4 ms·
>Hector Martin: If you use Copilot, you are basically playing Russian Roulette that the random mashup of existing, copyrighted, hegerogenously licensed code tha
by coldtea 4y ago
>Hector Martin: If you use Copilot, you are basically playing Russian Roulette that the random mashup of existing, copyrighted, hegerogenously licensed code that you get out of it qualifies as an original work, mostly by chance. Or that nobody will ever sue you otherwise.
Well, that's already the case with Stack Overflow copypasta enterprise code. If anything, use of Copilot would be an improvement...
- moffkalast 4y ago> If anything, use of Copilot would be an improvement What do you mean, Copilot regularly pastes stuff directly from SO. One of those automatic doc generators was able to point me to the exact answer where one of them was from.
- coldtea 4y agoThat it doesn't just "copy and paste" but does more involved "AI" mixing
- moffkalast 4y agoI don't think renaming variables and adjusting spaces holds up in court.
- t0suj4 4y agoThat quote applies to any creative work. Be it code, audio or video.
- coldtea 4y agoHe talks about code, and Copilot works with code, so I'm not sure how it "applies to any". If you mean that if you make a "random mashup of existing, copyrighted, hegerogenously licensed" works of art (audio/video), it also applies that you might be sued for it, then yes. But that's not much of an issue with Copilot if you're using it for enteprise code that's already a mashup of copypaste "existing, copyrighted, hegerogenously licensed" and that you wont release and nobody will see anyway. Whereas audio/video you generally want to release. If you make them for your own consumption, then it's my response that rather applies: since nobody will see it, and you don't release/sell/circulate it, you can go ahead and mix Michael Jackson, Disney and Star Wars material - nothing will happen to you.
- tagyro 4y agoDo people really copy/paste from StackOverflow? I feel this is more a meme, rather than reality. I do check StackOverflow, but never have I took an answer verbatim. I try to see if it's the same problem and what was the approach in deconstructing it, which I find more useful in the long run.
- coldtea 4y ago>Do people really copy/paste from StackOverflow? All the time.
- ldoughty 4y agoI've done it, and I know others that have, but I think it depends on people's definitions of copy/paste. I've certainly copied a sort anonymous function from SO, it was one-liner. Is that copy/paste? or is it only copy/paste if it's X lines? Otherwise I agree, usually I just get hints and go my own way.
- Timwi 4y agoIt depends on what you need. In most cases the code on StackOverflow is not exactly what you need, so you need to understand it in order to adapt it. But if you're looking for a specific well-defined algorithm (MD5, say) then you can just copy & paste it.
- Aeolun 4y agoThis has more to do with the code never being immediately copy-pasteable, not so much my reluctance to copy-paste from SO for licensing reasons.
- concordDance 4y agoAnecdata: Everyone I work with does.
- Flimm 4y agoAccording to Stack Overflow's blog: "One out of every four users who visits a Stack Overflow question copies something within five minutes of hitting the page." https://stackoverflow.blog/2021/12/30/how-often-do-people-actually-copy-and-paste-from-stack-overflow-now-we-know/ https://stackoverflow.blog/2021/12/30/how-often-do-people-ac...
- Hamuko 4y agoIf you post content on Stack Overflow, your contribution is distributed using the CC BY-SA 4.0 license.
- coldtea 4y agoYes, but nobody that copies it cares... (Where nobody is a stand-in term, to mean "less than 1% of those do")