9 ms·
A mysterious cult that predates Stonehenge
- tombh 4y agoCult? What unfortunate word choice. We're talking about a period possibly 8000 years ago! The common understanding of "cult" is shaped by the Euro-centric, post-Christian New Religious Movements (the preferred academic nomenclature) of the 1960s. Not only did European culture not exist in the Neolithic, nor did Christian nor even the so-called Axial Age whence the roots of many of the world's major religions.
- nwatson 4y agoThis is the technical use of the word "cult": "a system of religious veneration and devotion directed toward a particular figure or object". As is "the cult of Diana" and not "the Branch Davidian or The Children of God cults."
- tombh 4y agoIn what field is it technical? I have a degree in Religious Studies and we were taught it was strictly jargon.
- LegitShady 4y ago> I have a degree in Religious Studies and we were taught it was strictly jargon. sounds like you were in a cult
- pvg 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cult_(religious_practice) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cult_(religious_practice) just like 'cultic practice' is used in the article which is not related to the 'New Religious Movement' meaning.
- tombh 4y ago> This article discusses the _original_ meaning of the word "cult", not the term in the sociology of religion, new religious movements called "cults", cults of personality, or popular cult followings. Emphasis mine. As far as I was educated this is neither the commonly understood nor academically encouraged usage.
- pvg 4y agoIt's still used like that in historical or anthropological writing. Cult of the emperor, cult of this or that. You're just used to a different meaning that is also avoided in your particular field where the two meanings are more negatively collidey.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> In what field is it technical? I have a degree in Religious Studies and we were taught it was strictly jargon. Those two terms are synonymous. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/jargon#Noun https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/jargon#Noun
- UnpossibleJim 4y agoIt's a religion that was worshipped by a peoples who covered the area of modern day Poland. Cults are lead by a single, charismatic leader (sometimes a couple)... like Jesus, or Jim and Tammy Faye Baker or Jim Jones. There have been many Christian cults, but Christianity is not, itself a cult (any longer). Cults do not have large social influence, like this one obviously did. Calling this a cult is like calling the religion of the Maya or the pre-Christian Romans a cult. As far as "a system of religious veneration and devotion directed toward a particular figure or object"... You just described Christianity. The worship of Jesus... while that might not be what the point was supposed to have been, you might want to send a memo out. There are a lot of folks who are idolatrous to that cross.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Tagbert 4y agoYes, Christianity is a cult but not really in the tabloid, cable news meaning that you are used to. “Cult” is not inherently negative or out of the mainstream. It simply means a system of religious worship. It has become more negative in recent decades in popular culture by being associated with some “unusual” religious groups.
- UnpossibleJim 4y agoI don't mean it as a slur, really but Christianity started as a cult, though it can no longer be construed as one for the most part - aside for certain sects (though I'm unsure about Catholocism and their fealty to the Pope above almost anything... it seems almost antithetical to pure New Testiment teaching, but I'm non religious and wasn't raised Catholic, so much of it is a mystery to me). This religious group they're describing in the article, however seems very out of bounds for the term "cult" and they seem to use the term in merely a pejorative sense. As far as the legal definitions of cults go (under US law), well there it gets "squishy" and kind of comes down to a popularity contest, almost. "Are you of a certain age", "Are you of a certain size", "Have you a certain amount of influence", type of thing. http://jur.byu.edu/?p=4386 http://jur.byu.edu/?p=4386
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jccooper 4y agoThe common understanding of cult (which I would argue is probably "religion I don't like", but that doesn't matter) is not in use here. This is a technical usage in archaeology to refer to religious interaction with place and object... which is basically all prehistoric archaeology can see.
- tombh 4y agoI wasn't aware of that. It was so drummed into me at university (Religious Studies) to avoid the word that I'm intrigued as to why another academic field would uses it seriously. Do you have any reading recommendations that might give an insight into its technical usage?
- kortilla 4y ago>It was so drummed into me at university (Religious Studies) to avoid the word that I'm intrigued as to why another academic field would uses it seriously. Because there would be very little feedback from Religious Studies into other fields on what words are acceptable. There are disagreements on terminology within academia in the same sub-field (I saw this in even programming language research).
