8 ms·
One thing I'd really like to see more of is demand management - specifically ripple switches for eletric boilers 1) 1950s era technology, so well understood 2
by Havoc 4y ago
One thing I'd really like to see more of is demand management - specifically ripple switches for eletric boilers
1) 1950s era technology, so well understood
2) Comically cheap vs storage
3) Instant response
4) No/low inconvencience - well insulated boilers hold temp of 24hr+
It's such an easy win to shave the top off the evening peak & thus reduces need for battery storage.
- rr808 4y agoWith modern technology there are much more interesting things you can do, esp if you combine with battery storage and real time pricing. One of the main issues is that for residential pays a flat rate all the time. There is no incentive for people not to use electricity during those huge peaks which really drives generation costs. Ideally people would not cook/clean/heat water/charge anything during those hot summer afternoons or cold dark windless evenings. Your electric water heater is a good example of it could be saving costs by charging when its windy/sunny/low demand periods and even better lower water temperature so wont be so hot when prices are high. Smart EV charging is even more important, if you leave the car plugged in every night, but with logic so some hours it'll charge quickly and maybe some nights not at all.
- viraptor 4y ago> There is no incentive for people not to use electricity during those huge peaks Is that documented / true on a large scale? Anecdotally, I know a few people who turn on the clothes dryer, dishwasher, etc. at night or schedule the washing machine to start at 5am to run them on the lower tariff period. Maybe it's not very common though.
- rr808 4y agoEvery country and plan seems different. For everyone in my city we have a flat price all month.
- dismalpedigree 4y agoDepends on the utility/state. Some have different rates depending on time of day. Where I live does not. We pay a straight per kwh rate regardless of when used and how “spikey” our pattern is. The total per month is segregated into tiers, so the per kwh rate is incrementally higher as your total consumption climbs.
- landemva 4y agoThis is a good description of electric rate tariff which is becoming more prevalent in USA. It depends on what rate tariffs are approved by the regulator.
- avianlyric 4y agoYou’ve missed the previous sentence. > One of the main issues is that for residential pays a flat rate all the time. There is no incentive for people not to use electricity during those huge peaks I’ve you’ve got a lower rate at night, then you dont’t have flat rate tariff. Something very common in most of the world. Having a lower night rate means you obviously have an incentive, that’s the entire reason it’s offered.
- Scoundreller 4y agoOntario Canada found that residential Time of Use (TOU) billing only shifted demand by 3% at the beginning of rollout, diminishing to 1% shifting in subsequent years. And "little evidence of conservation". Figure ES1, Pg 8: https://www.brattle.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/7289_analysis_of_ontarios_full_scale_roll-out_of_tou_rates_-_final_study-3.pdf https://www.brattle.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/7289_anal... And "General service class [IE: commercial] customers show little evidence of load shifting behavior and are less responsive to the TOU prices than residential customers. However, general service class customers show some mixed evidence of conservation, although this is still marginal." But they don't like to publish this info much. Smart meters were controversial (from it's giving me headaches, to this costs a lot of money for ? benefit over regular metering). Electric utility pricing is regulated to be based on Return on Equity, so if they could increase their capital base through smart meter infra and cut the opex of meter readers, it economically benefits the utility, but not the consumer.
- Panzer04 4y agoDoes it matter? At least people are paying the right price for power, and it gives those who need it the ability to save money by shifting demand.
- Scoundreller 4y agoIf it costs more to precisely meter than the savings for 99% of individuals, it was a bad (forced) program to upgrade to smart meter infra - it's not free. Could have invested the money into demand reduction (free LED bulbs, insulation loans etc.) or supply improvements. Don't overspend on getting to 100% fairness. Same reason why if you ask for a meter audit, they'll do nothing if it's +/- 2%, even though anything other than 0.000000000000000000000000% error is unfair.
- jeffreygoesto 4y agoI don't expect zero energy costs to arrive at the consumers. Prices will artificially be inflated based on demand. The only way for consumers to profit will be to not play the game and go as much off grid as possible. But then you explicitly do not need smart meters.
- landemva 4y agoGoing off grid typically costs more and is often less reliable. It's not zero cost.
- zrail 4y agoMost residential plans in the US are either time of day rates or are a tiered flat rate.
- thaumasiotes 4y agoThere was an electricity provider in Texas that charged market rate plus a small markup. They were crucified when the freeze happened last year and they continued to charge market rate plus a small markup. They also went bankrupt.
- zrail 4y agoYeah, that's why I said "most". Texas is an especially weird case because of their almost total lack of regulation around pricing. From what I gather there were actually a number of power providers in Texas that charged cost plus. I don't know if any of them still exist but I'm sure there's demand for it because it's such a good deal most of the time.
