10 ms·
The Swerve
- PeterStuer 4y agoLast time we tried, they divided us back-seaters in tribes and fighting each other, window seater vs isle seaters, unpair against even rows, all tackling each other rather than trying to make it through the champagne sipping front rows and the wheel.
- thanatos519 4y agoIt's like a cross between 'The Big Bus'(1976) and 'Snowpiercer'(2013). Grab your pitchforks and torches and let's get to the front of the bus! Seriously, I agree that this is the only choice, but what is the actual plan?
- colechristensen 4y agoThe actual plan is “nothing”. There’s going to be an S curve where a large portion of fossil fuel energy is replaced with solar and a large portion of internal combustion motors are going electric. Both of those because they are cheaper more than any other reason. The climate is going to warm, the habitable zones of earth are going to move north, some equatorial regions are going to be uninhabitable, lots of people are going to have to move, lots of agriculture is going to have to move. How bad it is just depends on how well we prepare for and adapt to change. The people who just predict doom over and over and try to use that to promote some impossible change to “stop” climate change aren’t helpful.
- LarryDarrell 4y agoIt's not a bus, it's a train. Best case you can slow it down for a few people to jump off. Carter told people to wear a sweater and the American people flipped out and elected a ghoulish union-busting zombie. Twice. There will be no change until it is forced upon us when the treats stop flowing. And even then you just have to hope that the populace has an accurate story in their heads as to why.
- bsedlm 4y agoit's a train, and it crashed already, but it's a rather humongous train, most of the train hasn't yet felt the shock from the crash also, it's not a literal train, some people will be able to say there's no crash even as they fly out
- LarryDarrell 4y ago... and the first class passengers simply exit and fly off in their jetpacks.
- onemoresoop 4y agoto go where? Mars isn't ready yet
- panarky 4y agoCloser to the poles, anywhere north or south of 48 degrees.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jrmg 4y ago> Carter told people to wear a sweater and the American people flipped out and elected a ghoulish union-busting zombie. I think you’re underestimating how much of Reagan’s appeal was _optimism_.
- morelisp 4y agoOptimism is “things can/will be better.” When things are bad, “things are better” is fraud and jingoism. I agree much of Reagan’s popularity was due to his willingness to lie and flatter.
- voakbasda 4y agoIt is just me, or is this an open call for a proletariat revolution against the bourgeois? Any successful "plunge past the first-class passengers" will not be a peaceful event.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- knodi123 4y agodamn, if we only had a functional democracy.
- jacquesm 4y agoEven if you do: that democracy will have to somehow work in concert with all of the other governments towards a single goal. We have - historically speaking - never done this. Ever. So I think the lesson will be a hard one and after that whatever remains will maybe be able to do a better job the next time around. If there is a next time around. I don't take that for granted at all.
- prometheus76 4y agoI'm sure that tyranny of the majority will lead us to enlightened places...
- yxwvut 4y agoThank god we have the rich to care for us instead, they know what's best.
- imtringued 4y agoPseudo capitalistic central planning? I sometimes wonder if communism is just capitalism taken too far. E.g. capitalism devolved into monopolies and communism just skips straight to having the state be the ultimate monopoly.
- 4y ago
- themadturk 4y agoI like Cory, and I think he's right. But he's preaching to the choir. No one who can get hold of the wheel is listening.
- swayvil 4y agoPreaching to the choir pays his rent. The other options are sucking oligarchs, amusing children, selling off your body parts, living in a cardboard box and the vast frontier of crime.
- jamiek88 4y agoThe only thing stopping me being a very successful criminal since the world went to shit and leaders started getting away with heinous obvious shit is the thought that my parents would be very disappointed. if we are doomed anyway I might as well have my time on a yacht too.
- BLKNSLVR 4y agoSame here except the reason is "vengeance may be visited upon my children". I also think my subconscious moral compass would declare war upon my conscious self.