- Amezarak 4y agoThe Latin word cultus had no negative connotation and described this activity. Anything classicist and classicist-adjacent continues to use the word "cult" because that's how it was used in Latin and in English. The negative connotation did not arise until much later, probably in the mid-20th century. The "technical" usage is simply the normal usage of the word for anyone who mostly reads books published prior to the 1960s.
- jccooper 4y agoI went looking into it, but haven't found a good capsule reference. It's a pretty strong cultural practice (and an old one; references to Classical practices like "the cult of Dionysis" are well-worn) and isn't always specified. This article "“Cult” in the Study of Religion and Archaeology" in ASMA (https://www.academia.edu/5061036/Cult_in_the_Study_of_Religion_and_Archaeology https://www.academia.edu/5061036/Cult_in_the_Study_of_Religi...) has a pretty good discussion. Here's an article from a text book on "Archaeology of Cult and Religion": (https://www.academia.edu/13590600/2005._Archaeology_of_Cult_and_Religion._In_Renfrew_C._and_Bahn_P._eds._Archaeology_The_Key_Concepts._London_Routledge_pp._45-49 https://www.academia.edu/13590600/2005._Archaeology_of_Cult_...) You can see a working usage in "A Problem Oof Definition: “Cultic” and “Comestic” Contexts in Philistia" (https://www.academia.edu/1868319/A_Problem_of_Definition_Cultic_and_Domestic_Contexts_in_Iron_Age_Philistia https://www.academia.edu/1868319/A_Problem_of_Definition_Cul...) I haven't read the books, but there's a couple books covered in this review from AJA on the topic: https://www.ajaonline.org/book-review/619 https://www.ajaonline.org/book-review/619 Modern archaeology makes some odd-seeming linguistic choices to try to avoid implying more than they actually know; part of that is avoiding "religion" in favor of "ritual" and "cultic practices", because "religion" implies a whole lot of stuff that artifacts just can't see.
- insickness 4y agoAgreed. Was about to comment on the same. Seems like they wanted to imply that the religious practices were less evolved and complex than modern-day religions. But the word choice could be better.
- timeon 4y agoI'm not good in English or Latin language, but as far as I know 'cult' is from Latin 'cultus' which among other things may have something to do with worshiping. Maybe in English it has negative connotations but for example in my native language it does not matter if you say 'cult of sun' or 'cult of Jesus'.
- Tagbert 4y agoYes, cult means a system of worship and is an appropriate term to use here. It is commonly used like this in historical and archeological discussions. In recent decades, the most common use in popular culture has been as a label for some very unusual or even violent religious groups. Based on some posts here, even some religious studies programs are avoiding using the work for fear of this popular view of the word.
- j3th9n 4y agoThese are UFO landing strips.
- doodlebugging 4y agoFor evidence of this I think the archaeologists should focus on finding the holes in the corners of the mustatils where they planted their tiki torches used to guide those UFO pilots home. Maybe all the goat, cattle, and gazelle heads is just evidence that aliens are only interested in the rear portions of earth's animals. That would bolster my personal theory that earth is nothing more than a training ground for alien proctologists and gastroenterologists. Their first visit convinced them that there was nothing here but a bunch of assholes so they decided that in spite of that there was still something they could learn here.
- keyle 4y agoI laughed thank you. Then it got me thinking. If it were the case, hypothetically, ... These would be terrible. It would mean they'd have wings, they'd need air for landing, otherwise it wouldn't be a strip, it'd be just a pad. Unless, their vehicle is somehow oblong, which is a possibility. However, some of those sights are shown on mountain slopes, what a terrible place to land. Unless, being that old, those mountains slopes weren't slopes back then. Finally, why wouldn't there be any wreckage of any type of vehicle from back then? Shouldn't there be at least one ounce of evidence of a past crash? Unless, their vehicles were made of goat skulls, bones and rocks? ... A $5 Amazon ebook that writes itself. All hail the Ori!
