13 ms·
Two points to highlight from this article: 1. LinkedIn is an absolute godsend for bad guys, allowing easy targeting of everyone in the company with spear phish
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
Two points to highlight from this article:
1. LinkedIn is an absolute godsend for bad guys, allowing easy targeting of everyone in the company with spear phishing emails and texts. I know many security professionals no longer use their real name, and don't list the real name of their company, because they know it's such a great hacking vector. Not sure what/whether LinkedIn can do anything about this.
2. I wish there were more information about what the vulnerability was in the PDF in the first place. I think a lot of people would be wary of downloading a PDF from a stranger, but not from someone who you had multiple interview rounds with and who offered you a job.
- lupire 4y ago
- koofdoof 4y agoHow usable is LinkedIn with a pseudonym? Is that a security industry only practice or could a regular dev get away with that too? I've always been shy about having a profile with my actual name but id consider one with a thin veil of anonymity.
- 8organicbits 4y agoSame, although my perception is that LinkedIn has moved past its peak usefulness, and it would be better to spend time on other platforms than creating a LI account. All I hear about LinkedIn these days is spam.
- bckr 4y agowhich other platform?
- 8organicbits 4y agoThere's a lot of platforms that do sort of related things, so it's a hard thing to answer. For "finding a job" I've been looking at HN, remoteok, and a bunch of others. For professional networking I use various tools run by former coworkers (mostly Slack and Google Groups). For "blogs" I use HN and Reddit. etc. I don't think LinkedIn does any of those better (my perception, I'm not a current user). Personally, I'm probably not interested in a LI clone for many of the reasons I stopped using LI. I deleted my LI account maybe 8 years ago, after getting too much spam (and I think some security issue?)
- mistrial9 4y agoLinkedIn sceptic here -- I would assume that in 2022, the closer you are to real, legal Microsoft-ecosystem roles, the more useful it is.. meanwhile, the independent people in tech get splashed with mud. No comment in this discussion has indicated to me that LinkedIn is not useful for certain swathes of established professions, even now.
- charlie0 4y agoI really wish I could just dump LI and delete my account; it's just spam and another service for those who love to self promote themselves. I won't do it because I'm not sure how it will impact by ability to get a job. How many of you have gotten jobs with no LI account? YEO?
- _dain_ 4y agoi've never felt the need to use linkedin.
- chatmasta 4y agoAs an engineer I never found LinkedIn useful. But during college I made sure to connect with everybody, even if I barely knew them. The only jobs I’ve had I got through other means, in some cases even “connections,” in the traditional sense of the word, which incidentally exist on the LinkedIn graph, but that’s just a mirror of real life and it’s not like the coordination occurs over LinkedIn messages anyway. As a startup founder, it’s effective in some contexts, like as a contact point or promotional tool. We never felt the need to use it for recruiting. At least in the software industry, GitHub is a much more effective marketplace of talent. But LinkedIn can have some benefits for a startup outside of recruiting. Posting content about your product is a good way to stay in front of investors you’ve connected with who doomscroll their LinkedIn feed like a dev does HN. :) (it’s also something I need to automate because I block LinkedIn on /etc/hosts for productivity purposes..) I’m not sure I’ve ever _sourced_ an opportunity from LinkedIn. I also never accept connections without at least one prior interaction. For me it’s a tool for following up and keeping in touch, not introductions. It might also be useful in some rare sales contexts, for some specific archetype of audience especially susceptible to the psychological tactics commonly deployed to the LinkedIn newsfeed. Developers are definitely not that audience (well, not on LinkedIn at least…)
- skc 4y agoBut every single time there is an AskHN on the topic of how people got their current gigs, LinkedIn overwhelmingly dominates other channels. Just something to keep in mind. This post will have a lot of negative LI reviews simply because it was used as a sort of attack vector.
