5 ms·
Pretty underwhelming considering the current delta between Apple’s A15 and the X2. I wonder if ARM is hampered by having to release a design that has to work on
by rayiner 4y ago
Pretty underwhelming considering the current delta between Apple’s A15 and the X2. I wonder if ARM is hampered by having to release a design that has to work on more than just the most cutting edge TSMC process.
- Octoth0rpe 4y agoAnother way of saying this that I think is somewhat more accurate is that they're constrained by designing for an acceptable transistor budget, which sort of correlates to a particular node. IIRC, Apple's chips are _significantly_ larger in terms of transistor count than their competitor's chips. A design that uses an equivalent # of transistors - a very messy and inaccurate proxy for a requirement for perf parity - would likely price it out of the range of most phone manufacturers unless built on the newest process. Frankly, it may not be an acceptable cost even at the newest node - Apple seems willing to spend a bit more on their chips than most, and likely gets better prices in any case due to the size of their orders.
- pdpi 4y ago> A design that uses an equivalent # of transistors - a very messy and inaccurate proxy for a requirement for perf parity At some point it got twisted into "double the speed", but Moore's Law as originally formulated was precisely about this - doubling transistor count.
- Symmetry 4y agoIt wasn't really a matter of twisting. The phrase "Moore's Law" got coined in an interview at the same 1975 conference where Dennard presented on his scaling laws and has never referred just to the first periodic doubling Moore noted in his 1965 paper.
- vlovich123 4y agoBack then, the transistor switching speed was 1:1 correlated with size and the sizes we're talking about then the size dominated (capacitance between gate & source). That decoupled in the late 90s / early 00s (if my recollection of news is correct) & kept getting more decoupled. These days you can have a switching speed of 604 Ghz but that doesn't translate to overall clock speed (dominated by critical path latency of your pipeline) + there's thermal issues. Disclaimer: Not an EE / HW designer. Going off of memory from tech news + some university courses (info may be incorrect / stale).
- Symmetry 4y agoIt was more that leakage current (i.e. thermal issues) and velocity saturation suddenly becoming constraints on how much you could increase switching speed along with the difficulty of high frequency clock distribution. Your individual transistor switching speed is always going to be a lot faster than your clock speed because a pipeline stage has to be made up of many layers of transistors to get anything useful done (including latch the signal at the clock edge!) and each transistor will typically drive multiple others. I was seriously considering being a chip engineer for a while and did my master's thesis on adder design.
- mardifoufs 4y agoWhat made you change your mind?
- Symmetry 4y agoRealizing that I'd be a small cog in a large team for most of my career down that path.
- tyingq 4y agoAnother example might be this Cortex-X3 being the first in ARM's X line to drop the 32 bit ISA, where Apple had dropped that in the A11. That gave Apple several iterations to take advantage of whatever simplifications or reclaimed transistor budget came from dropping it. Edit: Small miss above...Cortex-X2 dropped aarch32, though that's 2021 versus Apple doing it in 2017 with the A11, so the overall point is the same.
- kramerger 4y agoHasn't aarch32 always been optional in armv8? I mean, technically you can emulate it in software. It was simply no market for solo aarch64 before, since a lot of costumers wanted the backup of having aarch32 compatibility.
- gsnedders 4y agoCortex-X2 dropped A32 & T32.
- tyingq 4y agoAh...yep, I was was wrong there. Though still much later than the Apple/A11...2017 vs 2021. What the article says on this topic: "The process of eliminating 32-bit and optimizing for the 64-bit ISA exclusively has been a 2-step process. With the Cortex-X2, the underlying circuitry used for handling 32-bit architectural-related elements was removed, saving on transistors and simplifying some structures. With the new Cortex-X3, the design team took the time to start optimizing specifically for AArch64."
- gchadwick 4y ago> I wonder if ARM is hampered by having to release a design that has to work on more than just the most cutting edge TSMC process. They're constrained by what their customers want. Yes it's nice to have the highest performing chip but plenty of space in the mobile market for less than best CPUs. Anyone buying arm CPUs doesn't have the A15 as an option so in a sense it's not a competitor. Someone selling premium phones is trying to out-compete apple but how much does the raw performance stats matter to the consumer markets? I think there's also a tendency for everyone to want to do their own CPU now. Qualcomm and Samsung might want their arm micro-architecture to be the A15 killer and only buy the lower performance cores off arm for instance.
- gumby 4y ago> I think there's also a tendency for everyone to want to do their own CPU now. I wonder how many of these are actually vanity projects? Apple spent billions for more than a decade on ARM development before using their own design as a central processor. OTOH MediaTek et all don’t worry about any of that.
- rbanffy 4y ago> Apple spent billions for more than a decade on ARM development before using their own design as a central processor. For their computer platforms. Apple has been using ARM since the Newton. Anyone who wants to differentiate from competition building x86 boxes will have to use a non-x86 design. Viable ones these days are mostly POWER for workstations and servers, and ARM for everything between mobile and midrange servers. If you build a commodity computer based on the same components everyone else has access to, your margin will be squeezed. If your product has different characteristics than your direct competition and that difference is advantageous on a given segment, your competitors will have trouble moving in. That's why Apple M-series and IBM mainframe CPUs are not available to anyone without a full computer attached.
- gumby 4y ago> For their computer platforms. Apple has been using ARM since the Newton. The Newton used a regular ARM design (that was back when Apple owned a huge chunk of ARM). They used 3P ARMs for the main processor of other devices for years (e.g. time capsule or some video dongles). That one sentence of mine you referred two made two points: 1 - it took a long time for apple to get to the point where they could replace external designs as the core processor for a device (starting with the phone) and 2 - that they had by that time quite a bit of experience for using their own designs for subsidiary processors inside their devices. All of that is a pretty complex undertaking. > If you build a commodity computer based on the same components everyone else has access to, your margin will be squeezed. If your product has different characteristics than your direct competition and that difference is advantageous on a given segment, your competitors will have trouble moving in. Well, it’s all about where your locus of differentiation is; all else you want to commoditize. It’s not like Apple makes their own DRAM, and those suppliers are the ones that get their margins squeezed (especially by Apple — look at who their CEO is). And the lack of a CPU design team is a competitive advantage for the MediaTeks of this world, even if it’s not exclusive to them. Instead the very lack of exclusivity in cpu has a network effect value for them. This is what killed arm competitors like MIPS.
- ksec 4y ago~20% Pref Increase ( Clockspeed + IPC ) gives you a Single Core GB5 score close to A14. Considering the transistor and power budget, and the IP cost of X3 I actually think this is pretty damn impressive.
- mmastrac 4y agoApple has an architectural license that allows them to build their own compatible processor [1] purely targeted to what they need. [1] https://www.extremetech.com/computing/319968-google-microsoft-and-qualcomm-dont-want-nvidia-to-buy-arm https://www.extremetech.com/computing/319968-google-microsof...
- MikusR 4y agoSo does Applied Micro, Broadcom, Cavium, Huawei, Nvidia, AMD, Samsung, Marvell, Microsoft, Qualcomm, Intel, Faraday
- monocasa 4y agoApple has something deeper than the architectural license the others listed have. They've gone further with changes than others are allowed to.
- mkj 4y agoDo Apple's chips keep 32bit compat? That seems a big win in the x3.
- msbarnett 4y agoNo, like the X3 they dropped 32-bit compatibility (Apple dropped it in the A11, ARM dropped it for Cortex-X in the X2)
- pjmlp 4y agoGiven that Apple's CPUs aren't available in cloud deployments, I couldn't care less other than when doing iDevices projects.