7 ms·
Startups, this is how design works (2012)
- EGreg 4y agoWell, these designers might have considered making this page responsive so the text isn’t super timy on a mobile phone.
- ronyfadel 4y agoThis “well designed” page is so hard to read on mobile
- turnsout 4y agoTo be fair, it's from 2012, so it's missing out on a literal decade of mobile web design.
- MonkeyMalarky 4y agoEven then, it's over designed? Is that a thing? Kind of like an over produced song.
- sparrish 4y agoBut one of the design principles is "Long Lasting" "It avoids being fashionable and therefore never appears antiquated. Unlike fashionable design, it lasts many years – even in today’s throwaway society."
- yodon 4y agoThe units conversion app shown on the page is particularly pretentious and poorly aligned with user needs. Everything about it is there to say "look at me" and "see how fashionable I am in the eyes of 2008 tech fashion." None of it is there to make the app easy or fast to interact with, nor is any of it there to make the results of the units conversion easy to read or use. The fact that the page designer chose this image to explain what good design is lays bare that the emperor truly has no clothes here.
- hbn 4y agoIn terms of aesthetic choices, I think the design does hold up quite well. In 2011, 6% of internet traffic was mobile, compared to 56% in 2021 (according to the first Google result I clicked) I wouldn't say not having a mobile-responsive design back then was entirely a design failure. I recall in the early days of smartphones, the vision for mobile browsers was they were "desktop class" and would display pages exactly like how they are on desktop. Look at Steve Jobs' original Safari demo during the iPhone reveal. Everyone was blown away by the full desktop experience of The New York Times and Amazon. This website was a few years into the iPhone revolution, but it was early enough into the mobile responsiveness era that I don't think it takes away from their point. The current design could be adapted to a mobile responsive page without needing an overhaul of the existing design language.
- tambourine_man 4y agoI agree with most of what you said but the iPhone was released in 2007. This was released in 2011.
- turnsout 4y agoYeah, the "mobile-first" movement didn't happen overnight—and ironically, because of Steve's influence, it took the longest for people who latched on to the ethos behind the original iPhone Safari. Just look at Gruber—Daring Fireball still isn't mobile-optimized.
- tambourine_man 4y ago4 years is not overnight. And Gruber's CSS has more to do with his obsessive to a paralyzing degree nature, than to sticking to whatever was said in a keynote 15 years ago. Besides, double tapping a paragraph zooms into what becomes a good reading experience on mobile. It’s that dangerous “good enough”. He obviously should update his site and ditch Verdana, we have better fonts and screens this days. But, if anything, it’s a testament of how good the original design was that it stood the test of time and what was designed for IE5/6 on 800x600px screen is still good on an iPhone 12.
- bioemerl 4y agoSomething that is long lasting can be a bit dated by the time it's ten years old, given how fast tech can move.
- turnsout 4y agoYes! Dieter Rams came up with those 10 principles, but I doubt he still listens to music with the wall-mounted reel-to-reel tape player he designed (though it's still beautiful). In fact, the reel-to-reel probably felt dated within much less than 10 years.
- defanor 4y agoTo be fair, it's hard on a desktop too, and with JS off the diagrams are hidden. I've clicked mostly to ensure that yet another website dedicated to design has a bad design.
- Signez 4y agoAt some point, we'll have to talk about the fact that designers can't explain anything about their work (and/or the vision of their work) to other non-designers professionals without being particularly condescending. The fact that we can notice this even in the startup sector speaks even louder.
- dfee 4y agoKinda like being ‘cool’. It’s not really formulaic, but instead subject to its environment.
- andrei_says_ 4y agoOh, yes, it is :) My favorite take on "cool" (and Albert Camus) is this existential comic: https://www.existentialcomics.com/comic/451 https://www.existentialcomics.com/comic/451
- oldstrangers 4y agoMaybe you're just hanging around annoying people? I work at a large agency, we have to explain our design rationale every day to people that have zero design backgrounds. The better we do this, the better we're able to do our job. If we acted like assholes we wouldn't be in business very long.
