9 ms·
Amazon has a book piracy problem
- codeslave13 4y agoAmazon has a piracy/counterfeit problem. And has for a very long time. I have basically stopped buying there as much as possible. My current trend is to use them as a search engine then got to the companies site. At this point you might as well shop alibaba as thats where half the crap is from anyway.
- randcraw 4y agoA better search engine (esp for used books) is BookFinder: https://bookfinder.com https://bookfinder.com. Between it and Goodreads, which has better ratings anyway, you can avoid Amazon entirely.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- simcop2387 4y agoThat's not avoiding them entirely, but it does avoid their store front for discovery. GoodReads is owned wholly by Amazon.
- solardev 4y ago...and aside from Goodreads (which is owned by Amazon), bookfinder is also hosted behind Amazon Cloudfront. No matter where you go and what you do, Amazon wins, lol. There's https://www.indiebound.org/ https://www.indiebound.org/ at least, which lets you search the inventory of local bookstores. I've also had good luck ordering used books from https://www.thriftbooks.com/ https://www.thriftbooks.com/ instead of Amazon.
- fernly 4y agoBookfinder is hella useful but sometimes, especially for pre-ISBN books, https://www.addall.com/ https://www.addall.com/ has wider coverage.
- dhosek 4y agoI’ve been using bookfinder since it was mxbf.com There have been some long out of print hard to find books that I was able to find thanks to them (although in one case early in the site’s lifetime, I found a book I’d been searching for for over a decade and placed an order only to have the bookseller discover that they apparently had either sold the book, lost it or had it stolen). It’s my go-to for used books.
- elcapitan 4y agoWith books, Amazon has become the opposite of a search engine for me. I have to use external resources to actually find the right titles, to enter them 1:1 into Amazon search to get to the books. Context based discovery has become next to impossible (which I used it before a lot for). Something must have changed in their indexing algorithm a while ago. Also many results are flooded with garbage, like some ridiculous "notebooks" with similar titles to the searched book or product name.
- diamondap 4y agoAmazon kind of gave up on discovery, at least for books, when they realized they could make more money running ads. I sell books on Amazon. Years ago, their book pages had two carousels of "similar titles" on each book detail page. Similar titles were selected by some pretty helpful algorithms based on what purchasers of the current title had also purchased, as well as some other secret sauce. At the time, ads weren't very prominent, and they were profitable for authors. I could buy them for 5 cents a click and even if only one in fifty clicks resulted in a purchase, I made money. Now, most of the algorithmic recommendations are gone, and for many ads, Amazon suggests bids of $2.50 or more per click. Those clicks bring in money whether Amazon makes a sale or not. To some extent, they've given up on matching customers to the best or most suitable products. Why should they work that hard if ads are more profitable? They've also had problems with piracy and counterfeits, as mentioned in this article. I heard a radio interview with a Target executive a couple years ago where a journalist said, "Amazon is underpricing you on everything. How do you plan to stay in business?" She said, "We vet every product on our shelves. We know who makes it and where, whether it's legit, and whether it contains lead paint and parts kids can choke on. Try to find that info on Amazon." The reporter didn't seem too impressed at the time, but the Target woman clearly saw where things were going. As the quality, authenticity, and reliability of Amazon's merchandise has declined, people are starting to notice. I'm not sure this is a problem they will ever have the will to fix. While they break even or lose money on genuine goods they have to ship for free, profits from third party sellers and Chinese drop shippers keep the retail operation afloat.
- rmbyrro 4y ago
- antonymy 4y agoI'm the same way. I used to say "at least you can rely on books bought on Amazon" but now you can't even say that much. Alibris or eBay are more reliable online retailers for books nowadays.
- chucky_z 4y agoAlibris is really great, and I've gotten a few hand written notes from bookstores I've bought from. Even if they're fake I'm a sucker for these kinds of things.
- iasay 4y agoI do similar. I use Amazon to find the ISBN number of the book I want then search for it on ebay and buy the cheapest second hand copy.
- HarryHirsch 4y agoBesides, on Ebay you usually get a photograph of the actual book or the seller is a known quantity. No such luck with Amazon.
- dhc02 4y agoYou can also go to bookshop.org, buy the book there (usually for about the same price as Amazon), and most of the profit goes to a local bookstore (which you can choose) instead of a big search engine with warehouses.