- twic 4y agoPreposterous. These are clearly UFO launching strips.
- doodlebugging 4y agoIt's pretty easy for some people with the benefit of 8000 years of learning to look at something like this and call it a cult. That must be the default description archaeologists use to describe a society that left no clear records written in the archaeologist's native tongue or one that can easily help them understand the culture that lived during that time or that built those structures. I originally read this article when it was posted to BBC news last week. I was not able to come to the same conclusion about this being some kind of cult. Cult to me has negative connotations. I would describe these people more charitably and probably more accurately as inhabitants who used local materials to construct buildings and structures intended to help them manage their local resources - food supplies, animals both wild and domesticated, protection from heat and cold, etc. The mustatils themselves look like efficient pens for animals raised for consumption and the fact that there are so many scattered in such a large area, where we also see evidence of many people living together tells me that these mustatils were probably meat markets. The existence of skulls of the goats, cattle, and gazelles just tells me what they had managed to capture, control, or domesticate. People have to eat. Another thing really chaps my ass here as the author uses ridiculously irrelevant hyperbole to describe one of the mustatil in terms of the Eiffel Tower that make no sense to a deep thinker. >Some of the mustatils weigh as much as 12,000 tonnes; more than the Eiffel Tower. What? A mustatil is a collection of rocks. When you put enough rocks together you can end up with something that weighs a lot. Their dumbass statement makes it sound like building a structure out of individual rocks that collectively ended up weighing more than a large modern steel structure was a major accomplishment. I disagree. I think it was an ordinary response to the need to keep a good food supply close to their settlements. I picture the people who lived here as industrious people who had all the skills needed to survive in the climate at the time and a good understanding not only of local materials, but of how to use those materials to their advantage. Later peoples in the area carved massive buildings into solid sandstone. Their predecessors were not ignorant cave men stumbling about. Instead, they were bright enough to be able to lay out plans for large structures and then to build them by doing exactly what we would do today. They would use their muscles and reach down and pick up rocks of many sizes and over a period of time they would be able to stack enough together to accomplish their goal. I don't know whether they used animals to help drag the larger stones or rolled them along the ground on sleds or even how they did it. The fact is that they built it one rock at a time and in the end they had a well-organized collection of rocks that weighed about as much (if you believe an archeologist's estimate) as the Eiffel Tower which was itself constructed one piece of steel at a time and held together with bolts or rivets. Again, that is the way you build something that starts off small and ends up huge. I hope they keep digging out there and that they catalog things and geo-reference everything as they go and that one day they can tell me what the last guy to live there had for supper based on the composition of the most recent coprolite found in the most recently dated septic pit. I just don't think they need to start right off describing something as a cult and making it sound mysterious that people would slaughter their food animals near where the animals were penned and eat the carcass somewhere else. How many of you bring a goat head home from the grocery store?
- crikeyjoe 4y ago
- wuliwong 4y agoIt is funny that they use Stonehenge as the metric for being old. I know it's the BBC...but still... Stonehenge is much younger than what they say this site in Saudi Arabia is and there are FAR older sites than either of these in that region of the world (Middle East). >This is important because it is evidence of a highly organised, cultic society, much earlier than was previously thought – predating Islam in the region by 6,000 years. Another weird comparison to the date of the origin of Islam. As if that was previously the oldest thing from that region.
- AlotOfReading 4y agoThe founding of Islam is quite an important date in Arabian archeology, because it was illegal to excavate pre-Islamic sites until the 1960s and even today there's less funding and support for these kinds of sites.
- tomrod 4y agoReally? Wasn't Tutankhamun;s unearthing from the early 1900s?
- ggm 4y agoEgypt was run as a french language, but british protectorate. It did not achieve full independence until after the suez crisis of 1956. It has a sizable coptic minority. (French because the egyptian rulers considered french modernising and much as Ataturk adopted western dress and alphabet, the Egyptians favoured french language to "modernise" their state) Technically, Egypt was a secular state until 1980 when Islam became the official state religion. Saudi Arabia was part of the Turkish Empire, until after WW1. The modern Saudi State, and islamic rules on Archeology did not apply across much of the earler 20th century, or was simply disregarded by western archeologists. Iraq, Iran, Syria and Jordan and Lebanon have extensive archeological sites which clearly pre-date the rise of Islam.
