3 ms·
"Personally I think they should not be able to decide such things. A payment provider should be forced to accept all legitimate customers." Payment providers a
by giantg2 4y ago
"Personally I think they should not be able to decide such things. A payment provider should be forced to accept all legitimate customers."
Payment providers are companies. They should be able to decide what they'll cover or not. In this case the bigger issue is that you essentially have a duopoly that allows 2 companies to affect the market with those decisions.
- GekkePrutser 4y agoI feel like in today's world they are also kind of utilities. This is where the trouble starts. If you want to run a business these days (especially online) you need a payment provider in many cases, and pretty much always need a bank account.
- franga2000 4y ago> Payment providers are companies. They should be able to decide what they'll cover or not Companies exist to provide people with goods and services. They have no inalienable rights beyond that. If a company does so in a way we see as unacceptable (in this case discriminatory), we have the right to force it and the only rights it has are to comply or cease operation. > In this case the bigger issue is that you essentially have a duopoly that allows 2 companies to affect the market with those decisions. Yes, everyone know that's an issue. The solution, obviously, is to limit their ability to manipulate. We can achieve a big part pf this this by forcing them to serve everyone equally.
- giantg2 4y ago"We can achieve a big part pf this this by forcing them to serve everyone equally." Why don't we force all companies to do this then? The other alternative is to break them up and create true competition.
- Aerroon 4y ago>Why don't we force all companies to do this then? Because this can end up adding a barrier to entry for new businesses, especially in new niches. However, I think once any company becomes large enough then this should apply to them.
- rlpb 4y ago> They should be able to decide what they'll cover or not. Why? Companies can be regulated. In cases where there isn't effective competition providing real consumer choice, I think it's perfectly reasonable to regulate them in the manner suggested.
- giantg2 4y ago"where there isn't effective competition" That's my point. The solution to this problem already exists - antitrust. The government has just chosen to to enforce it.
- eru 4y agoI don't think it's anti-trust that keeps eg competition between restaurants or shoe manufacturers alive. It's low-enough barriers to entry.
- ETH_start 4y agoIf there is not enough competition, the problem is one of two things: * barriers to entry created by regulatory restrictions * a naturally monopolistic industry creating a tendency toward monopoly/oligopoly In the case of the former, the govermment should simply repeal the regulatory restrictions. In the case of the latter, the government should directly provision a public option, until that public option becomes the de facto monopoly. With blockchain technology, the government could even subsidize the development of public good smart contracts that enable participants to coordinate, without an intermediary, to provide the good/service in question. I don't see any moral justification for allowing private citizens to build their own successful enterprise, and then seizing control over the enterprise to dictate how it is utilized.
- rlpb 4y ago> and then seizing control over the enterprise That's an exaggeration. For example, we already require companies to serve disabled customers. They can't just choose to refuse service to them. Have we already "seized control" over these companies? I don't think so. Nor would it be the case with this proposal.
- Closi 4y ago> Payment providers are companies. They should be able to decide what they'll cover or not. Legislation in other industries ensures that companies are not allowed to decide what they cover or not, because when companies pick and choose it leaves parts of the market being under-served (as is happening here). As an example - Under the Affordable Care Act, health insurance companies in the USA can't refuse to cover you or charge you more just because you have a “pre-existing condition”. Or as another example, the idea of net neutrality.
- giantg2 4y agoWe could add new regulations. Or we could enforce the current ones around antitrust and create alternative services out of them. By the way, I thought the ACA allows charging more for pre-existing conditions but set a multiplier cap on it?
- jacobr1 4y ago> I thought the ACA allows charging more for pre-existing conditions Nope: https://www.hhs.gov/healthcare/about-the-aca/pre-existing-conditions/index.html https://www.hhs.gov/healthcare/about-the-aca/pre-existing-co...
- cronix 4y agoPower companies, water companies, natural gas, heating oil companies, telephone companies are also private companies, that we classify as utilities because they are essential. They aren't allowed to discriminate at all. In 2022, I think credit cards should be viewed as a utility, as well as the internet itself. It's very difficult to live without either in the US and a lot of the world.
- Aerroon 4y agoI would potentially even go further than that. I think governments should make their own (digital) card payment systems that work like cash. Ie they should be as anonymous as cash and would have to serve all customers. This would have drawbacks in cases of fraud, but it could then be used exactly like cash is, but with less inefficiency.
- eru 4y agoI would go even further and say that governments should get out of the business of issuing cash. Especially having a monopoly on issuing cash. (For this proposal in eg the US, the Fed can still control the money supply. It's just that banks would print their own cash; exactly like they mint their own account balances that you can use to pay with already.)
- imtringued 4y agoMunicipalities should issue their own bank notes.
- eru 4y agoMaybe? Not sure they would be best suited for that? Just like we don't have municipalities produce their own smartphones. However, as long as there's no government-enforced monopoly or subsidies involved, it's fine?
- towaway15463 4y agoWouldn’t that just cause a massive amount of confusion over what was legal cash and what exchange rates are? One of the economic strengths of the US is its unified currency which has been poorly copied by the euro. A provably anonymous and untraceable digital currency backed by a government would see instant adoption. Before anyone complains about catching baddies just remember that serious criminals will astutely avoid any traceable currency or will find ways to launder it, only law abiding citizens and bunglers will be caught up in a surveillance state. The corrupt and criminal will remain as free as ever.
- pessimizer 4y ago> Payment providers are companies. They should be able to decide what they'll cover or not. Restaurants are companies, but that doesn't mean they can stir shit into the food. There's no law, rule, or ethical principle that says that companies cannot be regulated.
- karaterobot 4y agoI'm not sure how stirring shit into food is analogous, but restaurants, like payment providers, are allowed to refuse service to people in many different situations.
- pessimizer 4y agoAnd disallowed from refusing service to people in many other situations, just as they are disallowed from stirring shit into food. That we tell businesses what they can and can't do is a fact, so it's: 1) useful to discuss whether or not we should allow or disallow things, and 2) useless to discuss whether private business can do whatever they want because they are private businesses. The answer to that is that private businesses can't do what they want, instead they're allowed to do what we haven't told them they can't do, and must do what we've told them they must do.