5 ms·
On the other hand, I've consistently found you can often get what you want just by asking for it. A lot of people seem unwilling to do this.
by WalterBright 4y ago
On the other hand, I've consistently found you can often get what you want just by asking for it. A lot of people seem unwilling to do this.
- megablast 4y agoThanks for all the examples.
- zarmin 4y agoOn the other other hand, ask for forgiveness not permission.
- WalterBright 4y agoMore than one person has come to me with a story that they'd developed a side project without notifying their employer, and now that it was done and they were distributing it were worried their employer was going to claim ownership. I didn't have anything helpful to say. I've done side projects when I was working for Big Corps, but in every case notified management beforehand and got a written ok. Never had any trouble with it. When I've accepted job offers, I'd also provide a list of projects that were mine and had them sign off on it as a condition of employment. Never encountered any resistance to that, either. But these poor people were sweating bullets imagining all the bad consequences of their employer finding out. Just ask, in advance. If you're a valuable employee, they'll say ok. Never heard of one saying no. And they'll appreciate that you asked instead of sneaking around. But be careful not to use company equipment.
- zarmin 4y agoHow about, thoroughly read your employment agreement (and everything you sign). > Just ask, in advance. If you're a valuable employee That is a massive, massive if.
- krick 4y agoYeah, well, no. Realistically no one ever will fight or most likely even decline a good job offer over a typical employment contract, and no employer will ever change a typical employment contract specially for you, unless you are somehow preemptively assumed to be a very valuable employee, in which case you are most likely being hired for some very high-level (like, executive) position, so your contract isn't "typical" to start with. And this is far less likely than actually becoming a valuable employee just by doing your quite ordinary job for a few years. You might as well recommend fighting over your gym membership contract, of a bank contract, or a telecom operator contract. Right, it's your free choice, uh-huh. Either you accept it as is, or you go fuck yourself and workout at home, without internet, looking for a job where you'll be paid in cash (which also is far from being common). Again, unless you are preemptively perceived to be a very special customer (i.e. "expected to bring in a lot of money"), in which case your contract probably isn't typical to start with. And it is most likely your lawyer who negotiates over it for you anyway.
- flir 4y agoI must have had half a dozen contracts tweaked over the course of my career. Small things, of course, like making IP rights more explicit and changing notice periods. I can assure you I'm not that valuable. Weird.
- WalterBright 4y agoSaying a contract is "non-negotiable" is just another negotiating tactic. They're all negotiable.
- WalterBright 4y agoHow do you explain that I've negotiated lots of these "take it or leave it" contracts? The only contracts you can't negotiate are government job contracts and union jobs. Which is one reason I'm not interested in either of those job categories. > bank contract Haha, I once negotiated a large loan from my bank at an interest a full percent below their official floor. I'm not even very good at negotiating, some people I know are much better. > telecom contract Have you ever said the magic words: "that sounds high, can I get this for a lower price?" The salesmen are allowed to negotiate. The initial price they quote you is the sucker price. Every time I've been to the dealer for car work, all I have to do is balk at the quote and 10% comes right off. This is not a special skill. Anybody can do it. Fer gosh's sake, you're expected to negotiate.
- toast0 4y ago> Just ask, in advance. If you're a valuable employee, they'll say ok. Never heard of one saying no. And they'll appreciate that you asked instead of sneaking around Yahoo told me I couldn't participate in the Netflix recommendation challenge (not that I would have done well), and then 6 months later praised another Yahoo employee who did well in it. #notstillbitter
- WalterBright 4y agoYah, you have good cause to be bitter about that.
- hollerith 4y agoThe decisionmaker who praised is probably different from the one who told you no.
- egorfine 4y agoHave you got that "no" in written?
- toast0 4y agoIt was in writting, yes. I don't think I still have access to it: I don't keep archives of employer email, but I did use yahoo-inc email from mail.yahoo.com, as was allowed and sometimes encouraged, from time to time, and continue to have some access to old work emails through that; this chain of mail could be in there, but I'm not going to look for the same reason I haven't purged all that. It's too much effort and I don't care enough.