- Isamu 4y ago>explain our design rationale every day to people that have zero design backgrounds. The better we do this, the better we're able to do our job. Exactly, the really good and professional designers I worked with spent a lot of time to explain and work with me and show evidence for their approach. To be condescending and dismissive is a warning sign that maybe somebody is being arbitrary and has to cover up their lack of professional development.
- dgb23 4y agoAlso it's a two way street. When I'm implementing a UI, I try to understand the principles and ideas behind a design. Good tooling and some experience/knowledge helps, but ultimately it comes down to communication, asking questions and just having a discussion about a design. On the other side there is also a benefit of giving technical input about a design, sometimes there are more robust solutions from a technical standpoint that gel with what the designer does. I think both design and implementation are more efficient this way. It's also more fun.
- aetherson 4y agoIf you've ever seen those Kumon tutoring places, their windows usually have the slogan: "Math. Reading. Success." I always joke to my wife that people should skip the math and reading classes and just take a success class. Obviously, "success" is real. We can say very clearly that some people are successful, some products are successful, some projects are successful. But "success" isn't a unified thing that you can teach. What makes it possible to be successful in a given domain is different in different domains. To be successful in a foot race and to be successful in stock trading require very different skills, such that you can't teach a "success" class that will make you successful at both a foot race and as a stock trader. And further, in a lot of endeavors, being "successful" requires not just particular skills to that endeavor, but a lot of different skills. Making the iPhone successful was about manufacturing at scale, software, hardware, marketing, supply chain management, contract negotiation, etc. Let me suggest that "design" is more like success than it is like math or reading. A product can be well-designed, but I'm dubious that there are unified "design" skills, especially ones that translate across a fairly wide domain. What makes a product well-designed is much more diverse than what people who talk about design typically admit, and I'm not sure that design as a field really makes any sense.
- mrxd 4y agoIt depends on how you define design. Herbert Simon defined it as “to devise courses of action aimed at changing existing situations into preferred ones.” And there’s a lot of academic work around that. The problem is that that’s not how the word is used in practice. I think most people would call that “planning”, and certainly design is a type of planning, but not all planning is done by people who we call designers. I think a better definition that’s actually used in practice is that design is a way of looking at a product as if it was a kind of communication. The central question is “how will people perceive this?” so any type of art skill—not just visual arts, but theatre, music, writing, etc—is potentially transferable. Communication is a universal human skill, so it raises the question of why a separate discipline has emerged in companies to handle the communicative aspects of the product. And I think this is because many people who work in tech fields are educated in fields with very specific conventions of communication, and an expectation that the burden of understanding lies with the listener. When these norms inform the creation of a product, especially when it’s aimed at non-technical users, it leads to “bad design”.
- jeffrallen 4y agoCan't read on mobile, won't read. Come on designers... do your job, instead of talking about it.
- intrasight 4y agoSame. I guess it's an article about design by print designers. Have to print it out to consume it.
- sillycube 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- yellowapple 4y agoThe combination of tiny text and a giant Bitmoji (or whatever they're called) face toward the end is what immediately convinced me that this page must be satire.
- dang 4y ago"Please don't complain about tangential annoyances—things like article or website formats, name collisions, or back-button breakage. They're too common to be interesting." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html Btw, it was someone's school project from 2012 (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3790034 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3790034).
- tuyenhx 4y agoSorry, but the design for reading on this site is just too bad. I hate it. Why dont you keep it simple? Really? Is this how design works?
- h4waii 4y agoClassic do as I say, not as I do, made even better by this being about design and it's terribly designed. The page is both unreadable and unnavigable on mobile, any browser. Nothing better than being told what to do, by people who clearly are incapable of actually doing it but think they are masters of it.
- vachina 4y agoThis site is miles better than a wall of text. It actually made me read from top to bottom, which is something I rarely do.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- beardedman 4y agoI was just thinking that this feels like it's from like a decade ago - and then boom, 2012 at the bottom. Still good points though. I do believe design also has a culture/trend ebb & flow to it, so stuff we see from 2012 actually looks dated - just like music, comedy, movies (etc.) can also feel dated.
