7 ms·
I tend to avoid reading social news comments
- drewcoo 4y agoDamn it! I have to be half-serious. > People assume that any review or discussion must target them or their interests, preferences, requirements, or circumstances; therefore anything else is an affront. Great observation. So why? Why does that happen? That's the interesting thing, isn't it? Why do people assume it's all about them? Or react that way? Why are they so deeply entrenched in their beliefs? Because they are correct? All of them? That's where it gets interesting because it gets closer to a real definition of a problem instead of a set of symptoms.
- ratg13 4y ago“Everyone is necessarily the hero of his own life story. Hamlet could be told from Polonius's point of view and called The Tragedy of Polonius, Lord Chamberlain of Denmark.” -John Barth
- jackosdev 4y agoMy theory is they can't build anything worthwhile themselves, so they find something popular but with problems, which allows their ego to divert attention away from their own inadequacies.
- ratww 4y agoI wonder if there's a degree of FOMO there. People feel like they must participate in everything, so when there's something new that they didn't discover and research first, they compensate by doing some armchair criticism. If it were their had discovered it they'd say it's the coolest ever. It's funny, I thought this was an internet phenomena, but I've been seeing this all the time in meetups lately. Someone presents something that clearly works fine for their use case, and someone takes the mic to ask a question but eviscerates it instead. I also remember this with teenagers and music: the assholes always auto-dislike things others bring, and criticise the stupidest things, but if they rediscover it themselves it's the best band in the world. Myself, I prefer pretending I already know the stuff being presented. ;)
- mattlondon 4y agoI think this is a sort of non-humility thing. A humble person with humility would react with something like "oh cool! I had no idea this existed but I love it! Thanks for sharing this with me!" I have found myself on the other side of the coin many times. I have researched something, or invested a lot of time/energy/money in something and then someone who I assume (unconsciously or not) has not done these things and I instantly dismiss. E.g. if my mum turns up one day with a new phone and tries to tell me how great it is, there is no way (in my closed mind opinion) that she would have found something that I was not already aware of and using etc - what I picked and what I use is clearly superior for reasons X Y and Z and I will sub-conciously reassure myself that I am correct by pointing out why she is wrong. I guess it is a sort of pride/arrogance (and maybe even tribalism) thing - a sort of "you think you know something, but I know better than you, so I will explain to you how you are wrong as I know more than you about this. I am right and you are wrong, and I need to prove the point so you know that you are wrong" etc. Not just tech - people will do this about cars, sports, tools - anything. I try to stop myself being in this mindset as much as possible, and try to be more open to what others suggest.
- csydas 4y agoBecause it's normal for humans as I see it to be selfish, and we've built systems that force selfish desires to clash repeatedly. Selfishness has a bad reputation, but in fact it's how you end up not starving and broke in the street and able to keep a safe life. Pure altruism taken to a logical extreme would be dangerous, so there's always a balance of self-preservation based on your own wants and needs. When you go to any public forum, nothing is really different; you do the things you desire and that protect yourself, you talk about the things you're comfortable about, you can most effectively comment about your experience and how items relate to you. Where the problem with the above comes out is when this aspect gets out of alignment as well, as pure selfishness is just as disastrous. At a certain point to obtain your desires, you need _something_ from someone else, and likely that gets forgotten on social media that without the someone else, there is no social media. All other things in life require the contribution of human labor somewhere, even with more reliance on automation (someone's gotta maintain those machines and the code, even Star Trek still had an Engineering staff running around fixing replicators that made bad coffee/tea). By forgetting this, people feel entitled to having it exactly as they want, and why not? It's their leisure time, shouldn't it be exactly what they want to relax? I absolutely understand the author's point, but in a sense, they're doing the exact same thing, and trying to define a requirement for social media that not necessarily everyone subscribes to. I happen to think this requirement is a good one, but not the point I suppose. Once you allow public access, you have to accept also the bad, and maybe even revel in it a bit. And let's not forget how algorithms exacerbate this issue. Older "anything-goes" simple forums appeal to me mostly because you get exposure to things you normally wouldn't and there's no feed that gets polluted with bad data if you just check it out and there's no rewards system to push the content up; you just have some entries in your browser history. The users that do try to make the forums "their own" get the option to do so without having a feed/rewards system push this data heavily, and users have an easier time avoiding such content. There's a safety valve for their desire without some system forcing their desire on others. Feeds/rewards systems really muck up the situation because exploring a topic you aren't interested in or even dislike comes back to bite you in the ass because feeds aren't very good at getting when you're just checking something out versus when you're interested; any interaction is a change to induce further engagement so the feed tries. Rewards systems that promote content do much the same, but the system is powered by humans (and bots) instead.
