9 ms·
Documenting Aramaic before its native speakers vanish (2013)
- orionblastar 4y agoMake a Rosetta Stone type project for it. There was this Yiddish/Hebrew program for the Mac, but the programmer died and nobody has the source code and it stopped working. Make it free or open source so it can continue with the Aramaic language.
- forgotpwd16 4y ago>it stopped working Can always run it on a VM unless it requires connection to some server to function.
- Delk 4y agoA lot of the value of various languages is in the cultural nuances that are both expressed by the language and a part of it. Sometimes the nuances are in the spoken form, and properly understanding all the nuances would require living among the culture. A translator program might be an interesting project in some other ways, and I guess technology might help some people get involved with the language or help bridge the gap. A translator doesn't really solve the problem, though.
- dang 4y agoRelated: How to Save a Dying Language (2013) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20557429 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20557429 - July 2019 (16 comments) How to Save a Dying Language - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9366347 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9366347 - April 2015 (3 comments)
- dylan604 4y agoOnce the native speakers vanish, they can then go back and retranslate the new testament to read whatever they want it to, and only greybeard scholars could argue against it. Not that they haven't made X numbers of versions already
- themikejr 4y agoThe new testament is written in Koine Greek, not Aramaic. There are a few Aramaic phrases in the Greek texts we have and they are often accompanied by a translation or explanation in Greek.
- dylan604 4y agoIt's all Greek to me
- formerkrogemp 4y agoFunny enough, in Greece they say it's all Chinese to me. And in China they say..
- eesmith 4y agoHeavenly Script. There's an old graphviz chart about the connections, at https://languagelog.ldc.upenn.edu/nll/?p=1024 https://languagelog.ldc.upenn.edu/nll/?p=1024 . Someone should update it with the more complete list now at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greek_to_me https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greek_to_me .
- bee_rider 4y agoNeat list. I wonder how old the German expression "Polnisch rückwärts" ( Polish [spoken] in reverse) is. I wonder if it has anything to do with Reverse Polish Notation.
- eesmith 4y agoGoogle Books found an example in the 1965 book "Sprache und Humor des Kindes". However, it does not appear to have anything to do with "Polnisch rückwärts". While the term "Polish Notation" predates 1965, including in German as "polnische Notation", it appears to be in a specialized context not related to children's humor. The only other Google Books reference for "Polnisch rückwärts" is a 1982 reference with nothing to do with computers. Looking in archive.org, here's a 1984 German computer magazine which describes FORTH as „polnisch rückwärts“. https://archive.org/details/cpm-anwenderhandbuch-thom-hoganacme/page/166/mode/2up?q=%22Polnisch+r%C3%BCckw%C3%A4rts%22 https://archive.org/details/cpm-anwenderhandbuch-thom-hogana... On the other hand, a 1986 article uses a different structure, at https://archive.org/details/hc-mein-home-computer_1986-10/page/n27/mode/2up?q=%22Polnisch+r%C3%BCckw%C3%A4rts%22 https://archive.org/details/hc-mein-home-computer_1986-10/pa... : > Der Programmiersprache Forth eilt das Schlagwort „umgekehrt polnische Notation“ voraus, was ein wenig wie „polnisch rückwärts“ klingt und auf den ersten Blick meist als Rückschritt gewertet wird. Those are the only two uses of that phrase in archive.org. By comparison, "polnische Notation" is far more common.
- pcwalton 4y agoA huge amount of field linguistics is documentation of languages that are in danger of losing all their native speakers. Many Native American languages are in this category, for instance—it's common for these languages to have only a handful of native speakers left, all of whom are elderly. It's literally a race against the clock.
- auiya 4y agoAt that point does the language become archived?
- formerkrogemp 4y agoYes. What little of it remains however. Much of the worlds languages are disappearing permanently. There is a small movement for foreign individuals to learn dying tongues and for some descendants to learn, but I would not expect this to counteract the prevailing homogenization of language globally. Regional differences in dialect can become new languages over time, but I don't expect this to countermand the number of languages lost in recent times to colonization and the cultural dominance of certain countries and languages.
- FredPret 4y agoI’m part of the problem here. My kids will never learn my first language. English has become the language of technology, and will probably become even more dominant as a result.
- chimineycricket 4y agoHow old are your kids? The solution (if they're still babies) is to simply speak to your kids in your first language all the time. The brain does the rest. You don't have to "teach" them anything.
- thaumasiotes 4y ago
- oofnik 4y agoI was once hosted by a Syrian Jewish family for Passover. Their rendition of the classic had gadya (lit. "one goat") in the traditional melody brought over with them from Aleppo was hauntingly beautiful.
- erie 4y agoAleppo was an amazing city with rich linguistic diversity and rich musical tradition of several minorities. With Aramaic mixed with Armenian! All the inhabitants used to sing along in one neighborhood, each in his own house when one musician starts a tune, other neighborhoods would compete with their own musicians it was a magic experience that I was not lucky enough to witness. The Arabic dialect in Aleppo is very distinctive though, we used to make fun of it in TV series and in daily conversation.
