4 ms·
It's about time for the US to get back into manufacturing. Wages in China have gone up enough that the cost advantage isn't as great as it was a decade ago. Th
by Animats 4y ago
It's about time for the US to get back into manufacturing. Wages in China have gone up enough that the cost advantage isn't as great as it was a decade ago.
The average manufacturing wage in Shenzhen is now about US $36,000/year. US average manufacturing wage is $70,446/year. That's a little under 2:1. A decade ago it was about 30:1.
- 88840-8855 4y ago
- saiya-jin 4y agoYou are supporting wrong type of Ukraine migrants - we talk about country where average monthly wage was around 300-400$ last time I checked. Given its for completely different cost situation, but there were literally millions of Ukraine economical migrants all over Europe before the war, mostly the eastern part, working for much less than the amount you mention.
- anovikov 4y agoSimply because in Ukraine, no one lives on their salary. People hustle. Look at the famous photos of bombed-out Ukrainian places where people were tortured. Pay attention to the architecture, cars, everything. These are anything but poor, dilapidated places with people willing to work for food as the official stats may picture things. And people who worked abroad are just the unfortunate ones, the underclass, just as it is in Mexico: those who illegally cross to the U.S. are those who couldn't make it at home (often because of discrimination/racism yes). One looking at the desperate Mexicans doing hard work for almost nothing in the U.S. may assume that Mexico is a very poor place - which it isn't. Now, as the war started, it's the common - much more well-to-do - Ukrainians who started leaving the country, and they already enjoyed much better living standards than people abroad imagined. Ukraine is much like the rest of Eastern Europe - uneven, fragile, but in general a wide middle class society. It's done with widespread poverty. It's just that vast majority of that wealth is undocumented, and Ukrainian financial infrastructure makes owning, investing and moving undocumented wealth easy. People there have no idea what taxes are. Most never paid anything and don't know how it's done. And sure, it results in corruption, for which Ukraine is famous.
- sudosysgen 4y agoWhat you're describing is the truth in basically every country with a similar income. The point still stands.
- anovikov 4y agoI don't (quite) agree with it. Slovakia feels like a place where people live on their salary alone. Lithuania too. But yes.
- sudosysgen 4y agoSlovakia and Lithuania have 5x the GDP per capita of Ukraine. I'm specifically talking about countries with similar economic conditions, like perhaps Moldova or Morocco, or perhaps even Bulgaria.
- throwaway14159b 4y agoA few years ago I started a manufacturing business in a low cost of living part of the UK. Most of our staff make about £2000 per month after tax, which actually works out to just over $36,000 per before tax. This is a good wage for the area. All of our sales are to other manufacturing businesses, most of which are in the UK/EU. Most of our suppliers are UK/EU manufacturing businesses too, many of which are local to us.
- flohofwoe 4y agoObviously that's where automation should and already has kicked in (not for service jobs, but for factory jobs - which are strategically more important anyway).
- pydry 4y ago>BrInGiNg MaNuFaCtUrInG BaCk from the eViL ChInEsE will not work. People want to go to college, they want to do office jobs. People will want manufacturing jobs too if they exist and pay reasonably well. The era of the dow jones breaking record highs every other year might have to end first though.
- WJW 4y agoIndustrial production in the USA is near the highest it has ever been. Production has already returned, it's just that all the jobs are very highly automated now. An economy where the majority of jobs are involved in manufacturing is unlikely to ever return.
- pydry 4y agoIf the worldwide system of cheap, reliable container shipping network breaks down it'll probably happen (very slowly), along with a firestorm of inflation (that'll be quick). Right now it's only fraying around the edges.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- baybal2 4y ago
- acover 4y agoIt looks like it flat lined for the last decade. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/PRMNTO01USQ661N https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/PRMNTO01USQ661N
- londons_explore 4y agoThat's just an argument for moving the actual production to countries where the ratio is still 30:1. Thailand, Cambodia, Vietnam, etc. Maybe even bits of Africa.
- throwk8s 4y agoThat's trading a temporary advantage for a long-term disadvantage. Eventually labor costs will even out globally, meaning moving manufacturing to countries with a 30:1 ratio isn't a long-term benefit. But "onshored" manufacturing, in the long term, would reduce dependency on potentially unreliable (or adversarial) counterparties.
- londons_explore 4y ago> Eventually labor costs will even out globally, Somehow I have a feeling this will never happen.
- nawitus 4y agoWages are not that low in Thailand anymore. Vietnam and especially Cambodia are a lot lower than China.. for now.
- Closi 4y ago> The average manufacturing wage in Shenzhen is now about US $36,000/year Source? That seems remarkably high in my experience. Also you will need to adjust the two wages for working hours which are much longer in China.
- Animats 4y agohttp://www.salaryexplorer.com/salary-survey.php?loc=3023&loctype=3 http://www.salaryexplorer.com/salary-survey.php?loc=3023&loc...
- rfoo 4y agoI live in China and I have to say this seems way off, by a factor of at least 2. However, the website does list: > Factory Worker 8,800 CNY This is around 15800 USD per year, with all benefits included. This does seem reasonable. So bad average I guess.
- Closi 4y agoThose numbers are way off, no source is given, it's higher than anywhere else I can find, and the same website seems to think that the average in the UK (where I live) is also £71k per year while the UK National Statistics Office says it is £31.7k (so under half). So those numbers can't be trusted.