4 ms·
But you have to trade it away to buy the machines. That's very different from giving power to the people holding lots of coins.
by Dylan16807 4y ago
But you have to trade it away to buy the machines. That's very different from giving power to the people holding lots of coins.
- anonporridge 4y agoEspecially because mining is a business that you can fail at if you don't balance costs and income properly. That's much preferable to proof of stake where early investors can just squat on their coins indefinitely with almost zero cost to maintain their authority percentage forever.
- yokem55 4y agoExcept if the community at large doesn't like how a particular staker/validator is doing their job, the staker's assets can be burned in a hard fork that enjoys sufficient broad legitimacy. The capital can be outright destroyed. In contrast, there is no way a community in a proof of work system can burn a particular miners hardware if that miner becomes able to abuse the network. At most they could change the mining algo, but that wipes all miners out, and such a change can really only happen once.
- lottin 4y agoIn PoW miners buy physical capital and electricity, in PoS miners buy digital tokens. It's exactly the same, except PoS is less detrimental to the environment.
- rafaelero 4y agoIt would be the same if holding a token from a PoS system cost money. Since it doesn't, then it is definitely not the same thing.
- lottin 4y agoOf course it costs money, holding a token has an opportunity cost.
- Dylan16807 4y agoThe opportunity cost of not investing is in a different ballpark from spending that money on machines and electricity.
- lottin 4y agoYou don't know that. Moreover PoS can require that the tokens be spent permanently (not just deposited somewhere).
- Dylan16807 4y agoYes I do know that parking money is a different ballpark of cost from spending money. > Moreover PoS can require that the tokens be spent permanently (not just deposited somewhere). Is that really a "stake"?
- lottin 4y agoSo you're saying you know that an unknown quantity is greater than another unknown quantity.
- Dylan16807 4y agoI'm saying they have massively different risk profiles. If you want a different example that might be more obvious, "put it all on a single number on a roulette spin" and "invest in a big stock index" both have unknown rewards but they're entirely different ballparks too. (And no, those aren't supposed to map 1:1 to the coin scenario.)
- lottin 4y agoI don't think I follow you. As far as I can tell, PoS is as much of a lottery as PoW. In PoW a player increases their chances of winning the lottery by spending real money on electricity. In PoS a player increases their chances of winning the lottery by spending real money on virtual tokens. The outcome should be the same, except that no electricity is wasted in the case of PoS.