6 ms·
The Supreme Court positions to be elected positions. None of this is the will of the people.
by echelon 4y ago
The Supreme Court positions to be elected positions.
None of this is the will of the people.
- voisin 4y agoIf I understand correctly, it now devolves to the states where elected people make the laws that apply. So the issue is really what the hell is wrong with the states where the people elected feel empowered to take rights away from half their populace.
- jquery 4y agoThe Fourteenth Amendment guaranteeing equal protection was supposed to end the patchwork system of having to live in the right state to be recognized as a full citizen.
- brycewray 4y ago> So the issue is really what the hell is wrong with the states where the people elected feel empowered to take rights away from half their populace. As I just said in my chosen Mastodon instance: “Ever since today’s Supreme Court decision was leaked, some have said that this oddly might hurt the Republicans in future elections — i.e., they’ll no longer have Roe v. Wade to use against the Democrats. However, this ignores what made today possible: the power of the Christian Right, particularly those whose votes won’t be erased by some currently running for office on promising to make it harder for anti-Rightists to vote (or have their votes count).” Those of you who don’t have a lot of exposure to that culture, and the way it has completely taken over a good chunk of American politics — not to mention one of the two major U.S. political parties — in the last forty-plus years, will find today a shock. And wait ’til you see what else they have in mind.
- PathOfEclipse 4y agoWon't pro-lifers still vote for Republicans in order, to, you know, legislate pro-life laws? All this decision does is place the issue back in the hands of the legislative branch, where it should always have been. Now, it's up to you to vote for what you want. Of the following two forces, the Christian right and the atheist Marxist left, I promise you the latter is far more shocking, dangerous, and self-destructive to America.
- cr__ 4y agoI “promise” it’s the opposite so I guess everything cancels out.
- generj 4y agoRemind me which side recently had a coup?
- PathOfEclipse 4y agoRemind me which side calls for violent overthrow of existing institutions as a foundational belief? Hint: it's not the Christian right. Remind me which side is threatening supreme court justices right now? That looks an awful lot like insurrection: https://news.yahoo.com/protesters-descend-amy-coney-barrett-015809191.html https://news.yahoo.com/protesters-descend-amy-coney-barrett-... Remind me which side is planning to engage in acts of domestic terrorism this very weekend? https://aleteia.org/2022/06/24/department-of-homeland-security-warns-of-night-of-rage-after-roe/ https://aleteia.org/2022/06/24/department-of-homeland-securi... And if you say something like, "these people don't represent us," You can probably guess I'll respond: the small number of men who rioted at the capitol without any actual realistic plan to perform a coup don't represent us either. Leftist activists, unfortunately, are much smarter about what it takes to really overthrow a government, and they've been in it for the long haul for almost a century now.
- generj 4y agoOh I’m sorry did the protestors at Amy Barret’s house break in and smear feces on the walls? No, they just peacefully assembled? Yeah that isn’t an insurrection by any means. People loudly protest all the time, that isn’t the same thing as “domestic terrorism” even if some property gets damaged or relatively few people get hurt. By that definition the civil rights movement would have been domestic terrorism. You know what is domestic terrorism? Firebombing abortion clinics and murdering doctors like some “Christian” right members have done. Frankly the people who stormed the Capital are a sideshow. The real coup was directed from the highest seats of government to prevent the peaceful transition of power, and the mob was merely a minor part of the plan. The real action was in getting Pence out and selecting alternate electors illegally sent.
- mywittyname 4y agoIt's pretty clear that the country is in for near-total Republican control of the federal government for a long time now, maybe indefinitely.
- mistrial9 4y agosome papers claim that 24% of American voters are Catholics-or-similar at this time
- sumedh 4y agoRepublicans have always been against abortion, yet people vote for them, isnt that how democracy works? Major chunk of the US population dont support abortion and keep voting for politicians who support those beliefs.
- nightski 4y agoI wonder how many voted republican in spite of abortion because of Roe vs. Wade. Given what happened today this could hurt republican support because it makes abortion a more direct election issue. I wouldn't necessarily just assume all republicans are pro-life.
- mistrial9 4y agoCatholics and Evangelicals ... have always been against abortion FTFY
- rootusrootus 4y agoThat is extrapolating too far. Many (perhaps most?) voters are single issue voters. Saying that all Republicans support banning abortion is not accurate; some people are Republicans for the tax breaks, etc.
- JasonFruit 4y agoThe Court is a counterbalance against the tyranny of the majority. It's specifically, intentionally undemocratic.
- bandyaboot 4y agoThat worked well before it became just another body of partisan zealots. Now we have the tyranny of whichever partisan zealots have a run a good dumb luck.
- yeahNo88 4y agoTyranny of a religious minority it is then! I’ve taken to defining nihilism as being so dedicated to an ephemera and philosophy, harm to real people is ignored. This decision gives states to impact interstate business. It controls what doctors and patients can discuss. So it goes a good long way to squashing other rights in deference to pudding brains traditions. They chose not with logic but delusion. Figurative identity preferences are being leveraged to directly control human agency. I don’t owe coddling anyone else’s sensibilities. There is no greater good. And I hope this society collapses around us and reminds the majority how meaningless their personal self image is to others.
- jquery 4y ago“Tyranny of the minority” is even worse and that’s what we are seeing now. This Court isn’t upholding minority rights against the State, it’s doing the reverse, taking away rights from minorities (poor women without easy access to travel to another state if necessary). We have six jurists with an extremist legal view called “originalism” which is “let’s imagine I’m a white male in 1800, what would I think about X”. The first Supreme Court decision to mention originalism was in 1994, when Scalia dissented because he thought juveniles should be executed.