- seydor 4y ago'why' matters only if it helps fixing it. People who attempt to fix the internet usually want to make it be more about them
- barrysteve 4y agoThe internet was built in the last 10yrs to hyper-personalize everything and silo everybody off into their recommendation zones. I don't see people doing anything other than what they were trained to do by the algorithms they surf. Of course people think the content they read has been sculpted to their taste or otherwise pushed deliberately in their face.
- ratww 4y agoI find this very noticeable here in HN. Every time something new pops up, some people are very quick to dismiss, criticise the author for making another "X", or to ask "why would I need this" without doing an iota of research. Well, maybe the post is not for everyone.
- drewcoo 4y agoOh, well let's put this on a social site, then. That'll show them!
- the_only_law 4y agoYou do realize the author and submitter are not necessarily the same person right?
- tylerchr 4y agoOf the news sources I frequent, HN is the only one where I bother with the comments. In fact, I often find myself reading the discussion here _before_ the article. It’s not perfect (we are people, in the end) but this community is refreshingly mature, insightful, and respectful. Thanks, all.
- mrjin 4y agoSimilar feeling, but I'm on the verge to quit HN too.
- d--b 4y ago> I have little motivation to separate the wheat from the proverbial chaff anymore. That’s what it comes down to, really. Comment quality distribution certainly follows a bell curve. Voting helps bubble up the best top-level comments. But if you start reading the sub-comments, you’re on your own. That’s not new, that is how it has been putting one’s voice out since the invention of speech… The pompeii grafiti were not particularly “front page material”.
- lapcat 4y ago> Voting helps bubble up the best top-level comments. Does it? Seems like early top-level comments take on a life of their own. Everyone wants to reply to the top top-level comment (possibly to maximize the chances of their own comment getting noticed, or possibly just because it's the first thing they see on the page). And the way HN is designed, with discussions expanded by default, you may have to scroll down quite ways on the page to even get to another top-level comment, much less multiple top-level comments. Crazy idea: how about presenting comments at each level in a random order on each page load, and get rid of voting? There could still be flagging to hide the worst comments.
- b3morales 4y agoI'm not sure of the exact details, but HN does have some feature whereby a new comment is displayed at the very top for a few minutes. I see this often when opening an active article. But there is definitely an early-mover advantage in terms of visibility.
- seydor 4y agoI don't know if there is a way to measure it, but there is a big increase in spitefulness in online conversation. I 'm not even sure it is driven by karma-hunters because it seems people care less about it, but there is a desire to publicly display antisocial behavior. Maybe because antisocial is more tolerated now? Bad faith is the driver. It's probably a majority of people now who respond in bad faith. They assume that everyone is talking in bad faith, probably to justify their own bad faith. Maybe it represents a broader shift in attitudes. That's also why humor and sarcasm are not tolerated, because people assume bad faith behind it. This was markedly different in the 90s and 00s where any joke was allowed and the intent was always assumed to be humor.
- xupybd 4y agoI think there might be a split in world views. There is a new emerging set of beliefs that are incompatible with some more traditional beliefs. When discussing them people tend to focus on the consequences of these beliefs and not the axioms. It also seems that people are not willing to agree to disagree online. Yet they're often happy to in offline relationships. I think this is a consequence of how superficial online interactions are. HN appears, to me, as one shining light in the darkness. Conversations here remain civil. I have just deleted my Twitter account for that very reason. If they had an army of Dangs they might be able to moderate to the degree that HN does. However I don't think Dangs scale.
- mnsc 4y agoMy take is that it's the scale of things that pits the entire world against itself in every issue. Because irregardless what belief you have, whatever your take is, chances are there exists an individual that is passionate about the exact opposite of your take. And the global interconnectedness has removed all barriers from instantly arguing, in some cases letting you setup keyword searches that notifies you when your "enemy" dares to speak up. Add to that the fact where there's lots of passion there's less of reason. Which will make you more inclined to argue in bad faith.
- dsign 4y ago
- agumonkey 4y agothe web2.0 era didn't bring a lot of good fruits.. the time wasted to makes transient comments on articles that will do nothing but annoy people around.
- addingnumbers 4y agoObligatory plug for shutup.css and the browser plug-ins derived from it: > shutup.css is a CSS stylesheet that can be applied to your web browser to hide comment sections on many popular websites. https://github.com/panicsteve/shutup-css https://github.com/panicsteve/shutup-css
- mrwnmonm 4y agoI was trying to go through all the research that has been done on how to understand the internet recently, and I found a jem. A book called No Sense of Place, it reads like Aristotle:) the way he was trying to correct the philosophers before him, but I still have a couple of chapters to finish. (btw, something very important in order to understand that book and others before it, is to give up on that fancy abstract idea that the internet is just "flow of information", this idea appeal to programmers for obvious reasons, and it is the most silly way to look at the internet) Alone Together is very good too, the way Turkle focuses on empathy is important I guess. That all is being said, but some people on the internet deserve to be attacked, or proven wrong let's say, if I am in a good day that I think it won't exhaust my soul, I will do it. "Maybe the web, BBSs, forums, mailing lists, and chat rooms were always like this." Life is like that, has always been and will continue to be like that, get used to it.