- nikanj 4y agoIs it a problem though, when it's not affecting their business in any way?
- iLoveOncall 4y agoI have thousands of orders on Amazon and have never received something different than what I expected. Have I received items that were crap? Sure, because I chose to go with the noname item from the random seller for cost reasons. If it’s unusable I just return it. That said, I don’t think I have even a 1% return rate. Buy items with a few reviews and read the top reviews instead of only trusting the star system and you’ll get exactly what you paid for 99% of the time (and will get your money back the remaining 1% of the time).
- nirvdrum 4y agoIt's more involved than that. You can buy a brand name product shipped and sold by Amazon.com and still end up with a counterfeit item because Amazon mixes inventory with third party sellers.
- KerrAvon 4y agoWhat amazes me is that the FTC doesn't address the problem. You'd think they'd care. This has been going on for years; you really can't tell whether you're buying genuine products or not on Amazon anymore. I've stopped buying anything where I actually care about the provenance (like power tools and anything personal hygiene related) on Amazon.
- mountainb 4y agoThe FTC does do some things, but below a certain threshold it doesn’t bother. There is lots and lots and lots of crime that does not get prosecuted or otherwise litigated.
- hellcow 4y agoSurely one of the largest businesses in America facilitating fraud en masse has to meet said threshold.
- bwb 4y agoif the big 5 publishers and others would complain it would prob help. At some point its about the amount of damages and if they can make a statement. Things move slow so it could be coming...
- b8 4y agohttps://isbn.nu/ https://isbn.nu/ is what I use to find the lowest price for a book. I saw it on Aaron Swartz's weblog I think.
- brownbat 4y agoCounterfeit DVD box sets are pretty rampant. For example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Zwa9uKIYhM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Zwa9uKIYhM I remember getting obviously burned DVDs run through terrible label makers back in the day. Now they're copying all the the art and packaging for box sets. I'm both impressed at the work they put in, and also confused why they occasionally leave obvious errors like typos on the box after all that work.
- newman8r 4y agoAnd if you want fresh product for any reason, ordering directly from the company is the best way to ensure that.
- beej71 4y agoAmazon makes money from every pirated book sold. Maybe book publishers lack the clout of the music publishers?
- dhosek 4y agoThat seems likely. Book publishers are also less exploitative than record companies. If you look at the copyright notice in a book, with rare exceptions it will be Copyright 2022 by A. U. Thor, while on music it will be Copyright 2022 by Exploitive Records, Inc. Then there’s finances. When a publisher pays you an advance on royalties, if your book never sells enough to earn those royalties, you will not have to pay back the advance (although, for a two-book deal, it might reduce the effective amount of money you get on the second book, depending on how the contract is written, which is why a good agent is necessary). The publisher shoulders all the production, editing, distribution and publicity costs. With a recording contract, all the costs of recording are deducted from the artist’s royalties and many bands have had a hit record where they ended up owing the record company money. And for all of that, as noted above, the record company claims ownership of the recording that the band paid for. TV/movie production ends up being somewhere between the two. Not as exploitative as the record companies, not as genteel as the publishers.
- iasay 4y agoIf they got rid of marketplace sellers and actually got control over their supply chain then they might actually go up in people's opinion. However Amazon and AWS isn't about doing a good job, it's about doing a mediocre job and making everyone happy though apologies. And that's why I'm still using them. They are a good balance.
- themitigating 4y agoWhat does aws have to do with this article, piracy, or the retail side of Amazon
- iasay 4y agoThe same soulless automation running the show.
- hourago 4y agoThat is going to be the fight of the next generation. Inappropriate videos on YouTube for kids, extremist propaganda in Facebook or fake products in Amazon all have that soulless automation as main culprit. (Let's not talk about Roblox) Cost goes against resilience and quality. You can automate things to a limit until everything breaks down.
- themitigating 4y agoWhom?
- __mharrison__ 4y agoNot sure why enabling piracy is a good balance. Care to expound on that?
- warkdarrior 4y agoInformation just wants to be free, even if you call it "piracy."
