12 ms·
I'm conflicted. TikTok collects data for an adversary at scale. Many complain that the US does the same but that doesn't change the fact that I live in the US.
by 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y ago
I'm conflicted.
TikTok collects data for an adversary at scale. Many complain that the US does the same but that doesn't change the fact that I live in the US. The Chinese government is an adversary of the West whether we like it or not.
With that said- It's pretty telling that the FCC only needs to go to Apple and Google. It would be really nice to have some antitrust regulation so that the FCC doesn't have this power.
- Abishek_Muthian 4y ago> The Chinese government is an adversary of the West whether we like it or not. It's not like they became an adversary overnight, China's economic success was predominantly sponsored by the West; Their abysmal human rights regulations were favorable for Nike to Apple for employing child labor and they in-turn used that economic growth to increase their defense budget 6-fold in just two decades. Of course autocracies and democracies would be adversaries; But the sabre-rattling without holding the West's capitalist interest in China accountable seems disingenuous(In general, not your comment).
- ALittleLight 4y agoThere's likewise a conflict for Google, which runs a TikTok competitor/clone in the form of YouTube Shorts. "Well, if we have to ban our competition... I guess..."
- tomatotomato37 4y agoWhile I agree Apple & Google have a near perfect duopoly on the mobile space, the addition of more companies wouldn't give the FCC any less power. The "Federal" part of FCC still gives them jurisdiction over electronic communication happening in the US federation; whether they have to enforce it through 2 entities or 2000 doesn't really make a difference
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoHow would you enforce it though? It's like in the 90s when PGP was export controlled. It was a total unenforceable joke.
- tjoff 4y agoDepends on the goal, PGP sure. Anyone who wanted could get it but it was still a hurdle. A hurdle that for sure would kill tiktok, or at least enough for it to be irrelevant.
- igneo676 4y agoTrust busting would open up a larger ecosystem of stores and/or phone companies, which may even be in other countries and outside of the FCC's reach Though, fair, that's a glorious and highly theoretical future :P
- rhacker 4y agoIt's not actually a "lot" of power - it's just enough. If there is evidence that an actor is doing something bad, we shouldn't have months in court to stop it. It should be immediate. It's better to have it stopped and then spend months in court trying to get it back.
- dantondwa 4y agoHowever, one could argue that geopolitical matters are a lot less interesting for you, private citizen. If you're not a world leader or someone involved in said geopolitical events, you will live the consequences of "the enemies of the West" from a mostly economic perspective. On the other hand, the same cannot be said about your own government. They collect data on you and your fellow citizens and they use it. And they can mess up your life much more than what China will ever do. One recent example: the worry over period tracking apps and the recent decisions of the US Supreme Court. Those apps are a weapon against citizens who, until yesterday, were not doing anything illegal. All tracking is bad, and the FCC should do something about it all.
- imoverclocked 4y agoChina does a lot more than the US government in terms of tracking and surveillance. Most tracking in the US is likely done via Google/Facebook/etc which makes it technically opt-in. https://www.nytimes.com/video/world/asia/100000008314175/china-government-surveillance-data.html https://www.nytimes.com/video/world/asia/100000008314175/chi...
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoIt's done by telcos and data brokers. Every US citizen has a detailed profile compiled about their personal lives that the US government can access at will. Google and Meta are the new kids at the table of a long running game.
- mistrial9 4y ago> US citizen has a detailed profile compiled partially true but fodder for schizophrenics and compulsive obsessions.. A truer picture is harder to convey in a few sentences.. however as a US citizen I believe that an uneasy truce has been established via law in the USA since inception, between those casually referred to as "Law and Order" who genuinely believe that governance means record keeping and monitoring, and others who do not. Unfortunately for the "others" that includes genuinely bad actors who seek to use rights to evade detection, or those too stupid or simple to think about these things at all. Meanwhile, the Net has given magnificent, grandiose power to build and use surveillance, which they have done. ill wind blows
- elldoubleyew 4y ago> The Chinese government is an adversary of the West whether we like it or not. I'd like to se a source on this. I don't think different political ideologies imply adversarial intentions. China has been as friendly to the west as it can be while still protecting its own cultural and economic interests. If western leaders would stop seeing China as the enemy and instead as a partner we would see a rise in infrastructure and economic opportunity globally. China is not trying to do global charity work, they have their own motives as well. They are also not the devil incarnate. I would argue that their intentions in foreign policy are still _generally_ more morally palpable than most western nations.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoI didn't say enemy, you did. I said adversary.
