12 ms·
We've had this trope before - Andrew Carnegie, for example. Gates is just copying the idea... Honestly, the company he built makes some good stuff, and also m
by zdw 15y ago
We've had this trope before - Andrew Carnegie, for example. Gates is just copying the idea...
Honestly, the company he built makes some good stuff, and also makes a lot of trouble for everyone else. The Embrace/Extend/Extinguish methodology which was created under Gates is something that anyone working in infrastructure is going to be fighting for the next 30 years, and it's holding innovation back. Does anyone out there love IE6, or Active Directory? Both are primary examples of this.
I don't hate Gates. I just think that he did a great job of making money at the expense of others, and in ways that still hurt the industry today.
Paying penance after the fact doesn't excuse the original actions.
- 3am 15y agoI didn't see it mentioned, but I give a ton of credit to Bill Gates for convincing Warren Buffett (who he plays bridge with) to give his money to charity in his lifetime. AD isn't as bad as IE6, either. And I no longer blame MSFT for IE6 now... it's kept alive by bad, outdated corporate policies.
- zdw 15y agoAD is much worse than IE6, but unless you're doing ops work that has to deal with it you probably wouldn't realize this. MS broke or eliminated other authentication modes from Windows, so companies were forced to use AD (with the associated DNS and other infrastructure). 12 years after introduction, there are no stable/viable alternatives. Competition really was exterminated in this case.
- 3am 15y agoSorry, I don't want to defend what they did with breaking compatibility with any product other than their own (IE, AD, Office, IIS killed Corel, Netscape... and so many other companies). I just don't see AD as a terrible standalone product. But you're right, I don't have a deep understanding of its shortcomings vs, say, OpenLDAP (though I'd love to learn something!).
- walkon 15y agoYou've heard of Novell, right? Microsoft didn't break it, it just wasn't that good. AD isn't horrible at all; I use it regularly and have zero issues.
- lloeki 15y ago> I use it regularly and have zero issues. People said that of IE6. Then came Firefox and despite it running circles around IE it took years before we could feel any displacement. The problem is there's simply no contender to AD anymore, and that's not by virtue of its quality.
- rrohan189 15y agoagree. that's huge value! And a whole bunch of other billionaires as well
- phzbOx 15y agoPeople bash over ie6 just because it was revolutionary at that time and some people are still using it. Yeah, it's a pain to deal with as it's a pain to deal with any old technologies. Try to support Netscape 2.0 for fun.
- wanorris 15y agoI don't know that I'd call IE6 "revolutionary", but it was indeed an excellent browser for its time. As terrible as its standards support was compared to later browsers, it was exemplary for its time. But it's impossible to ignore the way Microsoft reacted to winning the browser wars by shuttering the IE team and leaving web standards effectively adrift until Firefox came along and starting taking market share. Whether you call it reprehensible or want to call it a "good business decision" that just happened to be bad for consumers and the web, that will always be the legacy people remember about IE6.
- zerostar07 15y agoI 'm not sure how any rational account of Gates' legacy can be negative. He helped make computers affordable internationally, paving the way for their explosive mass adoption. Even with internet explorer, it introduced the internet to thousands of people. Computers (windows computers) have increased productivity dramatically since the 80s, so much that the cost of having to modify HTML for IE6 is relatively negligible.
- mekoka 15y agoIt's not rational either to only necessarily netting his contribution in the positive. Just ask yourself these two questions and you'll see what I mean. Did Microsoft contribute in advancing certain areas of computing and speed up the adoption of Internet technologies? Did Microsoft contribute in impeding certain areas of computing and slow down the adoption of Internet technologies?
- zerostar07 15y agoSurely Microsoft innovated, in a less-than-spectacular way most of the times with things like direct3d, plug-n-play etc. They added tcp/ip stack to windows and created internet explorer, even brought the internet directly to the desktop initially. While they did use their monopoly to push their products thus eliminating rivals, they did not directly block competition. You could still install netscape and windows is still a very open platform. I 'm not going to defend MS monopoly tactics of course, or make a scientific account of microsoft's pros and cons, but Windows had competitors in the open market, and yet they prevailed, not always because they were the better system, but they were not significantly worse than others. Compare that to the oft-praised Apple model: directly block competitors from making similar functionality instead of competing with them and lock people into their systems. Does that model not impede technology from advancing?
