8 ms·
Sad Trek – How an exhausted liberalism killed sci-fi’s sunniest franchise
- aruanavekar 4y agoI could not watch Discovery, nor will I attempt to because the challenges/issues seemed stories rather than findings and solving with optimism. Too much emotional chaos than coming together towards building a future. It did not leave be in a better sense of mind, definitely left me feeling hopeless and demotivated toward tomorrow.
- s0rce 4y agoThe Orville is much better.
- orangecat 4y agoIt really is. The first few episodes were shaky as they were trying to decide whether it was Family Guy in space or TNG with more humor, but fortunately they chose the latter. Also enjoying Strange New Worlds which takes itself much less seriously than Discovery and Picard.
- s0rce 4y agoI'm also liking strange new worlds, although the latest episode was really boring.
- KerrAvon 4y agoThe Orville is inconsistent and often unpleasant.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- s0rce 4y agoI'm a fan. Discovery is consistently unpleasant.
- ASalazarMX 4y agoJust like TNG, sometimes it was brilliant, and sometimes it wasn't. That's the risk with actual creativity instead of fistfights and non-stop action. Discovery looks good, but very thin on the meat.
- izzydata 4y agoI watched season 1 and 2. It is only Star Trek in name and not in spirit.
- KerrAvon 4y agoYou stopped just as it was getting good. Season 1 was bad. Season 2 was a bit better. Season 3 was pretty good. Season 4 is boring and poorly paced.
- rainwolf 4y agoThe plot of season 4 reminded me a little too much of "Orphans of the helix"
- izzydata 4y agoPerhaps, but I saw no reason for it to be named Star Trek. They should have named it anything else and I'd probably have enjoyed it more.
- cassianoleal 4y agoI've found it consistently bad all the way. It did look like it was going to get a bit better when S3 started but it's still a lot of moping and crying and even the ship's AI having existential issues and zero exploration and socio-politics. Even the most high profile representatives of the different peoples are just a bunch of emotionally immature and persistently frightened individuals.
- tjpnz 4y agoThey should just rename it to The Michael Burnham Show at this point.
- TMWNN 4y agoI've not seen the show, but have heard that Burnham is basically the Mary Sue of all Mary Sues.
- 4y ago
- random-human 4y agoSeason 2 & 3 get better - there was a major production shakeup between 1 & 2 and smaller ones for 3. Season 4 goes slows, but I think one of the biggest problems is the way the seasons are told. One large overarching story with minor character building because of it, instead of the episodic storytelling from TOS etc. It took some getting use too and I almost stopped watching the first season as well. Season 2 is good to watch if you watch Strange New Worlds, which does go back to the episodic stories making it more like Star Trek. Also, Lower Decks is pretty funny - I put it on for background noise and ended up binge watching, something I rarely do.
- ASalazarMX 4y agoSame here, people kept telling to give it a chance, as TOS found its stride until season 3. The ending of season 2, and the beginning of season 3 looked like they were listening and addressing their flaws, only for it to redouble on them. Their seasons can be resumed as: Michael is the beginning and the end, all things are about Michael.
- pacarvalho 4y agoInitially, I attributed the difference in the sentiment of the show to them being developed by a different team of writers. However, reflecting further on the matter and taking into account that similar changes occurred in other sci-fi franchises such as Stargate SG-1 vs Universe, it does seem to be somewhat related to the eras' changes in their perception of the future. Regardless what the reason may be, I would like to see a return to shows like Startrek Next Generation or Stargate SG-1 and a depart from their current versions. A return to the exploration and selflessness that contrasts our real-lives' hardships, socio-political discussions and routine. The utopia of Startrek. I, for one, could not wait to engineer my next thing after an energizing episode of exploration focused sci-fi. Something that does not happen after watching the dark, emotional facsimiles of today.
- oracardo 4y agoI recently came across the term "hopepunk" which I think fits with your point. There is a line where hopeful, positive stories provide a lot of value before crossing into pandering/boring territory. I wish more modern stories built that up.
- ASalazarMX 4y agoI'm new to this term, and as a big fan of cyberpunk, I'm glad to see a non-dystopian take on it.
- ajmurmann 4y agoI wonder how much this has to do with the philosophy and outlook at the time as opposed to just the mundane trend more and more action and fast-paced story telling and the need for stories that span many episodes. Some episodes of season 2 of Discovery were able to weave in the visit planets and explore stuff from older Trek, but it's hard to explore and discuss philosophical problems if you need to have a lot of action and conflict to keep an audience. TNG still had a strong following, but would a show that slow make the CFO happy today? It would get more fighting with the Borg, more war like in DS9, but without all the episodes about other stuff. In fact if you'd take the episodes related to the Dominion and make them faster and cut a lot of the interpersonal stuff, it would be much closer to Discovery than TNG.
