9 ms·
Teachers write their own online textbook, save district $175,000
- dquigley 15y agoMaybe I missed it in the article, but what online tool were they using to develop the textbook?
- tokenadult 15y agoMaybe I missed it in the article, but what online tool were they using to develop the textbook? The tool is called CK-12 FlexBooks, and the link http://www.ck12.org/flexbook/ http://www.ck12.org/flexbook/ is near the bottom of the submitted article.
- dquigley 15y agoThanks!
- earl 15y agoThey seem to have used something called Flexbook from the ck-12 foundation [1] mentioned in the article; here's some tutorial videos [2]. Here's a link to their text [3]. I'm actually not a big fan of the text. I skimmed it a bit and I don't think it's as well written as one might hope for. In particular, I hate when formulas just appear with no explanation of how they where derived, and in sections 1.2 to 1.3, the use of big names such as "Fundamental Counting Principle" makes stuff sound more intimidating than it is. I think the discussion about the cardinality of the sample space when you have events that are order sensitive vs order insensitive (ie just counting permutations) could be clearer. Nonetheless, it's an awesome start and the teachers involved should be congratulated. [1] http://ck-12.org http://ck-12.org [2] http://www.ck12.org/about/tutorials http://www.ck12.org/about/tutorials [3] http://print.ck12.org/www/2630552d0bf13d39a2850c0e9f0a523f.pdf http://print.ck12.org/www/2630552d0bf13d39a2850c0e9f0a523f.p...
- dquigley 15y agoThanks!
- protomyth 15y agoI applaud the effort, but I will bet money on a follow-up story about a copyright lawsuit filed by some publisher.
- qjz 15y agoThat strategy isn't as cost-effective as sending the principal to Cancun for a "conference."
- mechanical_fish 15y agoMy guess is that suing free textbooks out of existence will be a losing proposition on every level, so nobody will try. Obviously, the optics will be terrible for the textbook company. That's problem one. Problem two: The first strategy of a lawsuit is scorched-earth: Force your opponent to settle out of fear of legal expenses or an unpredictable jury. But: Foundation Executive Director Neeru Khosla said the foundation started five years ago because she and her husband, Vinod Khosla, the founding CEO of Sun Microsystems, wanted to improve math and science education in the country. Gosh, I wonder if Neeru and Vinod Khosla know any IP lawyers who'd be willing to help their nonprofit foundation defend some public schoolteachers? The remaining strategy is to win the case. Maybe one of the schoolteachers was actually foolish enough to copy a whole chapter from a copyrighted book. Oops. Congratulations, that book goes off the web [1]... ... to be replaced by a different book with a new version of the infringing chapter, written by a completely different schoolteacher. Given that mathematics is hardly a trade secret, it's going to be hard to squelch all of it. The textbook companies should save their money for lobbyists and free gifts. --- [1] I wonder if the foundation hosting this textbook has a DMCA safe harbor defense. You would think so. But this is probably a good place to point out that I Am Not A Lawyer, IP Or Otherwise, So I Know Nothing.
- mgkimsal 15y agoHow long before textbook publishers start threatening to sue districts that use these sorts of texts? Or start playing with prices, such that districts are 100% "publisher X" get discount pricing, while other districts get "a la carte" pricing at 3-5x other districts? Yes, I'm a bit far out about this stuff, but education is big business and the more this sort of idea spreads, the more it erodes publishers' profits - they'll fight back sooner or later (maybe it's already happening?)
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- jeffreymcmanus 15y agoWhat would they sue them for? Not adequately meeting requirements of niche markets? If that were an actionable offense, you'd be able to sue half the startups in Silicon Valley.
- felipellrocha 15y agoMy thoughts exactly.
- mgkimsal 15y agoA) you can bring a lawsuit for anything - just the threat of tying up small districts might "keep them in line". B) there may have been some unspoken agreements with earlier decision makers which, while not contractual, might still constitute some good faith issue. I really think there's probably less a chance of lawsuits specifically, and more likely variable pricing, with "use of free texts" thrown in as an equation that's not shared with anyone but mgt and sales teams.
- nobody3141592 15y agoTypical solution would be to introduce a requirement that teaching materials had to meet some national standard- for the good of the children - the standard would of course be set by the major publishers and the certification wouldn't be available to anyone else.
- 15y ago
- ajaimk 15y agoThis is great but the reality is also, "Professors write their own textbook, cost students $175,000 and an arm"
- artursapek 15y agoI don't understand. It doesn't mean the district spent less of their budget, it just means it can spend it on more meaningful things like promoting sports and the arts.
- antidaily 15y agoOr pop machines!
- aheilbut 15y agoYou don't understand. What happens is that once the teachers/professors (this happens more often in universities) realize that they can force the students to use their textbook, they do a deal with a publishing company and sell the book to the students for $120 a pop.
