7 ms·
FTC committed to enforcing law against illegal use, sharing of sensitive data
- mtgx 4y ago
- legalcorrection 4y agoI think the focus is misplaced. I’d much rather people have my health and location data than my browsing history, which reveals so much more about you.
- lelandfe 4y agoYou’re not the demo. This is pursuant to Biden's executive order providing a floor to abortion restrictions[0][1], and specifically the lack of HIPPA guidelines on period tracking apps. I.e you may not want your history shared, but someone’s period app data may result in a felony (or worse[2]) in the future [0] https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2022/07/08/fact-sheet-president-biden-to-sign-executive-order-protecting-access-to-reproductive-health-care-services/ https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases... [1] https://news.bloomberglaw.com/tech-and-telecom-law/biden-summons-ftc-action-in-bid-to-guard-abortion-data-privacy https://news.bloomberglaw.com/tech-and-telecom-law/biden-sum... [2] https://www.texastribune.org/2021/03/09/texas-legislature-abortion-criminalize-death-penalty/ https://www.texastribune.org/2021/03/09/texas-legislature-ab...
- legalcorrection 4y ago
- loeg 4y agoIt’s HIPAA.
- kornhole 4y agoThe data brokers have both and more for most people. It is easier (not easy) to keep browsing history private. It is much more difficult to make mobile phones not leak your location. You need to run a custom OS, stay in airplane mode or use no SIM, and install only certain apps to accomplish this. Since few people know how to do this, regulatory enforcement on location data is more important.
- jjulius 4y ago>... which reveals so much about you. I would caution you not to speak in absolutes here, and consider that life has a lot of nuance. There are a fair many people who are in pretty darn good health, and only need the occasional checkup. That person's location data and browsing history is far, far more enlightening into who they are than their medical history.
- shadowofneptune 4y agoYour health data can be used to produce ransomware attacks against the clinics, hospitals, etc. you go to. It's much more valuable data because people will pay more for it when stolen.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 4y agoThis is actually bad for online privacy in the long term. The reason is because this is tying online privacy to mainly one side of the abortion debate, and to one political party. There is a greater than 50% chance that Republicans win control of Congress in 2022. I would say that there is likewise a 50% chance they win the Presidency in 2024 (especially if they run someone other than Trump). If online privacy is nothing but just yet another point of contention in the culture wars, what chance do you think this will have of standing?
- woodruffw 4y ago"Doing something good is bad because it'll cause someone intent on doing bad to do bad faster" is not ideal logic.
- devindotcom 4y agoI suppose you feel this way about net neutrality as well, since it was established and then reverted as a partisan issue, also part of the so-called "culture wars"? Don't forget, they make everything part of the culture war so people will vote based on their "culture." Right now people who want to get abortions are a group of major concern in the privacy debate. Others also need these protections, but people getting abortions and abortion-adjacent care are in immediate, real danger and their privacy is suddenly much more important than a few weeks or months ago. The FTC is expressing that it intends to protect the privacy expectations of all Americans in mind, regardless of state rules limiting certain medical procedures, medications, or even sexual orientations. The current data economy provides numerous opportunities to get around those expectations and protections. That's something that should change - though it will need legislation, probably, not just an agency rolling up its sleeves.
- jahewson 4y agoRoe vs Wade was based on the notion of a constitutional right to privacy. So it is very much tied to privacy! There is currently real doubt that what were assumed to be constitutional privacy protections (far beyond abortion) will hold going forward and so the executive is keen to demonstrate and exercise its existing powers in regulating affairs which previously would have been assumed to be protected by such a right.
- octokatt 4y agoI'm hoping this gets established, and then expands so data brokers can't sell data sets with labels like "anxious" or "likely depressed". Right now, corporations are intentionally or unintentionally behaviorally conditioning people. Given behavioral shaping is a medical practice and is largely being performed without consent, it needs to stop.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoIf Congress cared about privacy they would have enacted relevant laws decades ago. They sure were quick to protect their own video rental records when those were weaponized. The data broker industry is relied upon by the government to sidestep 4A and Congress has been complicit in not regulating them. Because of the attention, there will be some hollow gestures to further protect health data outside the current reach of HIPAA and nothing more. I'll just add that the brokers don't need app data to get information about menstrual cycles. I sat in a meeting at a long established data broker in the late 90's (pre-Google) where they gushed about their ability to track cycles from purchase records. A lot of detailed personal information can be gleaned with data analysis from seemingly innocuous sources and, without broad data protection laws, none of us are immune to this invasiveness.
- vasco 4y agoMaybe these superhuman marketers with perfect understanding of human behavior exist, but since I've never met one it's hard for me to picture. What does it matter when the cycles are? Is it to try and sell pain medication for the low percentage of women that suffer during it? Whenever these stories are told you'd think someone is achieving world domination, but my suspicion is that the large majority of companies can't even do anything very interesting with this data that they collect unethically.