- atlasunshrugged 4y agoThere's literally a category of diplomacy called 'wolf warrior diplomacy' because of the recently aggressive nature of China towards foreign nations. I'm not sure they have been "as friendly to the west as it can be while still protecting..." unless you believe that to protect their cultural and economic interests they need to expand. Can you help me understand the logic of "generally more morally palpable than most western nations?" When I look at China's global activities, I see lots of IP theft, aggressive trade deals, debt diplomacy, investing in infrastructure yes... but then bringing in their own people to staff the projects (I saw this firsthand last year doing work in both Kenya and Cameroon and traveling through Uganda), bullying governments and organizations to toe the CCP party line (e.g. Houston Rockets), taking over Hong Kong and shutting down the free media there, basically paying off Muslim nations to keep them quiet regarding the Uyghur genocide.... and this is just off the top of my head!
- MetroWind 4y agoI don't know if you are American or not. But it's funny to see US people saying other countries are "aggressive".
- 4y ago
- loudmax 4y ago> It would be really nice to have some antitrust regulation so that the FCC doesn't have this power. Antitrust regulation is to prevent an Apple+Google duopoly (or cartel) from having this power. This is nothing about the FCC.
- hackernewds 4y agoYou could argue the FCC has less power since both Apple and Google need to comply to make a meaningful difference. And the FCC can't just ban iphones tomorrow, given the impact to the populace - and that's the basis of the duopoly
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoI meant there would be a more diverse cast of characters and sources of software for mobile devices so that the FCCs power would be diluted. In theory.
- igneo676 4y agoThat's not the point The point is, without antitrust regulation, the FCC only has to go through two giant corporations. After trust busting Apple and Google, we would theoretically have many more competing stores. The FCC would have to then ask each individual store for a takedown, perhaps even across different legal jurisdictions (read: outside of the USA) and therefore be unable to take down TikTok in such a centralized fashion
- dylan604 4y agoBut in this case, it's working in society's favor. Banning TikTock is a good thing. We should then turn around and ban all of the social media platforms regardless of nationality that does any sort of harvesting/manipulation of the data that their users are sharing in any other form than to display that information in the expected ways for the site to have purpose. Any social platform doing things in the shadows with user's info directly input by them or scraped,tracked,inferred,gathered,etc should be banned from existence.
- 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- aaaaaaaaata 4y agoThey have a PWA — nobody else to go to. web apps, baby.
- psyc 4y agoI just want to reiterate this point because I feel like people of a certain level of sophistication miss it all the time. Knowing which side of a conflict you’re on isn’t hypocrisy. I don’t want my adversary to have weapons. I don’t mind me having weapons. I like it in fact. There is ultimately no referee to cry foul to in geopolitics.
- cmroanirgo 4y agoWell, there was this guy a couple of thousand years ago who made some remarks contrary to your point: turning the cheek and loving your neighbor. He also went as far as saying to resolve conflicts before you're put in front of the judge. Many millions of people follow his words & think it still relevant today. He also had a special way of recognizing & calling out hyprocrisy.
- psyc 4y agoAnd which nation has ever turned its other national cheek when aggrieved? (Don’t say France)
- stickfigure 4y agoDidn't that guy get murdered, with his friends complicit? Doesn't sound like a role model to me.
- CWuestefeld 4y agoIt seems odd to me that the FCC should be doing things regarding trade and geopolitics. If they've got a need to create regulations based on technology or other matters relating to, you know, Communications, that's one thing. But trying to get a seat at the table for international diplomacy seems quite a stretch. It's kinda like the FDA earlier this year declining to approve a covid-19 vaccine not because it was ineffective (it wasn't!) or because it was dangerous (it wasn't!) but because they thought that saying that one brand was OK for kids but the other wasn't (yet) would be confusing and send a bad "message". The FDA's job is to help us identify what pharmaceuticals are safe and effective, not to worry about messaging.
