5 ms·
They're beaming almost 100mbps from the space to surface of the earth, to us, mere consumers, and they're the worst because they're slower than some wired solut
by bayindirh 4y ago
They're beaming almost 100mbps from the space to surface of the earth, to us, mere consumers, and they're the worst because they're slower than some wired solutions?
I'm seriously worried about the pollution they create for astronomers, but that's seriously absurd.
Do I need to repeat? They're beaming this from space, to your home.
- gamblor956 4y agoStarlink chose the 100mbps threshold over trying to satisfy the lower speed threshold because the higher threshold makes their business plan viable (it lets them get $$$ government funding for providing high-speed rural connectivity). They don't get kudos for failing to meet the standard they're required to meet as a condition of the government program they need to make their business work.
- spywaregorilla 4y agoThey built and shipped something really cool and useful. That seems like it deserves some kudos.
- fshr 4y ago> The full Starlink satellite system doesn't have 4,408 sats. That's just the Gen 1 constellation. They have committed to completing the Gen 2 constellation, with an additional 7,518 sats, which each provide many times more bandwidth than the Gen 1 sats, by 2027, well in time for the RDOF.
- yellowapple 4y agoAnd not just to your home. I'm very strongly considering ponying up the money for Starlink to be able to work while camped out in the middle of nowhere.
- Alupis 4y agoThe receiver doesn't seem to be easily portable, say on a backpacking trip or something. Perhaps that will change in the future though.
- yellowapple 4y agoTrue, but I've got a pickup :)
- xbar 4y agoI'm expecting an official cybertruck-bed-based antenna dish.
- skykooler 4y agoThe RV receiver fits in a backpack, though you'll need to carry a fairly heavy battery to power it for a while.
- mikestew 4y ago"fits in a backpack", with the implication that it will consume the internal volume of said backpack. That does not make it a solution for parent's "backpacking trip", unless you wish to sleep on the ground in the clothes you wore. And you ate before your left. The "heavy battery" was just icing on the cake. You know some backpackers saw the handles of their toothbrush to impress other backpackers^W^W^Wsave weight, right? :-) That's not to say Starlink or a competitor can't get there eventually. I already have pocketable/backpackable device that can shove data up and down a satellite link (Garmin InReach), it's just dog-slow, and that's likely down to the antenna and transmitter power if I were to guess. Someone with more RF smarts than I can probably cook up a foldable antenna, perhaps boost the power a bit, I dunno. But the PoC is there, it just needs iteration.
- dreamcompiler 4y agoThis is more of a physics problem than an engineering problem. Garmin InReach uses an omnidirectional antenna on the Iridium network. With an omni antenna your S/N ratio is simply too low to send bits fast. If you made the device powerful enough to roast birds in flight it might work for faster uplink but then it would be dangerous to you too and the FCC would never let you use it anyway. And even this wouldn't improve your downlink speed. The only way to improve the speed in both directions is to use a directional antenna, which points most of the uplink energy toward the satellite and concentrates the satellite's incoming energy to get the S/N ratio high in both directions. That's exactly what Starlink does. This is made even more difficult because we're talking about LEO satellites and LEO satellites move. So the antenna has to track the satellite. Again this is what Starlink is doing. (You can also use GEO satellites which don't move, but then latency becomes terrible. That's how the older satellite internet systems work.) It's certainly possible to build a portable, directional, tracking LEO satellite antenna. That's exactly what the Starlink RV solution is. But it's never going to be as small as your Garmin unit.
- BurningFrog 4y agoFriend of mine does that and works from ultra-remote southwesterns deserts when so inclined.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kenchan 4y agoMine is arriving today and I'm SUPER stoked. Bye AT&T forever!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rootusrootus 4y agoI do this. Anywhere I can drag my trailer. I have a favorite location up in the mountains that gets no signal of any kind, but now that I have Starlink I can get perfect Internet there. So instead of going up for a weekend to relax, I go up for a week at a time, work during the day, and come home on the weekend to top up supplies.
- logosmonkey 4y agoSame, I got a setup before I went out west this year and I can now camp off grid at places I couldn't the previous years. It's great.
- yellowapple 4y agoYep, that's exactly the sort of routine I have in mind. Longer-term, I'm hoping for that favorite location to be a piece of land I actually own, in which case my goal is to setup a semi-permanent "base" with solar, Starlink, and a yurt or somesuch.
- Already__Taken 4y agoI'm serious that with rent costs increasing, starlink live roaming might see a real boost in live-aboard sailors
- jonah 4y agoUntil they have their inter-satellite links working, you and the downlink station have to both be visible to the same satellite.
- UmbertoNoEco 4y agoIt's not only the pollution. The world is "unwillingly" giving up space spots to a company that can use those satellites as technological weapons. What happens when a Chinese/India/Russia(Insert any non-Anglo "bad" country) decides to emulate them , I would happily bet my left kidney the _commentariat_ here would not be so happy.
- panick21_ 4y ago> space spots What does that even mean? You can't see them unless you have highly speziallised equipment. And in terms of physical spots, space is absurdly huge, space is not really a limited resource.
- wmf 4y agoIt seems like they're keeping a ~10 km buffer zone around each satellite which does add up. Between Starlink, OneWeb, and Kuiper a bunch of shells have already been taken.
- panick21_ 4y agoThose are current technological limitation the same way Montana farmers in the West didn't have barbed wire. Tracking and control technology is constantly improving. Just like as with airplane safety humanity will improve with increase use.
- bpodgursky 4y agoIf Russia wants to use satellites as technological weapons, I don't think they're going to ask the FCC for permission.
- AtlasBarfed 4y agoWould they provide a usable broadband alternative to the broomstick-up-butt treatment I get from the telcos? Hell yes I'd take them. Oh they'd steal my data? Well, so does everyone on this site and the telco I have now. Consider this, Mr Geopolitical power. Do you want the US with this weapon, or sit on our ass and let China deploy one now that SpaceX has shown how powerful it is? This is the single greatest Western soft power weapon since the iPhone. And you're begrudging it? Come on.