7 ms·
Tracking evasion is close to the concept we in Germany call "Datensparsamkeit" or data scarcity — the idea that only the data that needs to be collected for a c
by atoav 4y ago
Tracking evasion is close to the concept we in Germany call "Datensparsamkeit" or data scarcity — the idea that only the data that needs to be collected for a certain purpose should be collected.
The idea is: Data that just isn't there cannot be lost, abused or stolen. Or phrased differently: Data is also a liability for you and your users and you should balance this liability with the use it has for you.
The idea comes from Germany's Nazi past, when the Nazis invaded the Netherlands where religion was a field in the official documents, which lead to an very efficient genocide.
- _carbyau_ 4y agoThis is one thing I came away from Germany with. Germans today don't hide what happened - the better to learn from it. In this regard to data, the rest of the world seems intent on repeating their mistake. Hopefully to a lesser degree but only time will tell.
- n0n 4y ago"[...]data is a toxic asset and saving it is dangerous." https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2016/03/data_is_a_toxic.html https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2016/03/data_is_a_tox...
- 4oh9do 4y ago> the idea that only the data that needs to be collected for a certain purpose should be collected. The US has a similar stature, the Paperwork Reduction Act, a "law governing how federal agencies collect information from the American public", with the aim being to "not overwhelm [the public] with unnecessary or duplicative requests for information" and that the data collected be "a good fit for its proposed use" and further still "To respect privacy, we avoid asking for personal information that’s not relevant or necessary." https://pra.digital.gov/about/ https://pra.digital.gov/about/ In practice, of course, this is all bullshit and any data that the government cares to collect is rationalized as fitting all those requirements. So I'm curious if the German Datensprsamkeit is actually effective?
- atoav 4y agoIn my (university IT) circles it is definitely part of the lived culture. IT sees itself as the ally of the users and not a data collector for the management. The management mostly agrees with the principle of data scarcity as well. I recall one instance where the highest person at a university tried to get all the user's contact tracing data because of some incident (theft), IT explained that their request was not only illegal, but also useless, because the way data was stored would not allow to extract data without going to another official place and requesting the other half of the data which could only be accessed by the health department. There is a german saying that goes a bit like: "where there is a feeding trough there are pigs". The idea of data scarcity is to avoid putting up things that can be used as food by pigs. So instead of defending data silos, you build them in a way that they don't become targets in the first place because they are of limited use outside of the intended use case. Judging by the number of politicians complaining about data privacy, it works.
- 9dev 4y agoWell... I suspect German Datensparsamkeit is only a figment of the utterly ridiculous digital infrastructure of the german governments, both federal and state ones. Most processes are still carried out via paper or fax (fax!), you have to show up personally for the most insignificant things, every single village has their own records (practically never digital), and every time the government attempts to make a stab towards more digitalisation, big corps waste billions on giant projects that never get finished - we had the attempt to get health insurance (mandatory here) cards with an NFC chip on them that would securely store medical records and grant online access to your data; finally, no more carrying X-Ray CDs from MD to MD or filling out registration forms at the doc. But of course, 10 years later, everyone has a new card, but you can't do anything with it. Someone has earned a lot with it though. So, all in all, it's not that Germany's government is so privacy conscious, but we're simply stuck in a pre-digital world with no reasonable way to share data.
- nicbou 4y agoGermany asks for your religion during your address registration, to collect church tax. It's one of the first forms you'll fill after moving to Germany. However, this is largely correct. German offices don't even talk to each other without your consent. It can be frustrating at times. Germany also has some of the strongest photography laws I know of. You have a certain expectation of privacy even in public.
- rawbot 4y agoAnd they start charging you without telling you directly (by a letter) or getting your consent! First thing I tell everyone moving here is that they should be careful with that form and be atheists officially. I ended up paying 4 years of tax before they relaxed the process.
- stavros 4y agoBut when the New Crusades begin again, guess who'll be the first to go!
- marcosdumay 4y agoThere are a few centuries of history telling you what are safe options to put there and what aren't. They won't come for atheists first.
- tut-urut-utut 4y agoI don't want to be a devils advocate, but why is it a problem that you paid a church tax? In Germany, members of the church pay for the church service, it is made available to them by the church. It's just how it is, you pay the tax, and then you can marry for free, attend church for free, baptise your children free of charge, ... If you don't want to use or don't need their services, you can always cancel your church membership. It costs one visit to Bürgeramt and a few euros. I am sick of people staying in church and complaining that they should not pay. Before church tax, everyone had to pay through taxes, even people that are not members of catholic or evangelical church, like atheists and members of other confessions. That is immoral. Either pay or leave the church if it is not worth it for you to pay.
- bheadmaster 4y ago> The idea comes from Germany's Nazi past, when the Nazis invaded the Netherlands where religion was a field in the official documents, which lead to an very efficient genocide. I am very afraid that a similar thing could happen in the modern world. The Great Surveillance Machine is just a ticking time-bomb, waiting for the right tyrant to use it to enforce their own idea of Good. Whatever characteristic they want to cleanse out of society, they can easily track down people with that characteristic, and neutralize them. And when that happens, there will be nothing we can do to save ourselves, because we have already surrendered our whole lives to The Machine.
- Agamus 4y agoCould happen? Isn't this what is already happening in totalitarian countries?
- paskozdilar 4y agoPerhaps, but I didn't want to claim anything without proof. If you have any proof, please post here, so I may use it in future arguments.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]