5 ms·
The learned oblivion in this discussion is very disheartening: every person saying to “leave politics at home” should understand that our basic boundaries aroun
by woodruffw 4y ago
The learned oblivion in this discussion is very disheartening: every person saying to “leave politics at home” should understand that our basic boundaries around personal and working time came from long and protracted political battles over the powers of our employers. Those battles were fought because people complained, loudly at their workplaces, and won their colleagues over.
Abortion is not the labor movement, but the principle holds.
- thr0wawayf00 4y agoI agree. At the same time, I think we're sadly coming to terms with the reality that our voices don't matter in the political arena anymore. If anything, I think social media has created the illusion that being loud and angry online is an effective replacement for actual strikes, protests, etc. We can tweet angrily all day long, but those in power are going to continue doing what they do because they know we're just going to tweet about it and that just doesn't matter.
- woodruffw 4y agoI absolutely agree, and I think this nicely summarizes why political discussion at work is more important than ever: it amounts to real discussions between human beings with emotional and professional ties, not flame wars between angry Tweeters. I don’t agree with my coworkers on everything. But when they talk about politics I listen, and try my best to engage in a cogent discussion. Maintaining a culture of political discussion at work is critical to both healthy corporate cultures and healthy civic processes, which might provide a hint as to why Meta is opposed to it (outrage is their business model.)
- icelancer 4y agoMeta isn't banning discussion of politics in groups of employees. It's banning discussion in open channels. If you want to listen to employees talk pro-life / pro-choice, join the groups for that and do so. Keeping Roe v. Wade discussion out of the equivalent of Slack #general or All-Hands email list seems more than reasonable.
- woodruffw 4y agoThe article itself concerns online discussion spaces, but what constitutes an “open channel”? Should employees expect to be reprimanded or potentially punished for talking about abortion rights in a company hallway, because an uninvolved coworker might happen to walk by? The baseline position here (“don’t create political distractions in large channels”) is reasonable on face value. But I have difficultly believing that it’s not pretextual, and that the real goal isn’t to generally chill political discussion between colleagues.
- 1123581321 4y agoAt most companies, open physical meetings would not include private conversations inadvertently overheard. I can see how companies employee some people who don’t understand things like that, panic and overreact. I think most companies would have trouble admitting they employ such people in higher level planning meetings.
- UkrainianJew 4y ago>We can tweet angrily all day long, but those in power are going to continue doing what they do because they know we're just going to tweet about it and that just doesn't matter. Oh, those in power are actively manipulating you to be upset about things that do not interfere with their profits. Somehow, nobody is protesting against unviability of single-income households, lack of retirement savings, part-time employment/independent contractor bullshit used to skirt regulations, etc. It's always Worker Alice against Worker Bob and never Workers against the Corporation.
- collegeburner 4y agoYou're right, I should be using my work environment to agitate for repealing all the ridiculous and unjust gun laws we have and the shitty bill congress just passed. It's more important that we win colleagues over to protecting our rights. Not that I will do this, but when I see people talk about things like this, they usually do not feel the same if I suggest what I might do. I think the abortion laws in my state need a little loosening (though not a lot) but there are other people who want them even tighter. Are you just as okay with them agitating at work? Or will you want them to be censored by HR or fired or passed over for promotion/bonus?
- woodruffw 4y agoYou shouldn’t “agitate” for anything political at work, unless you mean that in a humorous way (I sometimes do!) Instead, you should put your best self forward and treat your political positions as a humanizing element. It’s been my experience that extremely healthy workplace discussions can occur when people start from a place of human respect, not agreement (indeed, it seems like agreeing parties eventually find something to disagree over, no matter how trivial.)
- collegeburner 4y agoI meant more in the political sense but yes, maybe not the best word choice. I agree with your position a lot more. I have had political discussions with my coworkers, just like I have had discussions on sports even though work is not a place for sports. And sometimes I have changed my mind based on what they said. The concerning part is more that some workplaces have people or cultures that push politics very hard. Where you either agree with prevailing sentiment or are penalized in your career. In O&G you can not easily be a Democrat (or you had better be a Manchin Democrat). In tech you can not easily be a Republican (or you had better be a Romney Republican). I have seen people's careers fucked up by somebody who hated their politics. In other words it sounds like you are approaching this in good faith. But not everybody does. Or sometimes people do but they get mad and stop thinking so much. And that is hard to manage, and can make workplaces bad and hostile. And of course there is always the problem that it is harder to maintain civility at scale like Facebook.