- mhaberl 4y agoDoesn’t it bother you that you have to ask some manager if you can do something (a side project) in your free time? It sounds as you are their slave, and not an employee who works x hours per month for y amount of money. Imagine a baker that has to ask the boss if he/she can bake a loaf of bread at home
- topkai22 4y agoIf that baker intends to sell that bread they also may run afoul of non competes. See https://www.eater.com/2017/10/13/16459044/non-competes-chefs-how-do-they-work https://www.eater.com/2017/10/13/16459044/non-competes-chefs...
- tuxie_ 4y agoIt's their free time, they can do whatever they want with it. If there is something unlawful or disloyal well then you deal with that situation, but you can't tell someone "I will tell you what you can do in your free time just in case you may do something I don't like". Also, let's be honest, how much harm can a 1 person project do to a multi billion corp? It's a fallacy.
- jhallenworld 4y agoWell I had kind of the reverse situation: I wanted to contribute to Cygwin, owned by RedHat. RedHat would not accept my contributions unless I got a signed release from my employer, IBM at the time. Well I tried to get this signed release, but all I got was the run-around. Nobody would bother taking the risk. It's one of the reasons I left.
- WalterBright 4y agoIt's a good reason to leave, if the separate project is important to you.
- usrn 4y agoI've just been accumulating all my contributions for when I quit or come up with a good enough alias to contribute them under.
- foobarian 4y agoIt's complicated. If your contract says you can't do it, that means there is a legal path toward stopping you if someone bothers. That means someone has to care enough, which means that as long as you don't piss anyone off and don't get too much press you'll be fine. If you ask, it is in nobody's interest to say yes especially lawyers.
- WalterBright 4y agoAnd yet I never had any trouble getting a 'yes'. One of those companies was Boeing - as big and bureaucratic as they get.
- AndrewDavis 4y agoOr, ensure that it is in your contract eliminating the need to ask. For example my employment contract states (I'm paraphrasing), anything I do outside of work I own copyright on. And anything I do for work is owned by work.
- Asmod4n 4y agoI wonder if there is more than one country in the world where it’s possible for companies to own their workers like this. In Germany for example you can’t give away the copyright on something you wrote as a person. The only thing you can waive is the distribution part of your copyrighted works. What you do outside your work hours is only subject to the law, not an employee.
- tuxie_ 4y agoThis doesn't stop companies from putting it in their contacts to scare you though. I worked at a FAANG in Berlin and that clause was _the_ reason I almost don't sign.
- WastingMyTime89 4y agoUnenforceable clauses are part and parcel of the typical employment contract in France. Non-compete are the one of the most common offenders. I have seen companies try to enforce hours while paying by the day - two incompatibles provision in French labour law. Most employers know they would lose if it came to the worst but they try anyway.
- tombert 4y agoI might not have been a valuable employee, but I tried making a Plex clone in my free time when I was at Apple, asked if I could open source it, went all the way to the VP of tech to ask permission, just to be uncerimoniously told that it was not allowed, because they "really wanted me to be fully focused on Apple". I'm not sure I agree at all that they'll say "ok" just because you're a valuable employee; I think you might have gotten lucky at your BigCorps.
- ncmncm 4y agoApple will be Apple. But there are lots of other places to be.
- dylan604 4y agoI always refer to the Apple=>Woz=>HP story where Woz went to his employer 3 separate times to seek their blessing and receiving an a-okay each time that his involvement with Apple was not going to be contested by HP. DOH!
- WalterBright 4y agoOne of the reasons why Woz is a smart cookie. Think of all the problems Apple could have had if he didn't.
- dylan604 4y agoWoz is an absolute hero of mine, and if you're reading HN and he's not a hero of yours, then, boy, I don't know.
- starfallg 4y agoIt really depends on the organisation, but from my observation (I, myself, never developed any side projects worth releasing so this is based on what others did), most large organisations are not like that. Legal and HR specifically are very risk averse, so permission is usually denied by default, unless there is a overriding benefit to the company (or someone else to take the hit when things go wrong, a very cynical take I know). Ethically speaking, I would think that as a principle, employees should never agree to ask the employer for permission to do things in their own time, for their own purposes, outside of the area of the business. Employees are just that, employees, not indentured servants. There are duties owed by employee to employer (and vice-versa) but this should not be one of them.
