15 ms·
Admit It, Squirrels Are Just Tree Rats
- BillSims 4y agoI cannot remember who should get credit for this: rats=bad hair day in sewers and run down buildings versus squirrels=good hair day in the parks and trees, and the squirrels hired a very good public relations firm. See how much of a difference that makes?
- akhmatova 4y agoNo, it's not PR operation, and no, Sarah Jessica Parker does not have anything of interest to to say about the matter. Squirrels are obviously very different from, and much smarter than rats. Their appearance and grooming are a reflection of this deeper fact, not simply a gimmick or an accident. What a silly article.
- blacklion 4y agoRats are social animals and much smarter than most of rodents (including squirrels). Trust me, my mother was behavioral biologist, and she experimented with both rats (black rats, Rattus rattus) and red (European) squirrels (Sciurus vulgaris).
- akhmatova 4y agoI'll have to take the subject up with your mom, then. On the surface, at least, almost everything that squirrels do (from their manual dexterity to their nest building and food storage) suggests that they operate on a higher plane than rats.
- blacklion 4y agoTypical old-skool behavioral test, like maze solving, button mashing (with food reinforcement), and alike, are much better passed by rats. Maybe, it is wrong tests, there are some discussion in this field how we (humans) should asset animal intelligence.
- josefresco 4y agoI have both in my neighborhood. Squirrels live in the trees, prance around my yard, are very passive and bury nuts. The rats live in the trash heap that my shut-in neighbor keeps in her garage and property, carry disease and are quite aggressive. They may be similar in biology but not in behavior or diet.
- cafard 4y agoThe leave pretty big divots in the yard, but as long as they stay out of the attic, I don't mind much. A squirrel's tail does look like a rat's if it has the sun behind it.
- s0rce 4y agoI'm not sure if you are saying rats leave divots? The squirrels around here live in the ground and make huge holes. I don't really see many rats.
- cafard 4y agoThe squirrels leave divots. The rats, if they are around, will have burrows.
- jrumbut 4y agoBut if they do get in the attic it's a nightmare. I would take 100 mice over one squirrel.
- marcodiego 4y agoLike hamsters?
- reidjs 4y agoAdmit it, The Atlantic is just a dumbed down The New Yorker.
- jhbadger 4y agoThey are very similar publications, but I'm not sure which one is "dumbed down" relative to the other. Instead, there is a lot of variation within each magazine. Some articles are brilliant examples of "long form" journalism which sometimes later get expanded into entire books, others are puff pieces, and yet others (like this article) are somewhere in between.
- 3pt14159 4y agoAs someone that dated an Atlantic contributor (as well as her being the senior editor over at The Walrus, Canada's answer to The New Yorker) I can very clearly give you an answer here: The Atlantic is great, but it is in no league with The New Yorker. I wouldn't have called it "dumbed down" but it's still not as sharp and that is ok. The world appreciates both.
- beckingz 4y agoYeah the Atlantic has clearer writing. The New Yorker has 'better' writing, but I can't stand it.
- turns0ut 4y agoThey’re like every other media outlet; trying to trigger people into having an opinion that does not matter, because the public having opinions that matter would mean a low effort blogger has to get a job.
- systemvoltage 4y agoYou mean, this New Yorker? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32044754 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32044754 I completely and categorically disagree. The New Yorker has derailed on many fronts. It has become an ideological hell hole. If you have access to a public library, you can browse pre-2000's New Yorker on archive.org which was a totally different publication all together.
- parenthesis 4y agoI totally hate (grey) squirrels. The damage they do to my garden is turning me into Mr McGregor. Just today I removed multiple discarded peanut shells from a bed I was preparing. (Perhaps I just hate the humans who feed them these.) They've dug holes in my lawn, killed a sapling by digging into its pot. And they are so tame you have to chase them off from close quarters.
- jjtheblunt 4y agoadopt a rescue dog? game on!
- nibbleshifter 4y agoGrey squirrels are invasive where I am, but hunting them is unfortunately legally dubious at best.