- heavyset_go 4y agoReproductive rights are workers' rights, only workers will need to worry about the consequences of abortion bans. Others can afford the freedom to do what they want with their bodies.
- encryptluks2 4y agoLeave politics at home is the same as saying capitalism above all else.
- _8j50 4y agoIt's not the place. Don't shit where you eat. When you have these discussions at work people are forced to listen to your view, not only are they not getting paid for that, their response will have consequences. Are you looking for coworkers to reaffirm your belief or an actual discussion? Because if it is the latter the Janet from accounting might feel strongly about capital punishment for women who abort, now should Janet get fired for her political views then (which are protected)? Would this affect your ability to work with Janet reducing her value to the business? Is it fair to forcibly shove your views on others with the threat of harming their career and livelihood otherwise? The workplace is not a social club. You can still socialize with willing coworkers after work where everyone is free to leave with no repurcursions.
- woodruffw 4y agoWhere’s the force? Nobody is required to have lunch with me; nobody is required to respond to random off-topic messages on chat applications. We’re taking about the thing that each of us spends 1/3 of our weekdays doing. The majority of our waking hours. It’s one of the largest aspects of all our lives, and is fundamentally derived from the outcomes of very recent political battles over the roles of individual laborers. I believe that we owe it to ourselves and, as a basic matter of respect, to our coworkers, to have important discussions. If you don’t want that for yourself, then you can stick to sports and weather. That’s fine too!
- aahortwwy 4y ago> If you don’t want that for yourself, then you can stick to sports and weather. That’s fine too! If I had a private office and didn't have to block out background conversation with noise-cancelling headphones and loud music that would be fine, yeah. Happy I can mainly work from home nowadays.
- woodruffw 4y ago> If I had a private office and didn't have to block out background conversation with noise-cancelling headphones and loud music that would be fine, yeah. These sound like the kinds of employee privileges you’d like to negotiate for at work, ideally with multiple other coworkers backing you. The kind of thing that would ideally come from multiple discussions, some of which would ultimately boil down to your and your employer’s obligations. Let’s hope that won’t be too political for your taste, should you decide to stop working from home!
- tyrfing 4y agoHarassment or discrimination over religious beliefs, which can include opinions on abortion, is illegal under federal law. Where is the line between arguing and a hostile work environment?
- woodruffw 4y agoIn my book? It becomes a hostile work environment once an aggrieved party seeks retribution or revenge for perceived harms. It’s obviously not that simple, though: there are lots of opinions that are a priori incompatible with a functioning workplace, such as beliefs that fundamentally dehumanize one’s colleagues. In those instances, I’d argue that the hostile work environment begins the moment those beliefs are aired. (And, to the best of my knowledge, no court has ever concluded that the particular derived beliefs of an individual are protected as an extension of their religious rights. Religious rights include things like being given reasonable accommodations for worship and lifestyle requirements; it doesn’t require your coworkers to placidly accept whatever positions you’ve extended from the larger religious doctrine.)
- vegai_ 4y agoPerhaps the point is that 2/3 of the people are mostly disconnected from the places where most intensive discussion about these topics is going on. But at the workplace, also these people are forced to be connected. It's probably these people (mostly moderates I would assume) who are the base force steering this.
- thrown_22 4y agoYou sound like you have no friends and are replacing that lack with co-workers.
- woodruffw 4y agoIt’s a testament to the relative lack of problems in my life that my single biggest current problem is scheduling time with my friends. I think having serious conversations with my coworkers is a very good thing for all parties involved, especially when I don’t want them to eventually become friends. Opinions and beliefs are plainer that way.
- thrown_22 4y agoI can't see a reason why anyone would avoid scheduling time with you.