7 ms·
I think it's shortsighted to think of it as an alternative to conventional aviation. People send freight (and themselves) by plane because it's fast; in the ca
by gumby 4y ago
I think it's shortsighted to think of it as an alternative to conventional aviation. People send freight (and themselves) by plane because it's fast; in the case of cargo it's goods that are so expensive that the speed is worth it.
If you're not in a hurry you can use ships, which are quite cheap.
The value, IMHO, is in landlocked areas without rail links like Africa and central Asia. These are areas that mostly skipped the landline and went straight to wireless. Airships would be an analogous transition for them possibly even for passengers, though I think of freight.
- echelon 4y agoIf airship startups stopped trying to make them safe by filling them with precious helium, we could have affordable autonomous bulk cargo transports. If hydrogen airships "explode" at some small rate < 0.0001%, they can stick to transportation corridors away from population centers for the majority of their route to destination. It seems easier to replace a trucking fleet with autonomous hydrogen-powered airships than to have 100% safe self-driving semis operating on the road alongside human drivers.
- nradov 4y agoThere might be a niche market for autonomous hydrogen airships in some other countries, but it would be decades before the FAA allowed commercial use anywhere in the USA.
- worik 4y agoReally? Given jets take off in very marginal conditions with tonnes of high octane fuel n their wings. Is the FAA that much of a bigot? The Hindenburg was minor compared to what we regularly see in crashing jets.
- nradov 4y agoYes really. Hydrogen isn't allowed as a lifting gas. Congress would probably have to pass legislation to allow it. https://www.thecgo.org/benchmark/bring-back-hydrogen-lifting-gas/ https://www.thecgo.org/benchmark/bring-back-hydrogen-lifting... Besides the lifting gas, the previous comment mentioned "autonomous". The FAA also prohibits autonomous aircraft outside some very limited designated airspace. Until that ban is lifted, they can't be used for any real commercial service.
- jessriedel 4y agoAirships can also be useful over land even in places with dense rail/road networks if the cargo is too large for rail/road. A primary example is factory-built housing: currently, such houses have to be manufactured in pieces small enough to go on a truck and then assembled on-site, increasing cost. But if you can build larger sections (or even the whole house) at the factory and just air-lift it to the site, it could be much more efficient.
- m4rtink 4y agoNote that when the airship drops a heavy load, it might shoot into the stratosphere unless an action is taken due to suddenly having so much lift. So either you have to vent potentially expensive lifting gas - or get some replacement load, such as water or even a load of rocks. Not an impossible to solve but some site preparation is needed.
- usrusr 4y agoBut it's much easier to truck in a few dozen tons of ballast than to truck in, say, a 400 ft rotor blade. Transport is seriously limiting wind power, not just because larger gets better wind but also because larger would actually get less nimby, not more: rpm scales inversely with size, and rpm is what draws our attention to where we don't want it.
- bewo001 4y agoThat was the idea of CargoLifter (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CargoLifter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CargoLifter). The plan was to build an airship that can lift 160 t of oversized payload and beat train or road transport on price and speed. They ran out of money before they could build anything useful (besides a mighty hangar).
- PaulHoule 4y agoEverything else equal, fast = cheap The Hindenberg could cross the Atlantic in about two days https://simpleflying.com/cruise-ships-of-the-air/ https://simpleflying.com/cruise-ships-of-the-air/ If we average that out to 4 days to make a round trip, whereas today's airliners can make the round trip in a day, the capital cost of a seat on an airship has to be multiplied by 4 compared to the capital cost of an airliner because the seat on the airliner can move 4x as many people. On top of that, the airship is going to need to provide a much higher level of amenity (space, food, water, supplies, staff) to be comfortable for a much longer trip. Ocean liners became uneconomical early in the jet age for this exact reason: you're not just burning up your own time riding a slow boat, but you have to pay for a much longer time on that boat. In the 1960s, Boeing thought the 747 was a stop-gap solution because it was commonly thought supersonic airliners would be able to manage at least twice as many flights per unit time as subsonic airliners. When the Concorde came along it became clear that you couldn't manage this trick because you'd have to take off and land late at night, something the community finds unacceptable. The odd thing about supersonics is that the fuel economy gets better as you go faster (in the range from Mach 1 to the low 3's) and if you were able to make an airliner that flew at SR-71 speeds you might be able to manage a double flight rate.
- gumby 4y agoAll true but the economics are different when there is little cap ex budget. You don’t have to build an airstrip or lay rail to ship bulk goods like grain this way, and it need only go from inland to a port. Think Almaty to Singapore or Lusaka to Luanda. Any passengers for such a journey can put up with a lot of privation for a low cost trip (but I imagine passenger traffic would be fit into a cargo trip on a space available basis; I can’t imagine passengers being primary) You could use containers for some goods; bulk goods like grain could be decanted straight into the hold of a bulk carrier
- cagenut 4y agoI feel like doing this analysis without accounting for carbon is the mathematical version of climate change denial. Like, to not account for it is to deny it needs to be.
- 4y ago
- killjoywashere 4y agoYeah, uncontested landlocked airspace is a clear winner for blimps, and the US military didn't forget that: https://www.lockheedmartin.com/en-us/news/features/history/ptds.html https://www.lockheedmartin.com/en-us/news/features/history/p...
- john61 4y agoI think it is shortsighted to look at it with the economics of the past. CO2 emissions change the equation significantly.