- thaumasiotes 4y agoSo, there are two problems: 1. When the price of power went up, everyone spontaneously decided that charging the market rate for power was evil and the company deserved to be destroyed. 2. The company delivered a lot of power at high market rates because customers demanded it. But those customers then refused to pay (and in many cases weren't able to pay), which is why the company went bankrupt. It doesn't matter so much that there's demand if the government and the population all hate you and you can't collect the money you're theoretically owed.
- silvestrov 4y ago> residential pays a flat rate all the time Only true for some countries. Denmark has a mix of flat rate and hour-based variable rates. In my case prices are often 3 timers higher in "rush hours" (typically weekdays 5pm to 8pm, 17:00-20:00) than during a midday in a weekend with a lot of wind. I cannot choose flat-rate due to the situation in Ukraine. edit: This map is very good to see the price and source of electricity in Europe (and how well the countries are interconnected): https://app.electricitymap.org/zone/DK-DK1 https://app.electricitymap.org/zone/DK-DK1
- rr808 4y agoYes Denmark is a great example of high proportion of Wind power where it could make a big difference. I'm not sure what the hour-based variable rates are - do you know what the price is so you can change usage? Is power free or very cheap on windy days?
- silvestrov 4y agoOn windy days the price can go to zero, so you only pay the fixed tax. I can log into my provider at see the price for previous days and for tomorrow.
- rr808 4y agoTomorrow, that's cool. Its the whole point to be able to adjust your usage based on the market. I was thinking appliances can be smart enough to get the pricing to adjust usage, but if you can see tomorrow you can adjust your life yourself.
- silvestrov 4y agoTomorrow Wednesday we will have prices at zero some of the day: https://i.redd.it/cpmx4cvj56b91.png https://i.redd.it/cpmx4cvj56b91.png
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- michaelt 4y ago> One of the main issues is that for residential pays a flat rate all the time. One of the problems with real-time energy pricing is: poor people don’t have the cash on hand to replace their furnaces or upgrade their insulation- or worse yet rent and can’t improve energy efficiency at all. It’s difficult to raise prices enough to make it economically rational for middle class types to get batteries and heat pumps without reducing the poor to poverty.
- seltzered_ 4y agoYep, or worse the real-time energy pricing causes the highest prices during weather crises introducing ethical issues, such as during the 2021 Texas Winter Storm on customers using real-time energy pricing plans: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2021_Texas_power_crisis#Power_outages https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2021_Texas_power_crisis#Power_... Sometimes consumer smart grid gets evangelized as 'the fourth industrial revolution' - Dr. Simon Michaux argues the material blindness of it in such a way that only the rich may experience it : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O0pt3ioQuNc&t=625s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O0pt3ioQuNc&t=625s ( Dr. Simon Michaux: “Minerals and Materials Blindness” | The Great Simplification #19 with Nate Hagens ).
- Scoundreller 4y agoYou could just cap the max price and let the grid make it up during other times. That's basically what time of day billing does anyway: a blended approach to electricity rates that averages out but provides some incentive. Of course, my jurisdiction rolled out time-of-day billing and found that demand shifted only a few percent, so I wonder if the program even covered its costs for smaller users.
- mrexroad 4y agoAnd the funded programs which offer rebates for upgrades are a pain to navigate, even if you know they exist. Even if you overcome the awareness, procedures, etc. hurdles, the financial relief (rebate) is often too delayed to affect decision making when struggling financially.
- Ekaros 4y agoAlso depending on residential they might not care about price. Like I don't. I live in apartment. So best I can do is choose some activities. And even then I could save what couple dozen euros? Maximum of hundred? Just easier to not really have the mental load to think about it.
- Scoundreller 4y agoYeah, I lived in a rental apartment where they wanted to rebate the average electricity cost and run the metered electricity scam. But at a ~$40 rent reduction and a $13/month account fee, you'd have to reduce your electricity consumption to 33% below average just to break even. All so the installer/metering provider can buy a bigger yacht. Hard to do conserve much when the apartment operator provides your major appliances (typical in north america), no dishwasher, laundry is in a central laundry room, and HVAC+hot water are centrally provided. Would do a lot better if they just ran a program to replace all of our light bulbs/fixtures.
- Mvandenbergh 4y agoThe GB grid has half-hourly pricing for retail customers (with a cap and floor to prevent exposure to full wholesale risk i.e. not like those Gridly clowns in Texas).
- blablabla123 4y agoThat would be especially interesting for hours with negative energy prices (at least once they become accessible for retail customers). Also various appliances like washing machines or dish washers can be timed
- jamesvandyne 4y agoAt Octopus Energy, I think we’ve made negative prices available to retail customers (at least in the UK, not sure about the other countries we’re retailing in). People getting paid to charge their cars because the grid has a surplus of (probably green) energy.
- jonatron 4y agoThe most recent in the UK was 11 June, I can confirm I had a negative rate for a few hours then.
- pydry 4y agoEverybody I know with an electric car has this tarriff. One of them is trying to install a heat pump too to double down on this approach. It rarely gets discussed in the media for some reason.
