7 ms·
It's kind of deliberate. there's bullshitters, and bullshit-takers, and you are in the latter group. Setting the agenda and defining the terms is a way to exert
by anigbrowl 4y ago
It's kind of deliberate. there's bullshitters, and bullshit-takers, and you are in the latter group. Setting the agenda and defining the terms is a way to exert power, in many ways far more important than any substantive outcome to the meetings. That said, quite a few managers are just high on their own supply and chasing a fashionable idea or doing a poor job of trying to explain whatever they were told in their last meeting. You don't have to assume malice.
You can try using some BS of your own; for example, say modestly 'I love [the strategic thing] but I've struggled to communicate it effectively to my team. How can I make it easier for them to understand?' which flatters the person running a meeting enough that they might be tempted to show off. Don't have a team? Invent one, just evoke the existence of some confused and dissatisfied co-workers who you are eager to motivate.
Keep notes on different people/ideas and give them a BS score out of 10 (nothing complicated). After a while you'll get a sense for what actually impacts productivity or business outcomes vs what's just the corporate cheer squad.
- globalreset 4y agoThis. Most bigger corporate meetings could have been an email with some bulletpoints on top with most important things everyone must know, and later then details for people that are interested. But if it wasn't a meeting, where else would the management get a change to flex, pat their backs, do some ritual sucking up and self promoting and generally justify their existence? OP: Just focus on your real work and responsibilities, ignore the corporate meetings as much as you can get away with. Unless you want to join management, in which case you have to start clapping loudly and play the game.
- mmcnl 4y agoThe fact that you're talking about "management" as some separate evil entity and not you coworkers who just want to help you and live their lives happily ever after, in the same way as you do, tells me a lot.
- corrral 4y agoTells me the poster has work experience.
- yesenadam 4y agoPlease spell out for us the lot it tells you, instead of just ominously hinting.
- mmcnl 4y agoSorry about that. Non-technical coworkers are just people with probably the same goal as you. Talking about management in this specific way tells me that they see their management coworkers as enemies, and not as equals. I don't think that's healthy.
- globalreset 4y ago> Talking about management in this specific way tells me that they see their management coworkers as enemies, and not as equals. How am I being a jerk here, pointing out the obvious truths. I don't treat other people as enemies. I'm just speaking my mind about systemic problems. I don't book company wide meetings that are (semi-)mandatory and waste thousands of person-hour of work time for the company, just because I enjoy it and am in position that can do it. I try to be mindful about the communication I initiate and treat other's people time with respect. I write TL;DR in my emails and optimize for groups performance, not just my own self-interest. The thing you should deduce from what I wrote is that instead of being self-optimizing stupid/naive/cynical person, I actually (possibly irrationally) care about my craft and efficiency of the group I belong to, and can do my own critical thinking, instead of accepting status quo uncritically.
- yesenadam 4y agoThank you!
- anigbrowl 4y agoSome managers are just team members with organizational skills, they're great. Others are ladder-climbers who use bullying and economic force to advance. The more hierarchical an organization,the more likely you are to find the latter type.
- ianpurton 4y agoAfter 30 years in the industry I can confirm that this is indeed the case. They only generate BS. I would only add that you should try to avoid these meetings if at all possible. Just say you have a pressing deadline that requires your full attention. Then continue coding.
- daveslash 4y agoYou see, I try to efficiently build stand-alone opportunities to enthusiastically architect frictionless adoption of our Turbo Incabulators, thus creating compellingly extended multidisciplinary potentialities across our interactively strategized low-risk high-yield web-readiness platforms. C'mon, I'm not the only one here who uses "The Corporate B.S. Generator" for all their meetings, am I? Am I? https://www.atrixnet.com/bs-generator.html https://www.atrixnet.com/bs-generator.html You may also appreciate https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MXW0bx_Ooq4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MXW0bx_Ooq4
- pkulak 4y ago> You can try using some BS of your own Oh man, I would never start playing some sitcom-style communication game. That seems like it could go very wrong, and be stressful and annoying even if it goes right.
- 88913527 4y agoThe most important thing here is buttering people up. I've never seen any more of an effective strategy than that. Just being kind and saying you like their ideas is an incredibly effective way to influence their next steps.