- CuriousSkeptic 4y agoYou might be interested in adding Wealth of Networks to your list. At this point of time it may perhaps be more of a misunderstanding of things but it is a fascinating take on how things could have been understood before social media took over. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Wealth_of_Networks https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Wealth_of_Networks (btw, thanks for the book tip)
- mrwnmonm 4y agoOh, thanks very much, any addition to this is precious for me. Hugs to you :)
- canadiantim 4y agoHow is the internet not just flow of information?
- mrwnmonm 4y agoBecause that view doesn't tell us anything.
- dieselgate 4y agoThanks for the article, author. Curious if the same goes for social media in general? Probably in vain to ask here because they’ll never see it heh. I agree HN is better than most. Have personally found technical forums (engine/vehicle/diesel etc) to be higher quality as well - but what are we comparing to here, youtube?
- nathias 4y agoSince the 90s internet has swallowed the world, and this changed it completely. The big platforms replaced the wild west of protocols, but this shift also changed content, from peer-to-peer to creator-consumer. This creator-consumer coupled with adds is how you get populations of people that feel so completely entitled: regular people are used to being the center of universal attention.
- kkfx 4y agoComments under news have few usages beside making click for ads: - tracing single individuals ideas, attitude for the future western-Chinese social score; - tracing how people react to the article as a driver for new articles - eliciting potentially emerging ideas who might be interesting for a new article or interested to block them, writing an article that appear in the same line but diverge to completely different results For us "readers" they are just useful to find extra infos by commenters who know something and decide to share, touch the climate a bit less than the media but still a view of a certain cohort of users ideas etc. That's is.
- contingencies 4y agoSolid piece of serious satire.
- mavhc 4y agoBut where else can you easily find racist climate change deniers who communicate in English worse than the people they're attacking?
- rockbruno 4y agoI think there was a study showing that humans will gladly engage in unethical / repulsing behavior if there were zero consequences in doing so, and it's why the internet is such an awful place. It's global unwritten rule of "talk shit, get hit" that keeps us in check and that doesn't exist in the anonymous internet.
- Markoff 4y agoit depends on the site, often comments provide more insight/context than the article itself in MSM
- mynameishere 4y agoWhich is to say, "Almost always". They can make whatever objections they want ("trolls!", "racists!", "climate-deniers!") but news sites and many of their readers don't like comments because they don't want randoms destroying a 4000 word article with a quick "Here is why you are wrong."
- 5350-uiop-1130 4y agoso much "news" now is clickbait or designed to infuriate, so don't expect much from those comments. what i dislike the sanitization of comments like youtube. top comments are some overly sugary kind of simping comment only. sort by new and you might see a contrarian view, before its deleted.
- mrjin 4y agoI feel the same in general. I was naive enough trying to convince them but it turned out in most of the cases I was wasting my time: they either deliberately took it wrong or simply could not comprehend it at all. In neither case there wouldn't be any point trying to discuss. So virtually I stopped reading or replying on most sites, HN is one of the few I haven't stopped yet, but I feel it won't last long too.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y ago> assume things about the author that are hilariously and transparently false I run into this, a lot. I'm 60, and don't hide the fact. I get "OK, Boomer"'d* all the time. It sucked, when it happened when I was still looking for work, but it's mostly amusing, these days. It appears that the very fact that I exist, is enough to drive some folks into a rage. It seems to piss them off, even more, when they find out that I'm actually fairly good at some of the stuff that younger folks are into. I had an interaction, some months ago (maybe more. My enfeebled mind has become palsied with eld, and I lose track), with a chap that just started slapping at me, out of the blue. When I suggested that it might be better to try making friends with me, rather than starting our relationship with an attack, he admitted that he is (and, I guess, many others, are) pretty upset at my generation for making a hash of the world. Can't really say I blame the sentiment, but, in my case, that's hilariously off the mark. I just suggest that prejudice/bigotry (which is what ageism is) tends to be fairly destructive, and seldom gives positive results. And, course, in some contexts, it’s actually illegal, but that doesn’t seem to deter many folks. I also get attacked because I'm an Apple developer. That's not new at all. I've been weathering that, since the 1990s. The ageism is a lot more recent. I suspect that may have something to do with my well-coiffed pompadour, taking on a rather fetching shade of gray. *At 60, I'm not really a "Boomer." I'm in that weird generation between "Boomer," and "X." We're the ones Dazed and Confused was about. My older siblings are "Boomers."