- wrycoder 4y agoThey pulled down and chewed on every one of the corn plants I grew a couple of years ago. They didn't eat them all, just seemed intent on maximum carnage.
- genocidicbunny 4y agoI've had a bit of luck with using a homemade 'mace' spray on my plants to keep them away. A high concentration of peppermint oil and capsaicin emulsified as a very light gel using xanthan gum. I end up having to apply it every other day to be effective, but I have seen it turn away squirrels with my own eyes. The other thing I've done is set out a small water bowl and another bowl with some pumpkin seeds for them. Given the presence of my homemade mace, they usually choose to just forage in the 'safe' seeds and water and leave my plants alone. But if they ever lose that distaste, the next option will be nuclear.
- 6LLvveMx2koXfwn 4y agoUnless they're red [1] 1. https://greysquirrelcontrol.co.uk/ https://greysquirrelcontrol.co.uk/
- hunglee2 4y agoit's an interesting premise - how to explain our irrational categorisation of animals as tolerated vs not tolerated. I believe it is in the main due to the animals attitude to us. here's my sketch framework 1. Pets - vassalized companions who accept human hegemony 2. Prey - harmless food, too dumb to realise what we have in store for them 3. Predators - resistant to human hegemony, dangerous competitors which need to be contained 4. Pests - resistant to human hegemony, not direct competitors but more invidiously have figured out a way to uniquely exploit the system we have set up exclusively for human benefit. To be exterminated
- Scarblac 4y agoCats are predators who accept our offerings of food and petting.
- hunglee2 4y agothey are also edible, so prey item in some cultures also. Truth is you can move animals across these boundaries but it does feel unethical. Rabbits good example - clearly widely eaten, yet once a pet, could you turn it into food? You'd be a wrong 'un if you did!
- InitialLastName 4y agoYou forgot "Victims - Incompatibility with human hegemony can be used to sell calendars"
- 4y ago
- enriquto 4y agoGood for squirrels, then? Rats are really cool animals!
- adastra22 4y agoI know, right? We seem to be the minority though. I know multiple people in real life who have an absurdly irrational reaction to rats. They react to merely seeing a rat or mouse scurrying around the way you might if you suddenly felt a tarantula crawling up your neck. Interestingly my wife is one of them, and my daughter once thought mice and rats were cute (I agree!) until she saw mom freak out, and now she's just as jumpy. Makes me wonder if this response is in-built or learned behavior.
- t_mann 4y agoI've often wondered along similar lines, and my explanation was always related to what's mentioned in the article as well: the Black Death killed around two thirds of the European population, without rats being identified as the main source of the disease. So today's Europeans (and Americans with European ancestry) have a high probability of being ancestors of people who, for whatever odd reason, had an intrinsic aversion to rats.
- adastra22 4y agoThis doesn't affect your evolutionary argument, but rats didn't spread the Black Death. Human lice was the carrier. We've only recently confirmed this previously minority theory through genetic evidence, but it always fit the data better. Goes to show that there is some sort of deeply held aversion to rats such that people were more willing to believe that explanation. I don't understand it. I think mice and rats are cute :\
- t_mann 4y agoInteresting, do you have a reference? I'd say it affects my theory a lot, haha
- adastra22 4y agoI learned about it on a BBC documentary about the Black Death I saw a few years back. I'm about to run out the door so I haven't the time to properly figure out which one and see what paper they were citing. But I remember it was a French university that did the genetic tests, IIRC. The data which fit that theory better came from London and some city in Scotland (Glasgow? I'm not sure.) Basically there were houses which shared gardens (where rats would live) but the disease didn't spread between the two houses. Likewise in London there was a poor district that got hit hard, and a rich district next door that saw very few infections. Due to the way the sewers were laid out, the rat population was the same between the two. But the lice wouldn't have transferred without close contact, which of course rarely happened between rich and poor. The more damning evidence was out of Scotland where the doctor making a very detailed study showed that the disease only transferred between people who shared close living quarters. And in particular, during a lockdown with all-day curfew it didn't transmit at all. But where beds were reused, the new inhabitants got sick. But the genetic evidence sealed the deal. I'll have to look up that French study later.
