5 ms·
That is what disruptive innovation looks like. "Oh look, a multi-billion dollar problem people were trying to solve by getting two sides of the market to simul
by patio11 15y ago
That is what disruptive innovation looks like. "Oh look, a multi-billion dollar problem people were trying to solve by getting two sides of the market to simultaneously ubiquitously install new hardware. How about we solve it with stuff they already own plus new software instead?"
- tansey 15y agoWhat's even better about Card Case is that you don't need every retailer to have it for it to be useful. The example they show in their demo video is perfect: going to your regular coffee shop. If just that coffee shop supports it, Square is already solving a huge headache for both the customer and the merchant. The customer gets easier payments and a more personalized experience; the merchant reduces transaction friction and time, while increasing customer loyalty. Brilliant.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- thinkcomp 15y agoI respectfully disagree. This is what an investment from Visa looks like with really good design. Not everyone was trying to get both sides to adopt new hardware, either. As long as Square uses cards for funding, it will be robbing the poor to pay the rich just like every other card company. To me, "disruptive" in the payments world means no cards, period.
- dpark 15y agoAnd why exactly do you imagine that Square couldn't debit directly from a checking account in the future (as the article mentioned)?
- thinkcomp 15y agoBecause they don't have any money transmitter licenses and it will take them a few years to get them.
- dpark 15y agoHence the phrase "in the future". There's no way that Square doesn't see this obvious step. It's probably already in progress. Also I'm guessing that what Square currently does already requires a money transmitter license, since transmitting money is exactly what they do.
- thinkcomp 15y agoSquare does not currently require a license, and they have not yet applied for one in California.
- dpark 15y agoOut of curiosity, where are you getting this info? From a cursory look, I was under the impression that they would need a license in every state that they'd do business in.
- thinkcomp 15y agoIt's all public information. Square is exempt from the California Money Transmission Act per FC § 1805(d) (see http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/cgi-bin/displaycode?section=fin&group=01001-02000&file=1805-1806 http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/cgi-bin/displaycode?section=fin...), since it's actually JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A. that is moving your money. Square does not have a license. http://www.dfi.ca.gov/directory/mt.asp http://www.dfi.ca.gov/directory/mt.asp And Square has no plans to get one as of last month. http://www.dfi.ca.gov/publications/summaries/2011/september.pdf http://www.dfi.ca.gov/publications/summaries/2011/september....
- dpark 15y agoThanks! Would it not be possible for them to partner in the same fashion to do direct debit?
- mbreese 15y agoYou're seriously still beating this horse? Why couldn't they partner with another institution that already has the appropriate licensing? Or, alternatively, they seem well enough funded to be able to post the appropriate bonds. I get your position, but with the constant whining, you're not winning over people.
- lazerwalker 15y agoYou don't think moving people away from physically using cards for the transactions is a big first step? With the transaction taking place without any physical handling of any paper or plastic, using a card as a payment source is just an implementation detail. It'll be trivial in the future for Square to add alternate funding sources without any pain to the user, and in the mean time it drives adoption because people are already used to the idea of giving Square their credit card info.
- reissbaker 15y agoWhat were the non-hardware non-card payment methods attempted? I'm familiar with NFC, and somewhat intimately familiar with Square and its card-based rivals, but the only alternatives I know of are those pay-through-your-carrier attempts that are an even bigger can of worms than a card company. Were there others? To reference your Visa point (which I suspect wasn't serious), Square was card-based long before the Visa investment.
- thinkcomp 15y agoStarbucks (for payments) and the airlines (for boarding passes) have done pretty well with barcode scanners. It requires hardware only on the merchant side than most merchants already have in one form or another.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- reissbaker 15y agoEr. But unless you've given Starbucks direct access to your bank account, those are fundamentally card-based too.
- thinkcomp 15y agoNot quite. Starbucks uses its own pre-paid system that does use a plastic card, but one without any major network's logo on it. It's just store credit.
- corin_ 15y agoAnd in America (I believe - last I heard it was rolled out in some American cities but not others, nothing here in the UK) the iPhone/Android/Blackberry(?) apps let you manage your account balance, and you hold up your phone for the cashier to scan the barcode off your screen.
- vidarh 15y ago
- jcampbell1 15y agoWhat is the fundamental problem with cards? What needs to be disrupted? Paying with phones is cute, but it is really just technical masturbation, as there is only a tiny connivence benefit and it is slower than a no sign swipe. I have been able to pay with my phone for 2 years now, and I hardly ever do it. My MC pay-pass RFID card fits under my cellphone's battery cover. I am genuinely curious as to the problem that needs to be solved.
- maximusprime 15y agoBecause it's stupidly insecure, unregulated, won't reach mass adoption etc?
- Saavedro 15y agoAdoption I can see being an obstacle. But I don't see this being particularly insecure.
- jorangreef 15y agoIf the product is right, if it serves people well, adoption will be limited only to that which Square can support.
- vidarh 15y agoCredit cards are stupidly insecure. Last I heard, a few years ago you could buy blocks of thousands of valid, tested credit card with CVV2 values for about the cost of a coffee. Credit cards works because the banks are willing to stretch far to block fraudulent transactions or take them off the bill because having you trust the card makes them lots of money. The same will be the case here: Unless the fraud takes on truly endemic proportions, far higher than for credit cards, they'll just eat the cost.
- T-hawk 15y agoIt's not out of goodwill that the banks will eat the cost of fraud or work hard to prevent it. Banks do this to protect their own pockets, because (US) law says that customer liability for credit card fraud is limited to $50 and anything beyond that is the bank's loss. For a counterexample, see Paypal. Paypal's unresponsiveness to fraud situations is legendary, because it's not their money at stake and as legally-not-a-bank they can simply stick their customers with the loss. (Paypal's customers are merchants, I don't mean end-consumers here.) Getting back to Square, as long as they're not regulated like a bank, they will in the long term become more like Paypal in dealing with fraud. The founders may be able to delay or mitigate this with a strong organizational commitment to customer service, but that would be pretty unprecedented in the financial industry; the bottom line always looks better when the corporation can push fraud costs off of itself.
- refulgentis 15y agoI am the cofounder of a startup that builds an iOS/iPod/iPad POS Ambur, and it's absolutely astonishing to me to see people claim Square is doing anything useful for merchants. Their software is far too simplistic for anyone running more than a very basic coffee shop with tech savvy customers to use. Even something as simple as most customers demand receipts, and Square's functionality beyond taking basic coffee orders is non-existent. That does not cut it for businesses, no matter how cheap Square is. They really, really, need to launch a platform for people like us to innovate on. We're young, forward-thinking, and as an ex-restaurant employee I know how much CC companies and traditional POS companies screw businesses. We're trying to change that on the POS side, and I desperately wish Square would be less egotistical and let us change the payment side. It would be tremendous for them, because it lets POS companies solve adoption for them, instead of them trying to engineer 1000 solutions for 1000 different types of business, and let's them focus on their core compotency - beautifully designed software for consumers.