6 ms·
I have no faith in machines that suck the atmosphere through a straw. The thermodynamics and fluid dynamics just don't pencil out. We need to remove something
by gumby 4y ago
I have no faith in machines that suck the atmosphere through a straw. The thermodynamics and fluid dynamics just don't pencil out. We need to remove something like 3.5 Tt of CO2, so 3.5 Kt is nothing. Our only hope in this regard is solar/uv-powered systems, mainly biological, for example algaes in pelagic waters (that grow and then die and sink to the bottom of the ocean). These systems aren't trivial to build either.
For other GHG and pollutants there are uv-powered systems like TiO2, olivine etc, though there are also limits to how much they can do.
Basically we have to "mash our hand on the keyboard", i.e. try to do them all, but I can't see machines like these making any meaningful contribution.
Note: I'm working on methane destruction straight in the atmosphere, so I'm putting my money (and my time) where my commenting is.
- keithnz 4y agoso, in the article it says "they’re aiming to remove millions of tons of CO2 per year by 2030 and a billion per year by 2050." So, this is just a step on the path....but, those numbers do seem pretty aspirational at this stage.
- malthuswaswrong 4y agoEverything is going to be okay.
- FredPret 4y agoMalthus was wrong, hopefully Gretha as well
- lnwlebjel 4y agoMalthus was wrong because of innovation, and if Gretha is wrong, it will also be because of innovation.
- mrguyorama 4y agoHow do you innovate out of basic thermodynamics? We could stop emitting every single atom of CO2 right now and still suffer from some significant consequences. There is no solution that doesn't involve "wasting" energy (and since we live in a capitalist world, money) on capturing CO2
- lnwlebjel 4y agoBill Gates's books has a great account of what it will take to get us out of this mess - and I agree, it is a huge mess - and Carbon capture is likely to be a small part of the solution.
- OtomotO 4y agoand in the case it doesn't: no worries, the end was always the same, the heat death of the universe :) so try your best and if it doesn't play out: memento mori!
- gumby 4y agoNo momento mori beyond the heat death of the universe I'm afraid.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Gigachad 4y agoHonestly I can't see how it will be. I think we will get incredible technologies that cut resource usage. But we have already done this several times now and every time we make something more efficient we just consume more. We have made car engines massively more efficient but the gains were entirely lost to bigger cars and driving longer distances. There are billions of people living almost primitive lives just waiting to consume as much as we do driving everywhere and buying new iphones every year. We are about to make things cheaper and more efficient and give them access to this consumption. Despite all of this advancement, resource usage and emissions has never once gone backwards or even slowed down its increase.
- systemvoltage 4y agoClimate catastrophy arguments needs more scrutiny. The error bars are huge. https://twitter.com/birdhillcap/status/1541812452760776705 https://twitter.com/birdhillcap/status/1541812452760776705 https://twitter.com/AlexEpstein/status/1541768533004148738 https://twitter.com/AlexEpstein/status/1541768533004148738 https://twitter.com/luisbaram/status/1523671791062843393 https://twitter.com/luisbaram/status/1523671791062843393 https://twitter.com/AlexEpstein/status/1529809797582815244 https://twitter.com/AlexEpstein/status/1529809797582815244 There is a bigger problem. Those who scrutinize climate change are punished by the society even though we need legit scientists and people that debunk overarching claims. You could accept CC arguments but still be a critic of some of the insane claims going on today. It's like the early COVID days. Can't criticize. Can't speak against the mob. Can't do science without scrutiny.
- chimprich 4y ago> Climate catastrophy arguments needs more scrutiny. Right, so your sources for this is a few Twitter posts. Let's take a look. The first one is a supposed quote from Al Gore, but he never said that. Even if he did, Al Gore getting something wrong would hardly disprove anything about climate science. > Those who scrutinize climate change are punished by the society You're parroting untrue claims. How about some self-awareness?
- 4y ago
- gumby 4y agoI agree. I just wish I could be around 50M years from now when the cockroach-descendent paleontologists marvel at the weird biped fossils and wonder if they could ever have been sophisticated enough to have had a civilisation. We are not ruining the earth in any way. We are merely making it inhospitable to vertebrates and some other life forms.
- softcactus 4y agoAny tips for getting into the "climate industry"? What are the most promising technologies that aren't just greenwashing?
