10 ms·
Wild turtles age slowly, and some basically don’t age at all
- hunglee2 4y ago“It sounds dramatic to say that they don’t age at all, but basically their likelihood of dying does not change with age once they’re past reproduction,”
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoSame with humans, to a degree. Actuarials place your chance of dying at 50% after the age of 80. So we 'stop aging' after 80!
- spython 4y ago71569457046263802294811533723186532165584657342365752577109445058227039255480148842668944867280814080000000000000000000 is a good age to stop aging. Sorry, couldn't miss a factorial joke.
- RGamma 4y agoYou could witness https://czep.net/weblog/52cards.html https://czep.net/weblog/52cards.html 3748508088259971967302999598973478215811072000000 times until then. Frankly, I'm terrified.
- vaishnavsm 4y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but shouldn't the criterion be that the probability of death is the same between 80-90, 90-100, and so on (for example) to say that humans stop aging after 80? Saying that your chance of dying is 50% after 80 != saying it's the same consistently after 80?
- zamfi 4y agoI think the parent poster meant "annual chance of dying after 80" as in, for any year 80+, you have a 50% chance of dying that year: it doesn't go up each year, so you don't "age" in that sense.
- jewayne 4y agoBut this is not true. The life expectancy for an 80 year-old Caucasian American woman is over 9 years. The life expectancy a 90 year-old Caucasian American woman is less than 5 years.
- izzydata 4y agoBut if you flip a coin every year the chances of getting heads after 10 rolls is quite high.
- hutzlibu 4y agoYup, it is then still quite high - exactly 50%.
- capitainenemo 4y agoI'm sure he meant within 10 years. So (1-(0.5¹⁰))=99.9% chance (that is, chance of flipping tails 10 times in a row is 0.5¹⁰ - chance of any head is what's left)
- pawelmurias 4y agoWasn't this result largely cause by small sample size?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- andsoitis 4y agoDoes this actuarial table support your claim that chance of dying is stable at 50% after 80: https://www.ssa.gov/oact/STATS/table4c6.html https://www.ssa.gov/oact/STATS/table4c6.html
- jewayne 4y agoI love how, even for men, life expectancy doesn't fall below one year until age 113.
- candiodari 4y agoWell that happens because the ones who die get excluded from the calculation. So it doesn't drop off nearly as fast. It's calculating P(death|age = N), not P(death|age <= N). Now luckily you can calculate the second one, by adding all values up to that age together. I would argue the value you're looking for, "when you die", is different still: P(death|age <= N, current_age=M), where M is your current age. You know, taking into account that you didn't die from sudden infant death syndrome or measles, or you wouldn't be here, but leaving everything in the future up to chance. To get that value, you should the odds of dying at all ages up to N, but only starting at your current age.
- LeifCarrotson 4y agoNo, not exactly. Your chance of dying at year 80, per that table, is about 5% at 80, 15% at 90, and 30% at 100 (averaging for males and females). Not the same, and not 50. I think the observation they're trying to convey is that your expected number of years remaining goes down by much less than one year per year at those ages. A 90-year-old can expect to live for another 4.5 years, but on their 91st birthday, the chart surprisingly predicts not 3.5 but 4.2 years remaining. The number of expected years left drops more than 0.95 years per year until age 20, 0.9 years per year until age 40, down to 0.8 at 60, 0.5 at 80, and 0.1 at 100.
- bena 4y agoQuirks of statistics. To have an average of 4.5, you need people to die before and after the mark. So a lot of people drop off between 91 and 92. But those who make it to 92 have about 4.2 years remaining. If you have a population of 100 people and 50 of them will live less than 1 year, and 50 of them will live an average of 10 years, that's 5.5 years on average for the whole population. But if you check that same population one year later, you will have 50 people who all live 9 years on average. You've managed to increase the average by eliminating the bottom. Same thing is happening here. And it's probably similar to professional sports careers. The average NFL career is about 3 years. However, if you make to 3 years, your average career length is about 7 years. We probably need more of a median or mode than a mean.