- jacquesm 4y agoTechnically, we all fractionally have hold of that steering wheel, but the decisions made in the boardrooms and the houses of parliament (assuming democracy, not always a given) will easily counteract the effects of private individuals deciding for themselves. It's actually really simple: this level of comfort is not sustainable without a major re-tooling of the way we interact with the eco-system, and if we don't adapt we will be adapted, quite likely by 'downsizing'.
- wrnr 4y agoThe is wrong on so many levels, in most places be it country or company the bus is being steered towards what is thought to result in global carbon reduction. This is a classic example of a moth and bailey argument, if only we had the same confidence about what to do about climate change as the fact of climate change. According to this article it is as if we only need to elect the right people and then those shall do the right thing.
- jacquesm 4y agoSomething I read in another comment on HN: "Climate denialists have gone in one smooth move from 'we'll fix it' to 'it's too late to do anything about it anyway'". Which unfortunately rings very true. The really, really big problem is that people seem to think that they personally are going to be exempt from this, that it will happen to others, but not to them. Waking up from that will be pretty harsh. But if COVID denialism is any indication of how well humanity deals with complex problems on a planetary scale I'm not too optimistic about climate change countermeasures, the problem is much more complex and would require cooperation on a far more massive scale than anything COVID related.
- UncleOxidant 4y agoThere's been all kinds of comments here about how Malthus' thesis was wrong. I'd agree that was the case if we could get the vast majority of humanity on the same page and actually deal with the many crises that currently face us (climate, food, extinction,etc). But given how we've dealt with the climate crisis up til now and how we handled (or didn't handle) covid, I think Malthus was probably right. I don't think he was even factoring in human nature just carrying capacity (and his calculations there were probably flawed), but it's human nature that's driving the bus.
- sbierwagen 4y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nSXIetP5iak https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nSXIetP5iak >Bernard: What if the Prime Minister insists we help them? >Humphrey: Then we follow the four-stage strategy. >Bernard: What's that? >Richard: Standard Foreign Office response in a time of crisis. In stage one we say nothing is going to happen. >Humphrey: Stage two, we say something may be about to happen, but we should do nothing about it. >Richard: In stage three, we say that maybe we should do something about it, but there's nothing we can do. >Humphrey: Stage four, we say maybe there was something we could have done, but it's too late now.
- danhak 4y agoHere in the U.S., at least, what has widely been maligned as "COVID denialism" was actually a deeper and more nuanced conversation about whether sudden, sweeping changes to society would prevent more harm than they cause. And now looking at outcomes across different states (e.g. Florida vs. California)--and considering ALL outcomes (public health, homelessness, unemployment, substance abuse, mental health, truancy, graduation rates, violent crime)--it's indeed unclear that draconian policies in the name of public health were a net positive. I am extremely concerned about climate change. But there seems to be little introspection from those who propose sweeping policy change about the need to consider second-order effects on those whose lives and livelihoods will be upturned. The general disdain for people in places like West Virginia gives me little hope that will change.
- 0des 4y ago> “Long before we go over the cliff, we’ll have figured out how to put wings on this bus.” Sounds like something a PM would say in a roundabout fashion
- karaterobot 4y agoI guess I'm in the camp that says that unless there are a bunch of people in the back row trying to sew a bus-sized parachute together out of old clothes, we're screwed. In other words, the only hope I have left is that somebody invents a climate-fixing machine. Or a bunch of different climate-fixing machines, I don't care. But, I don't see a lot of other appropriately-scaled options at this point.
- LeifCarrotson 4y agoAgreed. We're past the point where culture can shift in time to turn the wheel. Only technology shifts quickly enough to do so. EVs and wind/solar energies are examples of technologies which are so much better than the alternatives that they're succeeding at reducing emissions faster than consumption can grow to catch up. We don't have the time to get enough people together to mandate that the front row drives a Tesla instead of a Ford, nor to mandate that they produce wind farms instead of coal plants, but they're doing so of their own accord - and demand for them exceeds production capacity by a large margin - because the electric car is better and the wind energy is cheaper. As you say, we now need parachute tech.