- AlotOfReading 4y agoTutankhamun was buried in Egypt, not Arabia. Egyptian archaeology is considered its own, separate specialty with a different history and different rules / norms. Take this as the opinion of someone who isn't an Arabian archaeologist, but researchers working in the peninsula have long had to deal with the sensitive issue of pre-islamic sites. Getting access is still a bit difficult today (especially Yemen) and most of the leading researchers are careful to be politically well-connected and avoid stepping on too many toes.
- phonescreen_man 4y agoPutting the cult in culture since 6000bce
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- fuzzfactor 4y agoWoudn't vestiges of every unexplained culture that predates Stonehenge seem mysterious and cult-like by now?
- IncRnd 4y agoWhy is the implication a religious activity when bones are found? Was the idea of an abattoir considered? In a few thousand years, if there are even remains from today's slauterhouses, will rival cults be discussed? The cult that only killed chickens and the cult that only killed cows?
- boringg 4y agoI feel sorry for anyone who has to dig up our current civilization. Imagine digging up nuclear waste and hoping it is some grand sarcophagus or treasure. Worse yet all the landfills.
- lkrubner 4y agoThis place is not a place of honor. No highly esteemed deed is commemorated here. Nothing valued is here. What is here was dangerous and repulsive to us. This message is a warning about danger.
- IncRnd 4y ago"Zahi Hawass quotes an example of a curse: 'Cursed be those who disturb the rest of a Pharaoh. They that shall break the seal of this tomb shall meet death by a disease that no doctor can diagnose.'" [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Curse_of_the_pharaohs#Tomb_curses https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Curse_of_the_pharaohs#Tomb_cur...
- xvilka 4y agoGood point, if those who will dig it out are anything like us, it will only instigate even more curiosity.
- wchar_t 4y agoImagine all the adult toys that would be dug up. Fertility cult or something.
- Tagbert 4y ago
- lkrubner 4y agoFor perspective, here is a cult the Neanderthals were running 175,000 years ago: https://www.newscientist.com/article/2090183-neanderthals-built-mystery-underground-circles-175000-years-ago/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/2090183-neanderthals-bu... By comparison, Stonehenge happened yesterday, and this other cult was the day before yesterday.
- 1123581321 4y agoThat looks like what a bunch of stupid kids might do in a cave today. Humans haven't changed.
- fuzzfactor 4y agoI would estimate this one as more of a cult phenomenon, not the local mainstream Neanderthal culture. After all, what do hominids do in caves, anyway? They get away from the crowd and it could be an exclusive location where only the true "cave men" held their business meetings, smoked cigars, and stuff like that. OTOH it could have just been teenagers trying to be rambunctious without getting caught. I doubt they were allowed to break off stalagmites just anywhere. Either way a truly subterranean non-mainstream sub-culture intentionally differentiated by its members.
- bergenty 4y agoThose are just… stalagmites. There’s nothing to signify it was made by Neanderthals and that article mentions nothing about the structures.
- twic 4y agoStalagmites, but not just stalagmites (my emphasis): > In one chamber, 336 metres from the cave entrance, are enigmatic structures – including a ring 7 metres across – built from stalagmites snapped from the cave floor. Predating modern humans: > Natural limestone growths have begun to cover parts of the structure, so by dating these growths a team led by Jacques Jaubert at the University of Bordeaux could work out an approximate age for the stalagmite constructions. > They are roughly 175,000 years old, which means they easily predate the arrival of modern humans in Europe. They were built at a time when Neanderthals were the only hominins in the region.