- halfmatthalfcat 4y agoI've watched Star Trek pre-Discovery ad-nauseum since I could watch TV; easily my favorite singular piece of media/franchise. What JJ Abrams, Alex Kurtzman and the rest of the production brain-trust have done to Star Trek is an absolute shame. Maybe it's hubris, money or a heavy-handed Paramount not fundamentally understanding Trek but it's been a real tragedy watching something I love being systematically torn apart and become a shell of it's former self in the worst way.
- batperson 4y agoDid you get a chance to watch "Strange New Worlds" ? It's some of the best trek to come out in ages, feels a lot closer to the roots.
- HonestOp001 4y agoThe part I keep trying to figure out is how did they kill the formula. Strong captain dealing with ethical and moral quandaries in space. Work it around a military hierarchy and go. The latest outing had them go back in time during season 2! And spent a significant time there. Is there any star trekking to this? This is why the Orville took over for a lot of people.
- krapp 4y ago>The latest outing had them go back in time during season 2! And spent a significant time there. Is there any star trekking to this? Several of the most revered Star Trek episodes ever, "City on the Edge of Forever," "Far Beyond the Stars," "Time's Arrow" as well as the end of TNG (generally well recieved by fans) involved time travel. Moral quandaries can be compelling even outside of the ready room and bridge. I don't understand why people are so hung up on the franchise formula of "Strong captain dealing with ethical and moral quandaries in space." Those ethical and moral quandaries as presented were pathetically shallow more often than not and (thanks to the interference of people like Rick Berman) rarely challenging to any real-world establishment. Trek now is at least presenting a progressive view of a future that actually includes diversity and non heteronormative characters who aren't thinly veiled alien metaphors because God forbid our luxury space-socialist utopia offend people in the Bible belt. But I guess old school fans just want adventure and pablum that appeals to their nostalgia and never rocks the boat. They can have it, but I personally like it when Trek takes risks, even if they fail sometimes.
- light_hue_1 4y ago> This new wave of Star Trek is internally consistent, then, in harboring a pessimistic view of the future, one that seems to emerge from a particular contemporary sensibility. This is very accurate. But it has nothing to do with liberalism. The view of our current future is bleak if you're young. Climate change is poised to devastate large parts of the planet, disasters that used to be once in a century will be once every few years. Corruption is increasing, what leaders are getting away with now would have been totally crazy to think about 20 years ago. We live in a gilded age more extreme than in the 1920s, where the rich hoard the majority of resources. Many of the technologies that were supposed to lead to freedom and utopia have turned into a stark dystopia, like the internet, that threaten the very foundations of freedom. At the same time, the basic necessities (housing, education, healthcare) are almost out of reach for most young people. If you don't already have a house, it's hard to see how you will ever get into the market now. College is insanely expensive. And healthcare, particularly childcare since this affects the young most, has become completely unaffordable. New wealth isn't shared anymore, since income become disconnected from productivity. Social mobility is down significantly. The rich barely pay taxes compared to everyone else. Major new social projects are increasingly unaffordable, that's why our infrastructure is crumbling. The US is coming apart at the seams in a way that hasn't been seen since the civil war. It's hard to see how the country will ever come back together. No one sees a path toward this. And one party is going down a dark road (they just had a convention in Hungary to learn how illiberal democracies work). These problems aren't specific to the US. They're everywhere, different counties are just at different points along the path of decay. There's now a nationalist party running at the federal level in Canada. France almost voted for a Nazi party. Poland and Hungary are barely democracies. Almost every index worldwide is going down sharply, from freedom of the press to the corruption index. Star Trek isn't dark because of liberalism. It's dark because in the 1960s through the 1990s we lived through a golden age. Housing was affordable. Education was affordable. Healthcare was affordable, and childcare wasn't a hurdle. Major climate wins were made (acid rain and the ozone hole). People were getting richer (at least until the 1980s). New technologies seemed poised to make life better. Star Trek is dark because the future we see is dark. And it's getting darker.
- uoaei 4y ago> the future we see is dark. And it's getting darker. I think it's "exhausted liberalism" which has this outlook, not "liberalism" per se. I think you largely agree with the article, no?
- tjpnz 4y agoI've given the new shows a shot, I find them either preachy and nonsensical, or in the case of Strange New Worlds, boring. Who are these for exactly?