- joshstrange 4y agoPersonally I don't update my LinkedIn until I start looking for a new job. There is absolutely no need for anyone to know where I work (or at least for me to share that far and wide publically) and I'm not interested in cold emails/cold linkedin messages. My decision was cemented in 2020 when someone who didn't like a tweet of mine retweeted it to my old company's twitter account trying to get me fired/reprimanded (The tweet in question called out my local PD for a dubious tweet they made, the person who tried to get me in trouble lived in a different state 12+ hours away). Thankfully my current company wouldn't have cared but there is no need to give people ammo.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y ago> Personally I don't update my LinkedIn until I start looking for a new job. Perhaps semi-off topic, but note there are companies that sell software (spyware?) to HR departments that specifically trolls LinkedIn looking for when employees update their LinkedIn profiles as a sign they're looking for a new job. This may or may not be a good thing depending on your position, perspective, or company, but just be aware it exists.
- joshstrange 4y agoYeah, though I'd get dinged by that either way since I normally update my bio to include recent projects/tech I've worked with. This way I can hide behind plausible deniability "Oh, I just got around to adding X company to my LinkedIn" if I need to, whereas updating an existing entry is harder to justify (without giving away you are looking). Though I also try not to work for companies that I would need to worry about that.
- mgkimsal 4y ago> whereas updating an existing entry is harder to justify (without giving away you are looking) I don't think it is at all. Indeed, if you're updating it regularly (every 3-4 months, perhaps?) with new project/task stuff, it's simply keeping things fresh in your mind, vs having to try to trawl back 3 years to think about project FOO. If you only update it once every 2 years, then people can draw more nefarious conclusions.
- Forgeties79 4y agoIt’s a shame too. In my experience LinkedIn has been great for job hunting, indeed et al. were worthless time sinks for me. I want to keep it just for the ability to job hunt and get results but as you said…it’s a risk too.
- V-2 4y agoThat's the only thing it's good for, but that thing actually works. My last three job offers were from LinkedIn (I ultimately rejected one because my employer at the time gave me a counteroffer when I handed my notice, but I did accept the other two). The "content" on LI (feelhgood / motivational BS) is do ridiculous that I sort of contempt-read it ("hateread" would be to strong a word) for the heck of it, but I can't wrap my head around WHY people would participate in this nonsense for real.
- Forgeties79 4y agoYeah I really don’t see any appeal beyond jobs (my current job came from it). The content is just SEO/personal branding fodder.
- rurp 4y agoWhen I first signed up for LI I honestly couldn't tell the difference between the actual feed and a what I imagined a parody site would look like. The posts that proclaim themselves to hold controversial ideas, followed by the most banal cliches possible, crack me up. Once in a while I check the feed for kicks and it's always 100% spam, cliches, humble brags, and not-so-humble brags.
- caseysoftware 4y agoSome in the security community demonstrated this with Robin Sage, circa 2009: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robin_Sage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robin_Sage It introduces the idea of "transitive trust" where person A might not know person B but if the two have a bunch of contacts in common, the odds of A trusting B goes up. When there's a profile with tens or hundreds of shared connections, it looks real by all accounts. I wrote about this is an intel gathering/attack vector way back in the day but it's 100x better now because connecting is second nature and people trust more now: https://caseysoftware.com/blog/open-source-intelligence-linkedin https://caseysoftware.com/blog/open-source-intelligence-link...
- aaronharnly 4y agoOn (1), I have seen employees get spear-phishing texts (Welcome X! This is the CEO of Y. I need you to do a small favor…) within hours of updating their LinkedIn. I assume there are robots crawling it constantly looking for fresh candidates for account takeovers or other scams.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y ago> LinkedIn is an absolute godsend for bad guys I am listed as the Principal on a couple of companies, and get constant approaches that are obviously fake (like an attractive young "stewardess" from Dubai, who just happened to like my picture (which is actually my logo)). I've given up reporting them, as LI always responds with "This is not in violation..."
- djbusby 4y agoIsn't LI owned by MS?