- matwood 15y agolike direct3d You just brought up the horrible memories of computer gaming pre-directX/3d. What a mess it was. Wonder if I have a floppy lying around with all my old custom autoexec.bat files? :)
- angelbob 15y agoMicrosoft builds stuff that's meant to last for an ungodly long time, and mostly they do it pretty decently. IE6 is still a standard because they built it to be a standard, and it has endured as a standard. This means it's hanging on, old and crusty and hard to use, when its contemporaries are long dead and thoroughly unlamented. I hate a lot of Java for this, too. That's not a good idea on my part either. Building this way is a specific market niche and we are all better off that there are products that fit that niche. You and I are not looking for products in that niche, but we should both give thanks that it exists.
- EdiX 15y ago> Microsoft builds stuff that's meant to last for an ungodly long time, and mostly they do it pretty decently. IE6 is still a standard because they built it to be a standard, and it has endured as a standard. IE6 is still standard because of customer lock-in, it was so littered with quirks and outright bad ideas that it still is very hard to replace and no-one, not even microsoft, is willing to replicate its behaviours. A prime example of why one should still hate Bill Gates.
- kitsune_ 15y agoAt the time, IE6's chief competitor was a bloated, slow, crashing version of Netscape. My first job after high school and before college was that of a web developer. If I recall correctly, we damned Netscape just as much for being so bad, as IE 4 and 5. "Cross-browser compatibility" -> FML. If you omitted the border attribute a table suddenly got 2 pixels of cell spacing in Netscape. Agony all around. AOL completely blew it when they acquired Netscape. You can't explain a drop from a 85-90% market share to 3-5% over the course of 6 years with shady MS tactics alone.
- EdiX 15y ago> At the time, IE6's chief competitor was a bloated, slow, crashing version of Netscape. At the time IE6 was released, every competitor of Internet Explorer had already been pushed out of the marked by the illegal bundling of IE4 and 5 with Windows 98. Microsoft had a precise Embrace, Extend, Extinguish strategy for the World Wide Web, IE4 was the Embrace, IE5 and IE6 were the Extend and then the IE team was disbanded and the plan was to never release a new version ever again (Extinguish). So, the reason IE6 is so hard to be compatible with is not just because "it's old" but because it was meant to be hard to be compatible with ("Extend") and it lasted so long because it was never meant to be replaced with anything (Extinguish). I'm surprised people couldn't see this happen 10 years ago, when Microsoft screwed us over, I'm even more surprised that some people don't see it now that the screwing over has happened. We should learn something from history.
- darrenkopp 15y agoi loved ie6 back in the day, it's just lasted too long. Does anyone like AJAX? And active directory is actually quite good.
- 6ren 15y agoI think both Gates and Carnegie should by evaluated by how they made their fortune, not how they spent it. They were both ruthlessly aggressive, yet also made their product affordable to more people. By the very act of creating a monopoly, Gates created a huge marketplace for applications that attracted investment - better in that sense that a fragmented market place. He didn't abuse it by charging monopoly rates (quite the opposite). Is a beneficial end through nasty means a net positive? Probably... overall..., but I hesitate - and the fact that both felt compelled to give the money away suggests that they weren't entirely comfortable with how they made it. And it seems most people weren't either. BTW: video of Gate's response http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FYQxLhlUtr0&t=6m50s http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FYQxLhlUtr0&t=6m50s (6:50)
- dereg 15y agoLets take your evaluation one step further. If you evaluate evaluate Gates and Carnegie through that lens, then governments are invariably more nasty than the sum of the world's past "monopolies". Do you agree with this? On another note, Gates' effect on the tech industry is merely your opinion; the effect of his philanthropic efforts is fact.
- 6ren 15y agoNot my opinion; just going by commentators. I personally think it's hard to judge, and was trying to illustrate that it's not simply black and white. Can you unpack your question and add some illustrative examples please? In what way are governments nasty, compared with previous governments?
- ramblerman 15y agoThe conclusion that them "giving their money away, at the end of their life" is correlated to them "not being comfortable with how they made it" is idiotic. Gates still leaves his family more than enough to live a comfortable happy life. Whatever his motivation, is purely speculative.