- duped 4y agoI'm surprised there aren't class action lawsuits targeting the FAANGs for this kind of thing
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- V__ 4y agoAmazon has shown time and time again that they don't care. They don't care about fake reviews, counterfeit products, cheap Chinese crap, their workforce, or anything really as long as customers keep on buying.
- m463 4y agoI wonder if they are jumping the shark? I intensely dislike the paid search results or sponsored recommendations. The nonsense-name brands that are either chinese or secretly amazon that prevent brand names from showing up (and many good brands ship counterfeits). The fake reviews. The popup "extended warranty" screens where if you close the tab/window... the item doesn't make it to your shopping basket. I remember when I had an iphone, and a few years ago when apple did not prevent abuse I just stopped installing apps. The app market had jumped the shark and become a cesspool. Nice apps I liked were bought and monetized in unethical ways, and apple didn't care. For example, I had an app called gas cubby, which let me locally - on the phone - keep track of all my vehicles. I could enter detailed information about each car such as year, make, model, vin, insurance policy, gas purchases, oil changes and the like. It would tell you gas mileage and remind you of upcoming maintenance. One day, the app was updated and all my local data was uploaded to the cloud! Another app, camscanner plus purchased by tencent basically did the same thing.
- nikanj 4y agoMy general feeling is that commerce has jumped the shark. You can make so much more money with scamming, the honest businesses are few and far apart. And nigh impossible to identify. It doesn't feel like a platform problem, more of a societal fabric unraveling.
- AlexandrB 4y agoIf there's no enforcement of anti-fraud laws or consumer protections, why not scam people? As you said, it's more profitable than legitimate business. We live in the golden age of fraud.
- vannevar 4y agoThis is just one example of a broader problem with Amazon. It has become essentially a vehicle for automated salesbots to push anonymously manufactured goods of all kinds---not just books---to as many buyers as possible, drowning out storefronts for identifiable manufacturers and retailers who might have legal right via copyright or licensing to sell similar, often higher-quality versions.
- eikenberry 4y agoThis is what copyright was actually for... Publishers would put out a book, it'd get popular then cut-rate copies would swamp the market. Copyright was done to protect the publisher from this sort of abuse (and secondarily the author, as the publisher was their only means of reaching an audience). This should be the top (and only IMO) priority of CC enforcement instead of going after sci-hub and the like.
- ptero 4y agoOriginally. But then publishers got greedy ("greed is forever") and instead of a relatively short term of protection before becoming public domain we now have stupid multi-decade restrictions. Those prevent us from printing good out of print books and do not give any benefit to either publisher or the author.
- plaguepilled 4y agoI agree with this. It would be nice to have a reduced grace period for books before they're public domain - something like 40 years seems reasonable to me.
- visarga 4y ago40 years seems excessive. I searched a bit for some reference > We find that almost all books, regardless of category, peak in the first 15 weeks after publication https://epjdatascience.springeropen.com/articles/10.1140/epjds/s13688-018-0135-y https://epjdatascience.springeropen.com/articles/10.1140/epj... A graph with sales per week/week after publication https://media.springernature.com/lw685/springer-static/image/art%3A10.1140%2Fepjds%2Fs13688-018-0135-y/MediaObjects/13688_2018_135_Fig9_HTML.gif?as=webp https://media.springernature.com/lw685/springer-static/image... Seems that 2 years after publication the number of copies sold per week declines by two orders of magnitude compared to the peak.
- plaguepilled 4y agoI think I like that idea more. My lean to 40 years is just to satisfy the needs of some academic IPs. I suppose it wouldn't be difficult to categorise IP duration though
- WoodenChair 4y agoI'm also a Manning author and this also happened to me a couple years ago. Amazon was allowing a counterfeit Kindle edition of Classic Computer Science Problems in Python to pose as legitimate on my own book's page! Only emailing Jeff got a solution. Manning seemed powerless to solve the problem themselves. I still have some bad reviews as a result of that counterfeit Kindle edition that plague my book page. Totally unfair! Here's my original Tweet thread about it: https://twitter.com/davekopec/status/1302578592552022018 https://twitter.com/davekopec/status/1302578592552022018 Here's the Hacker News discussion about it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24399301 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24399301
- clumsysmurf 4y agoI can understand how physical copies of counterfeit books get co-mingled with legit inventory, whether they are printed from PDF or "re-covered" from destroyed copies ... but how does one simply upload a counterfeit Kindle edition at all?