- krageon 4y agoThe harm is real, even if you try to ridicule it. None of your refutation is founded on the reality of the harm (or what was claimed, AFAICT). This is called a strawman.
- motohagiography 4y agoTook them long enough. Though I'd wonder what changed. I don't see why they're worried about location data that much, as phone location is not accurate enough to say an individual was somewhere at a specific time or to show their route in a city within a few feet, or at least that data probably doesn't meet the legal standard of being evidence of a crime, or of being an accessory or co-conspirator to one, so it seems pretty low risk from a privacy perspective.
- woodruffw 4y ago> Though I'd wonder what changed. They make it explicit in the statement: > Now let’s consider a particularly sensitive subset at the intersection of location and health: information related to personal reproductive matters – for example, products that track women’s periods, monitor their fertility, oversee their contraceptive use, or even target women considering abortion.
- chefandy 4y ago> I don't see why they're worried about location data that much, as phone location is not accurate enough to say an individual was somewhere at a specific time or to show their route in a city within a few feet, or at least that data probably doesn't meet the legal standard of being evidence of a crime, or of being an accessory or co-conspirator to one, so it seems pretty low risk from a privacy perspective. Eh? My phone can pinpoint its location to a part of a room in my 800 square foot flat. And the government uses phone location data for tactical and investigative stuff all the time— the Muslim Pro example most immediately comes to mind. Even seemingly innocuous data in the hands of correlating/mining data brokers would give them insights into your live that would make most people shudder.
- autoexec 4y ago> I don't see why they're worried about location data that much, as phone location is not accurate enough to say an individual was somewhere at a specific time or to show their route in a city within a few feet, Cell phones can provide precise GPS coordinates and cell phone tower data alone can give a person's location to within a mile while things like bluetooth beacons and wifi network info can give accurate data to within several meters. One of the major concerns with 5G is that because of the need for a much more extensive network of towers cell phone companies will have everyone's location data with precision measured in feet. As for not meeting the legal standard for evidence of a crime, it's already being used to identify suspects. It may not enough evidence on its own to convict someone, but it is enough to get you questioned/investigated/arrested. See: https://techcrunch.com/2021/08/19/google-geofence-warrants/ https://techcrunch.com/2021/08/19/google-geofence-warrants/ https://www.wired.com/story/capitol-riot-google-geofence-warrant/ https://www.wired.com/story/capitol-riot-google-geofence-war... I'd put the level of risk pretty high.
- upsidesinclude 4y agoThe one group, generally, that has been driven away from privacy via scare tactics of the surveillance state has finally been given the required incentive to recognize the grave importance of privacy. This is no longer a political issue or an issue of only people that 'have something to hide'. Public support for privacy will be the majority opinion regardless of political ambitions. Good news! Now we can accomplish what people with sense have known for the last few decades
- ls15 4y agoLet's hope so. Privacy needs to be acknowledged as a basic human right.
- charcircuit 4y agoNo, privacy runs counter to a world with free information. If privacy was an actual right we would need to destroy most history books because we never got those people's permission to reshare information about them. News reporters would have to get permission from people and companies they are writing reports about.
- smolder 4y agoYou're being downvoted, I think, because this entirely ignores the extent to which modern dragnet surveillance snoops on and categorizes every last person. We have history books that tell a lot about important public figures (and society generally) without data brokers or Palantir being a thing for any part of that history.
- charcircuit 4y ago>We have history books that tell a lot about important public figures That's because the process doesn't scale. With technology we can scale this to a large percentage of the population of Earth. Imagine being curious about someone and just being able to look up what they did in life.
- 4y ago
- Andaith 4y agoEven among congresspeople? I thought there's been quite a few instances where congresspeople have had access to sensitive data and tweeted about it?
- colechristensen 4y agoYawn. I'm done caring about what government figures and departments say they stand for, commit to doing, or promise is coming soon. It's proved fairly meaningless. Come back to me and show what you've done or just don't say anything. I think people need to become much more hostile towards "saying" and insist on "doing" or nothing.
- nerdponx 4y agoEven if they start "doing", US law is so lenient that even if they actually start enforcing it, most privacy violations will remain in place simply because they aren't illegal. The US legislative branch is the true source of regulatory capture. Executive agencies are secondary. I don't think the founding fathers anticipated, or could have anticipated, the entire legislature becoming an organized cabal.
- pilingual 4y agoA women’s health app recently tried to capitalize on the Roe decision by claiming they keep data private. I read through their privacy policy, and sure enough they allow themselves several liberties including using data for “research.” Amusingly, I caught “[INSERT COMPANY]” in their privacy policy. Apparently they haven’t even read their own policy! It was quite long —there should be an Internet law that the longer the privacy policy, the more likely your data is being abused.