- lkxijlewlf 4y agoSquirrels around here are super annoying. They love to play dodge wheel. I hate it because I don't want puncture a tire because of one of those little shits. Edit: Relevant - http://toddmitchellbooks.com/twelve-things-about-squirrels-that-will-blow-your-mind/ http://toddmitchellbooks.com/twelve-things-about-squirrels-t...
- dmix 4y agoThe migration part is interesting: > Squirrels in North America used to migrate in massive numbers, following cycles of bountiful acorn harvests. When settlers first arrived in this country, they reported squirrels being so thick in the trees above during a migration that they nearly blocked out the sun. The best part — squirrels could do most of the journey from the East coast to Indiana without touching the ground. > But as settlers started to clear the old growth oak forests, the great squirrel migrations became fragmented. Where squirrels had to cross fields, they were killed by coyotes, foxes, and other predators, including people who reported killing hundreds of squirrels (and getting three pennies a pelt). The last great squirrel migration was in 1968 in Wisconsin, when hundreds of thousands of squirrels were seen migrating (and dying on the highway and in lakes). One fisherman reported a wave of squirrels swimming toward his boat and nearly sinking it as they ran over him. Since then, this mass migration behavior has gone extinct.*
- adastra22 4y agoThat makes me sad :( I wonder if the right wildlife corridors were setup would the migration patterns resume? Or is this part of squirrel culture and once eradicated is gone?
- samatman 4y agoThe right wildlife corridors would need to include the American Chestnut, which was their primary food.
- m463 4y agoI get sad walking through the redwoods and seeing clumps of maybe 7 trees in a circle. Invariably in the center of the circle is a tree stump of a GIANT old-growth redwood that existed before the forest was clear-cut.
- dvh 4y agoJavaScript is just C without pointers
- protastus 4y agoI see no controversy here, but I like both animals and have had pet rats. Yes, they have many similarities. Both are rodents.
- james_pm 4y agoRats are fine by me as well and I also had a number of them as pets over the years. That said, the rats in San Fran that I saw a couple of years ago when visiting were HUGE and I was not a fan. I suspect some of the fear of rats is that they generally give off the vibe of "I'll bite you if you get close" vs. the skittishness of squirrels who will scurry off up a tree if you even try to approach.
- otikik 4y agoAnd shrimp are just sea cockroaches. But people keep eating them in this multiverse. At least they are not eating spiders like in the previous one.
- RajT88 4y agoSquirrels are annoying as hell and anyone who loves them has never tried to garden. Rats indeed. On the other hand, survival youtubers discuss how they are delicious and don't taste like rat at all.
- throw827474737 4y agoGardening and still loving squirrels... though the red European much less rat-like-looking cute ones, not your nasty gray haters!! The biggest annoyance are racoons here, still loving them.. rats, especially fat ones, ugh.. but they also just want to survive :)
- RajT88 4y agoThe red ones are haters too.
- Merad 4y agoGrowing up on a farm we were constantly shooting squirrels out of fruit trees and off of bird feeders. It was amazing to me how they were barely concerned with gunfire and not at all bothered by the dead bodies of other squirrels. There were a few days I probably shot 5-6 of them all in the same place in the span of just a few hours.
- ahazred8ta 4y agoThe Huntress shared her squirrel melt sandwich recipe... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gqo_GbzCjmg#squirrelmelts https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gqo_GbzCjmg#squirrelmelts https://www.google.com/search?q=huntress+squirrel+melts https://www.google.com/search?q=huntress+squirrel+melts
- RajT88 4y agoThat show is creepy for reasons unrelated to squirrels.
- greenbit 4y agoCan't grow pumpkins around here anymore, since the furry tailed tree rats discovered that pumpkins are full of pumpkin seeds. Ever since that year, every pumpkin big enough to bore three inch hole into has had a three inch hole bored into it and its insides removed. From there they decided to test the nearby winter squash and will mostly destroy that, too. Not a fan of squirrels anymore.