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoYup. I'm gonna remove my cynical comment (although I still totally believe it). It's just not helpful. I think people can figure it out, for themselves. Also, people use LI as a way to aggregate information, then send emails that appear to be from LI, but are not. I got one of those, yesterday, and reported it to LI, saying "These guys obviously used your service to construct this honker." And LI's reply was ... envelope, please ... "Not our problem. Go away, kid. Yer bodderin' me." but stated a bit more politely. I deliberately stay fairly open. I mentioned that, some time ago. It comes with some problems, like a determined bad actor can build up a fairly good profile. But I have had years of experience, rubbing elbows with professional con artists, so I am maybe a little tougher to fool than many (but some approaches have come close -these folks are good). I would never be so arrogant to say that I can't be phished or whaled, but it's almost certainly not worth the effort.
- PebblesRox 4y agoI'd love to hear more about your experience with con artists!
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoIt's not the type of story that I really share in the venue of press, radio and films, if you get my drift. I'm happy to chat -a bit- about it, directly. Many of the stories that I know, are not mine, to tell.
- _fat_santa 4y agoI think one shouldn't discount the attack vector that is just working in the Crypto industry, especially when you're someone who works with startups rather than the big guys. In the "Web2 Sector", it would be very easy IMO to snuff out a fictitious company. I've gotten a handful of "offers" in the past and you can see straight through them, because the company doesn't exist in real life and you can't find any info on it, huge red flag. The problem with the "Web3 Sector" IMO is you have a bunch of upcomming players in the space that no one has heard of. Just like investors in Cryto, if you're a developer in the space, no doubt you are jockeying to join a project that might land you a 7-10 figure windfall at the end. So if an unheard of company approached me, I would tell them to kick rocks. If a similar company approached someone in the "Web3 Sector", they might take it thinking it's an emerging opportunity. I'm sure this still happens with Startups but my gut says it's really bad in the Web3 space.
- lupire 4y ago
- searchableguy 4y agoMany teams may be pseudo-anonymous as well. So you may not find much about the founder or team beyond their public handles.
- secondcoming 4y agoAlso, don't use a company device for personal business. If you use your own device then do company work in a VM.
- jessaustin 4y agoOpening the pdf wasn't "company work", so maybe everything should be done in a VM? (Not the same VM!)
- secondcoming 4y agoHe opened it on a company device I assume
- jessaustin 4y agoThat's possible, and addressed by your first sentence above. You wrote the second sentence to address a different possibility. In that case, a process with access to the whole device could read e.g. auth tokens contained in a VM.
- alexfromapex 4y agoI think one other thing that bears mentioning is that LinkedIn's reporting doesn't easily let you explain how someone is performing a scam. If you're diligent you can find the link somewhere where you can actually explain it but when you just "report" someone or a job the response from LinkedIn is usually "We didn't find anything indicating this is a scam" or similar.
- bl_valance 4y agoIsn't the issue here that they used their work laptop or were on their work's internal network(VPN?) to "apply" for this job? This is something I see/hear so often, people using work equipment/network to conduct their personal stuff. This, IMO, should not be allowed at all.
- ineptech 4y ago> I wish there were more information about what the vulnerability was in the PDF in the first place. Agreed, I thought that opening a read-only PDF was GRAS regardless of the application.
- WorldMaker 4y agoPostScript is a Turing Complete language (always has been), and an over-simplified description of PDF is that it "just" wraps PostScript in a single Virtual Machine to target (versus PostScript has a lot of subtly different physical machines it was built for/targeted). That "PDF VM" has had many 0-day RCE bugs over the years. Thankfully though the VM is standardized with the format it does have multiple implementations still in different applications and many exploits are application-specific implementation bugs.
- jedberg 4y agoI'm not sure this is Linkedin's problem to solve. They are just a directory. I suppose they could add a phishing warning for messages sent on LinkedIn, but really it's an education problem, teaching people to identify what phishing emails look like and how to avoid them. This is a problem I've been working on since at least 2003, when we realized that the best way to prevent eBay account takeovers was teaching people what phishing is. We also identified that education is the hardest solution to achieve. It's ironic that the security professionals are the ones hiding their identity, given that they are the best prepared to identify and avoid phishing emails.
- hungryforcodes 4y agoYou're right -- apparently it's a PDF problem, and I'm still looking for an explanation of how a simple PDF could be worth half a billion dollars.