- jacquesm 4y agoTough problem. Once you start doing back-of-the-envelope math regarding the masses and volumes you are talking about here as well as the time remaining it quickly tends to require all kinds of unobtanium, besides the obvious climate impact of engineering such a solution in the first place, because it needs to be a net positive otherwise you may as well not start. Funny thing: the only system that I'm aware of that could do this on this scale and cheap enough is called biology, and it operates on a timescale that is too slow to make it work in time.
- klipt 4y agoRemember all our heat comes from the sun. The cheapest climate mitigation may be to just block some sunlight: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_geoengineering https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_geoengineering
- prionassembly 4y agoThe thing about this kind of take is that there isn't really one bus hurtling towards one cliff. Climate, biodiversity, water pollutants, sustainable agriculture and extractivism... these are not orthogonal, but often run in different directions nonetheless. And then there's civilizational issues...
- jacquesm 4y agoYes, that's very true, the trouble is on many, many axis at once. This is what makes it so hard to engineer a solution: come up with something that might work along one axis and chances are that you are making things worse along another. Which then need to be weighed to decide if the change is a net positive and this isn't always easy to see at all. For instance: a massive re-tooling towards solar and wind has its own climate impact as well as effects on available resources, pollution and lots of other side effects.
- SMAAART 4y agoThe moment we politicize science, is the moment that society at large loses. And by "society at large" I mean everyone. Game theorist should study this
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dougmwne 4y agoThe swerve is not happening. The bus driver and first class passengers are locked up front. The road is on a steep decline. The bus is going fast and still accelerating. This sucker is going over the edge.
- dash2 4y agoRespectfully suggest this is nonsense. No serious climate scientist thinks we are going to fall off a cliff. There will be huge costs, yes. Civilization won't end, no. What people fail to grasp is that costs can be absolutely enormous but look like a blip compared to the effect of GDP growth in the long run. World War II is an example. The millions of deaths barely show up on a graph of world population. The huge losses barely interrupt the smooth rise of GDP. Similarly, climate change could knock 5% off GDP permanently, this would be "the world's biggest collective action problem" as I think Nick Stern put it, but it wouldn't stop human society getting much richer. Edit: a bit of backup: https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaelshellenberger/2019/11/25/why-everything-they-say-about-climate-change-is-wrong/#166b581612d6 https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaelshellenberger/2019/11/25...
- the_af 4y ago> No serious climate scientist thinks we are going to fall off a cliff. There will be huge costs, yes. Civilization won't end, no. I've read more than a couple of articles, linked to here on HN, of climate scientists claiming that this is indeed a civilization-ending cliff. It's been mentioned like this in other media, for example in Cosmos 2. Yes, that's divulgation, but nonetheless, it means the scientists consulted for Cosmos 2 believe this. edit: just googled Michael Shellenberger. He is not a subject matter expert on climate change, and Wikipedia describes him as "a controversial figure" among environmentalists, which means his position is not mainstream and probably shouldn't be used to state "no serious scientist believes...". Note: I'm not saying he is wrong, he could be right; it's just that his view is not mainstream for now.
- kkjjkgjjgg 4y ago
- zitterbewegung 4y agoAlso the biggest problem to solve for the climate crisis is to solve for diesel fuel. If you could replace Diesel engines with anything else or curb their emissions that is the biggest contributor to CO2.
- 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- yongjik 4y ago> Incredibly, climate denial still festers. “There’s no cliff,” they insist. “This bus is on a smooth road that goes all the way to the promised land. Only a fool would swerve now.” I think I get the main theme, but I don't think "climate cliff" is a useful analogy. It makes one picture a scene of relative calm until suddenly (and abruptly) the shit hits the fan, when the reality is going to be far more messy. (Just look at all those historians who could never agree on exactly what year the Roman Empire fell.) If anything, it will make people argue "Well, we haven't hit the cliff yet, which means we still have time," or, worse, "They've preached that we will hit the cliff by 2020, a bunch of liars!" I think the fictional "denialist" in the sentence is actually half right. Instead of a cliff, we will have a smooth ride... to hell. We will never have one glorious catastrophe where we get to say "I told you so" five seconds before dying. Instead, half of the passengers will still be arguing that we're fine while we're slowly dying.