- vsri 4y agoFeels very dated. They don't even have Figma in their tools section and are still referencing things like Flinto and Skitch(!)-- a nice throwback to when I first entered tech 10 years ago.
- hangonhn 4y agoGood God, that page looks like someone barfed all over my screen. It's really ironic that a page that lionized Dieter Rams has such an atrocious layout and dizzying "print". It varies between highlighting and bold italics to emphasize something. The medium also switches from text, videos, and info graphics. Sometimes the text is one column but then shifts into 3 columns layout and back again. All I got from the page was "Dieter Rams". He's amazing but we already knew that if any of us only knew one thing about industrial design.
- greatgib 4y agoSo an awful page, things everywhere around the page without any logic, inconsistent highlight and colors everywhere. I'm not epileptic, but I felt that I was so close to a seizure just trying to read a few things on this page. Maybe it is not a real website but an ironic joke?
- mixedCase 4y agoNigh unreadable on a Thinkpad with the low-end screen due to lack of contrast. Good job designers.
- andrei_says_ 4y agoI was disappointed to see Pinterest and Facebook as prime examples of design. These are companies found on dark patterns, employing hostile methodology to manipulate their users. Yes, they are popular and use carefully selected colors etc. but are horrible below the pretty paint. I wish the page would mention the responsibility of designers to the end users of their work. I'd recommend Mike Monteiro's "Broken by Design" to the authors of the page.
- nerdponx 4y agoI would argue that Facebook and Pinterest succeeded in spite of their respective chaotic and difficult UX designs.
- mbesto 4y agoSimilarly there is some good research about this regarding Amazon. In short, if you tried to mimic Amazon's UX as a ecommerce startup, you'd probably fail: Paradoxically, Amazon's design may work well for Amazon itself. The company is simply so different from other ecommerce sites that what's good for Amazon is not good for normal sites.[0] [0] https://www.nngroup.com/articles/amazon-no-e-commerce-role-model/ https://www.nngroup.com/articles/amazon-no-e-commerce-role-m...
- radiorental 4y agoUXer with 25+ years here. To be respectfully blunt "the responsibility of designers to the end users of their work." No, it's our job to make the user's goals as seamless as possible - within the functional constraints of the business. If that business is to fuck users privacy over, we must operate within that overarching environment or GTFO. To be clear, I dont understand how conscientious UXer's function at a place like Facebook, unless the plot of Servance is a reality?
- mixmastamyk 4y agoProfessional ethics are a thing. "I was just following orders" not a valid excuse. This goes for developers and data folks as well (everyone), so not like designers are being targeted.
- reaperducer 4y agoThis feels like spam. The domain name for a single article is the same as the article's title? There's been a lot of these on HN over the last year. All very suspicious. No legitimate person is registering a domain for every single blog item they write. In addition, it's been submitted to HN 13 times before.
- velomash 4y agoClicking this on mobile makes for a very ironic reading experience. The medium is the message here.
- VoodooJuJu 4y agoThis site is a busy mess. I would describe its design as schizophrenic.
- mrwnmonm 4y agoI am building a startup, and with all respect to the creators of this project, when confronted with a UI full of objects that you have no idea how the user will preceive it, these advices don't really help.. "Make a product useful" is almost like "Do the right thing".
- achow 4y agoFrom 2012
- tlogan 4y agoMaybe this site should be designed better? Meaning it is not readable on mobile. It is not any better on the desktop. Also piecharts - really? Do they know that people with even minor color blidnes do not read piecharts in same way as you think? I 100% understand and agree with points but this site shows that achieving these points is really really hard. Maybe impossible?
- carom 4y agoDesign versus UX. Totally illegible on mobile. Looks pretty though.