- tito 4y agoThe book Project Drawdown is a good primer, with pictures! [1] After that, the My Climate Journey [2] and Work on Climate [3] communities are excellent entry points. Climate is a big buffet full of all sorts of cool problems to help solve. I'm focused on carbon removal as an example, but we need millions of people working across all aspects of the planetary system. [1] https://www.amazon.com/Drawdown-Comprehensive-Proposed-Reverse-Warming/dp/0143130447 https://www.amazon.com/Drawdown-Comprehensive-Proposed-Rever... [2] https://www.mcjcollective.com https://www.mcjcollective.com [3] https://workonclimate.org https://workonclimate.org
- tito 4y agoWhat's the methane destruction project you're working on? Enjoy those 24x carbon credits, that's good stuff. Regarding the main part of your comment, what is it you think people should be working on instead?
- ncmncm 4y agoThere are nascent efforts to get Sacramento River delta farmers to trade in farming in their (thousands of acres of!) sub-sea-level fields for collecting carbon credits by flooding them and letting swamp vegetation settle. Presumably they could also float solar and collect revenue and carbon credits from that, and grow freshwater shrimp, besides. There is a serious worry that in the next big Cal earthquake, dikes will collapse, pulling sea water into the delta. It has happened before. Generally, restoring wetland that had been converted to farmland can be done in many places to similar effect. Floating solar is a big win, producing much more power than the same panel in the desert, and lasting much longer, without interfering with anything else.
- gumby 4y ago> Regarding the main part of your comment, what is it you think people should be working on instead? Well, that's a broad topic! Here's how I look at it: 0 - people are going to continue peopling. Otherwise what's the point? So any argument based on privation ("you need to stop doing everything you like to do because it's sinful") won't work. Some stuff will drop at the margins (I expect meat will become increasingly expensive and other high protein alternatives will displace some of it), but all of that will continue to change gradually, though I hope the derivative will increasing in a non-linear fashion. 1 - concommitent with that: there's an enormous infrastructure of depreciating cap ex. So a power plant built today will be depreciated over the next 40 years. Yes, some economic changes can shorten that but people will try to eke out what they can from them. In fact as renewables increase, the cost of fossil fuels will fall (because of reduced demand) which will make old, polluting plants more viable. 2 - Governments have shown they cannot tackle this problem. I gave a talk at Asilomar a couple of months ago in which I showed a temperature graph and pointed out it's impossible to see the Paris conference on it. This year will be COP 27 and what has changed? Governments have a huge role to play in terms of incentives, but in actual action? Pretty much zip. I think this is an inherent property of some of the good properties of good government so I'm not claiming governments are mendacious, pathetic, controlled by some conspiracy or anything like that. I don't drive a motorcycle underwater, but I would drive one to the beach. Likewise I don't depend on governments to be able to do much directly to improve the global climate, but they can sure help. 3 - We need multiple kinds of improvement: A - yes, we need emissions reductions and replacements for emitting activity (e.g. "alternative energy"). Though there are many sources of GHG emissons, and I don't see a way to replace most of them (e.g. we can't simply stop growing rice -- see point 0). This is "stop making things worse" B - Because of point 1, some people need to work on adaptation. The climate isn't going to go back to the status quo ante right away (actually never -- see point 4) so the next 50-100 years will have to presume that the weather is going to get worse (hotter/colder, wetter/dryer depending on where you are). I am uninterested in this problem BTW. C - Climate repair (sometimes called restoration) is the longest term and most important. We do need ways to change the chemistry of the air and oceans back to 1775.* Reducing insolation, removing GHGs, etc. Like I said, I really only believe in a variety of solar-powered chemistry, both biological and not. Look at some natural processes that can be sped up, like synthetic limestone which has been discussed on HN. (Maybe let's not consider the gold standard of setting off 50 massive volcanic eruptions.) Most of these are only feasible at certain concentrations of a GHG, which is one reason I'm more in favour of biologics which are more adaptable and generally easier to power. I talk with a variety of people about these topics every week, but all my efforts right now are on methane, because there's a small amount of it and it's been responsible for about 1/3 of the temperature rise to date. There's a subgoal here, which is zapping emissions at the point of generation (so called "point source remediation"). Catalytic converters on cars work for some GHGs (though you can't stick one on a swamp); some efforts to zap methane in barns or mines are under way, etc. We could paint the insides of building ventilation with TiO2 and install UV lamps; if they could be cleaned would they work? Who knows. But stopping the emission when the concentration is highest is generally the easiest place to do it. 4 - in terms of climate repair, we aren't really going to ever "go back". We have no idea what the critical points are (where the path of the hysteresis curve changes) and will be curating the climate indefinitely. That's not terrible; we have been curating the forests of Europe for a thousand years or more (is there any original forest on that continent) and there's little "wild" forest in new england either. So it's quite doable from a social standpoint. We'll just find a point were we find the climate on earth adequate. 5 - Carbon credit can be used to cover a lot of sins (see point 1) and offset credits (don't cut down a tree) are tough to justify. But can be a pretty good way to fund repair and remediation, and could be a good way to shift the cost onto the people who create majority of the problem. * I used to think that "1775" automatically made everybody think of James Watt's first significant patent, but it seems in the US it makes people think of political events around that time. Apparently not everybody is a steam nerd -- who knew?