- bigmattystyles 4y agoIn the 90s there was a great sitcom called Spin City with Michael J. Fox and subsequently Charlie Sheen. The best line about this topic I've ever heard was on that show, "Squirrels are just rats with good PR". I wonder how well that show holds up, doesn't seem like you can stream it anywhere other than Pluto which I don't have - maybe I'll get yet another streaming service...
- pjmlp 4y agoIf I remember correctly, in today's cancel culture, the show's jokes would make it get out of the air rather quickly.
- bigmattystyles 4y agoDefinitely
- guardiangod 4y agoIt's my favorite sitcom of the 90s. The jokes are witty and have punches to them, and the show doesn't try to pretend its social observations are philosophically deep.
- deanCommie 4y agoBushy tail. That's 99% of it. We can talk about behaviour, or aggression, or disease, but i think even if rats acted like squirrels in every way, but still didn't have the bushy tail, we'd prefer squirrels.
- legerdemain 4y ago> The scientific name of the American red squirrel, Tamiasciurus hudsonicus, translates to “the steward who sits in the shadow of his tail.” Tamiasciurus hudsonicus means "hoarding squirrel from the Hudson."
- camtarn 4y agoThanks for the full translation. I don't know much Latin but even I could tell that the 'translation' in the article was most likely complete bunk.
- cgh 4y agoPossibly unpopular fact: lots of people hunt and eat squirrels. So this is another way we define differences between otherwise similar animals: one is food, and the other is not.
- xkcd-sucks 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rat_meat#Regionally https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rat_meat#Regionally
- wrycoder 4y agoRats are known to carry disease. But squirrels do, too, especially in the warm months. And never eat the brains!
- lumberjack24 4y agoJust like shrimps are sea cockroaches.
- kypro 4y agoAt my old house we had a family of squirrels that lived in the trees at the back which I would feed. One night I looked out the window and I saw a rat eating the nuts I had left out for the squirrels earlier. The rat somehow climbed up the fence and managed to get onto the squirrel feeder. After I saw this I brought a new feeder so that the squirrels had to jump to the nuts which meant the rat couldn't get to the nuts anymore, but then my girlfriend asked why I care more about squirrels than the rat and she had a point because the rat wasn't doing us no harm. It wasn't getting into the house or getting into our bins or anything like that. It was just eating the left over nuts in the evening. I'm an animal lover so it weighed on my conscience for a while, but I think there probably is a difference between the two. I was happy to feed the squirrels because I knew they wouldn't get into the house or damage my property. On the other hand a rat investigation can be a nightmare. Rats are cool creatures, but there's a reason people don't like them.
- jacquesm 4y ago> investigation Infestation?
- arthurcolle 4y agoRat investigation reminds me of that one Love, Death + Robots episode. Very industrious little guys.
- xhkkffbf 4y agoI wish someone would investigate these squirrels and interrogate them under oath. Get them on the record and not let them weasel out of telling the truth.
- dec0dedab0de 4y agosquirrels will definitely get in the house and damage property if given the chance.
- malshe 4y agoWe just found this out last week! The squirrels ruined our swing cushion on the porch. We were totally confused when we saw the torn cushion but later my wife saw a squirrel picking out the cushion fiber and carrying it to the tree.
- AvSaba 4y agoNear the place that I live squirrels are vital to the ecosystem. Basically they can't remember the location of all the seed that they buried and forgotten seeds become trees :)
- sliken 4y agoIndeed, which is why trees bother with the expense of making nuts.
- JayBear 4y ago... and pigeons are just air rats :P
- xhkkffbf 4y agoThey eat all of our pears before they're ready-- and before we even get a chance to get them. Very selfish.
