4 ms·
> Even today, it wouldn't be unconstitutional to, say, ban redheads or people born on Tuesday from voting. I think the 14th amendment would block any such ban,
by Dylan16807 4y ago
> Even today, it wouldn't be unconstitutional to, say, ban redheads or people born on Tuesday from voting.
I think the 14th amendment would block any such ban, since 15/19/24/26 make it clear that this is a right people have by default.
And that's ignoring how hair color ties into race.
- feet 4y agoIts only illegal if you're explicitly excluding people Oh but if you make laws that just happen to make it harder for black people and Latinos to vote, its just a bad coincidence yea? Awe so sad, wish we could do something about it!
- ceejayoz 4y ago> since 15/19/24/26 make it clear that this is a right people have by default No, they say the opposite. They set up specific conditions you can't use to disqualify for voting. It's a short list. > And that's ignoring how hair color ties into race. SCOTUS is pretty good at that. See the just announced Marietta case; Congress said you can't discriminate against end-stage renal failure patients. An insurer decided they'd get around it by not covering outpatient dialysis - of which 99.5% of patients are end-stage renal failure - and SCOTUS permitted it. Kagan's dissent correctly pointed out it's like banning yarmulkes and claiming you're not discriminating against Jews.
- Dylan16807 4y ago> No, they say the opposite. They set up specific conditions you can't use to disqualify for voting. It's a short list. Those amendments don't directly give maximum protection, but they establish it as a right, which seems to indirectly give pretty good protection.
- ceejayoz 4y agoWe needed the various amendments because it was entirely legal to forbid voting based on race, gender, age, etc. That implies it's still legal to forbid voting based on other reasons not listed.
- feet 4y agoWow it sounds like we shouldn't be forbidding people from voting at all, why the hell would we make specific carve outs. Its absolutely absurd, almost like the people who wrote the legislation wanted it that way
- Dylan16807 4y agoThe 24th and 26th were making adjustments to voting restrictions that were allowed by the 14th. Those rules applied to everyone in theory. The 15th is kind of iffy, but slavery interacts weirdly with citizenship to begin with. And before the 15th there was nothing calling voting a right. As far as the 19th goes, the 14th was in big part scoped to male voters at the time. Overall I think it would be pretty hard to argue the constitutionality of any restriction that isn't applied "evenly".