7 ms·
Pretty much. It’s like selling a house and buyer makes an offer with no contingencies. Sure, you can sue them to close the deal but the juice isn’t worth the
by refurb 4y ago
Pretty much.
It’s like selling a house and buyer makes an offer with no contingencies.
Sure, you can sue them to close the deal but the juice isn’t worth the squeeze. Does Twitter want to be locked into some multi-year court battle?
They’ll settle and the news will move onto something else.
- TillE 4y agoIt's not like there's another buyer out there offering $44 billion. Twitter has no reason to settle, unless maybe the stock price goes way up.
- refurb 4y agoIt’s like a divorce. You can either reach a settlement or spend a ton of money fighting for years. You imagine how distracting it would be for Twitter to have this in their quarterly updates? They certainly aren’t selling the company until it’s resolved. My prediction - lots of public tough talk, then a quiet resolution.
- jogjayr 4y ago> spend a ton of money fighting for years Twitter is worth $28b and Musk's offer was $44b - a $16bn delta. The most annual revenue that a single law firm in the US has made is about $4bn.[1] Any amount Twitter could spend on lawyers is nothing compared to what they stand to make by winning. If you're accounting for whatever "toll" it takes on the company's leadership and employee morale, $16bn is about 2.75 years of operating expenses. Even if you assume every employee is operating at 50% mental capacity the entire time, it still makes sense to fight as long as it's over in <= 5 years. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_law_firms_by_revenue https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_law_firms_by_r...
- CogitoCogito 4y ago> It’s like a divorce. You can either reach a settlement or spend a ton of money fighting for years. There's basically no way they could possibly spend even a tiny fraction of the overall deal's worth fighting this even if it went on for years. Not spending that money to fight this would really be stupid.
- jacquesm 4y agoAnd would open up many other lawsuits from minority shareholders that would love to see this deal go through at the price that Musk offered. They're between a rock and a hard place and I think that that is the thing that pretty much guarantees that they will take it all the way to the last appeal to get it enforced. They can't afford not to.
- MrMan 4y agoAnalogies don't work with corporate law
- jogjayr 4y ago> you can sue them to close the deal but the juice isn’t worth the squeeze That really depends on the offer you accepted (A), the current value of the house (B), the cost of litigation (C), and the price you put on your time and mental energy (D). If A > B + C + D, it makes sense to force the buyer to close. And in most cases, you're relying on the buyer to close in order to be able to close on the house you're moving to so you may have no choice.
- jcranmer 4y ago> Does Twitter want to be locked into some multi-year court battle? Delaware courts are pretty fast. The court case could conceivably be finished before the end of this year.
- refurb 4y agoPresumably Musk’s legion of lawyers can find some way to drag things out.
- CogitoCogito 4y agoWhy do you presume that?
- refurb 4y agoCourt decisions can be appealed.
- CogitoCogito 4y agoAnd those appeals can be ruled upon and then the case can reach a conclusion. It's not like the lawyers can just take _any_ case with _any_ facts and keep the case from _ever_ reaching a conclusion. The real question you should ask yourself is, if $44 billion is on the line, how long would you continue to pursue the case in the face of lawyers who are just trying to drag it out? Even if it went on for years (it's not assured Musk's lawyers could drag it out past a year), I can think of 44 billion reasons to continue with the case.
- refurb 4y agoI think you underestimate the burden on a company of multi-year litigation. They won’t get any more buyers while it’s happening and it’s a massive distraction. I’ve worked at companies like this and it brutal on employee morale. People just leave.
- mupuff1234 4y agoSuing to close the deal can be a way to get leverage for the eventual settlement.
- edgyquant 4y agoThe answer is almost certainly yes. It isn’t Twitter sitting in a court room for nothing they’re getting higher than the stock price was when the deal was announced. It’s a profitable venture for twitter
- jacquesm 4y agoMassively profitable compared to their normal state of affairs anyway.
- moralestapia 4y ago>Sure, you can sue them to close the deal but the juice isn’t worth the squeeze. LOL, I'm sure the juice will be worth the squeeze on a $44 billion dollar house.
- refurb 4y agoNope. Years of court battles distracts the company and keeps other buyers away.
- jacquesm 4y agoThere are no other buyers at this price or anything near it, Musk simply messed up. The deal he proposed is beyond stupid and the effect this can have on all of Musk's holdings is the thing to watch for, Twitter could well be his Waterloo. 'Is this the hill you want to die on?' is always a good question to ask yourself before you dig in and from where I'm sitting Twitter was 'optional' in Musk's arsenal, he had all of the benefits without the downsides as it was. Maybe his ego is incompatible with not owning the things he relies on but in this case that ownership comes with a pretty hefty price tag and even people at Musk's level don't throw around tens of billions of dollars lightly (normally speaking, that is).
- xiphias2 4y ago,,The deal he proposed is beyond stupid’’ The price in the deal was set by professional lawyers at Goldman Sachs, so if it was beyond stupid, it was not Elon’s fault. The deal was proposed before the recession, and at that time there were people proposing that the price is too low, because Twitter stock was over $60 at some point. Of course in the current market Elon would pay a few billions to get out of the deal, but it’s a different deal than what it has been a few months ago.
- jacquesm 4y agoIf I have a classic car appraised and don't like the appraised value I'll pass. Goldman Sachs was working for Twitter, of course they are going to try to maximize the valuation. Musk should have done DD before agreeing on a price, it's that simple.