- _delirium 15y agoYeah, this is unfortunately common, but it's also fairly common for professors to give their students a free book, or one that costs whatever the university bookstore charges for printing a spiral-bound softcover book. That usually happens with professors whose class notes grew over the years to the point where they basically formed a textbook, but for various reasons (disinterest, saturated market, etc.) they didn't take the final step of actually publishing a textbook.
- jules 15y agoThe €5 textbooks I buy from my professors have consistently been the best textbooks, much better than the €120 textbooks in other courses.
- technomancy 15y ago
- stock_toaster 15y agoIt is a bit sad that things like: > The problem with mass-produced textbooks, Engelhaupt explained, was that they can cost $65 each and aren't aligned with Minnesota's math tests so the district would be paying for whole chapters that are never used. and > She said most high school textbooks are written to the requirements of Texas and California, the two biggest markets for the book publishers. It means often a third of the books go unused in Minnesota, she said. appear to be the current state of things. Instead of targeting a good education in the subject, the norm today seems to be to teach k-12 students to pass the aptitude tests, not necessarily to learn the material itself.
- pgeorgi 15y agoI suppose (well, hope) that the point of these statements is that their curriculum differs in some aspects. Maths (like all topics in school) is too wide to teach everything, so they had to pick their battles. The 30% that aren't covered in the mass market books have to be provided by the teachers as additional material, while 30% of the books are not used in school. For $65, I'd expect more, too. On the upside: Assuming that the additional material isn't provided centrally, these teachers who wrote the book have more exposure to writing course work than their colleagues in Texas, who get optimized books.
- derefr 15y agoBut isn't that... test-driven design? ;) I mean, if the tests have 100% coverage, there's no problem with the education only covering what's on the test, right? It just means kids have to sit through exams that are perhaps eight hours long. (Which is fine, really, if those exams get split up so that they're given one exam per unit, rather than one humongous state-wide test. And while they're at it, if those exams were also, say, given online, accessible at the student's whim, and able to be repeated indefinitely without penalty (because of some form of procedural question generation), they could even be used as gates to determine when the student was ready for the next level of material...)
- dwiel 15y agoThis is kinda how Montessori schools do it - at least the one here where my partner teaches. They aren't online, but the student gets to chose to some degree what they are working on, however they can only move onto the next level of a subject once they've passed the 'works' that come before it. The grading of a work involves marking problems correct and incorrect. Note that this is 1st - 3rd grades
- TWSS 15y agoAs someone with a failed education startup in my past, this makes me deliriously happy. It means that there are still teachers out there who haven't had all the initiative beaten out of them yet. That said, yes, education publishing is a huge business. It's really only a matter of time until the publishers take over the digital publishing space, too.
- artursapek 15y agoa third of the books go unused in Minnesota The regional issues raised in this article are a great example of how computers still have a lot of world-changing to do. Doing things the old-fashioned way is sometimes just senseless when there's an alternative.
- grandalf 15y agoIt should be a requirement to be hired as a teacher that a person be capable of writing (or significantly contributing to) a quality textbook of the subject matter they are going to teach.
- cturner 15y agoOblig. feyman link on textbooks in schools: http://www.textbookleague.org/103feyn.htm http://www.textbookleague.org/103feyn.htm
- chrishenn 15y agoOne of the physics teachers at my school wrote a textbook for his students. He did so because he wasn't happy with whatever you can buy. I haven't taken the class yet, but it's supposed to be one of the best at my school. The district won't let him sell the book to his students, so they have to print it out online. (It's here for anyone that's interested: http://www.tamdistrict.org/Page/3217 http://www.tamdistrict.org/Page/3217)
- blahedo 15y agoI'm reading it now, and this is a great little book. I particularly like how many of the illustrations and examples came from students (presumably course projects of some sort) in earlier iterations of the course.
- chrishenn 15y agoYeah I think one of the assignments at the end of the year is to take a photo demonstrating some physics property. There is some really cool photos that come out of it, and he puts the best in the book.
- zem 15y agomy general relativity prof in grad school used our class to beta test his new textbook-in-progress. it was nice because we got free photocopies of each chapter, and in return were expected to point out mistakes etc.
- beloch 15y agoI have little doubt that a group of people well educated in any given subject can do better than the average high-school text book. They're often riddled, not just with mistakes, but fundamentally wrong lessons. First year university physics courses often review a substantial amount of high-school material to correct fundamental mistakes in students understanding of the basics. I think the problem lies with the notion that people who teach physics are more qualified to write a text-book than people who do physics. The result is a pretty text-book that uses all the latest teaching tricks, but teaches things that are wrong. I'd like to see text-book companies moderate some kind of collaboration between teachers and do'ers to produce a book that is both correct in its content and easy for students to learn from. In a sense, first year physics profs can also be viewed as the ultimate consumers of minds educated by high-school texts. They have a good idea of what students need to learn in high-school to be well grounded in their subject area for their first year of university. Instead, we design text-books to help students perform well in standardized tests that frequently prioritize the wrong things and make the same mistakes as text-book writers.