- ocdtrekkie 4y agoI'm not sure you realize it, but TOS, TNG, DS9, and Voyager were all extremely preachy. Picard is literally known for lengthy preachy monologues about how people should be.
- tjpnz 4y agoPerhaps but what differed with those shows was how the messages were presented in the form of an allegory. I wasn't annoyed by that and had a choice about how much I felt like engaging with it. If I had a long day I could just tune out and enjoy the story at face value.
- philistine 4y agoSometimes shows are just crap. Anything done by CBS since the revival has been crap. Simple as that. No need for a discussion on the value of allegory or preachiness. It's just crap.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Perhaps but what differed with those shows was how the messages were presented in the form of an allegory. Not really; I mean even when the main plot in outline could be seen as allegorical, they often had characters in-universe reference the specific “historical” (contemporary with the time of production) issue as a parallel the characters were reminded of by the events, peeling back the allegory, which in any case was only rarely not extremely heavy-handed. IMO, why people often see the earlier ones different (and which constitute the “early ones” varies a lot by person who does this) is: (1) People often will first have seen earlier series distant from the time of production, so heavy-handed framing in the terms of salient issues at the time of production will both be less likely to be politically sensitive and less likely to be a close match to current framing, (2) People will often first have seen the earlier series at a younger age when they were less aware of issues being addressed and less sensitive to the commentary even if it was current.
- ocdtrekkie 4y agoIt would have to be a Sunday night for this bad a take on Star Trek to make it this high on HN.
- braingenious 4y agoThe author of this article really likes using the word “liberalism” as often as possible. We mustn’t have a moment while reading this review of a couple of TV shows wherein we’re not freshly reminded of the raw intellect that went into talking about how one Star Trek show differs from another Star Trek show that was made decades before.
- anonymousiam 4y agoI thought the author's use of "liberalism" was exactly correct. Maybe the issue for you is that "liberalism" has evolved into something more akin to communism over the past few decades. Freedom of speech is dead. Racism is back. Civil rights are under threat by some perceived "right to not be offended", and the US Government is becoming the very thing that the founders were trying to prevent.
- braingenious 4y agoI have no idea where you could possibly infer that I conflate liberalism with communism. That’s kind of a weird and unfounded statement about my internal state. I’ll clarify: I think the author intentionally uses language to communicate how clever their opinions about Star Trek are (and how they should be received.) That was the whole post.
- NylaTheWolf 4y agoRacism is back? Are you seriously implying that racism went away in the first place?
- braingenious 4y agoRight?! When did it go away? When exactly did it come back? I have met real people in real life that think racism ended around the ‘08 election and stayed away until a speech by a candidate in June of ‘15. I would not presume to know what the GP’s experience is though.
- anonymousiam 4y ago
- tracerbulletx 4y agoDoes this also explain why they went from compelling sci-fi serials to being very very dumb?
- ohthehugemanate 4y agoStrange New Worlds is an improvement, certainly on the disastrous direction discovery took... but it still pales in comparison to The Orville. I'm convinced it's the best trek since the 90s.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tpict 4y agoThere’s nothing to read into here. The writers of these shows are chiefly interested in set pieces that will sell CBS subscriptions via dramatic trailers. They aren’t considering the implications for the ST universe any more than they’re considering the internal consistency of any single episode.
- philistine 4y ago> We can see it in the genuinely good first season of Star Trek: Picard (2020). I could live with an attempt at an intensive reflection on the lack of optimism in any of the new Star Trek shows, but then the author had to go out and say they enjoyed the first season of Picard. There can be a discussion about the future presented by those shows, but Star Trek: Picard was a mess with more producers than main cast members, and probably the lighting crew as well. It has been an atrocity of television, a fleeting attempt by a fading star to milk his cash cow one last time, and a farce of storytelling. The guys at Red Letter Media have them dead to rights.
- ASalazarMX 4y ago> Picard was a mess with more producers than main cast members I can't understand why that recent trend, you can't expect to make a quality show by committee.
- philistine 4y agoThey don't make it by committee. They change producers, and still have to credit the old ones. The more producers you see, the more troubled the production.
- latestatic 4y ago
- anonymousiam 4y agoI read this via RSS and came here to comment, only to find that the article was flagged. Did the critical examination of classic liberal values and current political trends hit too close to home? Most of the analysis seemed spot-on. Also, it made me feel better about not watching Discovery or Picard.
- ajmurmann 4y agoI wonder if some folks only read the headline and thought it was a "own the libs" piece
- ASalazarMX 4y agoI used to participate in the r/StarTrekDiscovery, an offshoot of r/StarTrek with a somewhat toxic fan base. If you write the wrong pronoun of a fictional character, it gets you a stern warning from the moderators, or a ban if you don't learn your lesson. Seems like it leaks into other social networks.
