3 ms·
>If you don't invade your neighbors, you have nothing to fear from NATO. You have to be kidding about this. Have you ever heard of Serbia, Iraq, Afghanistan?
by tsimionescu 4y ago
>If you don't invade your neighbors, you have nothing to fear from NATO.
You have to be kidding about this. Have you ever heard of Serbia, Iraq, Afghanistan?
In fact, NATO has never defended an invaded country before Ukraine - the record is all aggression.
Edit: I should mention that the aggression against Serbia was probably morally justified - what they were doing in Kosovo was truly despicable.
- lovich 4y agoAlright bud this is just propaganda if you’re mixing Afghanistan in there. Iraq was straight aggression and Serbia I admit to not being too knowledgeable about, but Afghanistan was in direct response to 9/11 and not handing over bin laden. If that’s considered being an aggressor then there’s not much point in using the word anymore
- the_af 4y agoAt least if you read Wikipedia's summary, there is disagreement about whether the US was legally justified to go to war against Afghanistan and topple its government because of the al-Qaeda attack. It's not clear cut.
- lovich 4y agoWhat happened post invasion and whether that fit the notion of NATO members definition for legality is definitely up for debate but we’re there any serious considerations that invoking article 5 in light of the attacks was not legitimate? I’d need to see some documentation on that as, as far as I am aware, every NATO member responded to the call and did not leave NATO
- tsimionescu 4y agoAfghanistan was asking for proof that Bin Laden was to blame, and had offered to set up some common courts to decide on the matter - as was their right as a sovereign nation. The invasion of Serbia was much more morally justified, as it helped stop a genocide that Slobodan Milosevic was committing against the Islamic Albanian minority, mainly in Kosovo.
- lovich 4y agoThe only rights you have a sovereign nation are what you can support by strength of arms or diplomacy. Rights are protected by common governments and there is no world government both the US and Afghanistan were party to. As far as NATO is concerned another party punched a member in the face and and the defensive pact responded as they had laid out in their public treaties. If other nations want to construe that as not a real attack and the defensive pact needed to take it slow and capitulate the the internal legal demands of an aggressor state, that’s a position they can take. They are however, going to be repeatedly surprised when NATO doesn’t take that stance under advisement
- tsimionescu 4y agoThere is no way to construe the Afghani government as an aggressor in an attack involving 15-20 people who were led by a Saudi noble who happened to live in Afghanistan, and who wasn't even established at the time as the definite mastermind. Furthermore, there was significant internal pressure in Afghanistan to give up Bin Laden, including from the main religious authorities. Instead of waiting for this to Halen, the US simply invaded, barely a few weeks after the attack. NATO acquiesced to the invasion because the USA was out for blood, and their closest toadies weren't about to get in the cross hairs.
- lovich 4y agoThat is a viewpoint none of the NATO members shared or they wouldn’t have responded to the Article 5. There’s no ifs ands or buts about it. Their end decision was that it was a valid reason to attack as a bloc.
- tsimionescu 4y agoAgain, most NATO counties and leaders are US sycophants. That they acquiesced to an obvious absurdity to do the bidding of the USA is not surprising, and definitely not evidence that the arguments weren't absurd. Most of the same countries beleieved the CIA fabrications about weapons of mass destruction in Iraq as well. Look outside the NATO sphere and very few countries actually agree with the US justification for the war.
- jollybean 4y agoThis is wrong and cynical. 1) The issue of 'NATO Aggression' vis-a-vis Russia is propaganda. The Russians are not 'afraid of NATO' - we know this, they know we know this, we know they know we know - and yes it goes on. Notice that they now have 1000Km of 'NATO Border' with Finland, does that change the equation? 'Oh, that's fine' Putin said a few days ago. 2) That NATO Article 5 has not been used is more or less evidence that it is working. 3) Iraq War 1, which might arguably be a NATO-driven war, was utterly justified, Saddam invaded Kuwait, it was bad. 4) Intervention in Afghanistan of 'some kind' was also justified, and initially there were hardly any serious military action, it was a mess, and therefore probably a mistake, but that's very different than Soviet involvement there. 5) Iraq War 2 was an American, not NATO enterprise. Russia's conquest of Ukraine is blatantly Imperialist, this is Putin's quest to reclaim the USSR, it's not even something he really hides. He says 'NATO expansion' as a convenient excuse for the 'useful idiots' (that is a term coined by Stalin for this exact situation), and of course this repulsive fantasies about 'Ukrainian Nazis' all over Ukraine. FYI - should not that Putin was behind 'both side' of the conflict of 'football hooligans with AK47's' in 2014 Donbas, using his GRU to funnel money to the supposed 'Nazi Azovs' (many of whom were even Russian) fighting against 'victim loyal Russians'. The 'future' of Ukrainian acquiescence to Putin is evident in Belarus as an example: a laughable stooge of a corrupt bag of lard, verbally farting his way through nonsensical press conferences, while doing the bidding of Putin, repressing those around him etc.. The Ukrainians as a whole have the right to fight if the want, so long as they want we should support them, and frankly, we should likely have a material presence on the ground, just not quite up to the point of direct face offs between NATO and Russian forces. And the same for Georgia, and whoever else. Literally today, the Kremlin was threatening the 'End of Human Existence' if NATO continued to interfere with Russia's genocidal murder [1]. These are psychopaths with nukes, and we probably cannot afford to exist with them, something likely has to be done, or, they can be little hermits like North Korea. The Russians don't bother to hide their real ambitions, they can do this because when asked in a public forum, they give the 'NATO' and 'Denazification' excuses willy nilly out of the other side of their mouths - because our system of information isn't competent enough to call it out for what it is contextually. We far too often just take their words at face value. We know what their foreign policy textbooks require, and in their purview 'public communications' don't have to have any bearing whatsoever on reality, ergo, we should assume that whatever they are saying is just a constructed lie with the truth occasionally thrown in. Read Putin's own words on how 'Ukraine is not a country or a people' and how that area of people 'naturally belongs under his power'. [2] Russia has nothing to say about Ukraine - either from a 'security' or 'cultural' perspective - they are the antagonizing force in all of this, and have been for 20 years. [1] https://www.express.co.uk/news/world/1636688/putin-russia-ukraine-war-Dmitry-Medvedev-latest-news-ont https://www.express.co.uk/news/world/1636688/putin-russia-uk... [2] http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/66181 http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/66181