4 ms·
If that's under a copyleft license, I can't just copy & paste it under my non-copyleft licensed code and call it mine. That's as simple as that.
by bayindirh 4y ago
If that's under a copyleft license, I can't just copy & paste it under my non-copyleft licensed code and call it mine.
That's as simple as that.
- sidlls 4y agoIt can’t be that simple. The function in the GP is not an original idea and is far too simple to merit protection just by slapping a license on it.
- bayindirh 4y agoI don't expect, or support, licensing that small amount of code, and suing everyone to oblivion. The point I'm trying to make is if something is under a copyleft license, you can't copy and paste it verbatim to something non-copyleft. It's what the license says. Also, to be pedantic, the function I'm commenting on is pure maths, and you can't license/patent mathematics. On the other hand, if there's some magic sauce of doing something, let it be 25 lines, what will you say? It's just 25 lines, so you can't license it? To be more pedantic, I actually have an algorithm, which is around 25 lines and does something novel. I've published a paper on it. If I license the reference implementation with AGPLv3+, and you use it and close it, and if I can't go after you, what's the purpose of the license? You can read the paper and try to implement it. It's free in that regard.
- williamcotton 4y agoIt seems rather silly to me that such small innovations would be worthy of legal protections under either a copyright or copyleft license. Isn’t there already precedent in other forms of IP, such as chord progressions in music, sentence length in literature, etc?
- dekhn 4y agoCopyleft isn't really a good example. Let's talk about copyright. That fragment of code is not copyrightable on its own. Too small, too trivial.
- bayindirh 4y agoLet's say I have 25 line function which does something novel and can be published as research (which I did, BTW, no joke), and I opened its reference implementation with AGPLv3+. Is it again too trivial?
- drexlspivey 4y agois 25 lines the limit then? do you count comments? can I codegolf a few lines to get below the limit?
- bayindirh 4y ago> is 25 lines the limit then? I don't know. That's my function's length. > do you count comments? No comments, no blank lines. > can I codegolf a few lines to get below the limit? You bet. But, if you copy my reference implementation, you need to get the license as well. However, the research is on the open. Read it, implement it. That's no problem. But, CoPilot is not reading my paper. It's reproducing my function verbatim, which is under a license which has share-alike mechanics.
- trasz 4y agoNot really. You can't copyright a trivial snippet, same way you can't copyright headers.
- bayindirh 4y agoI've provided a more realistic and logical examples in this thread, please refer to them.