- projectazorian 4y agoI'd also add that the purpose of a lot of these "consultation" meetings is not consultation at all - they exist to announce a decision that was already taken before the meeting, or to give exposure (and thus clout) to the people who convened the meeting. Seems like the latter is probably the case here.
- 0xbadc0de5 4y ago> Don't have a team? Invent one, just evoke the existence of some confused and dissatisfied co-workers who you are eager to motivate. ah, Tibor...
- spoonjim 4y agoGreat analysis. Also, the level at which the OP is understanding the situation means that he is never going to leave the world of the bullshit-takers. Thus his best strategy is to work on continuously improving his technical competence so that he can be a higher-compensated bullshit-taker.
- 734129837261 4y ago"I really love your strategic approach, and I think we should seamlessly impact our intrepid cloud-ready technology with another meeting to go more in depth. I would like you, or John Smith from Marketing, to restore backward-compatible partnerships between our team leads. That way we can continually seize efficient human capital. That will really synergise with our stakeholders. What do you think?" And you can respond to whatever they say with a thinking nod while stroking your chin. And street-kids would say "bet", you simply say "hmhm, very agile." You'll be CEO in no-time.
- codegladiator 4y ago> That will really synergise with our stakeholders This is so 2010s. You need to update your vocab. Let me FTFY > That will really decentralize our stakeholders
- hsuduebc2 4y agoGoddamit I cringed so hard. I just had flashback from my previous job.
- dr_orpheus 4y agoI have also found that people use [strategic thing] as a way of keeping something at a higher level without going in to the details. Because once they get in to the details the grand plans start to break down. I have been a part of a number of these high level strategy type efforts at my company. I have often found that I seem to be the cynical one against an onslaught of relentlessly optimistic people.
- AnimalMuppet 4y ago"Everything is easy to the one who doesn't have to do it."
- ethbr0 4y agoOne of the best planning exercises I've heard is asking every attendee to think of a way the suggested plan could go awry. The genius is that failure scenarios are, by definition, detail-oriented. Consequently, it's an easy bridge into the discussing the details that actually matter (i.e. those that could threaten the entire plan).
- benji-york 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pre-mortem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pre-mortem
- 121789 4y agoPre-mortems. In general I haven’t found them that useful as the teams/leads I’ve worked with generally have the risks covered already
- ethbr0 4y agoThey're more useful, the more disfunctional and rose colored glasses the org has.
- PragmaticPulp 4y agoThis is a painfully cynical worldview. If you find yourself in a company where management is this ineffective, get out. Or at least move to a different department where people are genuinely working together. Companies (or departments) wouldn't actually last very long if management teams were as bad as you described. > Setting the agenda and defining the terms is a way to exert power, in many ways far more important than any substantive outcome to the meetings. No, setting an agenda is a way to give people a chance to prepare for a meeting and to keep the meeting on track. A meeting with an agenda sent out ahead of time is far more efficient than a meeting where people just show up and think of things to chat about. > You can try using some BS of your own Please don't do this. Believe it or not, it's actually really easy from the management side of the table to tell when someone is just laying on the flattery and trying to say all the right things to butter people up. Engineers who try to "play politics" usually overestimate their ability to manipulate other people and underestimate other people's ability to see right through it. You may think you're just playing the game, but I guarantee it's coming off as patronizing to the genuine employees around you. Those genuine employees are the people you need to build trust with, and these political manipulation games will only do the opposite. > Don't have a team? Invent one, just evoke the existence of some confused and dissatisfied co-workers who you are eager to motivate. Now this is pure keyboard warrior fantasy material. Doing anything resembling this will destroy your reputation at the company in short order. Chronic liars and manipulators may not be called out in public, but their negative reputation will spread quickly among people in the know.
- johnwheeler 4y ago> Please don't do this. Believe it or not, it's actually really easy from the management side of the table to tell when someone is just laying on the flattery and trying to say all the right things to butter people up. Actually it’s been shown that ass kissing and flattery are quite effective unfortunately. > Engineers who try to "play politics" usually overestimate their ability to manipulate other people and underestimate other people's ability to see right through it. Actually, engineers are often quite adept at manipulating social systems to their advantage. If you think engineers are just heads-down nerds without personal agendas they promote ruthlessly, you’re the patsy. > Chronic liars and manipulators may not be called out in public, but their negative reputation will spread quickly among people in the know. Seriously? Politics over the last 10 years come to mind. Bad behavior is often rewarded. Doesn’t mean you should partake, but I don’t call it cynicism as much as realism.