- __mharrison__ 4y agoOne simply uploads it to Amazon. They (Amazon) don't vet it and the pirate gets to ride on your coattails. All of this pirating would be easy to prevent, but one wonders why they even enable this?
- copperx 4y agoWhat's Jeff's email? I need to right a few wrongs.
- iLoveOncall 4y agojeff@amazon.com
- JonSchneider 4y agoJeff has moved on, though.
- Mixtape 4y agoSlightly off-topic, but I've recently heard from some corners of the collecting world that this is a major issue for video game resellers on Amazon (and other platforms) as well. People regularly receive flash carts with stuck-on labels (i.e. stolen trademarks) on them and a pirated ROM running on counterfeited hardware. Unfortunately, it's nearly impossible in some cases to identify a well-crafted fake from a genuine copy before purchase, and the burden is thus placed on Amazon to take action against sellers of the products. Given that the loss of one consumer in a relatively niche yet very competitive market will not deal significant damage to Amazon's overall profits, (and that Amazon can feasibly shift blame towards the seller,) the issue persists. All of this is to say that the idea of pirated books proliferating on Amazon is entirely feasible if electronic devices can be so successfully faked. However, what's not lost on me is the irony of Amazon, a marketplace whose initial success was anchored by trust in its ability to deliver books, falling victim to such schemes in this specific market space.
- ilrwbwrkhv 4y agoI just cancelled prime this year. It has reached a point where I just directly shop from AliExpress when required or I buy from local stores.
- not2b 4y agoCan't the ripped off authors and publishers sue Amazon for big money for this? Or maybe band together and bring a class action suit?
- __mharrison__ 4y agoPerhaps. Someone who responded to my original tweet opined that Amazon and Google could kill the pirate market easily. It doesn't appear to be something that either wants to do.
- Barrin92 4y agoNowadays I do what François recommends in his tweet. Go to our local bookstore and order from there. The extent to which Amazon enables this kind of behavior and presumably also profits from it and the extent to which they ignore the problem altogether shouldn't be supported. Speaks to a larger problem as well, the excuses platforms make to not do due diligence when it comes to what is being sold and the lack of ability to talk to a real person on the other end quickly.
- dhc02 4y agoYou can also choose your favorite local bookstore on bookshop.org and order from there.
- __mharrison__ 4y agoAuthor of the article posting in the tweet. Happy to answer any questions. (Or discuss technical book authoring in general).
- dogsboywonder 4y agoI like how that article’s thumbnail was generated by DALL-E lol.
- __mharrison__ 4y agoI was going to use one with Jeff's face...
- mkw2000 4y agoI recently purchased a book that I was really looking forward to from Amazon and received a counterfeit version with the correct cover but complete nonsense inside. It wasn't the book I purchased at all just a scam. It was super frustrating and I returned it and will not be purchasing books from Amazon ever again, but I wonder what was even the purpose of the scam? Isn't everyone just going to get annoyed and return it? What would the seller even get out of this?
- notpushkin 4y agoIf Amazon doesn't hold money in an escrow (which, apparently, is not the case), the scammers get a free loan and they can run away with the money at some point. Also, I think some % doesn't return counterfeit items, even the most garbage ones.
- Johnny555 4y agoOne of the suggestions to get a legit book is to visit a local bookstore -- I wonder for how many people that's a valid suggestion? My nearest bookstore is around 40 minutes away (which these days means it's around $5 in gas just to drive there), and it's a Barnes and Noble, not an independent store. Until a couple years ago I had an independent shop downtown, but they closed suddenly (before COVID)
- Spivak 4y agoAnd independent bookstore doesn’t even mean much to you because the whole reason to care that it’s independent is because it functions as a community space. All but a tiny sliver of the book profits are still getting slurped out of your community by the publisher anyway. If it’s not more convenient or cheaper, and you’re not getting value from the space existing then you might as well just buy from Amazon. It’s like some people got “buy local” hammered into their brains without any thought as to when doing so is actually beneficial.
