6 ms·
> The company developed a ‘kill switch’ that would remotely encrypt its computers and devices if an office was raided by authorities, used at least two dozen ti
by Havoc 4y ago
> The company developed a ‘kill switch’ that would remotely encrypt its computers and devices if an office was raided by authorities, used at least two dozen times
How are they not drowning in gigantic obstruction of justice lawsuits and regulatory demands?
- aliqot 4y agoalso encrypting takes time, unless they meant FDE with a reboot button.
- worewood 4y agoThat's probably what they meant.
- rejectfinite 4y agoThe initial yes. Once encrypted you can trigger remote via intune/sccm/MDM https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/security/information-protection/bitlocker/bitlocker-overview https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/security/informatio...
- rob_c 4y agoObstruction is difficult to prove, costly to prosecute and they can afford the fine. Unfortunately when dealing with international groups financials come into the equation regarding prosecution as they could hold this in the courts in years and spend 10x the fine in lobbying for a change in obstruction laws. I agree there guilty and are behaving in a borderline devil way but given they're playing with the big boys in the valley who actually has any control over them?
- procrastinate1 4y agoIsn't obstruction of justice a criminal offence in US? Fines are not that scary, federal prison is.
- rob_c 4y agoif so, who do you think gets that, the mug that pulled the trigger will likely take the fall rather than CEO unless you've paper writing that he issued the instruction (which isn't likely to exist, even at twitter)
- djbusby 4y agoMost with the power to reign this in barely understand the tech in place; and if they do just "lobby" till they see it your way.
- devoutsalsa 4y agoWhatever you can't buy with money, you can buy with more money.
- oblio 4y agoThere is a corollary, or a parallel, if you will. If violence is not a solution, you're not using enough.
- mschuster91 4y agoA "kill switch" that engages upon unauthorized access to an office or a server rack should be standard operating procedure of any company that deals with sensitive data. Make it as hard as possible for actors like burglars or "inside actors" like cleaning staff to exfiltrate data.
- TehCorwiz 4y agoBut very easy to get in and shit them down by triggering it.
- londons_explore 4y agoFor most companies, the data is more important than the service uptime. Think about it... Would you prefer your Gmail to be down for a few hours, or for Moscow/Beijing to get a copy of all your sent/received emails cos they dumped them from Google's servers in the country?
- JKCalhoun 4y agoI think they're suggesting a scenario where your Gmail is regularly down.
- capableweb 4y ago> A "kill switch" that engages upon unauthorized access to an office or a server rack Wouldn't a raid by police (at least if they have a warrant) be "authorized access" because they are law enforcement? At the very least, they could trigger the kill switch when the raid first happens, but once it has been verified it is the police, the kill switch should be disengaged so they have full access.
- prvit 4y ago>the kill switch should be disengaged so they have full access. Only when you’re legally obligated to do so, which is probably often not the case.
- hotpotamus 4y agoWe've got a government so small that some startup bros can now drown it in a bathtub?
- izacus 4y agoBecause this "kill switch" might as well be something your iPhone has. You can lock it remotely at a moments notice as well and it'll remain encrypted against law enforcement attempts to unlock it. Should you be held accountable for owning such a device? MDM managed Windows, macOS laptops are such devices as well. See how easy is it to reframe a feature in a nefarious way?
- malka 4y agoyou should be, if using it when being raided by the police.
- willnonya 4y agoNot necessarily. The police don't automatically have access to everything when they kick down a door. The warrant needs to state explicitly what they're after. If the data specified by the warrant is suddenly and intentionally encrypted then they still have to provide that data or argue the obstruction angle in front of a judge. Just because a company is incorporated doesn't mean they lose all rights.
- capableweb 4y agoIs it even possible that the police has a warrant against a company like Uber that doesn't include data found in the very office they are raiding? If it's not stated that they are raiding the office to grab data, what could the raid even be for?
- s1artibartfast 4y agoYes, warrants are often specific. You can comply with a warrant with encrypted data
- capableweb 4y agoSo warrant say "Uber should hand over data about transfers in/out from the companies bank account" and Uber can then hand them over a password protected CSV and say "You didn't ask for data you could read" and the police should just be like "Hah, you got us! We'll come back with another one!"?
- themitigating 4y agoIs this illegal? Maybe if they destroyed evidence that would be. It's like if I told you "I use Veracrypt" what for? Am I bring investigated?
- onion2k 4y agoI wonder how many devs quit over being asked to build that. I suspect the answer is very close to zero...
- vintermann 4y agoWhere do you think the leak came from then? The executives? What hope there is about this sort of thing comes from the fact that they can't quite yet do to us as a profession what they do to taxi drivers.
- falcolas 4y agoThe leak came from a disillusioned lobbiest, not the engineers.
- aeyes 4y agoYou can remotely lock any MDM managed device, this was possible 10 years ago and you need zero development. iCloud lock even brought this to the consumer space. It is clear that non-tech people wrote this. Any company device I used in the last 10 years was always encrypted and could be remotely locked to not boot. Additionally most bigger companies will have "security" software like Crowdstrike on all devices which is basically a backdoor.
- amelius 4y agoAnd does anyone still trust the Uber app anymore?
- andrepd 4y agoBecause the justice and law enforcement systems serve mostly to protect the interests of propertied class. I'm only being half-hyperbolical.
- rejectfinite 4y agoBitlocker is standard in corperate enviroments. Trigger it and Windows PC is encrypted.
- throwaway787544 4y agoJobs. Tech. Donations/lobbying. Lots of reasons for politicians to hide their tails. Law enforcement & judiciary do what politicians say.
- alar44 4y agoBecause thought crimes aren't illegal yet? Jfc.
- eunos 4y agoUhh I don't really understand with the apathy towards the kill switch. Kill switch is there the same reason why your phone locked when you click the power button.