- andymoe 15y agoI'll give you the jab at IE6 but I take strong exception to your Active Directory comment. It is one of the cooler pieces of tech out of redmond and far and away better than the vanilla LDAP servers from Novel or just about anything else in the open source world. And don't get me started on OD in Apple Server... The multi-master replication features, plus distributed file system stuff, plus profiles, plus multisite policy deployments and on and on all made possible becuase of the core AD system. So sure, bag on IE6 but know there are people out there that can do amazing things with Microsoft software and AD is at the core of much of that.
- ww520 15y agoActive Directory is actually very good. Make admins life much easier in managing IT infrastructure.
- Alex3917 15y ago"Paying penance after the fact doesn't excuse the original actions." Wouldn't paying penance involve actually doing good in the world? So far as I can tell he's basically an overgrown man-child whose using his billions to basically enslave low-income minorities via school 'reforms'. Plus he's made a lot of investments into technologies to help third world countries, which have mostly been a bust.
- VMG 15y agoEven if the malaria vaccine is the only thing that pans out, it would have been worth it: http://www.forbes.com/sites/matthewherper/2011/10/18/glaxosmithkline-bill-gates-backed-vaccine-cuts-malaria-infections-by-half/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/matthewherper/2011/10/18/glaxosm...
- Alex3917 15y agoI doubt the malaria vaccine will pan out, and even if it does I doubt it will be worth it. Because Bill Gates 'donated' millions of dollars to politicians he was able to kill open standards and open file formats. Because of this there are literally hundreds of thousands if not millions of college-educated people whose entire jobs revolve around making things compatible with broken systems that were designed that way on purpose to make Bill Gates money. The net loss to society from this is far greater than the value of whatever money Bill Gates is trying to throw around after the fact.
- Niten 15y agoSome programmers having to use Microsoft software is a bigger deal for society as a whole than saving the world's poorest people from malaria and polio? That is a simply insane stance, if you really believe that.
- Alex3917 15y agoNo, I'm saying that if we had an extra million highly-educated people working on curing malaria then it would probably already be solved, instead of being maybe partially solved in another ten or fifteen years.
- blntechie 15y agoIt's hypothetical to say Gates held back innovation. Period. There is no way to arrive on what the world would be now if for e.g Bill didn't create Microsoft. I respect Jobs but admire Gates. The fact is, he contributed in making PCs affordable. Yes, the world could have had better technologies if not for Microsoft but you don't know that would have happened. It's always easy to imagine better things but reality is way different. Edit: And I'm surprised by the amount of hate against Bill Gates in HN. We all need to think a minute on what each one of us personally did to make the world better and then opine on Bill Gates. It's easy to hold grudge and hate someone for some hypothetical reasons.
- rrohan189 15y agoagree
- fauldsh 15y agoI have no issue with people hating Gates, but I hate how people mindlessly hate Gates whilst worshipping Jobs. I think there's in an argument that Apple holding back manufacturers through no-competes has a larger negative effect than anything Microsoft did, albeit in different markets.
- mixmastamyk 15y agoThe difference is between shitty products crowding out competition and great products crowding out competition. Therein lies the axis of opinion I think.
- gnosis 15y agoI think plenty of Apple products are pretty shitty -- though perhaps not always quite as shitty as Microsoft products.
- bzbarsky 15y ago"Great" products preventing even better products from coming to market is no better than shitty products preventing better products from coming to market. And the reason for that is that the goalposts for "great" are very easy to move. Once people see that something is better, they quickly demote the old "great". And that said, Safari on iOS may well be a case of shitty products crowding out competition. Can you get a browser with the stock iOS WebKit but the V8 JS engine on there instead of JavaScriptCore? Nope. Can you get a browser supporting web features that the stock WebKit on iOS doesn't happen to support? Nope. Lots of other things that could be done much better than Mobile Safari.... and yet they can't be, because such apps could not be offered through the Apple app store.
- marcamillion 15y agoYou know...this is something quite often misunderstood...as much as I hate IE6....believe me, I do....as a direct result of IE being included in the operating system, many more people got exposed to the notion of a browser. The fact is, there is no telling what 'true' Internet adoption would be today if it weren't for Bill Gates including IE in Windows. I am not saying that it wouldn't be the same, but you can't jump to the conclusion that it would be. We all use and love the internet because mainstream has adopted it. Bill Gates is a fundamental reason that the mainstream has adopted it.
- rbanffy 15y ago> Gates is just copying the idea... That's Bill's tragedy. To be remembered as the guy who never had a really original idea... (burn, karma, burn)