8 ms·
Air France announces end to research monkey transport
- yread 4y agoWill they also forbid their employees using latest cancer drugs? Without animal models they will be less safe.
- bsdz 4y agoActually it's probably the opposite. Using animal models can lead to drugs that are not safe or effective for humans and it can lead to drugs being rejected that might have been safe or effective. 92% of drugs which prove promising in animal trials fail in human clinical trials.
- david38 4y agoYou’re right. We should jump to human trials directly.
- tokinonagare 4y agoIt's what have been done recently, even enforced by governments in some cases.
- rootsudo 4y agoIn a way, why not - I agree animal testing is good, vs direct to human testing but I'm also surprised there isn't human testing arbitrage where medicine is created in a geographic region that allows it vs more in the west. I can see how quickly it ran run off to prison labor and more human testing atrocities circa 1940's world.
- bsdz 4y agoI didn't say that. There are a many alternatives to animal models before "jumping to human trials directly", e.g. testing on human cells & tissues, human-based computer models (like those used for cardiotoxicity) and more recently organ-on-a-chip technologies.
- Thorrez 4y agoWhy aren't the researchers already using those? If those work better than monkeys I would think researchers would already be using them.
- bsdz 4y agoMany are using these alternatives. For example, a computer model for cardiotoxicity has higher accuracy than animal models. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28955244/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28955244/ It's an educational process. A lot of folk just go along with the status quo and feel there's no alternative to animal research.
- oaktrout 4y agoI briefly scanned the paper. This is not a computer model for cardiotoxicity as a whole, it's a model for one very specific type of cardiotoxicity. These things may have their uses, bit they are a long way from replacing animal testing. This model checks for one side effect in one organ system. Animal testing can check all organ systems for thousands of side effects.
- WastingMyTime89 4y agoPeople don’t test on animals because it’s the status quo. They do so because computer models comprehensive and good enough don’t exist. Even from a purely cynical point of view, animal testing is bloody expensive. As soon as pharma companies will be able to get ride of them they will.
- jonlucc 4y agoShort answer: we are. Clinical trials are expensive. NHP (Non-human primate) studies are also expensive, but orders of magnitude less expensive than human studies. We pharma researchers don't want to put stuff into humans if there's risk of failure, especially if that failure is a tox finding and not just low efficacy. So we de-risk as much as possible. We go so far as to prove everything on human cells, then buy mice with humanized portions of their genome to test the target in mice that are more like humans in the way we need them to be. Then we test in NHPs, because it's very unsafe to assume that a drug that works and is safe in cells is safe in primates. In a current project, I'm dealing with the fallout of this exact problem. We did a ton of testing, modeling, in vitro work, rodent work, then we dosed in monkeys and it caused a massive tox signal. We have to go back to the drawing board and explain what happened to the monkeys, how we're going to address it, maybe kill the whole program, and find a new path forward. It passed all of the rigorous pre-monkey testing. And I'm at a major pharma company, where we have pretty specialized teams doing most of this work. edited to correct an error
- pvaldes 4y agoSo the message is: If you have a relative suffering cancer... don't use Air France?
- julienfr112 4y agoOr maybe use Air France, as it was the last major airline to do so, as stated in the very first line of the article. So it did so for longer than Delta, LuftHansa, British, ANA, ...
- goldenkey 4y agoI think the message is: "Your suffering isn't worth more than mine." - Monkey or Rat in a lab somewhere Tzu Don't quote me though, I'm just a brainlet.
- boopmaster 4y agoExactly correct. Nobody can have any differing ideals of morality than that. Those ideals are the |abs| correct values and exact center of the universe, and anything divergent must be castigated. There is no gray area. There is no pragmatism.
- bayindirh 4y agoMaybe this move would accelerate the computational biology a little further, no? BTW, I really welcome putting brakes on whole this animal testing stuff. I'm not really comfortable that it's still going on.
- Scandiravian 4y agoI have a background in drug development and computational models Computational models are decades, at the very least, away from being a replacement for animal models There is no replacement for animal models, except trials in humans, so if the alternative is that we do more, riskier trials on humans, then I'd much prefer animal testing
- mlyle 4y ago> There is no replacement for animal models, except trials in humans, so if the alternative is that we do more, riskier trials on humans, then I'd much prefer animal testing Totally true, but, at the same time--- Computational models have prevented all kinds of unnecessary animal testing of things that can be shown computationally to be unlikely to work. So, computational models avoid us doing more, riskier trials on animals. Of course, we've not reduced animal testing-- instead we've just pursued more compounds and ideas. I'd argue it's worth it for speeding up the pace of medicine. But these things are not completely orthogonal.
