5 ms·
Google proposes moving ad business to Alphabet to keep regulators at bay
- seydor 4y agoAnd what will be google 's business?
- BbzzbB 4y agoFunnelling customers to Alphabet's advertisers.
- etempleton 4y agoI was going to say, isn't 90 percent(ish) of Google's revenue advertising and 80 percent(ish) of that search advertising? What is Google's business if not to sell ads?
- Zondartul 4y agoCollecting and selling user data is a business.
- corrral 4y agoLicense some kind of IP to Alphabet for a rate that happens to be exactly what their operating expenses are?
- impulser_ 4y agoThey would split the exchange side of their ad business from platform side, which is Google. That's the whole reason they are being sued because they run both sides of the ad marketplace. Google's business would be the same. Sell ad space.
- strongpigeon 4y agoTo add to that, the exchange is specifically for the display network, so websites and app that aren't Google properties. This part of Google, while still worth a couple billions in revenue, is an increasingly smaller part of the whole.
- AnotherTechie 4y agoBut if google makes this change, it will likely follow that other (more self-referential) companies might also follow.
- hassanahmad 4y agoThere should be some sort of rules that consider subsidiaries to be part of the parent company for regulatory purposes.
- xhkkffbf 4y agoAbsolutely. This doesn't seem like it would be any real change.
- charcircuit 4y agoSo have a completely separate company and then make a deal with that company to find them and give them office space in Google's office and give them access to their intranet.
- happyopossum 4y agoThere are. There are also rules about how subsidiaries can and can't cooperate, self-deal, and collude under various circumstances.
- blibble 4y agosomehow I think they'll be able to see through that one
- hackernewds 4y agoand yet they can't do anything about it. that's the gambit
- blibble 4y agocountries are literally writing legislation to explicitly target google they are more than capable of modifying it to come up with whatever corporate laundering they can invent
- nojito 4y agomore info at the WSJ https://www.wsj.com/articles/justice-department-ramps-up-google-probe-with-heavy-focus-on-ad-tools-11580904003 https://www.wsj.com/articles/justice-department-ramps-up-goo...
- telotortium 4y agohttps://archive.ph/L9NwY https://archive.ph/L9NwY
- outside1234 4y agodo they really think we are that stupid?
- rdudek 4y agoUs? No. But regulators probably...
- amelius 4y agoWill they keep the data siloed?
- lokar 4y agoDepending on the "bet" (alphabet company) there can be little to zero separation between them and Google (full access to internal systems, etc) or it can be run as a fully separate company with no special access. This will depend on the details.
- amelius 4y agoI mean, what will regulators think if Google Search and Alphabet share user data, but not responsibilities?
- Willish42 4y agoAm I missing something here? Ars Technica article from OP is dated 7/8/2022 but the referenced source is from February 2020 > The US Justice Department is gearing up for a possible antitrust lawsuit against Google's ad business, and a new report from The Wall Street Journal [1] outlines a "concession" Google is proposing in response to the investigation. Google might split up some of its ad business and move it to Google's parent company, Alphabet. Even the archive link [2] shows this is from over two years ago from when archives were taken [1] https://www.wsj.com/articles/justice-department-ramps-up-google-probe-with-heavy-focus-on-ad-tools-11580904003 https://www.wsj.com/articles/justice-department-ramps-up-goo... [2] https://archive.ph/L9NwY https://archive.ph/L9NwY
- strongpigeon 4y agoIndeed, I can't seem to find the crucial part from Ars in the WSJ article, namely the : "As part of one offer, Google has proposed splitting parts of its business that auctions and places ads on websites and apps into a separate company under the Alphabet umbrella, some of the people said. That entity could potentially be valued at tens of billions of dollars, depending on what assets it contained."