- mquinlan 15y agoThis type of approach seems to beg for collaboration between schools. If something like this can be done for such a fraction of the normal price, what's stopping a school from molding this existing text to their own curriculum or building their own book from a repository of texts and other existing "open-source" books? Then they could allocate spending elsewhere.
- VengefulCynic 15y agoHave you ever been party to textbook adoption time? The textbook companies are buying dinners and drinks for the teachers, "conferences" for the department chairs and offers of all manner of paid amenities for the school district. Obviously, with a pricing model that can afford sales costs like that and a price tag like $175,000 for district-wide adoption of a single textbook, the industry is ripe for disruption. At the same time, the industry probably has lobbyists poised to protect their model with "think of the children." I know that my wife (who has been through several of these textbook adoption periods) is frustrated beyond belief based on the cost/benefit ratio of these textbooks as opposed to what the district could probably pay its teachers to produce themselves. I can only imagine that if this sort of thing spreads beyond a negligible percentage of schools making their own texts, the textbook makers will probably become more actively involved in stopping it.
- wazoox 15y ago> "think of the children." My children routinely carried 5 kg of books from the age of 8 years old up to 10 kg at times now that's they're 12 and 14. If there's an industry that should die for the benefit of the children it's this one... But for the time being the schools probably have something like 1 computer for 10 pupils, so the infrastructure really isn't there to switch to true online material -- Though a 200 euros tablet could replace easily a huge stack of books for a lot less money. Unfortunately here in France the books must be certified by the ministry of education, making the lobbying power of school books editors much more efficient, because they only need to please a few government officials.
- e40 15y agoMy child (11) goes to a school in a top tier CA elementary school, and he has never carried a single school book. Homework problems are all photocopies of typed up problem sets. I take that back, the books he carries are the ones he reads for pleasure (the Harry Potter books are really huge, too). Once I get my Kindle Fire, I'm giving him my old Kindle, which should help with that.
- hessenwolf 15y ago
- Causification 15y agoGood. I'm sick of paying for the same thing over, and over, and over. 1. Government taxes me. Some of that tax money funds research. 2. That research is published in a journal, which I have to pay (exorbitantly) for. 3. Professor reads the journal, and includes some of its information in a textbook, which I have to pay, again exorbitantly, for if I want to take class X. I'm slightly amazed that it's even legal to charge three hundred dollars for fifty cents worth of paper containing nothing but four hundred year old math principles and a handful of groan-inducing word problems.
- bd_at_rivenhill 15y agoI've been waiting for something like this to happen. If the teachers' unions could get behind this on a national level and coordinate the creation of open access online texts for all subjects, then I might start thinking that they're something other than dinosaurs worthy of extinction. They have no reason to support the publishers' goals of keeping prices high since less money spent on textbooks is more money that can be spent on salaries, and their political power would counterbalance the corporate lobbying.
- daemin 15y agoOn the one hand this is brilliant and a good 'rebuttal' to the expensive textbook market. I think that this style works particularily well with subjects such as Maths where there is little to no disagreement or controversy on the subject matter taught (unlike say biology in the USA). But that raises a concern of mine, where every school creates their own textbook, they are free to include their own side or angle of a particular topic, much to the detriment of their students. Sure this can be done in the current situation, but I would wager it would be easier to get experts to review one or a handful of textbooks rather than one for every school. Maybe some sort of cooperative organisation is what is required here, to share the best of the cooperatively created textbooks around.
- aik 15y ago>> But that raises a concern of mine, where every school creates their own textbook, they are free to include their own side or angle of a particular topic True, but who's to say a major publisher has experts and know what they're doing? Signs point to the fact that they don't. Also, they all have to teach to the standardized tests anyway, so they don't have a massive amount of say.
- edtechdev 15y agoYeah there are hundreds of examples of open textbooks for both the K-12 and college levels. It's nice to see a few school districts (and colleges - like Western Governors) officially adopting them and replacing the old books. However, again, thousands of instructors are already doing so individually ('edupunks' :) Here are some open textbook sites: http://collegeopentextbooks.org/ http://collegeopentextbooks.org/ http://www.openculture.com/free_textbooks http://www.openculture.com/free_textbooks http://www.ck12.org/flexbook/ http://www.ck12.org/flexbook/ http://www.lightandmatter.com/books.html http://www.lightandmatter.com/books.html Related are the many wiki-based books & notes created in or for courses. For example: http://anatowiki.wetpaint.com/ http://anatowiki.wetpaint.com/ http://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/FHSST_Physics http://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/FHSST_Physics
- tsellon 15y agoHere's a curated list of open texts for mathematics: http://linear.ups.edu/curriculum.html http://linear.ups.edu/curriculum.html
- DanBC 15y agoIs there a process of iterative refinement for any of these books? Perhaps a useful idea would be some kind of version control system; allowing people to fix errors, trim needless fluff, and improve examples. This could be funded by schools and by philanthropic grants.