- throwaway123989 4y ago> an adversary at scale. TikTok stores data on US soil. That's part of the deal brokered by the self-claimed best deal maker Mr. Trump. If there is unauthorized data access from inside China, then that's an issue to be investigated. So, where is the evidence of the large-scale data access from inside China to TikTok data?
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agohttps://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/emilybakerwhite/tiktok-tapes-us-user-data-china-bytedance-access https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/emilybakerwhite/tiktok-... > “Everything is seen in China,” said a member of TikTok’s Trust and Safety department in a September 2021 meeting. In another September meeting, a director referred to one Beijing-based engineer as a “Master Admin” who “has access to everything.” (While many employees introduced themselves by name and title in the recordings, BuzzFeed News is not naming anyone to protect their privacy.)
- throwaway123989 4y agoHah? A US companies' internal employees were conflated to China? And who the hell allows TikTok to operate in US in the first place. If someone working at MSFT has access to MSFT's China user data, is that a problem?
- elliekelly 4y agoI think it’s really important to note this isn’t “THE” FCC making the request. It’s one FCC Commissioner expressing their opinion. It has no legal authority. It’s basically meaningless. Nothing will come of it. It’s just complicated air flow that will briefly spark internet outrage on “both sides” of a debate over an issue that doesn’t even actually exist because the FCC hasn’t even done anything.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoTrue. I speculated that it's somebody asking nicely before more explicit orders are issued.
- elliekelly 4y agoNo, it’s just politicking.
- dafty4 4y agoAnd a commissioner appointed by Trump, no less.
- baisq 4y ago>The Chinese government is an adversary of the West whether we like it or not. Is it? I feel like it is an adversary of the Western governments. I don't feel like they are my adversaries. We could be friends if our governments wanted to.
- john_yaya 4y agoThe CCP at a minimum abets the shipment of fentanyl to the US. It aggressively collects personal information on every US citizen and resident. It relentlessly steals private and corporate intellectual property from the West and provides it to its own state-owned enterprises. If you’re a citizen of the US or Europe, the Chinese government is most definitely your enemy.
- lagmos 4y agoIsn't all of that true for the us government in one way or another? Except maybe the drug trafficking, which is a bit farther back in us history
- braingenious 4y agoIt would be ideal if the FCC didn’t have the power to ask politely? This situation sounds like it lacks power.
- TaylorAlexander 4y agoI would prefer we focus on making real data privacy possible. Instead of singling our foreign companies that collect the same data domestic companies are collecting, I advocate that we make data collection harder for everyone. That would mean passing real privacy laws with teeth in the USA that make data collection much harder, and interoperability laws that require Facebook and others to interoperate with other providers which may have a better security profile. Instead of being xenophobic we can be privacy focused.
- cde-v 4y agoA lot of people in the US currently find the US government their adversary.
- bergenty 4y agoYeah as a naturalized citizen, I’ve picked a side and it’s the US. Whataboutism on this issue has very little effect on me. Now if you bring up US political spectrums, whataboutism is highly effective.
- Spooky23 4y agoIt’s all moot. Facebook was happy to rake in the bucks to be a tool of Russian propagandists. If anything, TikTok is a national resource as at least you know that the propaganda bias will be towards whatever the PRC wants. Facebook will sell itself to anyone - KGB, prostate pills, whatever.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Dan_Sylveste 4y ago>TikTok is a national resource And if they want your kids to smash up their schools, does it help you with your geopolitical battles to know that's what 'they' want? Or would it be more helpful if that didn't happen?
- Spooky23 4y agoWhy is it a problem with TikTok, but not for Facebook? The boogieman of the PRC is less scary than Zuck imo.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoThe commissioner points out how they are breaking privacy law around the world and damaging US security. This is not the same as facebook or twitter. Please don't equate them. Also CCP doesn't have free access to user data on either of those.
- moconnor 4y agoBut… the FCC literally is how antitrust regulation is enforced - what do you want here? Competing antitrust regulators? Anti-antitrust regulation?
- lmm 4y agoYou live in the US but that doesn't mean your interests are aligned with those in power there. Personally I feel far more threatened by what US parties might do with my personal information than by what Chinese parties might do with it.
- tikiman163 4y agoAntitrust would be good, but that wouldn't affect the FCC, they'd just issue the same request to as many app stores as they deemed necessary. Technically, Microsoft will also probably have received the same request, but really who cares.