15 ms·
I support this ruling not because I think that the EPA shouldn't have the authority to cap emissions, but because I agree with the Court that Congress never int
by lolinder 4y ago
I support this ruling not because I think that the EPA shouldn't have the authority to cap emissions, but because I agree with the Court that Congress never intended to grant the EPA that authority. I believe strongly that the executive authorities--be that police, FBI, NSA, ICE, or EPA--should not have the ability to creatively interpret laws. If we allow them to do that, we open the door to innumerable abuses.
So, yes, I support the outcomes of this ruling just as much as I support the reasoning. Congress needs to get its act together and legislate, not let the Executive branch make up rules to fill the void they've left.
- th3byrdm4n 4y agoI barely post but here here. Leveraging the executive branch as the government creates a bipolar governance, every 4-8 years we have a totally different country and outcomes. We need a functioning legislator. How we go from here to there is unclear, but necessary
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Imnimo 4y agoIt strikes me as extremely naive to believe that this same precedent will be applied to agencies like the FBI and NSA. The supreme court is not an automaton bound by the laws of logic to act consistently.
- cyanydeez 4y agoThe "creative" you speak of is a bullshit stance because congress isn't a computer, never will be, and all you're doing is not liking the outcome which is what the parent is explaining: rationalizing your bias after the fact. Others would say they are implementing the details of broad brushed Congressional laws.
- abandonliberty 4y agoSo you're hoping pedantry will save us from climate change. Hopefully you live long enough to see how this turns out.
- csdvrx 4y ago> I believe strongly that the executive authorities--be that police, FBI, NSA, ICE, or EPA--should not have the ability to creatively interpret laws. If we allow them to do that, we open the door to innumerable abuses. Totally: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/jun/23/us-justification-drone-killing-american-citizen-awlaki https://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/jun/23/us-justificati... "Lawyers for the Obama administration, arguing for their ability to kill an American citizen without trial in Yemen, contended that the protection of US citizenship was effectively removed by a key congressional act that blessed a global war against al-Qaida. Known as the Authorization to Use Military Force (AUMF), the broad and controversial 2001 law played a major role in the legal decision to kill Anwar al-Awlaki, the former al-Qaida propagandist and US citizen, in 2011, according to a redacted memorandum made public on Monday." I don't want the executive or the administration to use creative interpretations to allow themselves to legally become judge, jury and executioner through executive order (pun intended) that may be very hard to claw back. The constitution and the supreme court are here for a good reason: to prevent such abuses.
- OrvalWintermute 4y agoAlthough I think that terrorists in general should be denied Geneva Conventions and protections, I do think there should have been a judicial process to determine, and make the case for said terrorist (Anwar al-Awlaki) being an enemy of the state, and an authorized target. Then, through an adversarial process, he would have had his day in court, along with all of the rights of appeal that come with a judicial decision. I cringe sometime when I think about the potential burden of evidence not being brought forth to make a case that someone is a terrorist, and then getting droned. > I don't want the executive or the administration to use creative interpretations to allow themselves to legally become judge, jury and executioner through executive order (pun intended) that may be very hard to claw back. The constitution and the supreme court are here for a good reason: to prevent such abuses. Well said. One man's freedom fighter, or terrorist, could one day become, one's political adversary.
- ChrisLTD 4y agoWhy should the Supreme Court decide if a government agency has assumed power not granted to it by Congress? Congress still exists, and Congress can always pass a law kneecapping the agency in question.
- stingrae 4y agoThe Supreme Court is supposed to be a check on the Executive and Legislative Branch? In modern times, the Executive Branch assumes much power not explicitly granted to it and it is the job of the Legislative and Judicial branches to keep it in check. If congress, doesn't like the ruling, it can reverse it in legislation.
- WalterBright 4y agoBecause our system is, by default, not one of assuming the government is all powerful and we restrict it here and there, but one where we must proactively add a power.
- lolinder 4y agoBecause that's literally in their job description: > The judicial power shall extend to all cases, in law and equity, arising under this Constitution, the laws of the United States, and treaties made, or which shall be made, under their authority ... --to controversies to which the United States shall be a party; https://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution/articleiii https://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution/articleiii
- landryraccoon 4y agoI find this argument very unconvincing. To use an engineering analogy, if the government were a software application, this is very much like a senior engineer going on a major refactor of a production system, causing huge breaking changes for the sake of "principles", without consulting product, CS or QA. For the sake of argument, lets grant that there's some force to those principles. Is that justification for suddenly breaking a system that was working and causing a massive amount of confusion for downstream users that were blindsided and now have to do massive updates of their own? Okay, now lets suppose that the same senior engineer was secretly (or perhaps even openly) beating the drum for some feature changes behind the scenes, and nobody liked the features he was proposing. Now after the refactor, it turns out that for "technical reasons" the features now work the way HE wanted them to. When asked, he claims it wasn't a political decision, it was driven purely by engineering concerns, "cleaning up tech debt" and so forth, he claims. Might it seem to you that the refactor was just a smokescreen for just getting the feature changes he wanted into production? If this engineer was at your company, would you keep them on, or fire them as soon as possible? Now according to your argument, you view SCOTUS as the engineering team, and Congress as the product team. You're saying that ten years after you release a feature, the technical lead can say "Hey, you remember that spec for those features we released to production 10 years ago? I think we did it wrong, we need to refactor it so it works right. Also that was the old engineering lead, and I never liked them anyway. It'll be a major breaking change, but that shouldn't be an obstacle to doing it right this time. Should we ask Product or the Executive team first? Of course not, we know what we're doing."
