3 ms·
It is murder, simple as that. The moment a sperm fertilizes an egg, a new unique genetic material is formed, which is damn near the closest thing we have to an
by chungy 4y ago
It is murder, simple as that. The moment a sperm fertilizes an egg, a new unique genetic material is formed, which is damn near the closest thing we have to an objective standard of when a new human life is started.
Embryo is a stage of development in a human being (and many other life forms on this planet). Maybe it's not synonymous with baby, I could grant that, and allow for baby to represent a different and later stage of development (possibly after birth), but even if I grant this, I'll still say killing that embryo is akin to murder. (Calling it a baby or child regardless of being inside the womb is still fairly natural and common in everyday speech.)
There's a grave fallacy in the article where it tries to compare an acorn to an oak tree. No, the acorn is not an oak tree. No more than a baby is an adult. But where the acorn is still oak, a baby is still human. Further fallacies are made as it tries to compare (and maybe equate?) human embryos with that of pigs and cows. Yeah... no. A woman is not going to give birth to a cow. That doesn't happen.
The article doesn't really do anything to establish anything new. It's only trying to dehumanize human development before birth.
Four ethical alternatives to abortion:
* Abstinence
* Contraception
* Adoption
* Motherhood
The last of these is the most preferential, and none of them involve murdering other humans.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- shadowfiend 4y ago> none of them involve murdering other humans A brief look at maternal health outcomes, especially in the United States, should suffice to disabuse you of this notion.
- kgwxd 4y agoOh, argument over I guess. You don't get to play the fallacy card when you start off stating your premises is irrefutable. All you've manage to argue here is "it's murder because I say so."
- chungy 4y agoThen I'll make it really simple for you. Human life begins at conception. Deliberately killing other humans is murder. Killing a human being in the womb is thus murder.
- vehemenz 4y agoLet me guess. Piracy is theft?
- chungy 4y agoAre you talking about the high seas or copyright infringement? Either way, it's irrelevant to the topic at hand.
- vehemenz 4y agoMore precisely, you don't see the relevance my rhetorical question has to your point.
- alexvoda 4y agoActually both. Copyright infringement by definition is not theft. And high seas piracy is an issue to be dealt with by the military, not law enforcement, especially if a letter of marque is involved. Same as pillaging by an invading army.
- eterps 4y agoSo there are no situations where deliberately ending the live of other humans is not considered murder?