- InCityDreams 4y agoName the app, and company?
- sbierwagen 4y agoMy interpretation of that sentence was that it was the string literal “[INSERT COMPANY]”. A company name placeholder that hadn't been replaced.
- hackernewds 4y ago?
- Dobbs 4y agoI think the person you are replying to is trying to say something more along the lines of "name the company so we can shame them, and avoid them", not "what is '[INSERT COMPANY]' actually.
- guerrilla 4y agoYeah we got that but we need to know who the company is anyway.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tepitoperrito 4y agoIt's more fun to Google "INSERT HERE" intitle:privacy policy Then you'd know they're talking about stuff like this https://www.salvationcoffeecompany.com/pages/privacy-policy https://www.salvationcoffeecompany.com/pages/privacy-policy
- zackees 4y ago
- csnover 4y agoEnforcing laws against illegal use of sensitive data sounds cool, except that only the most incompetent ones will ever meet that bar federally. HIPAA’s privacy protections are so weak that companies can just shove things like this in their EULA[0] and they are good to go: > Any information in the FollowMyHealth Universal Health Record is considered PHR Data. PHR Data might include, but is not limited to the following: > Your name and contact information, such as your address, phone number, or email address > Your medical history, conditions, treatments, and medications > Your healthcare claims, health plan account numbers, bills, and insurance information > Demographic information, such as your age, birthdate, gender, ethnicity, and occupation > […] > Allscripts may use your PHR Data for marketing and advertising purposes, including sending you customized marketing and advertising communications whether on our behalf or on behalf of third party partners with whom we may engage. As a postscript, if you are curious how some Allscripts subsidiaries used PHR Data for marketing purposes in the past, the answer is to get doctors to push opioids[1]. [0] https://www.followmyhealth.com/UseDocuments/PrivacyPolicy https://www.followmyhealth.com/UseDocuments/PrivacyPolicy [1] https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/electronic-health-records-vendor-pay-145-million-resolve-criminal-and-civil-investigations-0 https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/electronic-health-records-ven...
- bigbacaloa 4y agoThe whole idea of EULA needs to be scrapped. As currently configured they will never be fair to consumers. They institutionalize unethical, bad faith agreements.
- hackernewds 4y agoThats one side of the argument. However they are necessary for companies to function, and have some protections from fraudsters, con artists, hackers, litigious opportunitists, etc now you may argue that there are not freq enough instances of these frauds to require EULAs. anticipate that the counterargument could be that they aren't BECAUSE of the presence of EULAs
- jstanley 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- boffinAudio 4y agoUntil the OS vendors wake up and start addressing the elephant in the room - that our operating systems are no longer servicing our needs as users, but serving up our data as consumers - there is no point in any of this political theater. It is because OS vendors decided to use their technology to gain access to our eyeballs that we are in this mess. OS vendors deciding not to make encryption a first-tier service provided to their end users, with a user interface abstraction that enlightens and educates instead of obfuscates and minimizes. OS vendors deciding to hide filesystems and shared data from us, because making a UI that makes them usable is hard, and prefer instead to replace it with broken cloud services. It is because OS vendors are selling ads and eyeballs, not operating systems - which are secondary to the purpose of creating a consumer database.
- sneak 4y agoThe concept of "illegal use" does not, of course, apply to things like ICE/DHS buying access to this data without a warrant to conduct fishing expeditions. https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/hamedaleaziz/ice-dhs-cell-phone-data-tracking-geolocation https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/hamedaleaziz/ice-dhs-ce...
- Shadonototra 4y agowhenever an old man is tracking and watching every steps of your little daughter, it's a weird dude it should be the same for anyone who wants to track you online, including, and specially, companies
- josephd79 4y agoWere they not before?
- kornhole 4y agoBan the collection in the first place unless company can prove it is necessary and will completely delete it after not needed for that purpose. Once location data is collected, it will and does leak. I fear this effort by the FTC will have too many loopholes and exceptions to be meaningful and only provide a false sense of security.
- analog31 4y agoIndeed, make possession of the data illegal, and create a statutory civil penalty per violation.
- thr0wawayf00 4y agoI called State Farm yesterday to file a claim and an automated message prompted me that if I was a California resident, I could press 1 and opt out of having my personal data sold. Seeing as how I'm not a California resident, it felt like a subtle little "f** you" since I couldn't even opt out but I still heard the option.
- joveian 4y agoOnline you can benefit if your IP address geolocates to California. I'm not in California nor is the particular server I use as a web proxy but because the company is based in California the whole address range usually geolocates there (plus I send "do not track") and I've seen sites that apply the California rules because of that without asking.