4 ms·
This is maybe a tangent, but: how long before we're allowed to stop calling cryptocurrencies a new technology, and admit that actual usage is not being blocked
by woodruffw 4y ago
This is maybe a tangent, but: how long before we're allowed to stop calling cryptocurrencies a new technology, and admit that actual usage is not being blocked on early development? Bitcoin itself is 14 years old; if it were a web framework, it would have been "obsoleted" half a dozen times over by now.
- zamalek 4y agoNow that the Year of the Linux Desktop might happen for real, I guess we need a new "Year of the X."
- gleenn 4y agoWhat you're saying clearly makes sense but Bitcoin isn't accepted almost anywhere which is what "new" means. Porn would be an early adopter for potentially mass consumption. It would be new to me certainly as I've never purchased a single thing with Bitcoin and that's almost certainly true for most people.
- woodruffw 4y agoI don't know. I passed a bitcoin ATM machine (don't ask me what that actually means, please) on the street yesterday. Friends and family members, including (especially?) non-technical ones, have asked me about Bitcoin and how to invest in it. One of my friends recently bought a car with Ethereum. "New" means "new," it doesn't mean "not widely adopted yet." We don't widely adopt things that fail or have unacceptable side effects; that doesn't make them new again.
- gleenn 4y agoHow about new in the sense that other currencies have been around for hundreds of years compared to only 14?
- jcranmer 4y agoThe euro is most certainly not hundreds of years old, and isn't that much older than Bitcoin.
- sophacles 4y agoThe euro is not a new type of currency tech. Its just a new painting on the same type of currency that has existed for hundreds of years (that is it's a new brand of banknote).
- woodruffw 4y agoI don't buy that. The Euro was conceived in 1992 and constituted a radical shift in international monetary policy; it wasn't fully rolled out until 2002. That's 10 years compared to Bitcoin's 14, with arguably far more in concrete financial activity (and quality of life) to show for it.
- gleenn 4y agoSure but again let's be a little more nuanced. When the Euro came out, trillions in wealth were automatically converted to it. Pretty apples to oranges comparison. If all USD was converted to BTC, BTC would become useful everywhere as fast as people could change the POS systems. Not a fair comparison at all.
- woodruffw 4y ago> When the Euro came out, trillions in wealth were automatically converted to it. This is true, but also misleading: the physical Euro switch took place over months, and involved a coordinated public campaign to encourage millions of Europeans to exchange their physical bills. Digitalization helped with banking, but a significant human and policy effort occurred in parallel. And there's another problem: it's really not clear what it would mean for "all USD to be converted to BTC." BTC has already been issued, and will continue to be algorithmically issued. The Euro switch could not be economically triaged per se, because it was an in-kind transition. No such transition is possible for cryptocurrencies, unless we allow a central authority into the mix.
- ClumsyPilot 4y ago> it were a web framework, it would have been "obsoleted" half a dozen times over by now. So a point for Bitcoin then?
- woodruffw 4y agoOnly if we think "it's better than web development churn" is somehow a positive marker, and not a neutral one at best.
- ChadNauseam 4y agoI wrote about this subject here, if you're interested: https://chadnauseam.com/coding/cryptocurrency/a-hackers-case-for-crypto/ https://chadnauseam.com/coding/cryptocurrency/a-hackers-case... The TL;DR is that blockchain scaling is a very difficult problem. There are scaling layers like ZKSync that are only possible because of cryptographic primitives that literally didn't exist in a usable form 14 years ago. And I somewhat disagree with your premise – cryptocurrencies are actually used in the real world today. Most of the usage is to get around regulation, like when you want to send remittances or buy drugs, or bet on betting markets. But on the whole I do agree, it's disappointing that the technology is still so immature. Disclosure: I work in the cryptocurrency industry
- themitigating 4y agoI think it's both acceptance and time. The internet was more than 20 years old in 1999 but still had low usage
- pbhjpbhj 4y ago25% of UK adults had internet access in 1999. Low compared to today (93%), but still pretty high. https://www.statista.com/statistics/275999/household-internet-penetration-in-great-britain/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/275999/household-interne...
- pbhjpbhj 4y ago25% of UK adults had internet access in 1999. Low compared to today (~95%), but still pretty high. https://www.statista.com/statistics/275999/household-internet-penetration-in-great-britain/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/275999/household-interne...
- sophacles 4y agoNew is pretty context dependent. Money is literally older than history. That sets up a lot of context by itself, and further the fact that it's so important means people, governments and institutions are pretty conservative (in the slow to adopt change sense) about it. Banks have only recently reached infrastructure status in that context - and only in well developed nations. Credit cards are still new in that context (and it shows). The 14 years of bitcoin is basically embryonic in terms of "money tech".
- woodruffw 4y agoThis is a reasonable point, but it demands that we ignore the parabolic trend in every other aspect of human development. We've gone from horse-drawn carriages to moon landings and instantaneous global communication in the last 125 years; why does Bitcoin get over 10% of that time to do what I can already do with the piece of plastic in my wallet?
- sophacles 4y agoAre you sure this tech isn't "parabolic"? Depending how you define personal credit, its been around ~100 years (or more!), with the card format being adopted in the 60s. It's only been the last 15 years or so that not carrying cash has become a reasonable approach to day-to-day life. So for bitcoin to become as big as it has as a brand new technology in only 14 years seems accelerated. This is analysis complicated a bit by the fact that bitcoin is not a top-down tech like credit, there's no centralized group deciding who gets to use it. On the other side of that though - the tech infrastructure build-out that made credit cards ubiquitous also benefits and accelerates the potential adoption of bitcoin.
- woodruffw 4y agoIt's parabolic with respect to middlemen, but none of the other properties I care about. That isn't to say there are no advancements (I think privacy-preserving finance is an important frontier), but they don't stack up well, to say the least.
- 4y ago
- ryandvm 4y agoNot to put too fine a point on it, but my guess is there is probably little overlap in the Venn diagram of people paying for porn subscriptions and people capable of managing a crypto wallet.
- woodruffw 4y agoAlas, it's probably hard to pull the cap off of your hardware wallet with only one hand. But isn't that what we're told Coinbase is for?
- PheonixPharts 4y agoAt this point, the fact that cryptocurrencies haven't successfully captured this markets tell us that they never will. 14 years ago the argument was "you just wait!" Today, everyone in the US knows what "crypto" is, far more than know what "cryptography" is based on my casual conversations. The fact that porn hasn't moved to entirely crypto means that crypto has not survived the test of time. There are plenty of other examples as well, the fact that Russian oligarchs (or even just regular old wealthy Russians) aren't creating massive demand for crypto to thwart sanctions is another example that crypto will never become an alternate, super-legal, currency. It's honestly a shame that it doesn't work because, during the first wave of crypto hype, I rather liked the libertarian visions of an unregulated underground economy. I thought crypto enthusiasts were wrong then, but I at least hoped they were right.
- fulafel 4y agoCryptocurrencies were a thing for internet payments already in the 90s: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ecash https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ecash