- jacquesm 4y agoIt doesn't really matter, does it? As analogies go it's pretty clear what the message is and for that purpose this metaphor is good enough. Any arguing over the shape of the metaphor is essentially pointless, if you didn't get it then it doesn't matter because you are clearly not the target audience, and if you did get it you realize that it is a leaky abstraction, but a useful one nonetheless.
- mulmen 4y agoIt's more like we are stuck in a confined space and slowly gassing ourselves with CO2 and we are arguing over turning the engine off. Oh, wait, no, it is literally that.
- shadowgovt 4y agoI like Cory, but he's an optimist. He's missing a key fact about the first class passengers. Globally, classism has become so pronounced that, to preserve the metaphor, if anyone tries to swerve the bus the first class passengers will just kill them and won't stop killing until the bus is light enough to jump the gorge. They don't see the need to now, because nobody is making any serious notions to grab the wheel. But the 1% can pay another 5% or so to leverage the asymmetric warfare tools available against the remaining 94%. There are approximately 8 billion human beings on the planet right now. Cory is proposing a solution that saves 6 billion of them, maybe, if we play our cards right. But we already have weapons that can atomize cities. Removing a few key, highly populated cities from the planet would crater the number of people that our resources need to sustain, which is to say the number of people generating the sort of pollution that is threatening the biosphere, into the one to two billion range. And hey, bonus effect, overuse of those weapons results in a global cooling phenomenon. Win-win. I wish those grabbing the wheel luck, because they're going to have to grab it faster than the first class passengers can reach for their knives.
- syrrim 4y agoThis analogy is too hopeful for a couple reasons. First, the swerve is made to seem like a decisive action that is taken once and then is never repeated. In practice, if people don't like that we've slowed the bus, they can speed it right back up again. Second, the one's blocking the swerve are supposed to "first class passengers", which seemingly stand in for the rich and powerful. In practice, its many of the least well off who are against decisive action to stop climate change, which they perceive as being especially harmful to themselves. If all it took was one person rushing to the front of the bus and yanking on the steering wheel, then it likely would have happened by now.
- jacquesm 4y agoFunny, I read 'first class passengers' as 'those in the rich and developed countries who are for the most part responsible for climate change due to their excessive carbon footprint'.
- sbierwagen 4y agoIf you define "rich and developed" as NATO+Japan then that's more than a billion people. Forcing that many people to reduce CO2 emissions to third world standards wouldn't require a "yank of the steering wheel", it would need nuclear war.
- actionfromafar 4y agoSo, you are saying there is still hope?
- shepherdjerred 4y agoAre you saying nuclear war is preferable to climate change? What exactly is your definition of good? It sure isn’t the well-being of humanity or the planet.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tarr11 4y agoargument by analogy is so frustrating. Half of the comments here are about bus drivers and cliffs.
- people_not_bots 4y agoComrade Cory Doctorow is correct as usual its tragic how absolutely capture capital and political systems are by dying generation of reactionaries whose entire political ideology is a refusal to change with the times.
