4 ms·
Of all the naysayers, the Hacker News community seemed to be one of the most consistent. I'm curious why that is? Is it because Groupon doesn't look ostensibly
by pbreit 15y ago
Of all the naysayers, the Hacker News community seemed to be one of the most consistent. I'm curious why that is? Is it because Groupon doesn't look ostensibly too technical? Is it a general disdain for commercial success? Is it for perceived arrogance? Is it a lack of business acumen?
- hugh3 15y agoWow, now there's a loaded question. Why don't you just ask us whether we're gonna stop beating our wives? The reasons to be skeptical of Groupon are well documented. Not that it's a bad business, by any means, it's just that it's an industry with low barriers to entry and many competitors, and Groupon's early success is unsustainable since it was built on persuading businesses to offer ridiculously good deals which are likely to lose them money; businesses are wising up to this, deals are getting worse, people are getting less interested, and in general the whole social-coupon industry seems to be settling into a new equilibrium in which a $10^10 valuation for Groupon seems excessive.
- byrneseyeview 15y agoI used to think it was an industry with low barriers to entry, as did lots of people who have lost lots of money on Groupon clones. I'm not sure why, but it turns out to be a really tough business for all but a few companies.
- Woost 15y agoGroupon's business is basically all sales and marketing. The v1 tech behind the deal-a-day offerings is trivial. (leaving aside recommendations and such) You need to be very good at signing up businesses and getting good terms for your company to succeed. In addition, you need to figure out how to get a stable base of customers of your site. Basically, Groupon clones have very low technical barriers to entry, but if you don't have a really good sales and marketing staff you're in trouble.
- pbreit 15y agoIt has natural monopoly-like characteristics: buyers go where the best deals are, sellers go where the most buyers are.
- fleitz 15y agoThe founders and early investors have all cashed out, they invent accounting metrics. When you look at the actions of their management team and combine it with weird accounting metrics, it would be more aptly named Grouponzi. It isn't a lack of business accumen, divesting yourself of a business at the height of it's market cap is the right thing to do. The problem is that in order to do sell at the highest price you need to convince someone else that the business will be worth even more in the future. For being able to do that he is a brilliant business man. If pouring cash into this business would make it profitable then why did 90% of their Series G go to cashing people out? It seems to me that if Andrew Mason believed what he says then he'd go all in and take a modest profit to secure himself for the rest of his life. Instead he sees what everyone else sees which is a business about to tank.
- pbreit 15y agoSo when is the right time for an executive to take money off the table? Ever? AirBnB founders took money off the table. Is that a bad sign for it? Founder liquidity is not rare.
- fleitz 15y agoWhen it suits them, it doesn't matter to me, I could care less if an executive can convince someone to take their stock off of them. Taking 'like a billion dollars' in liquidity when your company is bleeding cash does not engender me to believing that the management team sees long term viability in the company. Groupon is built to flip, if you're a trader a stock like groupon is perfect, there will be lots of volatility to trade on. I'm not a trader, I believe in creating long term value. Groupon might be the kind of thing where a guy like Buffett could take advantage of the cash flows it generates to build a bigger better Berkshire. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5ydqjqZ_3oc http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5ydqjqZ_3oc This is fundamentally the best explanation of the groupon business model.
- tadfisher 15y agoNope; it's mostly their ethical void. The business boils down to temporarily delaying payments to merchants, in the meantime reporting those payments as revenue. This inflates the value of the company and misleads investors into believing their business model is more viable than it actually is. On the flipside, their customers (merchants) are reporting that they do not see the conversion rates that Groupon advertises to lure them into a deal. In response, they try things like raise their prices prior to honoring a deal, which further dilutes the value of Groupon's product.
- pbreit 15y agoNeither point makes much sense. No matter when payouts are made, Groupon keeps around 40% (an extraordinarily lucrative business). I'm not exactly sure what you're getting at regarding conversion rates. From a merchant perspective Groupon offers the unheard of conversion rate of 100%. Every single prospect generates a sale and the vast majority walk through the door.
- chefsurfing 15y agoI think it has to do with a perception that Groupon does not create as much of the value they take credit for.
- joezydeco 15y agoIn Chicago, there's an additional resentment that the business community considers Groupon the first successful web startup in the city to ever go public.