- asah 4y ago35 Kt... per year... but yeah it's daunting and we need more scale.
- tito 4y agoAgreed. In case you or others you connect with are looking to help create more scale for carbon removal solutions, here's an online educational course I helped develop called AirMiners Boot Up -- https://bootup.airminers.org/ https://bootup.airminers.org/
- Gigachad 4y agoCarbon capture feels a lot like having a public pool which has raw sewerage pumping in to it and the proposals all focus on installing more powerful filters which can clean up some of the sewerage rather than focusing on stopping the sewerage from dumping in to the pool which is a much cheaper and more realistic solution.
- DennisP 4y agoDefinitely we need to stop the dumping, but we've already dumped a lot of sewage in the pool so we also need to clean it up.
- ncmncm 4y agoWe need most to avoid confusing work to clean it up with progress on not dumping overwhelmingly more in.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tito 4y agoAs someone working in the industry, it can definitely feel like that at times. Using your analogy, ultimately a functional public pool depends on both not dumping in sewage, and also having filters for whatever gunk does get in the pool anyway. So on a long time horizon both are necessary.
- 4y ago
- slowmovintarget 4y agoI'd worry they make things worse and suffocate plant life near them.
- gumby 4y agoWhat plant life? We're talking about the pelagic ocean, which was more fertile before we broke the back of the ecosystem,* but even then didn't have the wild growth of coastal waters. * when you hate on the fossil fuel industry, don't forget that it saved the whales.
- jay_kyburz 4y agoI agree that we need to do be exploring all options, but we need to make sure not to destroy other parts of our environment in the process. Massive algal blooms in the ocean gives me nightmares.
- 0des 4y agoalgae blooms in my reef tank give me nightmares, thank you for compounding that.
- edgefield 4y agoLet’s explore all options that generate $$$ so we can avoid real current solutions that lack the profit motive like planting and protecting trees, conserving energy, reducing consumption, etc.
- ncmncm 4y agoMassive algal blooms where there are no fish need give no one nightmares. Once we are electrolysing lots of water for the hydrogen, dissolving the waste oxygen in river outflows could start to save the current dead zones. But restricting over-fertilization would have a bigger effect.
- gumby 4y ago> Massive algal blooms in the ocean gives me nightmares. Why? How you you think much of the carbon at the bottom of the sea got there? Biological activity, most of small species that died and sank. The pelagic ocean is pretty nutrient-poor, so anything you grow there is going to need to be farmed. I've been reading that used to be far more fertile before the ecosystem crashed as we decimated the whale population (there are experiments under way for basically adding "artificial whale poo" (as it was jokingly described to me by one of the participants) to try to form little regions of more fertile surface waters. IMHO you do want to stay away from coastal waters which are a witch's brew of all sorts of things, from runoff to various organic processes. Some algal blooms in coastal regions have been of toxic species (e.g. "red tide" -- those algaes also show up in snow BTW) but most are not that kind at all, and as I note above, in the pelagic (open) ocean you'll have to be seeding it anyway. You want it to die and sink, but of course it will be attractive to other species some of which will eat it, grow, eventually die and sink, but will probably breath some of that carbon out again. But in the end, you'd want most of it to sink.
