4 ms·
> “A lot of people are like, ‘How, morally, can you do this job?’” How did people's moral compasses get so corrupt that instead of believing stealing is immora
by josephcsible 4y ago
> “A lot of people are like, ‘How, morally, can you do this job?’”
How did people's moral compasses get so corrupt that instead of believing stealing is immoral, they believe that stopping other people from stealing is immoral?
- feet 4y agoCopying my other comment here. There definitely is a moral issue >busting people who are shoplifting items that they either need to survive or items that they can sell to survive to say, pay rent, because our capitalist system has shit on them and left them with no options Property rights should not be above human life. Full stop.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoWhat country are we talking about. In the US nobody needs to steal to survive. The homeless don't even need to steal to survive.
- trs8080 4y agoWhat country are /you/ talking about? In my city, there are homeless people living in tents under every overpass, in every empty lot, parking lots, tennis courts, in broken down cars, etc. You think these people have trust funds?
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoNo, but they have food in the cities they decide to camp in, which are selected due to weather, social services (e.g. calling Seattle as "Freattle"), and lax enforcement of camping rules.
- trs8080 4y agoI see the exact opposite of these claims.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoYou mean, homeless people choose to shelter in cities with bad weather, poor social services, and places where the police aggressively crack down on encampments? I once took a greyhound bus across country. From Mississippi all the way to LA, the bus would stop at each prison, pick people up..they were all going to one place (LA), many of them for the first time. They had nowhere else to go, an open bus ticket, and knowledge that they could survive in LA. These days, Portland and Seattle are increasingly popular places, not just sunny California.
- voldacar 4y agoYou are actually proving their point by noting the plethora of homeless people who are surviving
- micromacrofoot 4y ago"surviving" in slums of filth and crime while likely costing taxpayers more than homing them would (not to mention the high prevalence of mental illness among the homeless) it's just outright idiotic policy to accept the current state of homelessness in many major cities, it's inhumane AND expensive
- voldacar 4y agoI generally agree with the second part of your comment, but it is still true that homeless people survive fine, their quality of life is just usually bad. This is very different from starving to death and needing to shoplift
- micromacrofoot 4y agoIt's a little more indirect than you're presenting, but it is still a fraught situation where people have significantly shorter lifespans. Starvation is unusual, but murder, exposure, overdose, and withdrawal are common. A lot of these people shoplift to keep up a physical addiction that they can not easily or safely move on from.
- josephcsible 4y agoHow can letting people shoplift stop them from getting murdered? Also, I wonder how many people die of overdose who would have survived if they had less money to buy drugs with, versus how many people die of withdrawal who would have survived if they had more money to buy drugs with.
- micromacrofoot 4y agoletting people shoplift doesn’t make it better, but arresting them doesn’t either (often worse)… it’s just the symptom of a greater problem
- jakear 4y agoMore people steal to "survive" that you probably realize. In my experience with lower income college graduates (arts degrees, for instance), the question of where to go to steal food for the day is a common discussion point. Could they survive by going to food banks instead? Probably. Or by taking any other job. But stealing is easier, less "degrading", and more inline with their career goals. That said, the system works. Some people get small personal servings for free; others pay extra for their full family's meal so the store can make up for the breakage. It's that same terraced pricing structure every SASS loves.
- gjs278 4y ago
- cafard 4y agoIs it OK to bust middle-class shoplifters, such as a number of my high school and college acquaintances?
- mikkergp 4y agoNot really, no, why do we think the legal system is the solution to every problem. Besides the fact are they even doing all that good a job at this?
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoHuh? In my city, shoplifters can walk out with 70 inch TVs while the police watch them do it (shop lifting is decriminalized). Everyone who isn't a shoplifter is pretty pissed off about it, I think the police are there to prevent mob justice from happening.
- satsuma 4y agoit's a sad state of affairs when the shoplifters make more than loss prevention.
- Grim-444 4y agoYou're assuming a) that they're shoplifting items needed to survive, and b) that there were no other, legal, sources of the items they needed (food banks, ebt, welfare, etc.) that they could have chosen to make use of instead. Of course the fact that you chose to insert some political anti-capitalist quip nonsense shows that you're not really interested in arguing from good faith and instead mostly just want to further your propaganda.