- R0b0t1 4y agoThere is the chance the computational model is wrong.
- iasay 4y agoThe animal and human trials don't always go well either. You only hear about the human trials that go wrong.
- mlyle 4y agoYes, and there is the chance the animal model doesn’t represent human responses well, too. We still use both to weed out treatments, for both ethical and cost reasons. Better to errantly eliminate a working drug occasionally than to let a lot of unhelpful stuff through.
- goldenkey 4y agoThat's right, the chance of saving a human life is not equal to horrid abuse of other lives, in all but the most twisted utilitarianist, sapien-centric models. Animal testing is a moral quandary. Rats, even if they weren't intelligent (which they are), don't deserve the tortures we put them through. Gender identity and sentient AI equality have become fenceposts for our populist cross-dressing Musk-rat technocratic movement - but somehow, for many among us, animal rights still doesn't fit in... The ends do not justify the means. Feminism and equality means giving a voice to those who cannot be heard - women, minorities, LGBTQ, and yes, primates and other animals. You must follow your precepts to their logical conclusions. Otherwise, you are not for true equality, and instead are for convenient equality, shackled to time and place, not forward thinking.
- cphoover 4y agoSo you volunteer to replace the monkeys in experimental drug research?
- goldenkey 4y agoNo, I'd prefer to remain free. But at least you are asking for consent - that's a start in the right direction! Consent - something which the monkeys have not given. Something which their world-splitting cries of agony, anguish, and tortured existence, clearly indicate. It appears their disposition to being used as biological pin cushions is quite oppositional, one could say their entire life is dedicated to saying "No." Imagine a life dedicated to saying "No." Your mind is disoriented, deteriorating. The world is spinning, and your insides are churning, throbbing, and burning with the pain of a thousand suns. Your skin is peeling, your muscles ache, your bones dull with a hollow pain, and your body feels like it isn't even yours. Implants and incisions, scars and scabs, your body riddled with pockmarks. It sounds laborious and awful, more than nightmarish. Would you volunteer for it?
- peoplefromibiza 4y ago> . But at least you are asking for consent trials are not about who's willing to partecipate, but about the best model available. monkeys are not asked for consent, true, but they're not picked at random either, because it would be useless. There's also another matter: who's gonna consent to participate to trials in your proposal, rich people or poorer people? An finally, how would you ask for consent to monkeys? Do you ask mosquitos to leave before killing them? edit: what really baffles me about this discussions is how much the mood of the population swings. We have seen literally revolts on the streets against COVID vaccines being a way to force untested drugs onto the people but at the same time people complain that there is too much testing on non people
- goethes_kind 4y agoPersonally, I find it morally questionable every time one of these activist groups puts non-human life above human life, whether it is a dog or a monkey, I don't care. Just feels wrong. I guess I would not want to be neighbours with some weirdo who would value my life equally to that of a monkey.
- andyjohnson0 4y agoCare to expand on why you feel this way about different species? > some weirdo who would value my life equally to that of a monkey Do you feel this over-values the monkey's life or devalues yours? Or is it something else?
- timeon 4y ago> puts non-human life above human life Well my pet has EU passport unlike my friend from Macedonia.
- maxbond 4y agoThis is a bad faith reading of what these activists want. It amounts to a strawman. If you were their neighbor - you probably wouldn't know it. Why should we be systematically cruel to animals? Why shouldn't we develop technology that replaces these techniques? Has it not even occurred to you that we don't necessarily have to have a giant industry of animal testing, that that is a local minima we don't have to accept? Does that not seem morally questionable to you?
- colordrops 4y agoNot sure why you are getting downvoted - the GP is definitely putting forth a heavy strawman. Wanting to stop animal cruelty does not equate to believing that animal lives should be put above human lives. There are more than the two options of killing monkeys for testing or killing humans for testing.
- maxbond 4y agoDownvotes come fast and upvotes come slow. I wasn't surprised to see it hit zero immediately after I clicked submit, or to see it climb back up to 1.
- xkbarkar 4y agoC19 vaccine development caused the extreme shortage according to the article. Always a little terrifying that we dont have any good alternatives that animal testing. I do beleive that animals used for medical testing ( at least in the west ) are treated a whole lot better than the poor unfortunates we breed for food. And I dont see anyone declaring the end of transporting those.