- ddulaney 4y agoThis is not true. Either that it’s 50% at 80 or that it is flat after 80. Here’s an actuarial table: https://www.ssa.gov/oact/STATS/table4c6.html https://www.ssa.gov/oact/STATS/table4c6.html Annual chance of dying is 5% at 80 and continues rising every year (9% by 85, 16% by 90, 25% by 95, 35% by 100).
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoI see that! The chart I recall is clearly very out of date. Thanks!
- Someone 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gompertz–Makeham_law_of_mortality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gompertz–Makeham_law_of_mortal...: “The Gompertz–Makeham law states that the human death rate is the sum of an age-dependent component (the Gompertz function, named after Benjamin Gompertz), which increases exponentially with age and an age-independent component (the Makeham term, named after William Makeham). In a protected environment where external causes of death are rare (laboratory conditions, low mortality countries, etc.), the age-independent mortality component is often negligible. In this case the formula simplifies to a Gompertz law of mortality. In 1825, Benjamin Gompertz proposed an exponential increase in death rates with age. The Gompertz–Makeham law of mortality describes the age dynamics of human mortality rather accurately in the age window from about 30 to 80 years of age. You probably remembered the first part of the sentence following that: “At more advanced ages, some studies have found that death rates increase more slowly – a phenomenon known as the late-life mortality deceleration – but more recent studies disagree.” Even if that were true (something wikipedia contests. See also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Late-life_mortality_deceleration https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Late-life_mortality_decelerati...), that doesn’t mean rate of death decreases, just that it increases slower than this model predicts.
- sethammons 4y agoto the downvoters: https://www.science.org/content/article/once-you-hit-age-aging-appears-stop https://www.science.org/content/article/once-you-hit-age-agi... At a certain point, humans appear to stop aging. Just it is at 105, not 80 :)
- lkrubner 4y agoThe Permian/Triassic mass extinction seems to have been the turning point. The creatures that have not changed much since that earlier time are the creatures that don't age. But when life revived at the end of the Triassic, the world was more competitive, eco-systems were more integrated, and specialization became more common. Aging allows specialization, we can see that most obviously with birds, which need to maintain a specific weight and body mass and ratio of wing span to body mass. A bird that simply grew and grew and grew, like a tortoise, would have a changing ratio of wingspan to body mass and therefore it would soon lose its ability to fly. The creatures that age are those that have a fixed adult body shape. By contrast, the tortoises and reptiles and fish that live forever also seem to grow and grow and grow -- their body mass to external ratio changes over time, therefore they are less specialized.
- jessermeyer 4y agoNone of this was mentioned in the article. Where to read more about this point of view?
- dalbasal 4y agoThis kind of happens to slow aging reptiles too. Massive snakes like anacondas, reticulated pythons and such are partly arboreal when small. When bigger, they can't really climb or hide in trees. Same thing for giant monitors. Komodo dragons are arboreal when small, and live a different lifestyle once large. They're kind of like different species, inhabiting different ecological niches.
- nofollow 4y agoI wonder how some snakes' ability to atrophy and regenerate internal organs (including the heart) is related to aging: https://www.tacc.utexas.edu/-/how-pythons-regenerate-their-organs-and-other-secrets-of-the-snake-genome https://www.tacc.utexas.edu/-/how-pythons-regenerate-their-o...
- Retric 4y agoThat’s much closer to recovery from hibernation than an anti aging effect.
- andsoitis 4y agoThe article talks about the protective phenotypes hypothesis, which basically says that animals with physical or chemical traits that confer protection (e.g. armor, spines, shells, or venom) have slower aging and live longer (compared to other animals their size). The thinking is that these protective mechanisms can reduce mortality rate (you're not getting eaten by others), so you're likely to live longer, which exerts pressure to age more slowly. Biggest support for the protective phenotype hypothesis is in turtles.
- pkulak 4y agoAnd these protections probably take more resources to produce, making it less advantageous to create offspring and die off.
- ehsankia 4y agoIsn't the worry that a specie that doesn't die off will have the older generation consuming all the resources, reducing the chance at survival by the newer generation? Also, how do these species with extremely long lifespan adapt to changing environment?