- burrows 4y ago> I'm not sure this is Linkedin's problem to solve. They are just a directory. If the issue reduces user metrics, then they will want to fix it. Ultimate responsibility seems irrelevant. > It's ironic that the security professionals are the ones hiding their identity, given that they are the best prepared to identify and avoid phishing emails. I might have demolitions training, but I’d still rather walk around the minefield.
- _dain_ 4y ago> I'm not sure this is Linkedin's problem to solve. They are just a directory. this was the attitude Microsoft had about malware on Windows for a long time and it led to so much misery and ruin across the world.
- rmbyrro 4y agoThe main problem was using a machine that had access to half a billion dollars to also browse the web and do stuff like applying for jobs. If you're gonna have access to such amount of money, it's worth buying a dedicated machine and using it very, very cautiously.
- abxytg 4y agoYep. Bad opsec at the org level. Either the eng was doing work stuff on a personal laptop or personal stuff on a work laptop. This is easily preventable and should be table stakes when handling money, phi, etc
- andrecarini 4y ago> when handling money, phi What does _phi_ stand for?
- rcyeh 4y agophi = protected health information pii = personally identifiable information
- abirch 4y agoI still can't believe that they opened the PDF on the company computer. I always use my home computer and the poor hacker would get bored of seeing all of my Raspberry Pi projects that I haven't done.
- kuboble 4y agoIt might be hard to believe that the particular person in a particular company did that, but given a lot of attempts, dedication and lucky / unlucky circumstances eventually somewhere someone will trust a malicious person and will get socially engineered into opening a pdf on a working computer.
- godot 4y ago
- jcrawfordor 4y agoMost PDF "attacks" in the real world are very unsophisticated. One of the most common uses of PDFs in a phishing context is just as a way to deliver a link that would likely result in blocking by email security products (many don't inspect inside PDFs, and even for those that do the PDF format is complicated enough that it offers tremendous opportunities for obfuscation). I would wager money that the "PDF attack" involved here was as simple as a link to a malicious executable presented in a PDF to avoid detection by email filtering... in my time as a security analyst this was the #1 source of real compromise incidents, and anecdotally it seems to remain popular today based on the number of such PDFs I receive in my spam email. The PDF format presents many opportunities for other exploits, either obfuscating a payload or running code, but modern PDF viewers are locking these opportunities down to such a degree that they are not very reliable (most of all because it is difficult to know which PDF viewer your target will use, and many popular PDF viewers today like pdf.js are relatively feature-incomplete which is a significant security advantage in this case). It's possible that something more sophisticated was going on but I would be very surprised if it was anything more complex than using the PDF as an obfuscated transport for a binary packed in it and invoked by the user (e.g. by clicking a link in the PDF with a javascript target). Non-user-interaction PDF vulnerabilities exist but are increasingly hard to come by as there has been more than a decade of work on locking down PDF viewers and the situation has improved dramatically in that time. Contrary to what people sometimes expect, highly organized groups (such as APTs) tend to stick to very basic, simple methods as much as possible, since they are relatively reliable. The use of recent vulnerabilities in a specific PDF viewer, for example, is high risk due to the likelihood of failure and the opportunities for analysis it presents (you will have to do custom development rather than using off-the-shelf tooling). This is the kind of thing that organized groups try to avoid as much as possible, subject to an ROI analysis. Or in other words, if putting a link to an EXE in a PDF still works, why would you bother with anything else?
- noduerme 4y agoIf it's just a javascript link to download an EXE, doesn't the target of the hack still need to run the EXE? Or are you saying that a link in a PDF can install and execute code on its own? Assuming it can't, then the engineer had to click to run some unknown EXE after downloading it... that should hardly be described as a "PDF attack".