- lostmsu 4y agoDiscovery had pronouns beyond he/she?
- ASalazarMX 4y agoYou didn't know? If you thought Michael being the angsty human stepsister of Spock who somehow was a better Vulcan than Vulcans was unrealistic, get ready for Adira. Adira is a human non-binary girl who was in a relationship with Gray Tal, a transgender male Trill. TL;DR Gray gets hurt bad, and his symbiont gets passed to Adira (despite TNG establishing that humans aren't compatible hosts), becoming Adira Tal. The symbiont holds the memories of all the previous hosts, which somehow allows her to chat with Gray as a separate person. IIRC it even got to the point that Gray's vision can go and experience things independently of Adira. https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Adira_Tal https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Adira_Tal https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Gray_Tal https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Gray_Tal
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- squarefoot 4y agoWhat a surprise: TV shows are made to reflect the current public perception of the world so they appeal more watchers. News at 11. Star Trek isn't alone in this shift. Budget and special effects aside, could anyone imagine the remake of Battlestar Galactica (a show I didn't like at all, btw), Breaking Bad, Lost etc. in the 80s along the cheesy shows of that time? Of course not as they could only be conceived after a certain set of events, which very likely are 9/11 and the following absurd Iraq invasion; those events changed everything in what we think of the world and the people around us, including our own governments. Actually, TV shows were already transitioning to a less optimistic view of our society, which, speaking of SciFi, is clearly noticeable in B5 and DS9, but I think those events marked a milestone. Also, from the 80s to the early 2000s, the biggest change affecting our society has been the ability to be online and engage in public discussion with others, which brought even more stimuli and opportunities -whether for the good or bad it's completely subjective- further accelerating our normal social evolution; the world has changed virtually centuries in 20 years. I couldn't imagine anyone seriously thinking of shooting today a remake of The A-Team series in which they maintain its original thousands bullets shot every episode but nobody dies format.
- oceanghost 4y agoThis article get Star Trek, barely right. First of all, they're based on the Horatio Hornblower novels-- they're basically those in space. Second of all, Star Trek, the core before it lost its way (Enterprise and anything after it) is about aging. Either intentionally or unintentionally. TOS, and TNG, both have a space alien telling humanity to stay home. In "The Cage" which is literally called The Cage (metaphor for not advancing), the telepathic aliens warn humanity about the dangers of space, while sheltering (parenting) a disfigured human woman. In my theory, this is the adolescent humanity. In TNG, literally, a race called the Q warns humanity to stay home, we defy him and suffer through our teenage years straining against a well meaning but no longer welcome parental figure. DS9 and Voyager, to me doubly so since they ran concurrently, are about middle to late age. DS9 a younger middle age where you're still in your prime but you have children now you have to think about and there are hard decisions to be made. Voyager, because it starts with literally, "The Caretaker" dying (parents) and deals mostly with spirituality and ethics, and in my theory is placed later in life. *This is my theory and my theory alone. I will take all shit :-) So what's wrong with the new Star Trek? It's not liberalism, it's not lack of liberalism it's the same thing wrong with Star Wars and a lot of other entertainment out there-- its not GOOD. The entertainment industry has lost and idea of subtlety or complexity. If TNG offered me loving viewpoints that were beyond their time ad now and then preachy (the trans episode for instance--where Riker falls for an alien who doesn't have a clear sex)... things like Discovery and Brave New Worlds just bludgeon you with bullshit, and then when you don't like the mess they're serving you-- they blame you for that. I'd point to the Captain America debacle as the exemplar of this-- Brie Larson tells everyone the movie is for little girls (this was a deeply narcissistic, cynical and most of all dishonest viewpoint) and literally said she didn't care what 40 year old men thought about her movie and it "wasn't for them." Then she demonizes the same demographic for not showing up to see the movie she told them not to see. We're in a weird growing-pains stages of society. I am a card carrying, Bernie Sanders progressive, and I can't tolerate most of this bullshit.
- drewcoo 4y agoStar Trek was socialist, not liberal. Capitalism killed it once Gene was gone.
- poisonborz 4y agoA lot of the problems with the franchise is the same what the HN crowd sees all around with software development, hardware - with the digital boom of the 2000s, stakeholders see the possibility and sudden need to cater to EVERYONE. Who had the screenwriters in mind when writing scripts in 1989 or 1995? A wide enough geek minority that keeps the show afloat with healthy constant viewer numbers. Now they need to cater to the general population, and constantly seek ways to expand the crowd.