- voldacar 4y agoIf you think the average shoplifter is like Jean Valjean stealing a loaf of bread, you're deeply out of touch with reality
- karencarits 4y agoOn the other hand: this approach may act to disguise some of the distress that people are actually living under so that society thinks things are less bad than they are - and so less inclined to fix the problem in the "civilized" way: by welfare schemes that guarantees a minimum of dignity and daily needs
- hyuuu 4y agoso if I just do drugs and I take your property to survive, that's okay? if I decide not to work, I can just go to any grocery stores to steal? they need to survive by stealing is a failure of the system that is in place, either education or the social support system. Accommodating for the system's failures by giving up property rights is a defeatist take at best, virtue signaling at worst.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- josephcsible 4y ago> Property rights should not be above human life. Full stop. Sure, if someone's bleeding out on the street, and you grab a tourniquet from a nearby drugstore and run out without paying for it, you should get a pass. But I think cases like that make up approximately 0% of shoplifting. Most of the times people say that shoplifting is necessary to survive, it's not actually true.
- feet 4y agoThat's an extraordinarily short sighted view of the needs of a living human Yes only things that can happen to kill someone within like 60 seconds are what should trump the property rights of the capital owners that have been looting the country and take advantage of the dire straights of the poor working class. Awesome
- tyleo 4y agoI live next to a grocery store with a high rate of shoplifting and I disagree. Grocery stores are not charity. The issue has gotten so bad that freezers containing frozen sea food and ice cream now have locks on them. Problems should be solved with real solutions rather than sacrificing businesses who are not equipped to solve the problem. In other words, if “property rights should not be above human life” then cities should provide for those lives through taxes and meal programs rather than letting random businesses be targets.
- mcphage 4y ago> then cities should provide for those lives through taxes and meal programs rather than letting random businesses be targets. I agree, but America as a nation isn't really big on social safety nets.
- tyleo 4y agoIn my opinion, America not being okay with social safety nets is not equivalent to shop lifting being okay. It seems to me either: * Americans care about shoplifting but not social safety nets and it would mean that society has implicitly decided that some shoplifting folks may not get the support they need. * Americans care about shoplifting and social safety nets enough to force political change. I think what doesn't seem okay to me is to say, "Americans care about shoplifting but not social safety nets... but we are going to make an end run around what society thinks and allow shoplifting as a solution to the social safety net problem".
- reidjs 4y agoPeople and businesses should be allowed to protect their possessions and discourage theft. People who steal should be punished if they’re caught.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoA lot of it is just to buy booze and drugs in cities where the social services are decent (food is easy to get, shelter is available if are somewhat sober), but those two things are not provided, and many see it as a survival need. It is also much more organized now: rackets have a list of stuff to steal that they can then pawn off more easily. That is why LEGOs and laundry detergent are increasingly locked up.
- feet 4y agoYea let's just shit on the people who are at their lowest point in our society and not let them have comforts such as alcohol that the rich enjoy on a daily basis. The existence of people in poverty is absolutely fucking horrible compared to what most experience in the US and other OECD nations
- seanmcdirmid 4y ago> at their lowest point in our society and not let them have comforts such as alcohol that the rich enjoy on a daily basis. A lot of them are in the position they are in now due to drugs and booze. Let's not conflate those homeless for economic reasons with the ones that just burned all their bridges via substance abuse. > absolutely fucking horrible compared to what most experience in the US and other OECD nations I used to live in Switzerland and the cops were pretty rough on the local drunks as well. They got a place to sleep at night, but were spared no quarter on everything else.
- feet 4y ago>A lot of them are in the position they are in now due to drugs and booze Quite simply this is false. Mental health issues generally lead to addiction, in nearly all cases its a dual diagnosis situation with mental health issues and substance abuse which is usually due to the mental health issues. These people are just trying to cope with their daily existence and all the rich people are constantly shitting on them, telling them to pull themselves up by their bootstraps and hiring lobbyists and think-tanks to write legislation to shit on them more. We spend so much money on stupid programs instead of just giving people fking places to live its insane in the US >They got a place to sleep at night That's the big difference. Austria also has great public housing
- IAmWorried 4y agoI'll let the other commenters do the debunking of this extremely stupid point you made - just want to point out that this is so clearly some shitty troll account. 5 months old and all the comments are idiotic crap like this.
- ad404b8a372f2b9 4y agoI dislike that kind of attitude towards the poor, it's infantilizing and strips people of their agency, it's like the modern "noble savage", just some others who are pure of heart and can only be corrupted by the evil influence of the system. I've been dirt poor, I've been homeless, I've been alone in a foreign country with no one to turn to, I've lived in such shit places that my neighbour got shot down with an AK not 100 meters from my doorstep ... in Europe. I still didn't steal. There are systemic issues which keep people down, that doesn't excuse immoral and illegal behaviour. I've known a lot of criminals, they're by and large scumbags, not some modern robinhoods stealing for the sake of their family because of capitalism.