- krm01 4y agoI’ve been helping startups design interfaces (B2B SaaS mostly) for 12+ years [1]. Here are my insights: the big misconception is that design is important in every stage of your startup. Which is not the case. Design becomes important after you’ve tackled the fundamentals and hit product market fit. The companies I’ve worked with that ended up being successful, all fit in that category. Startups that would contact us before having product market fit, would see themselves innovate slower by focussing on design. It would literally slow them down. Instead of talking to customers they would ask us to change the colors of their buttons for the tenth time. Once you have a product, that sort of works and a handful of customers love it, despite it looking like crap… that’s when design becomes a powerful fuel to your rocket. [1] https://fairpixels.pro https://fairpixels.pro
- edu 4y agoBut good design isn’t just the interface, good design is also about understanding the customer and discovering the product they will love. Function over form, as the mantra goes.
- efields 4y agoLol at the fact that this is unreadable on a phone.
- dgb23 4y agoI agree with some parts what is being said here, but overall I get a feeling that the content is ultimately superficial. I don't mean this as a joke or pun. For example really good UI design is more often than not conservative and not innovative. There are reasons to break the rules, but just breaking them in order to be "innovative" often comes off as edgy and showoff-y and almost always introduces unnecessary problems. A good reason to break the rules is borne from problem _solving_ and choosing the right trade-offs. Something I'm missing here is consistency. It is probably one of the hardest things to achieve, because in order to be consistent, a design needs to adhere to a common set of goals and restrictions. Being inconsistent and "patching over" a design or introducing new concepts is always easier. This can introduce actual problems in a design that need solving and this is where innovation can or should happen.
- joshstrange 4y ago
- mechanical_bear 4y agoThis is so condescending it’s hard to take seriously.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- maw 4y ago> Good design is makes a product useful and understandable. Good editing is makes all element of a lists is has the same grammatical form.
- parham 4y agoI mean at least have good design… that was a bad use of the web medium.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- seumars 4y agoYou can tell this was written when design-thinking jargon was at its peak. The retelling of Rams' "10 principles" is always funny to me because he never "set out" to write those rules. For the uninitiated, here's a summary: Starting in the late 70s Rams talked about the design ideas that led to the success of Braun, specifically three rules: a rule of order, a rule of harmony and a rule of economy. Later he would be describe these further as "function and performance, feasibility and aesthetic quality". Years later, his reflections on his contributions to Braun became six principles: "1. Good Design is innovative, 2. Good design renders utility to a product, 3. Good design is aesthetic design, 4. Good design makes a product easy to understand, 5. Good design is unobtrusive, 6. Good design is honest". It's not until one of his lectures in 1985 where he added the last four: "Good design means durability, Good design means consistency down to the last detail, Good design means respect for the environment and Good design means as little design as possible." By the time these principles where published in the late 80s they were referred to as "Braun design department’s Design Philosophy" and were mostly a reflection of Braun's practice than Rams'. Nevertheless it seems Rams outlived the Braun brand and became a bigger brand himself. In his retrospective exhibition at the Design Museum in 2009, many drawings and photos of braun products where printed on posters which arguably started the Rams merchandise trend. The poster that had the ten principles also contained a paragraph by Rams didn't get as much attention. He wrote: "I have distilled the essentials of my design philosophy into ten principles. But these principles cannot be set in stone because, just as technology and culture are constantly developing, so are ideas about good design".
- EgeAytin 4y agoFeeling like optimization of design is overkill for early stage startups. In my perspective, if product/service can express themselves clearly with simple words, they shouldn't worry about perfect design.
- throwoutway 4y agoIronic that it renders terribly on iOS
- dang 4y agoRelated: How Design Works (2012) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10190700 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10190700 - Sept 2015 (19 comments) Startups, This Is How Design Works - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4995199 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4995199 - Jan 2013 (2 comments) Startups, this is how design works. - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3793299 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3793299 - April 2012 (1 comment) How Design Works - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3791427 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3791427 - April 2012 (49 comments) Show HN: Startups, this is how design works. - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3789977 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3789977 - April 2012 (4 comments)