- SnowHill9902 4y agoThis article reads very strangely. Aramaic at least the Jewish Babylonian dialect is extremely alive. Children learn it in school, and thousands and thousands of adults study texts every day written in Aramaic.
- margalabargala 4y agoThe same is true of Latin, but that's still considered a "dead" language. It's not the same to learn to read something for scholarly reasons, vs using it as one's native tongue.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mike10921 4y agoIt's being studied but none of these kids/adults use it as a day-to-day language.
- HideousKojima 4y agoAnd the Syriac Orthodox Church still uses Syriac, which is a dialect of Aramaic.
- compsciphd 4y agosort of. People learn to read it, but they don't really speak or write it. the ability to read a language doesn't make it an alive language. This contrasts to Hebrew, which some say was a dead language, but was the living language of jewish law correspondence and jewish law / biblical exegesis, even when other languages were the day to day vernacular (ladino, yiddish or the like). People like to say that hebrew was a dead language before the modern hebrew movement, but that's not quite fair. It wasn't a day to day language of the streets, but new things in it were being written every day all over the diaspora. Basically, those who say it was a dead language are demonstrating their bias against religiously oriented texts and communications.
- dpq 4y agoI find it somewhat disappointing how cautiously the author avoids the subject on how Assyrians got "...scattered over the past century from homelands where their language once flourished". It wasn't just an unfortunate occasion when "a Kurdish chieftain murdered a Church of the East patriarch there in 1918". It was a genocide. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sayfo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sayfo
- Mikeb85 4y agoShhh it's politically incorrect to question exactly how all the Christians in the Middle East disappeared... Copts, Chaldeans, Assyrians, etc... were all displaced and/or slaughtered by invading Islamic armies.
- liorben-david 4y agoI think you're reading too much into the omission of historical narrative in this particular article about linguistics. The author, Ariel Sabar, wrote an entire book about his father's forced exile from his native Kurdistan by the Iraqi government.
- bergenty 4y agoNo it’s not, this is pretty well known and discussed. Don’t try and make a straw man because you want to paint “liberals” and Muslims in a bad light. You could have just replied with your second sentence… but you have an agenda.
- Mikeb85 4y ago> No it’s not, this is pretty well known and discussed It definitely isn't. Tons of people think Arabs are actually native to Egypt, Syria, Iraq, Palestine, etc... or that Turks are native to Turkey/Anatolia. Most Americans and Western Europeans have no clue about the history of Christianity in the Middle East and Turkey, Arab conquests, etc... Or the fact that Christians were still a majority in a Middle Eastern country within the last 100 years.
- lordleft 4y agoMy family is what is called St. Thomas Christian, part of a (fairly) endogamous and ancient community in South India. Though there is a lot of denomination diversity in the community these days, the most ancient denomination is Syrian Orthodox, which conducts its liturgy in Syriac, a dialect of Aramaic. This language is part of my linguistic heritage, even though I only know a word here or there.
- anonu 4y agoI've known about this. Fascinating history. So St Thomas somehow made it from the middle east to South India. The way I came to look into this history is interesting. As an Arabic speaker I was curious about the last name "Martoma" which was in the news some years back (for insider trading). It sounds like Mar Touma which is Arabic for St Thomas. I wonder how many people identify as St Thomas Christians in India?
- vrc 4y agoSeems like 6mm worldwide. They’re concentrated in the southern state of Kerala, and it seems you’re on to something about the Marthoma [0] [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saint_Thomas_Christians https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saint_Thomas_Christians
- KMag 4y agoI've had colleagues of Indian descent with family names of Thomas, David, and John, presumably all due to St. Thomas Christian roots.
- Bayart 4y agoThe syro-malabar Catholics also use Syriac for their rite.
- noodlesUK 4y agoThere are a lot of languages at risk of totally going extinct. UNESCO keeps a list of them, but the link has ironically also gone dead. https://www.unesco.org/sites/default/files/medias/fichiers/2022/06/redirect_new_world_atlas_of_languages_en.pdf https://www.unesco.org/sites/default/files/medias/fichiers/2...
- samstave 4y agoDUOLINGO (or some equiv) - should be actively going after all languages that will go dark at some point and building courses around them.
- Beltalowda 4y agoI'm not sure how effective this will be, you really need communities of speakers using it in daily conversation to keep languages alive, not some individuals learning it off some app. Speaking a language well is hard and full with nuance, much of which you can't really learn by "the elephant does not eat bread"-type stuff DuoLingo gives you. None of my Irish friends really speak Irish for example, in spite of being taught at school from an early age. Not that Irish is "dead" by any means – there are still parts of Ireland where Irish is used in daily conversation – but it's a good example how you need more than just education to keep a language alive.