- JasonFruit 4y agoThere are people who would dispute whether there's a helpless minority whose rights are being protected by this Court's decision. You can disagree on the resolution, but don't handwave away the almost unique conflict of rights abortion presents between the bodily autonomy of the mother and the right to life of the child. You'll convince nobody by proceeding so dishonestly. I'm not about to dignify such an obvious bad-faith argument as is represented by your parody of originalism.
- influx 4y agoAs I understand it, at any point where the Democrats held the majority of the legislature (including now) they could have passed federal abortion legislation and this would be moot.
- bluejekyll 4y agoThe Senate is split 50/50 with two Dems blocking significant portions of the platform. Saying they have control is misrepresenting the current situation.
- influx 4y agoAnd yet, the Senate just passed firearm legislation with support of some Republicans. But you're right, why try?
- ModernMech 4y agoIt took the murder of almost a dozen children to get Republican Senators to the negotiating table on that bill, and what they passed was a pittance.
- ceejayoz 4y agoThe Democrats don't have a filibuster-proof majority in the Senate. Any such legislation could be immediately undone if Republicans take things back. SCOTUS could strike it down, too.
- lern_too_spel 4y agoThe federal government cannot pass a law that restricts the state and local governments from passing anti-abortion legislation. The only remedy is a constitutional amendment, and there have never been the votes for that.
- kpennell 4y agoI think they would have to kill the filibuster to do that.
- PathOfEclipse 4y ago
- echelon 4y ago> When liberal justices are in charge, they unconstitutionally force their will onto the people. Gay marriage, which I enjoy, is not being "forced" on anyone. A ban will affect green cards, force deportations and family breakups, and ruin the happiness of millions of Americans. My country, which I love, is kicking me in the gut because some people are "uncomfortable".
- PathOfEclipse 4y ago
- echelon 4y ago> Like, are you serious? > Acceptance of gay marriage is being forced on everyone Wow. I'm sorry that my marriage to my loving wife is such a problem for you. Imagine saying that again but replacing gay with Black or interracial.
- nrmitchi 4y ago> Acceptance of gay marriage is being forced on everyone Don't act like the victim because you're no longer allowed to victimize others. Let me try this sentence with some slight adjustments and see where we end up: - Acceptence of Black people is being forced on everyone - Acceptence of women working outside of the home is being forced on everyone - Acceptence of women being allowed to vote is being forced on everyone IF you think you are a victim for having to accept other people there is no helping you.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- PathOfEclipse 4y agoBlacks gaining rights was done primarily via constitutional amendment and later civil rights acts, all passed by the legislative branch. Some believe the courts did in fact go too far during 60s. Women I believe were always allowed to work, so I'm not sure what this example has to do with anything? Women being allowed to vote was done via constitutional amendment, again, by the legislative branch. If you think marriage should be redefined and repurposed so it is not primarily about rearing one's own children, then, by all means, get it redefined, but, do it via legislation, not judicial activism.
- User23 4y agoVirtually nothing any branch of the federal government does is "the will of the people"[1]. But even if our government were a functioning representative republic with strong democratic traditions as it purports to be, the purpose of the courts will still be to act as a check on the will of the people, not just a cheerleader for mob rule. [1] https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/perspectives-on-politics/article/testing-theories-of-american-politics-elites-interest-groups-and-average-citizens/62327F513959D0A304D4893B382B992B https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/perspectives-on-poli...
- lokar 4y agoNo, the will of the people should be expressed as amendments to the constitution. It is a serious flaw is the US system that issues that carry supper majority support in the public for decades have no chance of making it into the constitution.
- theandrewbailey 4y agoThe last amendment was passed 30 years ago, and the one before was 50 years ago. Maybe most of the politicians in charge only pay lip service to an issue, and don't have the will to die on a hill for anything, or leave anything for those who come after them.
- lokar 4y agoI think it's a combination of it being too hard, and politicians "saving" issues, keeping them live, to motivate voters. Many times in the past 30 years the dems could have passed a federal law protecting abortion rights.
- Aunche 4y agoRoe v. Wade wasn't the will of the people. If the will of the people is to make abortion legal, they would vote for politicians that make abortion legal. In Mississippi, they clearly voted for the opposite.
- colinmhayes 4y agoMore than 60% of the country wants roe levels of abortion rights. https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2019/08/29/u-s-public-continues-to-favor-legal-abortion-oppose-overturning-roe-v-wade/ https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2019/08/29/u-s-public-c... It can't happen because 30% of republican primary voters are evangelicals, so every republican will vote against abortion protection, even if most of their constituents want it.
- systemvoltage 4y agoSo wouldn’t a granular authority be better than a nation wide ruling? It would serve people better.
- colinmhayes 4y agoIt's certainly a tricky question. How granular should we get? People's actions in other states still affect everyone in the country. I don't want unwanted children to exist in this country, they require government handouts and become a drag at a much higher rate. Plus kids are smart, they realize they're unwanted and that sucks. Since those people use tax dollars that I pay should I not have a say?
- systemvoltage 4y agoYou’re specifying your opinion (which is reasonable), but that’s orthogonal to the rights of the people that live in that state and vote according to the rights they wish to exercise. If state A wants to ban abortion based on what their constituency wants, isn’t that exactly how democracy works?