- atweiden 4y agoAnother option is to pump the brakes. > “As the lockdown to stop the spread of coronavirus in India continues, pollution levels across much of the country have dropped sharply. Now some residents in northern India say they can see the snow-capped Himalayas 200 kilometres away for the first time in 30 years.” [1] If we had a global deflationary economic system, the incentive to invest in capital and engage in consumerism would dissipate. People would work less, because there would be less reason to work. Without work, people would have less reason to travel. Pollution would drop accordingly. Under a deflationary economic system, a touch over $480,000 in savings would yield an effective “UBI” of $1000/mo [2]. Once adopted by the entire world, a global currency of fixed supply controlled by computer algorithms could achieve this. Humans would voluntarily work less and pollute less. [1] https://www.sbs.com.au/language/english/audio/himalayas-visible-for-first-time-in-30-years-as-pollution-levels-in-india-drop https://www.sbs.com.au/language/english/audio/himalayas-visi... [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31759685 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31759685
- jljljl 4y agoThis works really well if you have $480,000 in savings, but it doesn't really work if you have 0 savings, or debt. Deflation, with its disincentives to investment or economic growth, would reduce employment and real wages. Most Americans would lose their jobs or see their wages cut as the economy ground to a halt. Anyone with debt would likely be trapped working for the rest of their life at subsistence wages, never making enough to pay their debts off. At that point, you'd need an entire overhaul of the economy, not just an algorithmic monetary system
- noduerme 4y agoSo? What about the cliff? Isn't that more important than getting people out of debt? It's this kind of thing that makes reasonable people who do want to avert climate disaster wonder whether the cliff analogy isn't just a rallying cry to push an agenda of nationalization and redistribution of private property. In other words, just because we do swerve doesn't mean the socioeconomic upheaval is likely to work out in favor of people who want to eat the rich, or anything resembling justice either. More likely what will happen is everyone will get poorer in a somewhat linear fashion, meaning the rich will still be rich and the poor will be below water. If the only way to cure the climate crisis is to prevent people from flying having tchotchkes, how naive is Corey to think that the rich will somehow stop those things before the middle class and poor do? But it's dangerous and flawed to mix climate targets with social justice targets for this very reason. Hinging the swerve on a social/economic revolution means it will never happen.
- mbgerring 4y agoEverybody commenting on this should quit their job and work on climate change at the object level if they’re not already. That means: deploying existing solutions to reduce carbon emissions at scale, and commercializing new methods of doing so in order to deploy them. There are a lot of jobs in the field, and doing the work beats metaphors and speculation. Check climatebase.org for climate jobs and get to work.
- deltaonefour 4y ago
- ramesh31 4y agoMaybe it's fatalist to say, but the only rational action at this point is to adapt. This is happening whether any of us individuals want it to or not at this point. Perhaps it's time to drop the fear and uncertainty and look at this as a challenge to be dealt with outside the context of any form of emissions control. The only plausible foreseeable future at this point is one with total runaway greenhouse conditions. So now what?
- swayvil 4y agoPrinces fight other princes. This activity dominates their lives and fills their entire perspective. Which makes sense. Because if you let up for a moment, your competition surely won't. So to tell the princes, "hey, put that furious game aside for a sec. We have something more important to attend to" isn't gonna do it. I think that the princes, these people who control the world, are psychologically incapable of quitting the prince-game.
- macinjosh 4y agoHow many times have you flown somewhere in the last 10 years? How many commutes have you made? Travel is the most inefficient, wasteful, and anti-climate activity I can think of because for many cases it is simply unnecessary or discretionary. Beyond having some 100,000 flights per day pumping greenhouse gases directly into the atmosphere think of the infrastructure and workforce involved in running airports, hotels, car rentals, shuttles, parking lots, restaurants, uber/taxis, etc. I think air travel should be rare and expensive especially for business and vacations. Perhaps a heavy tax on business and pleasure travel would be good place to start. While we are at it work should be done remotely whenever possible and empty office buildings should be renovated into affordable housing.
- randallsquared 4y agoWe could have had wings on the bus already, but the same group of people who are most vocal about the cliff have an older and more pronounced fear of flying.
- graaben 4y agoIs it naive to think we could prevent the impending ecological collapse and international conflict with mass fusion power? Unlimited energy to remove carbon from the atmosphere, oceans, etc. You also don't need to sell the rich on a life of austerity, as that kind of electricity would allow us to continue and even increase our current Western way of life.