- autoexec 4y ago> And independent bookstore doesn’t even mean much to you because the whole reason to care that it’s independent is because it functions as a community space. Buying from a local independent bookstore is good for more than just supporting them for providing a community space. Buying from your local bookstore also means giving your money (at least in part) to members within your local economy. It also means not giving your money (at least in part) to Amazon. Both of those things are a win.
- __mharrison__ 4y agoGetting self published books into local bookstores is more of a challenge. I know a few 6-7 figure authors who only sell from their own store. (Not that this prevents someone from posting their content on Amazon).
- susiecambria 4y agoThis. There's an indie in DC I used before I moved away and I still use them and rely on them for suggestions and doing a little homework for me. Would rather support a small, local business in the town where I lived for 20+ years. And, when my husband wants a particular book, the kids get a link to that shop and they know we don't do Amazon so they buy from the indie.
- was_a_dev 4y agoThis was an issue at my university last year. Some seller was downloading PhD theses for free from the university, and selling the as ebooks. They uploaded thousands of theses across several large fields. It lead to the university taking legal action to remove all infringing material off of Amazon.
- g42gregory 4y agoI try to stay within "ships and sold from Amazon" category. It's more expensive, but it's worth for me. If that's not available, I use "ships from Amazon by the original manufacturer" only. I did not encountered much problems that way. Certainly not with books. The Amazon Marketplace itself is dicey. It feels like you taking a serious gamble. Once I ordered a $100+ textbook from the 3rd party and received a cheap international edition from India instead. On return, the seller asked to ship it back to India for $60 - $80 cost to me. I called Amazon and they just refunded the whole purchase and dealt with the seller themselves. So, in the end, it was still Ok. But I really do watch that I buy only things that, at least, ship from Amazon itself.
- fernly 4y agoThis is crazy when you think that if you upload a YT video with 10 seconds of a Beatles song in it, the YT copyright engine will be on you in minutes, "demonetizing" your vid. YT can spot copyrighted audio and punish it automatically, while Amazon can't recognize a whole book including covers as a violation.
- saurik 4y agoYou are legally allowed to buy a book and resell it. If you look, many of the legitimate offers for books on Amazon that are "from the long tail" of content are coming the inventory of small book stores, both used and new. The issue is not that third parties are selling a book at all but that the book they are shipping is a third-party low-quality re-print of the book in question instead of an official copy, something you wouldn't know until you receive the book.
- egypturnash 4y agoI guess the RIAA has a lot more power to get noticed than booksellers…
- kupopuffs 4y agoIf only books made more money ohoho
- whimsicalism 4y agoThey also have no restrictions on emailing digital ebooks to Kindles.
- deckard1 4y agoWhich tech companies aren't benefiting from piracy? YouTube has entire movies, songs, etc. on their platform. Sure, they take them down with a DMCA submission (legit or not). But you can't deny that them feigning ignorance and the whack-a-mole nature of their pirated content hasn't benefited them greatly. It won't change until they get hit with massive fines. Amazon surely knows what they are doing. They don't care that brands are diluted or merchandise is authentic. Because that just ensures people trust AmazonBasics that much more. There are no downsides for Amazon.
- kmeisthax 4y agoThe flipside of this is that the utter and flippant disregard for the basic principles of copyright are also responsible for one of the biggest expansions of freedom of speech in human history. The legal liability for copyright infringement itself, imposed upon every "link in the chain", was enough to deter people from running "content" pipes; and there was no distinguishing factor between a "publisher" that actively decides what content to publish, and a "platform" which does not. CDA 230 and DMCA 512 invented this new legal category of platforms that facilitate speech but do not editorialize it, and gave them broad immunity from basically every legal challenge. There's an argument that came out of the Copyright Office a few years ago that DMCA 512 has been grossly misinterpreted by the courts. You see, because 512 immunity only applies to things done "at the direction of the user", the courts have decided that social media recommendation engines can be immunized from suit through the 512 safe harbor. However, if that same curation is done by a human instead of an automated system, then it's no longer "at the direction of the user"[0], and the site is a publisher rather than a platform. This is absolutely bananas and I can think of no other part of law where deliberately ignoring the crime or tort makes it less criminal or tortious. If the Copyright Office had its way, both of these activities - automated and manual curation - would take you out of your safe harbor. YouTube could host your videos, like Vimeo's pro tier, but it couldn't put them in search or on the home page unless it was willing to take on your copyright risk. Shopify could run your online store but you couldn't sell your products on Amazon. There's been other proposals to change the process by which companies get their safe harbor, too. The EU got rid of notice-and-takedown and replaced it with license[1]-and-notice-and-filtering. The criteria for who has to abide by the new system is very roughly the same "do they curate" standard the US Copyright Office wanted put into DMCA 512, with online marketplaces - among other things - explicitly exempted from the requirements. So now our dichotomy becomes a trichotomy of "host" (no liability), "platform" (must license and filter), and "publisher" (full liability). I'm not sure if the EU will ultimately be able to thread the needle on this. We haven't seen the full effects of EUCD Article 17 yet, but my gut instinct is that it both goes too far (targeted platforms will be overregulated) and not far enough (copyright holders will still have horrific piracy problems). [0] See Mavrix v. LiveJournal [1] This is technically a "best effort" standard - you are not required to actually obtain a license, since copyright holders could otherwise just refuse you one. However, unlike IETF standards, those words do not mean "lowest effort" in law. Serving EU regulators a water sandwich will likely not go well with them.