- sosborn 4y agoI think that for some people, a lifetime of watching morally bankrupt corporations post record profits while your wages remains stagnant (made even more painful by inflation) can make it easy to fall in to the "If they can do it why can't I" trap.
- feet 4y agoCorporations have been looting america for decades but everyone gets their panties in a bunch when one of their victims loots one of the corporate stores so they can survive
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoCorporations don't care that much: they can just pass the costs on to us, so we are the ones who are ultimately being looted.
- Nasrudith 4y agoAh the syllogism of thieves perverse projection: I want it. You have it. Therefore stealing it "back" is justified.
- standardUser 4y agoExcessive wealth inequality and weak welfare state.
- satsuma 4y agoshoplifting absolute necessities and life essentials is a morally light grey area. it's stealing, but when the alternative is starvation, there's a bit of leeway. for everything else, it becomes this twisted worldview where shoplifters believe they're owed something by "the system." or because it's walmart/target instead of mom and pop's corner shop, it's like they're the modern day robin hood. the ability of our brains to think themselves into defending its own behavior, as immoral as it may be, is fascinating.
- bowsamic 4y agoThey absolutely should feel they are owed something by the system. America (for example) has built amazing wealth extremely quickly using capitalism, but the distribution is terrible. It is totally fine for the very poor to steal from the very wealthy in a system that makes it extremely difficult, tedious, or tiring for many people to even live a comfortable life legally
- micromacrofoot 4y agoBecause these people aren't stealing a Ferrari for a joyride, they're stealing things like diapers and laundry detergent... sometimes for personal use, but often to resell to other poor people to fuel a drug addiction. These are people who live in poverty. Their lives are so bad that punishment is near meaningless.
- vikingerik 4y agoThey believe that a business having resources that they don't is itself the immorality. They want any equalization of property between the rich and not-rich. There are plenty of comments justifying such stealing even here alongside this one.
- bowsamic 4y agoStealing a piece of inventory from a major corporation is not morally the same as stealing from another person. [Popular company] probably accidentally loses tonnes of [popular product] a week. They have easily enough money to cover that loss, money that isn't being redistributed to the people who feel they should/want to/have to shoplift. So yeah, it's pretty clear to me that for major shops, stopping people from stealing is more immoral than stealing.
- 1986 4y agoI'm not saying shoplifting is moral, but to play devil's advocate here: Walmart, to take one example, is one of the top employers of medicaid and food stamp recipients (https://www.cnbc.com/2020/11/19/walmart-and-mcdonalds-among-top-employers-of-medicaid-and-food-stamp-beneficiaries.html https://www.cnbc.com/2020/11/19/walmart-and-mcdonalds-among-...), essentially forcing the government to make up the gap from the incredibly low wages that they pay their employees and enabling them, in turn, to make more profits. Is that stealing from the government / other taxpayers? If you felt that way, you probably wouldn't see much harm in stealing a couple of bucks worth of stuff back out of Walmart's deep, deep pockets. Anyway, I think that's just one example of why people may feel differently about stealing from an individual versus stealing from a massive, faceless, profitable corporation.
- elicash 4y agoThe full quote: > Although McLeod enjoys his job, he knows it’s one that’s frowned upon by many. “A lot of people see that a homeless person got arrested for stealing a candy bar. They’re hungry, right?” he says. “A lot of people are like, ‘How, morally, can you do this job?’” I still think this is a perfectly moral (and important!) job. And it's the role of our justice system to define what punishments should be when folks are caught. But the context of the quote does change when you see he was talking about a situation where a homeless person takes a single candy bar. The "man steals a loaf of bread to feed his starving family" thing is a pretty classic ethical dilemma.
- josephcsible 4y ago> The "man steals a loaf of bread to feed his starving family" thing is a pretty classic ethical dilemma. But that's also an insignificant fraction of shoplifting cases. Changing our overall policy based on it would be like legalizing running red lights because once in a while people are rushing someone to the hospital.
- elicash 4y agoIt's related to 100% of the quotes I was responding to, however.
- Nasrudith 4y agoIt is also solved in theory via neccesity defense although not universal in practice. The real world is full of wrinkles.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]