- hodgesrm 4y agoIt's a little more nuanced than that. Developing home nuclear reactors is an example where the approach might not benefit society at large. Edit: Comment is off-topic but I've heard this phrase so many times it's triggering.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- strix_varius 4y agoI would generally say, "ask for forgiveness not permission if you'll be fine walking back your decision later." Forgiveness often makes sense at work, at least for software engineers, and for modest decisions. Do things the way you think is best instead of getting blocked for weeks looking for permission. If, later on, someone comes knocking and wanting to change it, fine, whatever. However, taking the "forgiveness" route with more important / harder to change / expensive things - like building some addition to your house, building a software business separate your software job - is a recipe for disaster.
- GeertB 4y agoIn particular, if you're developing Free Software or Open Source Software, and a company wants to hire you, it is _expected_ that they're OK with you continuing to do so. If any contract says otherwise, explain that you need to keep doing what you're doing in order to stay at the level of expertise that you're at. If a future employer would not agree for you to keep doing that, you shouldn't sign.
- WalterBright 4y agoIt's best to write down what you expect and get agreement on important matters like this.
- basicplus2 4y agoI find that if you simply change the wording of their contract to what you are happy with, initial all your changes, sign all pages, sign it, photocopy it, and send it in, nobody rejects it. Later when they try to hold you to the original contract, you simply ask them for the contract you signed.. This has worked for me everytime :)
- dottedmag 4y agoWait until contracts start to come in DocuSign, where the only thing you can do is to scribe something obscene instead of a signature.
- jacquesm 4y agoThere is no way I will every use DocuSign. Think about it: the chances in the longer term of DocuSign being hacked approach '1', and that means that everybody that ever uploaded their signature to that site runs the risk of having other documents signed with that signature without the recourse that it wasn't them uploading their sig to some online service. And then there is this: https://www.americanbar.org/groups/litigation/committees/commercial-business/practice/2019/electronic-signatures-contracts-agreements/ https://www.americanbar.org/groups/litigation/committees/com...
- tialaramex 4y agoIt definitely doesn't hurt to ask questions, even if you don't always get answers Many years ago I asked my employer why my salary was lower than the contractually agreed minimum salary for 21 year olds in their organisation. I never received a reply but I did receive a raise and pay backdated to the point where I was hired. Years before that I asked my bank why I can't just use all the ATMs since they all have money in them and they're all connected to the same network. I never received a reply but some years later the ATMs were indeed all usable (of course, subsequently many began to charge money for withdrawals, so it's still worth going to the "right" ATM if you care) More recently I asked my bank if they can avoid giving me a contactless capable credit card when they issue new cards. At first they said this was impossible, but when time came to renew my card and I mentioned being disappointed that it would now be contactless, the call taker said actually she can do that, she'll cancel the renewed card she's just had issued and send me one without contactless, but it will take a few days. That card expired, and a few months ago I received its automatic replacement, this time it does have the contactless logo like all the others, but it came with a slim "Contactless-less" sheet explaining that the bank noticed I don't want a contactless card and have told this card not to allow contactless transactions despite the logo however, it is actually a contactless card and so if I change my mind I can just call the bank and activate the contactless feature. [ You might wonder why I don't want a contactless card. Contactless credit cards can OK modestly sized payments based on proximity, which is convenient but clearly poses a risk of fraud I don't want. My phone is also capable of proximity based transactions, but it is not limited to some arbitrary size of transaction and I need to explicitly unlock it to allow the transaction. So, the phone "is" my credit card for the purposes of routine transactions, but it has better security. ]
- exabrial 4y agoI'd read up on how the protocol works... There could be a live "relay" attack available , but it's not like someone could just swipe your butt and make a bunch of cloned cards. The magstripe is more of a hazard than anything else as it the numbers on the front un-encrpyted.
- tialaramex 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]