- biryani_chicken 4y agoIn some cases, Amazon does the counterfeit themselves: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HbxWGjQ2szQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HbxWGjQ2szQ
- kelnos 4y agoSo... I'm sure it's not as easy as I think it should be, but isn't this just a DMCA takedown notice away from getting fixed? As much as the DMCA is generally horrible and abused, this seems like an actually good use for it. Of course, the counterfeit seller can just create a new account, and then it becomes a game of whack-a-mole, but perhaps that could be grounds for a lawsuit against Amazon directly, for failing to rein in all the copyright infringement occurring on their platform. (Maybe even a class action, since this problem seems widespread.) Again, I'm sure this isn't easy or fun (or cheap) to do, but tweeting at people to not buy your book from Amazon seems to be... not all that useful a response?
- yalogin 4y agoDoes Amazon have an incentive to fix this? This is the equivalent of Facebook or Twitter removing all bots. In this case they are much more directly seeing revenue. The only people losing are the authors and manufacturers of the original product. I see consumers don’t care and in fact actively buy the lower priced item and are happy about it. If they were to fix it, they need a huge operation to create a system to identify, vet, enforce originality across every single product on their platform. It’s almost impossible at amazon’s scale. They will never do anything about it. May be this is a business opportunity for a new company to come in and provide as Amazon will surely not be able to replicate overnight.
- __mharrison__ 4y agoFor books, especially self-published books, this is not a hard problem. Google and Amazon could solve this sort of piracy in a week of they wanted to...
- AlexandrB 4y agoAmazon absolutely sucks for buying books. It's not just the counterfeits, but the way they now ship books in flimsy paper envelopes. The last book I ordered from Amazon (because it was not available at other retailers) was left on my porch, in a paper envelope, during a rainstorm. Book obviously got wet and now has that distinct "wavy" look.
- ta988 4y agoAmazon has a problem of over-optimization. They treated everything as tiny optimizable problems, including hiring. Now they hire only people that optimized themselves to pass the interviews, who then optimize to climb the ranks but don't bring that much to the behemoth. And it is the same for many of their products, optimized for artificial markers and slowly becoming irrelevant. The search engine of the store is a perfect illustration of that. And the sellers on the platform as well.
- euphetar 4y agoAmazon has a UI problem. Unless you have a kindle it's extremely hard to buy a book and just get the god damn epub file. It's so much harder than pirating the book that I am not surprised. A few times I had to do it too: I would buy the book in the store and then go download it from a pirate website because amazon UI is too much pain
- PufPufPuf 4y agoAmazon's UI is terrible for pretty much anything, and I'm surprised that it's the dominant store in so many countries. (Thankfully it's not in mine.)
- ThePowerOfFuet 4y ago@dang Can we please replace the URL with the actual one, rather than a tweet pointing to it? https://hairysun.com/amazons-book-piracy-problem.html https://hairysun.com/amazons-book-piracy-problem.html
- ksec 4y agoJudging from HN comments I guess it is not that well known in the US but Book Depository [1] ships worldwide. It was founded by a former Amazon employee and acquired by Amazon. [1] https://www.bookdepository.com https://www.bookdepository.com