- samstave 4y ago"Ya lets hit the elephant for a stomp on some bread" (meaning go for a pint at the heavy pub or whatever weird cokney weirdness your language is - yet *thats* not dying is it, too many of you folk around" or the other weird colloquial things? Not working, "How do you say ; 'This is my home'?" in Aramaic?" <-- much easier to capture and translate. And from remaining speakers. Or... "Tell mw about your gods" (and then capturing/translating their responses)
- senorsmile 4y agoThe 7000 languages project is doing just that: https://www.7000.org/ https://www.7000.org/
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoEven young America has this issue: Appalachian, the dialects in Newfoundland, island pidgins, Cajun are all diminishing.
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoIs Appalachian a language, or a dialect? (I guess I'm assuming, first, that there is a reasonably sharp distinction, and second, that Aramaic falls into the "language" category.)
- the_biot 4y agoMy personal opinion, not a linguist: All languages start as dialects, and the point at which they become a separate language is arbitrary, more a matter of opinion than a hard rule. Languages are created by people speaking another language badly.
- koolba 4y ago> All languages start as dialects, and the point at which they become a separate language is arbitrary, more a matter of opinion than a hard rule. Having an army is a sufficient but not necessary condition.
- inglor_cz 4y agoDespite having the largest army in the world, Americans still speak English.
- fsckboy 4y agothe definition linguists use is, "the only difference between a dialect and a language is, a language has a navy"
- kubanczyk 4y agoIt's more of a quip: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_language_is_a_dialect_with_an_army_and_navy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_language_is_a_dialect_with_a... One can use "variety" to side-step the whole problem: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dialect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dialect
- liorben-david 4y agoNot sure why he omits this, but the author's name is Ariel Sabar and his father is Yona Sabar who is the one of the most influential scholars in the preservation of Aramaic. I would highly recommend Ariel's book, My Father's Paradise. It documents the life of his father being born into the poor and uneducated, but happy, Jewish community of Kurdish Iraq, being stripped of his property and exiled by the Iraqi government as part of the Jewish exodus in the 50s, and going from a refugee to a PHD in Linguistics from Yale.
- anonu 4y agoOne of my favorite encounters with Aramaic was coming across a tiny ancient church in the middle of the desert in Syria, where the mass was conducted in Aramaic. A humbling experience to hear a basically dead language still very much alive in the middle of nowhere. Another observation: portions of Maronite Catholic mass are conducted in Aramaic. The prayer books are typically in Aramaic and Arabic side by side.
- bass3l 4y agoI think you are talking about Maaloula? a small town to the north of Damascus where its Christian population still speak Aramic, mostly old people. It is a fascinating place to visit. Unfortunately, most of its inhabitants left after the 2012 civil war, or to a small percentage died protecting it against other islamist factions. Source: I'm from there. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maaloula https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maaloula
- muzani 4y agoAramaic has always had a certain charm for me. It sounds a little like Arabic, something like difference between Dutch and German (to someone who's not fluent in all these languages). I wish I knew a place to learn it.
- MichaelMoser123 4y agoOrthodox Jews learn Aramaic in order to study the Talmud, they learn it at a young age, does that count as native speakers? The Irony: the Neo-Assyrian Empire was the greatest empire ever, for its time. They destroyed the kingdom of Judah and the first temple in Jerusalem, drove the Jews into Babylonian captivity. Now who are among the last speakers of the Aramaic language?
- jmopp 4y agoIt would not really count as native speakers, because Talmud scholars didn't learn the language from birth, and would only use it for certain purposes rather than general communication. It's similar to Latin in the Middle Ages: Every European scholar could speak Latin, and in a medieval university you might be speaking Latin constantly, but the language was dead as no-one used it from birth or spoke to their families in Latin. Similarly, Hebrew was considered dead until it was revived and spoken by babies as their first language - even though people had a working knowledge of Hebrew for the entire period it was no longer spoken.
- erie 4y agoSyrian dialect still has few Aramaic words. The name of the city of Aleppo is a purely Syriac/an Aramic name and means the white city. The word Aleppo means white in Syriac. Since Aleppo is distinguished by its white limestone, it was called the White City. Aleppo was an amazing city with rich linguistic diversity and rich musical tradition of several minorities. With Aramaic mixed with Armenian! All the inhabitants used to sing along in one neighborhood, each in his own house when one musician starts a tune, other neighborhoods would compete with their own musicians it was a magic experience that I was not lucky enough to witness. The Arabic dialect in Aleppo is very distinctive though, we used to make fun of it in TV series and in daily conversation. Some other Aramaic words Martini: Mar means the master, and Tini is the fig, meaning the master of figs, , the shiah: the one who works by melting, and Touma: the twin. Al-Bajuq: They are based on the effects of Al-Bajuq and use it to mean bad mouth.
- acjohnson55 4y agoWhat's sad to me is that so many languages were just fine 100 years ago. World Wars, state action (in both totalitarian and democratic states), mass media, and globalization are eradicating most of the world's linguistic diversity. As a kid, I assumed languages, ethnicities, and states were almost synonymous. States would certainly want you think that! In the present, I can see how much damage the concept of the ethnostate has done to minority languages in any given territory. At this point, we've already suffered irreversible loss, and a lot more is already baked in.