3 ms·
SCOTUS decision regarding coach prayer misconstrues the facts
- shaftway 4y agoAnyone know how to contact a local chapter of the Satanic Temple? There's a "quiet and personal" ritual I want to conduct on my school's field right after a game involving a pentagram and salt.
- logicalmonster 4y agoI feel in a lot of areas of society, a clear distinction between what is subjective and what is objective isn't made. As everybody knows, both subjective and objective information exists. An objective statements takes this form: "The thermometer I hold in my hand at 3PM in the park registered a temperature of 55 degrees F". A subjective statement takes this form: "I felt chilly at the park at 3PM". Somebody else at the same park at the same time could reasonably say "I felt a bit warm at 3PM" and it would be an accurate statement. Both people can subjectively feel different about the same exact objective facts. The statement "misconstrues the facts" itself seems like a misconstruing of the facts. As far as I can tell, it's not the objective facts that are in conflict, it's the subjective interpretation. It's impossible to misconstrue a subjective interpretation. The words "Quiet" and "Personal" are descriptions that take the form of a subjective statement. There can be no misconstruing a person's assessment of something as Quiet/Personal. Two different people can reasonably see somebody speaking at a volume of 55 decibels and say that they think it was too quiet or too loud and both interpretations would be their subjective opinion.
- derbOac 4y agoOn the other hand, sometimes "you'll know it when you see it" also applies, where someone really has to stretch argument to make a case for a certain interpretation. There's also cases where appearance is important, in that anything giving the appearance of something creates potential abuse of power. That is, at some level it doesn't matter if the coach is praying privately, if he is creating an implicit pressure to join him or suffer consequences, even if unintentional. In this case, I can't help but wonder if the coach were Muslim or a member of an uncommon religion, what the reaction would have been. I doubt the case would have proceeded the same.
- jleyank 4y agoThen obviously other religions groups or individuals have to have their "quiet and personal" displays in a similar setting in a similar fashion. And, of course, everybody will be perfectly content seeing these alternatives, right?
- themadturk 4y agoI wonder what would happen if a Catholic priest decided to celebrate mass on the 50 yard line of a public high school? It may seem like an extreme hypothetical, but church/state separation principal seems the same to me. The coach's prayer time was a blatant use of publicly-funded property for religious purposes.
- _-david-_ 4y agoFirst, churches frequently rent out schools to do religious ceremonies. This has always been allowed. Second, this event happened after the game so it didn't disrupt the game or anything like that. Third, separation of church and state is not in the Constitution and so it is just a general principle not any sort of binding law. Fourth, separation of church and state does not mean that a church / religious person cannot use state property. Read Jefferson's letter where he coined the phrase. It means the state cannot interfere with the religious institutions. It was a one way separation. Fifth, this was a personal ceremony, not an entire mass.
- mrlonglong 4y agoI feel forebodings about the SCOTUS, Trump may have succeeded in turning the country into a theocracy using the law via the Supreme Court. Civil war is a distinct possibility if there are enough angry people out there with their guns. Thoughts, anyone ?
- feet 4y agoI hope things can get fixed without fighting, but we badly need to revise the constitution for the modern era. The thoughts and idea of the slave holding, racist, mysoginistic, rapist founding fathers needs to be scrapped. They didn't want black people, poor people, or women to have a say or rights and now we're seeing the effect of those ideas in the supreme court which is currently ruled by activist federalist society "judges"
- troon-lover 4y ago
- Throwawayaerlei 4y agoThe problem with your thesis the people who own guns in this county are not the ones being made angry with these three decisions.
- mrlonglong 4y agoNo, I've heard democrats are also buying guns too. Not as many as the republicans I'll give you that.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]