6 ms·
This would worry me if the AppStore were the only way to get aplications on to your Mac. I can see it being very disapointing for developers who enjoyed the co
by Angostura 15y ago
This would worry me if the AppStore were the only way to get aplications on to your Mac.
I can see it being very disapointing for developers who enjoyed the convenience of the AppStore, but need additional functions. But I guess they will have to sell ex-Store
I can also see the benefit of Apple being able to say that 'Anything you buy on the Store is safe(tm)'.
However if Apple every makes teh Appstore a compulsory way to get software onto the Mac, I will drop Macs. And I speak as someone who has used them for about 20 years.
- lisperforlife 15y agoThe same here. I do not think I would use a Mac OSX if they said that app store was the only way to get software.
- mbq 15y agoKnowing Apple's achievements in pwn2own, this most likely won't increase the real security... Whatever you do, security always boils down to aware user, thus it is in fundamental contradiction to this company philosophy.
- mike-cardwell 15y agoHow can you possibly claim that this wont increase security?
- mbq 15y agoBecause it is like X-raying people coming through front door to check if they are hiding anything metal having opened and unsupervised kitchen door. Plumbers are banned, yet you can still be killed with a ceramic knife by a polite assassin or with metal pipe by a brutal crook.
- mike-cardwell 15y agoThat analogy bears no resemblance to the issue at hand. These changes improve security. Just because they don't improve the security to 100%, that doesn't make them worthless.
- mbq 15y agoThe main problem is that it comes with a obvious loss of functionality which I doubt that can be leveraged with security gain -- the other thing is that it gives a faux sense of security to the user (i.e. yes, I have agreed for full file system access, but it was sandboxed, right?). Finally, the system is as weak as the weakest elements, and those seemingly lay in their own code (and can be fixed without hurting the functionality).
- mike-cardwell 15y agoSo if Google decided to remove the sandboxing functionality in the next version of Android and just run every app under the same user id, that wouldn't reduce the security of Android devices?
- mbq 15y agoAgain, I'm not against adding seemingly redundant additional security layers, I'm against calling sandbox an universal cure for everything and using it to constrain the user in morally ambiguous way. Android system is also damaged because it makes users to root the device to do things which might be done without such elevation of privileges and, what's worse, violating warranty.
- flomo 15y ago> How can you possibly claim that this wont increase security? I've honestly never heard of a third-party Mac application which contains spyware or steals personal information. It just does not seem like a huge problem which needs to be solved. (Of course there have been security issues with things like Adobe Acrobat and MS Office. But big ISV software is the least likely to be affected by app store restrictions.)
- statictype 15y agoBesides security, sandboxing is a good way to protect the User's system from poorly written apps.
- super_mario 15y agoGive it a release or two and app store will be the only way to get software on your locked down appliance owned by Apple.
- marquis 15y agoIf this happens they will effectively kill off a huge number of professional services, especially in the media industry. I'm not looking forward to a future where I have to look to Windows or Unix as my main development platform.
- super_mario 15y agoSad thing is Mac OS X is a certified UNIX.
- statictype 15y agothey will effectively kill off a huge number of professional services, especially in the media industry. Apple has already demonstrated several times over that the professional market isn't really of much interest to them anymore. Witness the disaster of Final Cut Pro X and the gradual phasing out of the Mac Pro hardware line. Apple's focus is squarely on the consumer market. Though it may seem unlikely today that they will permanently ban non AppStore apps, I wouldn't cite the professional market as a reason for it to not happen.
- glassx 15y ago"Witness the disaster of Final Cut Pro X" But they responded to that by putting Final Cut Pro 7 back on the market. Sounds like they care a lot... Hanlon Razor makes sense here.
- guygurari 15y ago> Apple has already demonstrated several times over that the professional market isn't really of much interest to them anymore. There is one group of professionals Apple cannot do without: developers. One of the main appeals of both iOS and the Mac is the availability of exclusive, high-quality apps. I expect that limiting all app distribution to the Mac App Store will send developers running to other platforms. A platform without developers is an empty shell, and Apple knows this.
- mitjak 15y agoI think if that ever happens, we will basically have iOS X on our hands. Unless they want to completely merge the two operating systems, I don't see that happening anytime soon.