- MrPatan 4y agoThe turtles don't seem to be worried about it.
- f6v 4y agoIt’s very interesting to know how they get protected against tumors at such an old age.
- platz 4y agoPlanaria essentially have immortal bodies, excepting being destroyed by environmental forces.
- dghughes 4y agoMicroscopic Hydra are even more impressive you can blend them to a pulp and they'll just grow into more copies of Hydra animals.
- cutler 4y agoEssence Of Wild Turtle soon to appear in a pharmacy near you.
- vrc 4y agoAlready part of Traditional Chinese Medicine (ex https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guilinggao https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guilinggao)
- rideontime 4y agoRumor has it Peter Thiel is already pumping turtle blood into his veins.
- randomopining 4y agoAging is def a feature of evolution.
- jamal-kumar 4y agoIn multiple locales (Japan and the Caribbean) people have tried to sell me on eating turtle meat because it 'makes you strong'. Like there's this virility transfer that happens or something between you and the meat you consume. I only tried it once in Japan and it tasted like a pond, will never do that again. I definitely appreciate how they're pretty cool animals in general. I hope people get it out of their heads that eating them is like natural viagra or whatever. Oh wait, I did try a turtle egg at a bar one time in a shot of chili guaro... Don't bite them open, there's sand inside.
- downut 4y agoPeople have been eating soft shell and snapping turtles in the SE US since... always? I grew up in the Everglades in South Florida and caught and ate many soft shell turtles. Fried up, tastes like... chicken? It's pretty good. The bullfrogs we gigged then were quite good too, the farmed ones I've tried in recent decades, not so much. At no point was there any reference to particular inherent qualities of turtle meat, that I recall.
- jamal-kumar 4y agoI dunno I kind of class them in animals which are too close to humans somehow to be desirable to eat. Like they have personalities and long lives that just get interrupted by people deciding they'd make a great meal. A lot of species of turtles are threatened by invasive species like bullfrogs and habitat degradation as well. I'm not a picky eater by any means but there's definitely some meats out there I see on the menu and don't order, octopus for example - They're too smart to be munching on.
- downut 4y agoI've encountered many soft shell turtles (if you fish with bait in South Florida you will catch turtles) and I would not classify them as close to humans. I think if this sort of determination were to get any social traction then pigs would be the first granted clemency. I don't see that happening, ever. (I have no opinion at all about your preferences, obvs.)
- sohrob 4y agoI like turtles!
- downut 4y agoBack in 1994 we purchased a box turtle at a Santa Clara pet shop. We still have it. It must have been fully grown then because I am pretty sure it hasn't changed in size at all. I don't think we have noticed any behavioral changes, either. Appetite seems the same. Still gets pissed off and bangs its shell against the terrarium glass when it's hungry. So that would be something like 27 years without noticeable change. Anyway we're close to retiring and I suppose it will transition to my daughter eventually. Maybe it will outlive her too.
- 202206241203 4y agoSounds like the beginning of a clan dedicated to serving a totem beast.
- downut 4y agoI have resisted naming our turtle 'Om'.
- justinpowers 4y agoResistance won’t be needed if you name it 'Ohm'.
- noir_lord 4y agoPratchett?
- sn41 4y agoSmall Gods
- nonameiguess 4y agoI found a box turtle once, in the middle of the street in Long Beach, CA, and despite all of the Internet advice not to mess with box turtles, I didn't want it to get run over, so I brought it inside, went to the vet, and ended up keeping her for a few years until the Army was supposed to send me to Hawaii, where you're not allowed to bring reptiles. So I gave her to a family at Fort Lawton that built a huge enclosure in their back yard, and they took her to another vet to try and get an age estimate, and they guessed she was at least 70 years old. She definitely did not behave in any obviously elder manner. Same as any other box turtle I've ever met.