- motowilliams 15y agoI'm curious about how an Amazon Publishing house stepping into the education arena might offer some disruption to the Texas Board of Education on their indirect grip on textbook standards. I suppose there is a chance of lobbing being replaced by a gaming of the system, as it were, but it might allow more visibility into the content that is being used in the your child's district. There is still the problem of the electronic media versus physical copies but maybe a Raspberry PI at ~$25 would make it more appealing.
- mixmastamyk 15y agoA compelling article. I'd love to see open-source textbooks on github/bitbucket to be built to html/pdf and easily portable to kindle/ipad, etc, etc. The ability for students to submit bugs and patches would be awesome and empowering for them.
- WalterBright 15y agoIt's a mystery to me why school textbooks are not a solved problem, after 100 years and tens of thousands of schools.
- biaxident 15y agoThe thing that I was most amazed at in schools was the lack of sharing resources. There was very little sharing between teachers in the same school and even less between schools. This seems like a massive waste of time as most of these teachers spend a large amount of time creating these resources and most of these schools teach very similar syllabuses. Creating resources like this textbook is a great step forward, if more teachers could collaborate to create really great resources it would not only improve the education provided to students but also free up teachers from spending all of their time creating custom resources.
- teja1990 15y agoBook Manufacturers instead of worrying about what this might do to the book industry, it'll help if they think how to make it an advantge to us. Tweaking always helps:)
- HilbertSpace 15y agoOkay, the book they wrote is at http://moodle.anoka.k12.mn.us/mod/resource/view.php?inpopup=true&id=26398 http://moodle.anoka.k12.mn.us/mod/resource/view.php?inpopup=... and I started reading it. Don't. No one should take a course from that book. The authors of the book don't know the subject. That book won't be a prerequisite for anything important. So, if want a first course in probability and statistics, then get a college textbook and/or just go to college. More generally, in college in the US, in math, physical science, and engineering, quite good texts are easy to find, and the best texts are excellent. Moreover, the prerequisites for college are quite basic, essentially just the '3Rs' where for 'rithmetic' we do include algebra and plane geometry (trigonometry and solid geometry would also be good). So, in K-12, just get the 3Rs and then start with college texts and/or just college. In particular, for anything much past the 3Rs, just f'get about K-12. Bluntly, as illustrated by the book of this thread, the K-12 system is rarely able to teach anything worthwhile much beyond just the basic 3Rs. This conclusion is not new: Once I looked at AP calculus. Don't. The people who wrote the AP calculus materials don't understand calculus. Instead, for calculus, just get a good college text and dig in. I learned from Johnson and Kiokemeister, taught from Protter and Morrey, and have seen several other good college calculus texts, e.g., from Thomas. When I was studying and, later, teaching calculus in college, there was no shortage of good texts. Just why K-12 has so much trouble getting good calculus texts is strange and tragic. Once I looked at some materials on optimization, i.e., linear programming, developed by the K-12 system in North Carolina. Don't. Those materials fill several much needed gaps on the library shelves and would be illuminating if ignited. The authors didn't understand linear programming. The site http://boston.conman.org/2004/01/21.1 http://boston.conman.org/2004/01/21.1 has some excellent quotes from Feynman looking at K-12 texts. Feynman was correct, and apparently the situation has not changed. My qualifications: I hold a Ph.D. from one of the world's best research universities; there I did research on optimization and also on stochastic optimal control. For calculus, I've done well studying it, advanced calculus, and well beyond, taught calculus in college, applied calculus in business and to problems of US national security, and published peer-reviewed original research using calculus. For optimization, I've studied it at advanced levels, applied it in both in business to problems of US national security, taught it in college and graduate school, and published peer-reviewed original research in it. My startup has some original, crucial, core, powerful, valuable 'secret sauce' that is based on some advanced topics in applied math including 'analysis' (way past calculus), probability, and statistics.
- brudgers 15y agoI remember seeing Clifford Stoll on CSPAN saying something along the lines of "Rich Schools will have good teachers, poor schools will just have computers." The article reminds me that this will extend to textbooks. [http://www.c-spanvideo.org/program/153929-1 http://www.c-spanvideo.org/program/153929-1]