- samstave 4y agoSpeaking of spear phishing: When I was at lockheed we had an incident whereby a bunch of folks had attended some defense conference, and after the fact received emails from folks they had 'met' at the conference, something along the lines of "Hey Bob, we met at the [defense] conference this last week and I wanted to be sure you had my contact info: malware-contact.vcf" or some other payload. This installed a very slow sprawling worm which would slowly trickle data out of lockheed to China. It was not discovered for quite a while due to how slowly it operated, but someone had complained about machine performance and IT looked at the machine and discovered the worm... after removing it - this somehow sent a signal to China that they had been found and all the worms started to firehose as much as they could until egress was closed. At the time, all of Lockheeds 150,000 employees had just three egress points to the internet. They had to shut them all down to kill that worm.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Dig1t 4y agoI deactivated my LI after my last job search, it hasn't affected my life at all since then. I don't know why you need one at all most of the time. Even without one, I think it would be perfectly easy to get interviews at companies, most interviews I've done in the past have been the ones I got by just going to the company's website and applying directly anyway.
- LegitShady 4y agoI see people posting things even on HN where its a link to a PDF and I don't click on them. I remember PDF being a leaky and buggy format whose interpreters were full of vulnerabilities. I don't click on PDFs.
- elif 4y agoI'm so confused by #2 as well. If pdf is compromised, is it fixed? This seems like the kind of vulnerability that would ruin pdf's reputation permanently. It was the safe alternative to sending someone a .doc particularly because of it's limited functionality.
- pph 4y agoPDF can embed lots of things and is quite hard to scan because there's some many ways to do things.. It is used for sending documents because its function is to have a fixed layout for printing (and look the same on every device), not because it's safer than other document formats. If you really want a safe PDF, there's a function in Qubes OS that basically opens a PDF in a new VM, makes screenshots and then creates a new PDF from those. You'll lose advanced functions (e.g. forms) as the pages simply become pictures but that's a tradeoff you have to make.
- stef25 4y agoSounds like https://dangerzone.rocks/ https://dangerzone.rocks/
- kornhole 4y agoI only use titles such as 'Employee' 'Worker' 'Carbon Based Life Form'.. on Linkedin. It also significantly reduces the amount of spam and cold calls.
- walrus01 4y ago> I know many security professionals no longer use their real name, and don't list the real name of their company, because they know it's such a great hacking vector. Not sure what/whether LinkedIn can do anything about this. on the other hand I bet you could collect some interesting things by creating a few fake people as linkedin honeypots at FAANGs, and I would be very surprised in their infosec/netsec teams aren't already doing this. or getting real people who opt-in to have their linkedin profile receive incoming scams, virus, trojans, phish links and pipeline them into the infosec/netsec team.
- cyanydeez 4y agoAll social networks with thorough mappings create vulnerability because of the trust people have in each other.
- duxup 4y agoI’ve gotten vague legal threats from competitors who just browsed linked in and searched who they maybe thought could make the change they wanted and emailed me. They seemed to avoid contacting executives or senior staff… but instead targeted folks capable of maybe making the change they wanted, and maybe jr / low enough on the pole enough to panic and do it. I’ve seen it happen three times now, pretty scummy IMO.
- h4waii 4y agoThis is hilarious. People on LinkedIn, using a name sufficiently far enough away from their real name so as to not be able to be easily found, listing their security jobs with again, sufficiently far enough away org names. Turtles all the way down.
- hydroplane 4y agoOne thing about LinkedIn that profoundly bothered me when it got popular was the fact that you were expected to share a photo on your profile. Back in the day, in the US, attaching a photo to a resume was a big no-no, but here was a new way of recruiting that circumvented that principle. I found it shocking how readily and eagerly people threw that convention out.
- tluyben2 4y agoI removed my profile from LinkedIn 2 years ago because it was starting to get crazy; I got calls and emails from obvious scammers every day. The problem is that when I introduce myself, people always get suspicious of me not having a LinkedIn profile. Someone needs to reinvent a professional network.
- DJHenk 4y agoA few months ago I searched and found a new job without having a Linkedin profile. Was no problem at all, especially as a developer. If someone asks you can tell then that you got fed up with the recruitment spam and they will understand and nod. I did have a personal website though. Doing it without any online presence at all would be harder I guess, as it was a remote job in another country.
- e40 4y agoThe easy fix for (2) is to only view the PDF in the cloud (e.g., Google Docs).