3 ms·
How hot is too hot for the human body? _Heat plus humidity gets dangerous fast_
- mdp2021 4y agoOriginal title: "How hot is too hot for the human body? Our lab found heat + humidity gets dangerous faster than many people realize" > Scientists and other observers have become alarmed about the increasing frequency of extreme heat paired with high humidity, measured as "wet-bulb temperature" [...] People often point to a study published in 2010 that estimated that a "wet-bulb temperature 35°C" – equal to 35°C (95 F) at 100% humidity, or 45°C (115°F) at 50% humidity, would be the upper limit of safety, beyond which the human body can no longer cool itself by evaporating sweat from the surface of the body to maintain a stable body core temperature > [A new study gathered] young, healthy [individuals] into the Noll Laboratory at Penn State University [... The] upper environmental limit is even lower than the theorized 35 C[: i]t’s more like a wet-bulb temperature of 31°C [ - t]hat would equal 31°C (88°F) at 100% humidity or 38°C (100°F) at 60% humidity I had to editorialize a bit the writing around the numeric data, because it was very confusing in the original. A graphic shows that such "average critical environmental limit for young men and women at minimal activity" at the lowest humidity level is 50°C (120°F)... ..Summing up, roughly 30°C at 100%, 40°C at 50%, 50°C at 0%. > Staying well hydrated and seeking areas in which to cool down - even for short periods - are important in high heat > A recent study focusing on heat stress in Africa found that future climates will not be conducive to the use of even low-cost cooling systems such as “swamp coolers” as the tropical and coastal parts of Africa become more humid. These devices, which require far less energy than air conditioners, use a fan to recirculate the air across a cool, wet pad to lower the air temperature, but they become ineffective at high wet-bulb temperatures above 21°C (70°F[, at 100% humidity])
- dublin 4y agoI call B.S.! Neither I, as a child, or my many ancestors that obviously did survive, could have done so here in Texas (or most of the South), if this were true. Near 100% RH and temperatures in the 100s are not common, but neither are they that uncommon within a few hundred miles of the Gulf Coast. Maybe more modern people are becoming wimps from the air conditioning. (My wife and I both attended some schools that were not air conditioned, and it's not like we're ancient - In my case, it was due to incompetent months-long repairs by the Austin schools; In her case, it was just a South Florida school that didn't yet have AC.) I expect there's a substantial geographic and occupational distribution of heat tolerance, but this research consists of people in a single area, so it doesn't catch that. That said, heatstroke risk is deadly serious, but fairly easily avoided with a few minor precautions. (Maybe a few more than Bear Bryant used with his famous Junction Boys workouts - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Junction_Boys https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Junction_Boys) I guarantee you that the average farmer, rancher, or oilfield or construction workers can withstand more than these results would indicate - if that were not true, we'd lose many more to heatstroke than we do...
- rwallace 4y agoNow I'm curious, 'Near 100% RH and temperatures in the 100s' should as the article says, be theoretically lethal; what are the precautions by which you avoid heatstroke, without air conditioning? (The one I thought of, if you have no air conditioning but you do have a fridge, was putting a bag of ice cubes on your head, but for some reason, people who live in hot countries, don't seem to do that.)
- jimmygrapes 4y agoAgreed. I can't parse the details of this article too well since I'm not a very smart person, but anecdotally I grew up with high heat and high humidity virtually every day, and I also had (gave) a strong aversion to drinking plain water (I'm better about it now, but my teeth suffered greatly for a long, long time due to sodas and juices until modern dentistry got me fixed up). If I understand this link, I should have died. So should most everyone else who lived in the same region. Now OK I am not a "climate denier" but I feel the need to remind Northern hemisphere people that it's Summer. That's all I'll say on that topic for now.
- willcipriano 4y agoI did ten years in restaurants. On the hottest most humid days of the year I was running around next to a oven for 12 hours. Then I'd bike home to my apartment with no AC. I'm just learning now that I died.
- mdp2021 4y ago> I feel the need to remind Northern hemisphere people that it's Summer You are paradoxically right to remind us, because some of us are puzzled about this climate we seem to be thrown in in usual places. I have never in the past summers had to go at 1500m altitude (4000..5000ft) to say "ok, now the conditions are comfortable enough", but for exceptional days. Oh, I do remember that evening many years ago in which I came to doing absurdities to get "at least a ludicrous idea of a tiny increase of fresh air" in the unbearable weather. It was summer, all right. It lasted dozens of hours, not months; it was August, not May.
- 4y ago
- sumanthvepa 4y agoI live in South India. The temperature is often 33/34 C with 88% humidity. That is getting very close to the limit of human endurance. It’s really difficult to work mentally or physically with no air conditioning. I work from home, and my wife and I mostly do our household chores (where the use of AC is not feasible) either early morning or after sunset. During the day it’s really hard to work without the AC.
- doodlebugging 4y agoThank you for your personal story. I had to do the math to discover that 34C is actually only 93F. I have to respectfully disagree that those conditions are near the limits of human endurance. My own experience working outside in all kinds of weather causes me to see that temperature/humidity combination as fairly mild (normal summer temps for June/July) and easily survivable since I personally have known many people of all ages who manage to go about their business with no ill effects in conditions more extreme than that here in Texas. Current conditions here today were 103F (>39C) with heat index due to humidity making it feel like 106F (>41C). I worked outside all day and I am over 60 years old. I know that our world is facing extreme conditions due to human-caused climate change and I see the effects here locally even this summer as we are firmly in an extreme drought with no rain in the forecast for at least the next 10 days. Overall though I think humans are quite resilient and smart and that we will find a way to mitigate the damage that is already built in and to minimize consequences of further damage. I have to believe that as an organism, we will find a way to adapt to whatever we manage to create or destroy. I believe it is probably more accurate to frame the problem as one where vulnerable members of a population will be much closer to their endurance limits over the next few decades. The human race though will adapt. Vulnerable members could be defined as those who have medical issues or those who have spent large parts of their lives indoors where the range of temperatures that they normally see is very small. They have not hardened their constitutions to the actual physical conditions of temperature and humidity where they live and work because they shelter inside year round instead of going outside to take it all in. I think we can see examples globally of populations that have lived in what many of us in the developed world would consider extreme conditions with no hardships. They manage their limited resources to take fullest advantage of whatever meager resources their local environment provides. They will serve as a lesson to the rest of the world as to how to adapt as everything changes.
- mdp2021 4y agoNews just in: from The Economist, > On Thursday some 1m pilgrims will begin the annual haj to Mecca in Saudi Arabia [...] But ... those who make it to Mecca will face temperatures above 40°C, which can play havoc with the human body. [...] Climate models suggest that, if global temperatures rise by 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels, lethal heat exposure during the haj will become five times more likely. A rise of 2°C increases the risks tenfold https://www.economist.com/the-world-in-brief https://www.economist.com/the-world-in-brief