- me_again 4y agoToday, fusion power is not workable. We have no idea if or when it will be. "Let's carry on as-is until fusion works" is "don't worry, we'll put wings on the bus" in Doctorow's terms. By all means, let's continue fusion research. But we should also urgently work on some other angles just in case.
- dzink 4y agoThe green of developed countries simply outsources the dirty to the poorer neighbours who don’t have regulations and need the money. Germany has outsourced food to southern and eastern europe, everything but high margin manufacturing to China, recycling or garbage to whomever is willing to dirty up their air for money (aka the mafia or authoritarian leaders who want more money, which then takes it to poor corrupt countries and burns it), energy to Russia, and military ti the US. Until your green is everyone’s green, the planet is not getting saved. Safe nuclear and other helpful tech is where surplus money should be going.
- darkteflon 4y agoWe are absolutely unprepared for what’s coming. There will be no swerve, no “coming out the other side”. As a species we have none of the character, nor the political and social tooling, to meet this challenge, even if we have some or all of the technological tooling. The incentives simply point the wrong way. It’s all baked in, this late in the day.
- narrator 4y agoIf you look at Sri Lanka right now, their society is completely falling apart not because of climate change, but because there is no oil. If you look at Saudi, they can't raise production, not because of climate change, but because there is no more oil. If you look at the war in Ukraine, the Russian ruble is the best performing currency of 2022, and the Russians are by all accounts not doing badly in the Ukraine war mainly because they have plenty of oil. Climate change may show up and get us is a few years, or it may take longer. Running out of oil is starting now, we're already in the middle of it. What's the deal with nobody talking about running out of oil and instead the focus on climate change? With the climate change narrative we get to the same place as the running out of oil narrative, but the only solution is to work together on alternatives. With the running out of oil narrative, the focus is on solutions, but it also becomes a war between nations for the remaining resources. We're seeing Germany revert back to coal now, for which there is more spare supply than oil. I don't really have a solution here. Maybe we would have better ones if there were more clarity around what the actual situation is.
- dredmorbius 4y agoAn author I discovered only in the past decade, though he's been active since the 1970s, is William Ophuls. He was amongst the first to write of the political dimension of addressing global catastrophic risks. Initially, that was largely focused on the concept of resource limits. Global warming isn't unrelated, though it's a sink limit: boundaries on the ability of the environment to absorb the consequences of human activity without making that human activity itself untenable. What Ophuls realised, and what I'm increasingly convinced of, is that it's not the technical element, but rather the political, social, cultural, and economic (commerce, finance, trade, power) aspects which will prove the most challenging. And he seems to have been correct. I strongly recommend all his work, though Ecology and the Politics of Scarcity (first published in 1977, revised ~1994) and Plato's Revenge (2011) are probably the best starting points. https://www.worldcat.org/title/ecology-and-the-politics-of-scarcity-prologue-to-a-political-theory-of-the-steady-state/oclc/1222878433 https://www.worldcat.org/title/ecology-and-the-politics-of-s... https://www.worldcat.org/title/ecology-and-the-politics-of-scarcity-revisited-the-unraveling-of-the-american-dream/oclc/1033584104 https://www.worldcat.org/title/ecology-and-the-politics-of-s... https://www.worldcat.org/title/platos-revenge-politics-in-the-age-of-ecology/oclc/8162554740 https://www.worldcat.org/title/platos-revenge-politics-in-th... Also available via Archive Org: https://archive.org/search.php?query=william%20ophuls https://archive.org/search.php?query=william%20ophuls Ophuls has a website with more recent writings: https://web.archive.org/web/20190311104851/https://ophuls.org/essays https://web.archive.org/web/20190311104851/https://ophuls.or... As he's on in years, I've looked for others who are carrying on his tradition. Canadian political scientist Thomas Homer-Dixon is referenced by Ophuls several times and seems closest: https://homerdixon.com/ https://homerdixon.com/