- 656565656565 4y agoyou find a political argument unconvincing so apply a software engineering analogy
- landryraccoon 4y agoI applied it by way of analogy. If you want a political analogy, politically, there is no "right or wrong". SCOTUS is not motivated by adherence to precedent, they clearly have an ideological agenda. They are not, for example, legalizing marijuana, on the grounds that the FDA should not have the authority to schedule drugs. They chose to go after environmental regulations because they ideologically prefer capitalist interests over environmental ones. It is brazenly political, as was their overturning of Roe vs Wade.
- scarmig 4y ago> I agree with the Court that Congress never intended to grant the EPA that authority Congress did grant the EPA that authority; the ruling is an objection to the principle that Congress can make broad grants of authority. Delegation of authority is key to every effective organization. Imagine corporations were governed like this, and any time a new service or feature was rolled out, the Board of Directors would have to explicitly sign off on it. Work would grind to a halt. Which is exactly the point of this ruling, to make the federal government even more ineffectual than it already is as part of an ideological crusade.
- dahfizz 4y ago> Congress did grant the EPA that authority; the ruling is an objection to the principle that Congress can make broad grants of authority. That's entirely incorrect, please read the article.
- scarmig 4y agoTo be explicit, Congress granted the EPA the authority to set "a standard for emissions of air pollutants which reflects the degree of emission limitation achievable through the application of the best system of emission reduction." The majority believes that's too broad a grant and that usage of that authority needs a second authorization from Congress.
- lasc4r 4y agoI wonder if the majority cares about climate change. My guess is they don't.
- jaybrendansmith 4y agoCongress: "No, we really, really mean it this time." What the actual fuck?
- lolinder 4y agoFrom the end of the ruling (emphasis added) [0]: > Capping carbon dioxide emissions at a level that will force a nationwide transition away from the use of coal to generate electricity may be a sensible "solution to the crisis of the day." But it is not plausible that Congress gave the EPA the authority to adopt on its own such a regulatory scheme in Section 111(d). A decision of such magnitude and consequence rests with Congress itself, or an agency acting pursuant to a clear delegation from that representative body. It seems pretty clear that Congress does have the authority to delegate, but that the Court ruled that Congress didn't intend to do so. This ruling places the ball firmly in Congress's court, it doesn't rule that Congress cannot act. [0] https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/21pdf/20-1530_n758.pdf https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/21pdf/20-1530_n758.pdf
- muaytimbo 4y agoTotally agree with this, the US has turned into an administrative state, which is far from the vision enacted by the founding fathers in which Congress and/or states regulate. Today congress has chosen to forsake their main role as legislators by creating unelected unaccountable bureaucrats with, essentially, unchecked law making abilities. That said, I would like congress to take up the matter of clean air and water directly, instead of this cowering behind other agencies after abdicating of their duties.
- patentatt 4y agoExcept this is a complete straw man in the current political reality. Climate change legislation will never get a single Republican vote, and we all know it. And they will never be held accountable for that because the people that vote for them are either uninformed or misinformed about climate change, by the same forces that influence congress!
- nradov 4y agoLegislating is an exercise in compromise. There are plenty of Republicans who would vote for certain elements of climate change legislation in exchange for getting other things they want.
- ejb999 4y ago>>That said, I would like congress to take up the matter of clean air and water directly, instead of this cowering behind other agencies after abdicating of their duties. Exactly - put them on the record voting for or against whatever they want - and the voters can vote to replace or keep those people based on how they actually voted - right now they all like to give speeches, raise money and not much else - congress, do your job, even if it costs you your job.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- datavirtue 4y agoThen they would have to tackle financial regulation reform, and that isn't in the interests of anyone in Washington or Wall Street---and likely not within their wheelhouse of competence. The fed and various people throughout the financial industry and private citizens have been begging for specific regulations for decades now.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 30944836 4y ago>because I agree with the Court that Congress never intended to grant the EPA that authority. Luckily nothing stops Congress from making laws that clarify what they granted the EPA. If they were so fussed with the EPA doing what they were doing, why didn't they leap up and pass a law that told them to stop? Why is it the court's job to tell congress what they meant to say? Is congress mute?
- lolinder 4y agoIt is the court's job to ensure the law is enforced as written. Where ambiguity exists, it is the court's job to interpret the law. That's literally the entire purpose of a court. Congress is not mute. Congress speaks by passing laws. Any other, less formal means of speaking is the voice of members of Congress, not Congress as a whole.
- 30944836 4y ago>It is the court's job to ensure the law is enforced as written. The supreme court has no enforcement mechanism. It has no army, no police. Abiding by Supreme Court rulings is by tradition only. >Where ambiguity exists, it is the court's job to interpret the law. That's literally the entire purpose of a court. This is also by tradition only. The Constitution doesn't specify this, nor are there any laws that say this is the job of the court.
- jaywalk 4y agoYou're looking at it completely backwards. Congress was fine to let the EPA run around and do whatever, because that means people can bitch at the EPA instead of Congress. > Why is it the court's job to tell congress what they meant to say? That's... not what they're doing. The court is telling Congress that if you want an agency to have the power to make vast, sweeping changes, then you have to be explicit. They don't get to create an agency and then just give them blanket authority to do anything they want, at any scale.
- dan_quixote 4y ago>police, FBI, NSA, ICE, or EPA--should not have the ability to creatively interpret laws That's simply not possible unless we have literal laws for every possible infraction - like a state machine for the human condition.