- jefftk 4y agoArs accidently linked the wrong WSJ article. They meant to link today's https://www.wsj.com/articles/google-offers-concessions-to-fend-off-u-s-antitrust-lawsuit-11657296591 https://www.wsj.com/articles/google-offers-concessions-to-fe... As part of one offer, Google has proposed splitting parts of its business that auctions and places ads on websites and apps into a separate company under the Alphabet umbrella
- Willish42 4y agoaha! Thank you for figuring this out and taking the time to reply
- AnotherTechie 4y agoI'm genuinely shocked at the lack of quality discussion here. Did anyone actually try reading the article? The concept here is not to obfuscate things but rather to de-couple Google's search engine and Google's Adwords products. Most opinion in this thread is "lol alphabet is google" which is apparent to everyone. Of course they are functionally the same entity, but someone whose job depends on it has proposed this as a solution. Are we really to assume that they just woke up and decided to turn their brain off? There's clearly going to be some actual change that attempts to satisfy regulators here. We can look at history and possibly speculate how this looks, and we can also identify a few things. 1. Google is a search engine 2. Google the company sells AdWords as a product to advertisers. 3. Google benefits tremendously from owning both of these things. Here's my take: Google wants to decouple their search and ads teams, move ads to a separate entity that works as an advertising marketplace, generate revenue there. Search will now sell its advertising space, likely in a way that can also be taxed, to the highest bidder rather than itself. I also predict that google will want to pressure other platforms, which will enable them to break into other markets. META is the second largest advertiser online, but they do all of their advertising on two platforms, Instagram and Facebook. If google can push for the forced decoupling, then it will likely also apply to META. They can then swing their AdsWords product on top of FB/IG and start to eat back some of the traffic that they have been losing in recent years[1]. It's a bit of a gamble, but Google is betting on their AdWords software to be stronger, and a lot of the history would agree. Also, now that I think about it, this has pretty big implications for user data sharing cross platform. Now you have to formalize the way that personal information is exchanged for the purpose of advertising. [1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/242549/digital-ad-market-share-of-major-ad-selling-companies-in-the-us-by-revenue/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/242549/digital-ad-market...
- blfr 4y agoYeah, a Chinese wall like that worked pretty wall for journalism back when it was a profitable endeavor. Google certainly is.
- dylan604 4y agoyes, because no Alphabet employee will ever talk to a Googs employee where one happens to work in ads and the other in search. Those conversations will never happen to discuss things that could work for the betterment of either/both. do you really think that Alphabet would do anything to lower their profits by making ads less viable and search less ad driven?
- gfxgirl 4y agothere are at least two if not 3 or more ad divisions at google 1) ads on search results 2) visual ads (banner ads), used to be double-click 3) ads on Android apps personally I want the search ads. If I search for plummer or doctor or even database or jeans or apple pie, I want to see ads I don't think search and ads based on the query should be decoupled. That will be arguably worse for me, not better banner ads and mobile ads can die in a fire
- paraph1n 4y agoWhy do you want to see ads in your search results? Wouldn't you rather see results based on quality rather than who can pay the most?
- judge2020 4y agoWould you be fine to pay for a search engine that does that, then? Without a direct payment or ads, that search wouldn’t be possible. Imagine how many people primarily use Desktop YouTube and have been watching since 2006, but have always had an ad blocker and have never seen a single video ad. There’s probably actual hundreds of millions there that have been ‘lost’ over the decade. It’s basically profiteering with the only difference being that Google doesn’t care because allowing ad-blockers increases their market dominance.
- gfxgirl 4y agoSome x-googler's started a paid search engine https://neeva.com/ https://neeva.com/ They're hoping you'll pay $50 a year
- gfxgirl 4y agoFirst off, Google already tries to do show quality and the clearly mark the ads so you can skip them and go to non-ads Second, even a search engine that doesn't take ads does not know that the content it's scanning aren't ads. So you'll still see the ads, it will just be more hidden. 9 out of 10 product review sites are all effectively paid ads AFAICT. Third, when I search for a product I want to know what's available. Companies tell you what's available via ads. Maybe it's because I'm old but before the internet we all used to buy and subscribe to magazines. We did it not just for the articles but also for the ads, to see what was available. BYTE (https://archive.org/details/byte-magazine https://archive.org/details/byte-magazine) , Compute! (https://archive.org/details/compute-magazine https://archive.org/details/compute-magazine), Creative Computing (https://archive.org/details/creativecomputing https://archive.org/details/creativecomputing), Wired (https://archive.org/details/eu_Wired-1995-12_OCR https://archive.org/details/eu_Wired-1995-12_OCR), PC Magazine (https://archive.org/details/pc_magazine https://archive.org/details/pc_magazine). They were all full of ads and we bought them partly for the ads. Same with gaming magazines. I don't have a problem with ads, I only have a problem with tracking. Showing an add based on my immediate search or based on the content of the page the ad is one doesn't bother me. (although intrusive ads do bother me)