- brycewray 4y agoI believe the Boomer definition generally includes births from the stretch of 1946–1962 so, if you’re 60, you’re a (fellow) Boomer, but barely. I'm nearing 67, so can relate tremendously to everything you said.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoI’d have to find the article that talked about it, but I think the years were like ‘59-‘64, where we were too young to be drafted, and too old to be punks, and how it gave our generation a different “mindset” from the “traditional” boomers.
- barrysteve 4y agoI also avoid reading news comments 90% of the time, I'm usually too busy to spend time reading and writing comments. Lately I've lucked into some spare time, so I have been indulging a bit. It feels good to discuss global meanings that everybody shares on social media sites. For anything really worthwhile, personally relatable or you haven't completely thought-through, it is very difficult to convey cleanly without being crushed by the local hive-mind. Most conversations have to fit inside a generic framing device, which is set by the website you're on, once you clue into the rules of the game, a lot of interest in reading and writing comments can fall away unintentionally. The kinds of comments you get, are the same again and again.
- nicbou 4y agoIt varies from community to community. Reddit tends to be really critical - almost deliberately mean - even when the original author is part of the discussion. The culture there rewards dunking on other people. On the other hand, Facebook, Twitter and LinkedIn users have been more supportive when I share my work. Posting here actually feels good. I try to be a nicer commenter. Some time ago I read my post History and realised that I acted like an asshole online. Now I express my approval and gratitude more often, and I moderate my criticism. If I have nothing nice to say, I say nothing. I try to keep the same tone I would in meatspace. It's easy to forget that there are humans on the other end, especially when I'm in a bad mood myself.
- niceWokr8 4y agoSame. Most sites should shut comments off. People would share links with their actual friends and family rather than rant like children at anonymous strangers. This it, everyone. Take away all the words and your literal routine is it until the end. Human languages are 5,000 years old, while human intuition for quantity; enough food, heat, shelter, has evolved with us for millions of years. I find the human gibberish exhausting, and useless. Anyone else wants to pull out Marx they’re going in front of a bus. You all are going to wake up, do some utilitarian work, goto bed. Stfu, please.
- lapcat 4y agoA number of my blog posts over the years have hit #1 on HN. I've noticed that HN commenters are more likely to follow the "guidelines" with each other than with the article author. Too often, the author is treated uncharitably, with contempt and/or ridicule. I've spoken to dang personally about this at some length, but I wasn't really satisfied with his response, which was more or less a denial of the problem, or at least a refusal to do anything about it. Honestly, I've occasionally thought of blacklisting HN referrers from my web server, though I've never gone through with such a drastic measure. I've found that the best way to handle it is to take matters into my own hands, create an account here, and reply in the comments. I can clarify my points and shoot down uncharitable reactions. It's a shame that authors have to self-manage the responses though. Left to themselves, HN commenters often becomes vicious wolves. I would say that the HN guidelines are worthless if the same respect isn't given to the article authors.
- boxmonster 4y ago
- lapcat 4y agoThank you for so helpfully illustrating the phenomenon that everyone is discussing here.
- boxmonster 4y ago"If you can't stand the heat, stay out of the kitchen" - Harry S. Truman There is nothing wrong with my comment. I am of the opinion that you wasted dang's time, especially since recently we have all been praising him for his very hard work running this site, for which you seem entirely ungrateful for. Where did you get the idea that the world has to agree with your opinions?
- lapcat 4y agoThis is again a very uncharitable reading of my comment. I urge you to read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html again. To clarify: 1) There is a literally a "Contact" mailto: link at the bottom of this page, so I don't know why one has to be "self-important" to contact the moderator. 2) The phrase "at some length" was meant to imply something less than "at length". It was a serious conversation, but I don't recall it continuing particularly long. [EDIT: Searching my email archive, I found that the thread was only a few emails, so "at some length" may itself be a bit of an exaggeration.] 3) I appreciate that dang replied, but that doesn't mean we came to an agreement on the matter. Where did you get the idea that I had to agree with dang's opinions? In any case, I don't see how I "wasted" his time at all, when he voluntarily replied and talked with me about an ongoing HN issue. Dang is responsible for his own choices and for managing his own time.
- arroz 4y agoYouTube is full of propaganda comments (from Russia / China / right wing), it is toxic
- acjohnson55 4y agoI think there's not a great way for people to learn how to be pro-social on fear forums. The feedback signals and coaching that help people develop social skills IRL are much, much weaker online and reputation has much less value. Moreover, a lot of people are initially attracted to these forums due to lack of success in IRL contexts. And then there's often these parasocial assymetries between the authors, who have high reputation and visibility, and the commenters. I don't want to paint the state of digital forums in a completely negative light. Online communities keep it real, to an extent. There are many examples of high reputation people getting much deserved pushback, when they're used to sycophancy IRL. And there are also many occasions where valuable insights from fairly anonymous people float to the surface, due to the democratization of these forums. It's interesting that 30 years into the Internet, the problem of facilitating digital community is still very much unsolved.