2 ms·
It's fundamentally embarrassing to be caught with your pants down not knowing the sort of basic things the line of questioning inevitably leads to. Most of us a
by marginalia_nu 4y ago
It's fundamentally embarrassing to be caught with your pants down not knowing the sort of basic things the line of questioning inevitably leads to. Most of us are intellectually sloppy. Few of us will admit to that.
You'll find an army of people willing to defend say human rights, but very few of them could convince Socrates why. It's not that it's an indefensible position, of course it is, it's just that nobody really seems willing to shine light at central ideals like that. It's something that's so often taken for granted that very few actually bother to learn to motivate it, so when questioned, they flounder and fear maybe it can't be motivated, and react with aggression and threats instead of curiosity.
In the end, the Socratic method is a harsh and bitter medicine that not everyone wants to swallow. Everyone likes to call themselves a skeptic when it comes to the thinking of others, but few wants their own assumptions scrutinized. I think walking around like Socrates accosting people with it probably will get you in trouble now as it did then.
- andi999 4y agoWell, any position becomes indefensible when the socratic method is applied to it. So it doesnt seem too useful.
- StanislavPetrov 4y agoThat isn't at all true. Only logically inconsistent positions are indefensible when applying the Socratic method.
- staticman2 4y agoIn real life there is no judge who decides what position is defensible or indefensible using the socratic method. Someone accomplished in rheteric can pretty much argue anything in a logical manner.