- jollybean 4y agoPlease stop this. This is the worst kind of technical cynicism. Tech people are not the people with 'real jobs' while everyone else 'bullshits'. Terms are above your head because they generally relate to operations outside the scope of your knowledge. (Edit: 'omnichannel' could mean a lot of things, it's definitely a bit 'buzzwordy' but it almost assuredly refers to some cross functional project of some kind that the OP is not aware of. This immediate implication of 'things I don't understand are bullshit' is antisocial and a bit glib - maybe understandable for some young people (?) but still, it's a problem to default to this posture.) The biggest 'bullshiters' tend to be on the tech side, who go on and on about technology that is not needed, this is because they can very easily talk past others on domain knowledge. I sit on both sides of the fence, and as soon as I get on the business side, I immediately see it - tech people 'controlling' the schedule and much of everything else because of their domain knowledge, often without the self awareness to recognize what's going on, operating with the implicit assumption that their need to push back 2 months for some refactor is inherently more important that other needs. And yes - a lot of effort is filler and inefficient - that is probably the real culprit here. Do not heed any of this ridiculous Machiavellian advice (aka 'keeping notes on people'? WTF?). Assume the best, do your jobs, obviously some people will BS, oh well, move on.
- convolvatron 4y agothis is true. its also the case that the various 'business' people have very different goals, very different terminology, and a much squishier sense of success. alot of the 'business' conversation is carried out largely in subtext. you can learn quite a bit about the internal machinery of the company where you work by just learning to read that. there _is_ quite a bit of useless sleeze on the business side. but to believe all of it is, and that somehow you have a better view of inter organization struggle and market response than all of those who do it full time is naive and counterproductive.
- watwut 4y ago> Assume the best, do your jobs, obviously some people will BS, oh well, move on. The reason this is common sense on business side and much less on tech side is that tech side is much cleaner in terms of relationships. Otherwise said, bullshiting is less common and people are not used to it. As you said, the moment you cross to in between or to management, bullshiting and lying becomes normal. Moreover, sales and management gets rewarded for lying and their words are rarely checked for accuracy. I have seen them lying with straight face about our progress or capabilities of our software one too many times. I have also seen them lying to damage other employees. The worst stab in back, lying about other people or situation I have seen were not coming from tech. Sure, I have seen tech people lying, but it is visible for higher up more quickly - and they are not in situations in which they can do as much damage in the first place. Second thing, tech people controlling schedule is a good thing. Writing from place where tech people often dont control that and the delays and pissed off customers caused by that refactoring not being done are very very real thing too. Everywhere where tech people did not controlled schedule was hot mess - and even relationships got much much worst. Because business then blamed tech for consequences of unmaintainable software (meaning absurd amount of bugs, deadlines not really met etc) and tech people resented business for causing it all.
- watwut 4y agoBased on post, those sentences had actual meaning and OP just did not understood. Take multichannel thing - it was real existing functionality. OP just had no idea what it refers to. You are doing people disservice here. If op followed your advice, op would look like idiot to teammembers.
- kube-system 4y agoAlternatively, this could be a comment written by management about developers, who when asked about why they are missing their delivery date, rattle off a list of microservices which need to be refactored, which they refer to by their Lord of the Rings code names. Sometimes when people don't understand something else, it isn't bullshit, it's simply something they don't understand.
- xbar 4y agoPrecisely. Consider this recommended reading: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/On_Bullshit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/On_Bullshit
- marcosdumay 4y ago> 'I love [the strategic thing] but I've struggled to communicate it effectively to my team. How can I make it easier for them to understand?' That is very transparent, by the way. If your goal was to hide that you don't understand it, you didn't achieve it. You will probably get a better answer if you are honest, anyway. If you never worked with [the strategic thing], you should not be expected to know it.
- mmcnl 4y agoThis advice is wrong on so many levels. All the engineers do the True Work, everyone else is just bullshitting. Yeah sure. Could it be that you don't understand their jobs in the same way "they" don't understand your job? Who knows.
- wahnfrieden 4y agoDavid Graeber wrote a whole book about this called Bullshit Jobs
- cbanek 4y ago> You can try using some BS of your own; Don't you worry about Planet Express, let me worry about blank.
- awsrocks 4y ago