- doodlebugging 4y agoSome links to related papers on mustatils, the subject of the article. [0](https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/antiquity/article/mustatils-cult-and-monumentality-in-neolithic-northwestern-arabia/80E2AD8B538C268E7CA5C3C29CB4EC52 https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/antiquity/article/mu...) [1](https://www.ancient-origins.net/news-history-archaeology/mustatil-0015260 https://www.ancient-origins.net/news-history-archaeology/mus...) [2](https://www.archaeology.wiki/blog/2020/09/01/vast-stone-monuments-constructed-in-arabia-7000-years-ago/ https://www.archaeology.wiki/blog/2020/09/01/vast-stone-monu...) EDIT: I grabbed a few screenshots from Google Earth to show examples of rock structures found around Khaybar, Saudi Arabia. [3] It looks like the article is correct in that there are many ancient rock structures around Khaybar. I didn't find any of the ones from the articles above but it is apparent that the local people built these from rock that was within a few meters of the structure since you can easily see on many of them that the immediate vicinity is free of rock. The keyhole features are very common. Their orientations appear to be random. [3](https://imgur.com/a/Qad9T7V https://imgur.com/a/Qad9T7V) Enjoy!
- twic 4y agoIt drives me absolutey potty that there are no scale bars in the wide and aerial pictures. I have no idea if the rocks they're made of are centimetres or metres across, and can't judge the overall size at all!
- ck2 4y agoAre cults really ever "mysterious"? Just a way to control people. The original politics. Much easier to make up woo-woo and make people think they better go along with it. The entire concept survives to this day via organized religion, well actually any kind of religion but abrahamic are the most obvious forms of tricking people they better go with the flow.
- nxmnxm99 4y ago“Religion is to control people” is such a played out and lazy POV.
- prmoustache 4y agoReligions are mostly a way for people to overcome the fear of death. Religious books, practices and leaders are used to control people or justify laws using said fear as a lever.
- nxmnxm99 4y agoAnd atheists are enlightened brave warriors who face death head on, right?
- UberFly 4y agoLots of things predate Stonehenge. Come on BBC.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- permo-w 4y agoI agree that it's a bit silly and pop-sciencey, but it is a cultural reference point for their British target audience
- boffinAudio 4y agoThere are far more interesting sites in Australia that could change our understanding of pre-history. Just look up the common art that is found in Narwala Gabarnmung, Australia and Gobekli Tepe, Turkey. That alone is enough to re-write what we think we know about agriculture ..
- verisimi 4y ago> Around me were more than 30 dwellings and tombs, and that was just a tiny fraction of the remains here. I tried to imagine the landscape as it may have been thousands of years ago: green, lush and teeming with people as they moved noisily round, herding goats and calling out to each other. When I read comments like that, I am reminded that changes in climate and terrain have always been going on. If we saw a green, lush environment turn to desert today, we would inevitably say it was global warming/climate change. I wonder what they blamed it on..
- permo-w 4y agoas far as I know, the climate change we're experiencing is at a far swifter rate than historical shifts, unless there was some sort of cataclysm
- verisimi 4y ago> Since no other animal's body parts were found, it led the team to deduce that these were sacrificial. "Sacrificial". I hate it when I read this sort if rubbish, sorry. It plays too the idea that I'm ancient times, when presumably things were harder, our ancestors indulged themselves in hocus pocus, being primitive, superstitious claptrap. Wouldn't it just be more honest to say "we don't know what the structures are" than play to these woeful stereotypes?
- Amezarak 4y agoWe have endless accounts of animal sacrifice across nearly every ancient culture from which we have either their own writing or the writing of other cultures who visited them. I doubt it began with the invention of writing.
- hutzlibu 4y agoHow many times has this trope to be repeated? Yes, some "ritual" sites might in fact have been dumbsters. But otherwise it feels very much like atheist mindset projection. To my knowledge all the "primitive" cultures and tribes we know of, are (or were) deeply entrenched in magical and ritualistic thinking in everyday life. The earliest written proofs are about religious topics. It therefore makes sense, to assume a religious background of sites, that look different and serve no obvious purpose.
- joshspankit 4y agoAnyone else think that the formula for BBC articles gets in the way of the information in a particularly mind-numbing way?