2 ms·
> But in the time where anyone can be an AI researcher on a hobby budget, without review by an ethics board, maybe a "test of reasonableness" or guideline of so
by mschuster91 4y ago
> But in the time where anyone can be an AI researcher on a hobby budget, without review by an ethics board, maybe a "test of reasonableness" or guideline of some sort would be useful to have.
Common sense would be enough: Don't involve un-consenting others in your research. Facebook discovered this with the backlash they got in 2014 (!) for doing a/b testing [1], it's not like the question of AI/algorithms being used in malicious ways is something new... even though I'd love to see a blanket ban on A/B testing in general. Users are not guinea pigs and A/B testing can amount to gaslighting.
Additionally, the whole world has been debating the influence of racist and other discriminatory language on the Internet since at least 2016 with the election of the 45th.
By 2022, it should be very clear where the borders of civilization are, and I believe that that Youtuber should have known that.
Side note: We definitely need a societal discussion about Youtube and Tiktok. The amount of extremely vile or dangerous stunts people pull for likes/clicks/monetization on these platforms at the expense of others is immense.
[1] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2014/jul/02/facebook-apologises-psychological-experiments-on-users https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2014/jul/02/facebook-...
- selfhoster11 4y agoI 100% hold that A/B testing is a form of gaslighting. It should be illegal.
- Hizonner 4y agoNot OK to use nonconsenting human subjects for research, OK, I'm on board for that. But, after you do all your oh-so-ethical research, why is it then OK to intentionally build products that do damage to unconsenting humans? It's not OK to emotionally manipulate people to write a paper... but somehow it's just fine to emotionally manipulate them to sell useless crap...