- olah_1 4y agoI've gotten interested lately in the world of Ray Peat. His big thing is energizing the metabolism, healthy thyroid, etc. The idea is to maintain the state that a child is in to prolong life and be healthy. Maximize energy rather than limit it. Below is an example of a random insight: > His article Cholesterol in Context states that aging “seems to be a state of cholesterol starvation.” In other words, the ability to make cholesterol diminishes as we age. https://www.womensinternational.com/blog/aging-is-cholesterol-starvation/ https://www.womensinternational.com/blog/aging-is-cholestero... It's tough to synthesize his thought though. Whoever does and sells a popular level book of it will make a lot of money.
- RappingBoomer 4y agoand we really have no idea how to transfer that to humans...and we won't for a long long long time
- andrewingram 4y agoRelated: Andrew Steele, a friend of mine whom I know from school, wrote a book about ageing, titled "Ageless", that was published late last year, It's a good read - highly recommended: https://andrewsteele.co.uk/ageless/ https://andrewsteele.co.uk/ageless/ Worth following on Twitter if you're into the topic: https://twitter.com/statto https://twitter.com/statto
- layer8 4y agoFrom the top Amazon review: Essentially, a brief summary of the book is that research is ongoing, there is some hope, but do not expect any treatment in the very near future, meanwhile eat healthy and exercise. Overall, it is a very good book for understanding the process of aging. Delves into scientific evidence and provides good description of the most recent developments. However, do not expect it to give you any valuable practical advice apart from you already probably know: you need eat healthy, do not smoke, exercise etc.
- omot 4y ago"Death is very likely the single best invention of life. It is Life’s change agent. It clears out the old to make way for the new. Right now the new is you, but someday not too long from now, you will gradually become the old and be cleared away. Sorry to be so dramatic, but it is quite true. Your time is limited, so don’t waste it living someone else’s life. Don’t be trapped by dogma — which is living with the results of other people’s thinking. Don’t let the noise of others’ opinions drown out your own inner voice. And most important, have the courage to follow your heart and intuition. They somehow already know what you truly want to become. Everything else is secondary"
- go_elmo 4y agoThis is one of the most important and mostly actively ignored facts that I know of. It is a uncomfortable truth regarding it as an individual but it is the only good solution for humanity as a whole. People (mostly) don't change - they (have to) die for change to happen. I'm considering myself to be modern - today. In 70 years I'm quite sure I will no longer be by a large margin and I highly doubt that I'll be able to adapt my thinking incorporating them - just as I observe my parents and their peers not to be fully able to do so. As humanity with this we have a pool of new approaches (young) and tons of experience (older) which maximizes the likelyhood of finding the right approach to new challenges & making us survive as a species
- chrisfosterelli 4y agoThe causality here seems unobvious. Is aging a necessity because we inherently lack the ability to change? Or do we become inflexible because we age? Measures of willingness to change your mind and ability to learn new concepts is correlated with age. It seems just as reasonable to argue that if we could solve aging, we'd solve stagnation.
- fleddr 4y agoI think it's just a roll of the dice with age as a side effect. Evolution's primary mechanism is to promote traits that increase the likelihood that you'll survive until you can reproduce. Perhaps multiple times. And for some species an additional period to raise the new generation. So if evolution selects for a hard protective shell, this increases the odds that you reach reproductive age, which is the goal. This may accidentally also add an additional 100 years of lifespan. Which does nothing for reproduction, but it just happens anyway.
- binbag 4y agoIf this is true, why is the oldest one only trivially older than the oldest human?
- wila 4y agoOldest known turtle you mean? [1] I wouldn't call 190 years old "trivially older". [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jonathan_%28tortoise%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jonathan_%28tortoise%29
- akolbe 4y agoThat article actually mentions that he's blind from cataracts and has lost his sense of smell. Clearly, some aging has taken place ... he would be unable to survive in the wild now.
- asdff 4y agoAging is an advantage for species that have it. Reproductive fidelity is at its highest just after puberty in our species and probably most others. Turtle reproductive fidelity also declines with age (1). Having organisms become frail and die off in the years after puberty helps to maintain higher levels of reproductive fidelity among the population. 1. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4988574/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4988574/
- MomoXenosaga 4y agoLucky bastards.