_default_tempdir raise FileNotFoundError(_errno.ENOENT, FileNotFoundError: [Errno 2] No usable temporary directory found in ['/tmp', '/var/tmp', '/usr/tmp', '/home/decompiler_user'] Hex-Rays: Error decompiling: /tmp/tmpanbyzjw9/tmpqx8sjhpv: is not decompilable angr and Ghidra still waiting at 150seconds and counting.... 320seconds and counting.... Boomerang: Error decompiling: Traceback (most recent call last): File "decompile_boomerang.py", line 57, in <module> main() File "decompile_boomerang.py", line 14, in main with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as tempdir: File "/usr/local/lib/python3.8/tempfile.py", line 780, in __init__ self.name = mkdtemp(suffix, prefix, dir) File "/usr/local/lib/python3.8/tempfile.py", line 347, in mkdtemp prefix, suffix, dir, output_type = _sanitize_params(prefix, suffix, dir) File "/usr/local/lib/python3.8/tempfile.py", line 117, in _sanitize_params dir = gettempdir() File "/usr/local/lib/python3.8/tempfile.py", line 286, in gettempdir tempdir = _get_default_tempdir() File "/usr/local/lib/python3.8/tempfile.py", line 218, in _get_default_tempdir raise FileNotFoundError(_errno.ENOENT, FileNotFoundError: [Errno 2] No usable temporary directory found in ['/tmp', '/var/tmp', '/usr/tmp', '/home/decompiler_user'] RecStudio: Error decompiling: Traceback (most recent call last): File "decompile_recstudio.py", line 59, in <module> main() File "decompile_recstudio.py", line 14, in main with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as tempdir: File "/usr/local/lib/python3.8/tempfile.py", line 780, in __init__ self.name = mkdtemp(suffix, prefix, dir) File "/usr/local/lib/python3.8/tempfile.py", line 347, in mkdtemp prefix, suffix, dir, output_type = _sanitize_params(prefix, suffix, dir) File "/usr/local/lib/python3.8/tempfile.py", line 117, in _sanitize_params dir = gettempdir() File "/usr/local/lib/python3.8/tempfile.py", line 286, in gettempdir tempdir = _get_default_tempdir() File "/usr/local/lib/python3.8/tempfile.py", line 218, in _get_default_tempdir raise FileNotFoundError(_errno.ENOENT, FileNotFoundError: [Errno 2] No usable temporary directory found in ['/tmp', '/var/tmp', '/usr/tmp', '/home/decompiler_user'] Reko: Error decompiling: Traceback (most recent call last): File "decompile_recstudio.py", line 59, in <module> main() File "decompile_recstudio.py", line 14, in main with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as tempdir: File "/usr/local/lib/python3.8/tempfile.py", line 780, in __init__ self.name = mkdtemp(suffix, prefix, dir) File "/usr/local/lib/python3.8/tempfile.py", line 347, in mkdtemp prefix, suffix, dir, output_type = _sanitize_params(prefix, suffix, dir) File "/usr/local/lib/python3.8/tempfile.py", line 117, in _sanitize_params dir = gettempdir() File "/usr/local/lib/python3.8/tempfile.py", line 286, in gettempdir tempdir = _get_default_tempdir() File "/usr/local/lib/python3.8/tempfile.py", line 218, in _get_default_tempdir raise FileNotFoundError(_errno.ENOENT, FileNotFoundError: [Errno 2] No usable temporary directory found in ['/tmp', '/var/tmp', '/usr/tmp', '/home/decompiler_user'] RetDec and Snowman are the only ones that work on a sample app supplied. If I get time, I'll upload another app to test it, which will introduces a new technique. I know for a fact Ghidra should work because I've used it myself.