- ParksNet 4y agoWhat's the cheapest Carbon Capture system we can imagine - $100 per tonne? Most are running at about $500/tonne right now. At just $15/tonne of Carbon Tax, we halve CO2 output, mainly by destroying the economics of coal: https://www.pgpf.org/budget-basics/what-is-a-carbon-tax-how-would-it-affect-the-economy https://www.pgpf.org/budget-basics/what-is-a-carbon-tax-how-... All the effort and funding currently spent on carbon capture should instead go towards lobbying for carbon taxes. The impact will be significantly greater. The best use of Carbon Capture technology would be in building ventilation systems. If we can capture and exhaust CO2 from inside air, we can reduce ventilation requirements, and potentially reach lower-than-atmospheric CO2 levels (which could have extraordinary benefits for cognition and sleep quality).
- human_person 4y agoEven if we got emissions to zero tomorrow we’d still be in serious trouble. We need carbon capture. Emission reduction just reduces our rate of acceleration towards destruction. We need to hit the brakes.
- toomuchtodo 4y ago> At just $15/tonne of Carbon Tax, we halve CO2 output, mainly by destroying the economics of coal Here is page 122 of NextEra’s investor deck. They are closing all coal plants by 2028 as they are no longer profitable to run. Even without a carbon adder per MWh, coal is dead (“near firm” solar and wind are renewables with battery backing to make them dispatchable when called on by the grid operator). Even existing combined cycle natural gas is under pressure! And their note: “We expect further technology improvements and cost declines will extend the competitiveness of onshore renewables and storage.” https://cleantechnica.com/files/2022/06/lcoe-small.jpg?mrf-size=m https://cleantechnica.com/files/2022/06/lcoe-small.jpg?mrf-s... Japan is opting out of financing coal plants further in Indonesia and Bangladesh, cancelling ~3GW worth of coal plant projects. https://news.mongabay.com/2022/06/planned-coal-plants-fizzle-as-japan-ends-financing-in-indonesia-bangladesh/ https://news.mongabay.com/2022/06/planned-coal-plants-fizzle... So we’re seeing some progress in avoiding electrical thermal emissions, which is the cheapest emissions offset. (Oahu, Hawaii’s last coal fired plant turns down in September after the Tesla Megapacks replacing their frequency response capability are installed, another 200MW of coal taken offline)
- jjtheblunt 4y agoHow do you destroy methane straight in the atmosphere?
- verdverm 4y agocombustion typically, but I'm also curious what GP actually means
- marcosdumay 4y agoProbably by pulverizing some catalyzer. Water on the high atmosphere looks like a good choice. But it needs some simulation to know if the water won't stay there long enough to create a greenhouse problem of the same size.
- gumby 4y agoVapourizing it, but yeah. I replied to the GP post with some brief discussion. We're working in the lower troposphere (like 0-50 m). The stratosphere frightens me (and the folks who want to spray sulphur compounds up there are terrifying. Water in the upper troposphere (AKA Marine Cloud Brightening) like Silver Lining is trying to do feels like a pretty good cooling approach. I wrote a jokey paper in the 80s about giant volcano-powered teakettles spewing steam into the upper atmosphere but the much simpler approach of simply spraying seawater into the air is clever.
- marcosdumay 4y agoIndeed, using existing ships as platform to vaporize salty water on the low atmosphere in the open ocean (I got it correctly?) is very clever. Congratulations on the project.
- gumby 4y agoTurns out about 15-20% of the methane is destroyed by the atmosphere at the ocean surface (the bulk is destroyed by hydroxyl reactions over the land). There are some other natural processes that catalyze those reactions. So we are working on augmenting the supply of catalyst over the deep ocean (far away from land). The reason for the open ocean is that it is remarkably free of topographic features :-) and much more uniform. Close to shore there are all sorts of other things going on, from runoff to life activity and it makes predicting anything quite hard. Doing it on the other 75% of the earth's surface is a lot easier. If you go to our crappy web site (www.bluedotchange.com) and click on the science you can read some refereed papers on the subject. We are looking for some MEs and ChemEs and a couple of EEs and software people if you're interested.
- hidelooktropic 4y ago> We need to remove something like 3.5 Tt of CO2 In order to what and at what rate? Break even? Each year?
- gumby 4y agoAs of right now that's roughly the amount of excess in the atmosphere. So if we remove that (and a bunch of other GHGs) and stop emitting we'd roughly be done. It's not as simple as I state above, but that gives you an idea of the size of the problem.
- kaiusbrantlee 4y agoBetter than the algae system described is capturing the carbon in plants that are later used in such ways as to keep the carbon sequestered. Trees whose wood is used as a building material, animal feed where the manure is then used as fertilizer, are 2 very accessible examples. No need to make this more complicated than it has to be.