- CJefferson 4y agoI just want to compliment Octopus Energy, I just tried popping over for a quote, and the website just says "No. You don't want to switch right now". Not sure if this is common with other energy suppliers, but it looks good (I'll remember for when/if I do end up switching next).
- thorin 4y agoThis is mandated by OFGEM in the UK now. uSwitch will also give you the current "best deal". I have done some work with the Octopus systems and they are very new an agile, but don't handle the complexity that the big 6 have put in place over several decades. The overall metering and settlements business in the UK is quite complex especially including legacy gas and elec accounts and meters.
- agumonkey 4y agoI don't have skin in the game but the electromechanical computers of the previous eras were all superb and solid yet digital electronics wiped the market away. Making a simple analogy (sic) I'd say the smart grid thing might be a glimpse of where society is going. Or it might be a marketing fad.
- lazide 4y agoMechanical computers were ‘superb and solid’? What are you talking about?
- agumonkey 4y agoEver seen the self aiming devices used in choppers during the war ?
- lazide 4y agoWhich war? There have been a few, like the Norden bomb site, but they were pretty far from anything we’d consider a general purpose computer. They also were not as accurate or reliable as was initially expected.
- maxhille 4y agoBerlin is building this in a somewhat bigger version https://www.energy-storage.news/vattenfall-starts-filling-up-200mw-thermal-storage-tower-in-berlin/ https://www.energy-storage.news/vattenfall-starts-filling-up...
- the_third_wave 4y agoUse sand [1] instead of water and you'll be able to store a lot more energy in a limited area. Water can't be heated above 98°C at atmospheric pressure which puts a limit on how much energy can be stored per m³ while sand can be heated above 1000°C without problems. Add enough insulation and you'll be able to store enough heat to warm your house through the long winter. Sand is cheap, non-corrosive and doesn't freeze or boil [2]. The specific heat for sand (830 J/g K) is markedly lower than that for water (4000 J/g K) but the density is ~50% higher. Together with the much higher temperature spectrum this translates to a higher capacity per m³. [1] https://polarnightenergy.fi/technology https://polarnightenergy.fi/technology [2] it can boil - silicon boils at 3265°C - but it is hard to see how such a temperature can be reached
- flaviut 4y agoResidential water heaters, at least in the USA, don't typically go above 60°C. So there's room to grow here, at least for now, without building a more exotic, and therefore expensive, system.
- tpm 4y agoAnd the reason they don't go much higher could be that at higher temps water hardness starts depositing water stone on the heating element and lining.
- goodpoint 4y agoThere's nothing exotic in a storage heater. They've been extremely common in UK for many decades. A resistor, some bricks and some insulation. If anything they are too rudimentary.
- wongarsu 4y ago> doesn't freeze In the sense that something that is frozen can't freeze. Apparently the melting point of sand is about 1700°C, so 1000°C sand indeed should handle about the same as 20°C sand or -100°C sand. That does sound rater neat for a large scale setup. In a small-scale setup the convection currents, easy handling and lower insulation requirements of a water setup would probably still win out.
- londons_explore 4y agoSmart demand management hasn't been rolled out because there are many different people involved who would all like to pocket the profits. Eg. a tesla plugged in at 6pm could shift it's charging time to earn quite a profit on the realtime-priced wholesale electricity markets. * Tesla et al (the company) would like to make that money - in the lifetime of a car, it could be tens of thousands of dollars. They propose to do it with 'virtual power plants' which can make/use power and trade on the power market. * The homeowner would like to make that money too. Through the use of manually setting timers to use power at cheaper times and having a peak/off-peak plan. * The electricity distributor would like to make that money - by mandating that devices like cars and water heaters be remotely controllable by them, so that they can buy less of the most expensive power generation. * Electricity generators would like to make that money too - by not doing any demand management, prices vary more widely, and they get big profits when they can spin up gas turbines to cover that peak demand. Technically, none of the above ideas are hard to implement - but each party blocks policies and rules that move in the direction of someone else making the money.
- schiffern 4y agoInsightful post. I've long suspected that the most viable path (only viable path?) is for Tesla to capture the profits and share a percentage with the equipment owner. Since the payoff to the homeowner happens "in front of the meter," it gets around the bureaucratic nightmare of fixing the perverse incentives in electricity pricing (eg the flat rate problem /u/rr808 mentions). All you need is one large aggregator to participate in the real-time wholesale market, issue commands to the "fleet," and divvy up the profits.
- maxerickson 4y agoTesla could make an open API at just let whoever capture the profits. Then owners could group together on their own terms to get market power.
- Forgeties79 4y agoI hate navigating utilities as it is, now I need to join/form a co-op just to use my car? I don’t know man. This sounds awful. Like an even worse HOA. Unless I’m misunderstanding your concept here.