- rdl 4y agoPresumably there will be transport of monkeys for reasons other than "research" to establish populations within Europe/US, then use of monkeys from those populations (shipped overland) for testing. Adds delay, and creates physical facilities vulnerable to activist attack, but possibly better for monkeys. Would be great if animal testing could continue to be minimized, but I'd like to continue having the benefits of safe and effective drugs. For somewhat irrational reasons I only really am personally bothered by testing on cats; dogs, monkeys, etc. don't particularly bother me, but I recognize this is irrational.
- Symbiote 4y agoAnimal testing is expensive, especially with primates, so it's already minimised.
- junofan 4y agoThe priciest part I believe is the people taking care of the monkeys. I’d wager it’s easier to send them in unmarked crates.
- tsol 4y agoThat, or its tested on humans instead. Neither seem like they'd actually be more ethical in the end.
- joecool1029 4y agoThis should help slow the spread of monkeypox.
- geoduck14 4y agoThere are a bunch of people here who are passionate about not having animal testing. There is a different thread on HN with people who are passionate about not releasing chemicals until they are proven safe for human consumption. Can we get Dang to merge these two threads and have a mosh-pit of passion and see what comes out?
- iasay 4y agoIf it's anything like the in-person discussions I've seen on the matter it's not productive. I'm firmly polarised on one side and was happy to sit in the sidelines and not say anything on the matter in case I also got punched :(
- phphphphp 4y agoI’m not sure of your point. The answer is pretty simple: test on humans. If we aren’t willing to test on ourselves, why should we be willing to test on other beings? There’s no contradiction.
- vczf 4y agoWhich humans? Is it more ethical to test treatments with potential long-term health complications on research monkeys or... poor people?
- melony 4y agoOP and their family of course, since OP clearly believes animal lives are as valuable, if not more, than humans'.
- FrenchDevRemote 4y agoWe are animals, we're not more valuable than animals, since we ARE THEM, we have always and will always be equally valuable to animals. There isn't one rational reason why a human should be worth more than any other animal. If OP and their family AGREE to, then yes, of course, it would be infinitely better than testing on unwilling sentient beings.
- htk 4y agoDid Air France decide this based on animal rights lobby or for economic reasons?
- lpolovets 4y agoA relevant aside: there are some companies and startups that aim to replace a good chunk of animal testing with in silico testing. Here's one that my fund is an investor in called VeriSIM: https://www.google.com/amp/s/venturebeat.com/2019/08/14/verisim-life-uses-ai-powered-biosimulations-to-replace-animal-drug-testing/amp/ https://www.google.com/amp/s/venturebeat.com/2019/08/14/veri...
- iancmceachern 4y agoAnd also some companies (not really a startup but a huge established company) working to replace human transplants with organs "donated" from pigs, on an industrial scale.
- marcosdumay 4y agoIf in silico was an alternatives, everybody would have switched already. And everybody will switch as soon as it becomes one. Everybody wants in silico models. If you are using that to argue that alternatives exist, you are unknowingly lying. They will probably exist some day, and everybody will use them without you having to ask.
- lpolovets 4y agoNot sure why you're accusing me of lying, I just said that there are companies working on this. I think the key thing here is that while eliminating 100% of animal testing is an ambitious -- and perhaps ultimately unreachable -- goal, data and computer simulations can make testing more effective. If you use data to prioritize animal tests, or in some cases conclusively predict if some test won't any have value (e.g. the dosing is toxically high or ineffectively low) then that is a win. Both in terms of reducing animal tests, and in terms of speeding up drug development and making it less costly.
- lofatdairy 4y agoVeriSIM seems to be targeting drug discovery, rather than drug testing. I don't think scientists regularly use animal models for drug discovery, if at all, because it's really not that efficient (animals aside, you'd have to synthesize a dose of everything you want to try, which is non-trivial). With drug discovery, what you need to do is just shotgun a bunch of molecules and test that they're even bioactive, let alone therapeutic (you don't even need to find all the bioactive molecules, just yield enough for further testing). For actual testing, there are also microfluidic systems and organ-on-a-chip systems that are a field of active research. I think most researchers are more confident in these systems than in-silico (even though organ-on-a-chip systems are a field of active research and have their own shortcomings) because biological systems are active on several different physiological scales, and simulating all of these is rather rough around the edges to say the least. C elegans and fruit fly simulations are still the target of research, and I think fruit flies aren't simulated accurately from the cellular level (though if anyone knows better let me know). Simulating anything more complicated is likely to require either enormous computational resources as well as actual discovery, since you'd need to first characterize everything before you can simulate it.
- siva7 4y agoLess biomedical research on monkeys means putting more humans at danger. An animal shouldn’t be put over a human!