3 ms·
All this ruling did was strike down the “may issue” requirements for concealed carry in NY. Just like most of CA, a permit to carry came down to “do the police
by refurb 4y ago
All this ruling did was strike down the “may issue” requirements for concealed carry in NY.
Just like most of CA, a permit to carry came down to “do the police like your reason”. Which allowed a few well connected celebrities in NYC to carry and most everyone else was told to “no”. San Jose Sheriff (edit:nope, Santa Clara) was selling carry permits for fat donations to her re-election is another example of where arbitrary decisions were rampant.
The court says screening on objective criteria like risk to public, criminal and mental health background, etc are still allowed.
- Throwawayaerlei 4y ago"All this ruling did was strike down the “may issue” requirements for concealed carry in NY." Presumably, if enforced by the Supreme Court over the next decade plus, it'll apply to NY's new "may issue" for simply owning a gun, as well that in NYC and Massachusetts. No "Shall Issue" law is relevant to bearing an arm if you can't even own any. And to the other 6 slave states in the US: Hawaii and New Jersey which are No Issue at all, California as you noted, Maryland where at least in times past people who could demonstrate a real need got a permit for the duration of that, and Rhode Island which is a mess. And maybe territories like American Samoa.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nradov 4y agoIt was actually Santa Clara County Sheriff Laurie Smith who was selling concealed weapons permits for campaign donations. San Jose is the largest city in that county, and the county seat. That incident showed how pernicious such laws are. The exercise of a fundamental civil right shouldn't depend on political favor. https://www.nbcbayarea.com/investigations/conceal-carry-permits-traded-for-campaign-cash-grand-jury-transcripts/2355412/ https://www.nbcbayarea.com/investigations/conceal-carry-perm...