- hancholo 4y agoSquirrels are a pain just as rats are but in another way. They're all around the apartments I live in and constantly get into our plants and destroy them. I spray cayenne pepper and other deterrents once in a while but they don't always work unless you keep at it multiple times a day.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Koshkin 4y agoSquirrels are really smart. I once tried to chase one away from a tree using a fishing rod, but it just moved to a distance an inch longer than where the rod could reach and stayed put, just keeping an eye on me while I was there. They are known to spy on each other and to steal each other's "investments." (Also, if one notices that another is watching, it will pretend like it's hiding the food here and then take it someplace else.)
- m463 4y agoProbably sat there waving its tail. That seems to be what taunting squirrels do...
- solar-mariner 4y agoI've had mice, squirrels and raccoons in the house. The raccoon had made a little nest in an attic space and gave birth to three kits. It was cold, so I didn't want to evict them, so I let them stay and I put up a camera recording on slo-mo on a VCR. I learned a lot about raccoons. The mother raccoon is a very very caring and devoted mother. She also keeps the nest completely clean. She always left and went outside to do her business. She removed all her kits wastes as well. Eventually, when it got much warmer and she started to chew the batten boards, I did evict her humanely. She had done very little damage to the house and no mess. I was probably lucky to get a good one. I had a squirrel fall down the fireplace chimney and roam the house while we were on vacation. My friend checking on the house discovered her after she'd been trapped inside for a couple of days. Squirrels poop everywhere they go, so I could tell everywhere she went. She explored the whole house, but spent the most time looking out the ground floor windows. The fireplace ashes on her hands revealed things she touched. There were black marks all over the window cranks, but few marks on the window sashes. It looked like she had tried to operate the window cranks. I appeared she understood that if she could move them the right way, she could open a window and get out, but she had been unable to move them. She found a bit of peanut butter to eat, and she shredded our curtains. Apart from that she did very little damage and the mess was limited. The poops are pretty dry, and she only peed in a couple of specific locations, not everywhere. I did a cleanup before my wife returned home, and as I cleaned up, the things I observed caused me to develop a lot of empathy for the trapped and frustrated creature, who didn't want to be there. As for the mouse, that was an experience I doubt most of you would believe.
- dymk 4y agoJapan already figured that out 木鼠 (ki-nezumi) squirrel 木 tree 鼠 rat
- purgedreality 4y agoReminds me of that old car commercial: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ppLHHuqZ3F4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ppLHHuqZ3F4
- pyuser583 4y agoThere’s a great scene in “The Inglorious Bastards” about this.
- yencabulator 4y agoI haven't yet had a squirrel crawl into my car, hide berries everywhere, eat the firewall insulation, chew other rubber parts and wires, or build a nest in the glove box. I also haven't yet had a squirrel carry dog poop onto my deck, thinking its a great way to build a nest under the deck. I haven't yet had to clean squirrel poop while thinking about how much fun it would be to catch the hantavirus while the healthcare system is overloaded with covid. If a squirrel decides to partake in these activities, I will also start treating them like rats.
- vixen99 4y agoAnd ...?
- sdiupIGPWEfh 4y agoHow many species are basically the same if you completely ignore differences in size, texture, color, and behavior? If you squint right, we're just apes in suits. It's almost like all those small differences add up to an outsize impact.
- dmix 4y agoCats also look very weird if you drench them in water. Much more rat-like. Same with owls, bears, etc.
- kazinator 4y agoAny two entities are the same, if you define equivalence in such a way that it ignores all their differences. "ABC" and "Abc" are the same, if we ignore case, and so it goes. You can't fix it with absolute equivalence, because absolute equivalence requires that some entity A is only equal to that same entity A, and no other entity; that is then inapplicable if we want to use equivalences for division into classes that have more than one member.
- cbozeman 4y agoIt's a little disconcerting just how chimpanzee-like some human beings look. I often wonder how anyone could dispute out origin when you look at a chimpanzee then look at a human. The similarities are incredibly striking.
- epakai 4y agoThe squirrels are working for the pigeons. Spies, every last one. Those pigeons, they're the masterminds. They'll sell you to the highest bidder, and you'll never see your family again. Just keep a low profile, and maybe you won't become a target.