7 ms·
I've never used a Khan Academy video but that's out of pure negligence on my part, not skepticism. That said, I have always wondered how effective video is as
by danso 15y ago
I've never used a Khan Academy video but that's out of pure negligence on my part, not skepticism.
That said, I have always wondered how effective video is as a teaching tool for programming? I guess when I think about it, it's the same delivery tool as an in-person lecture, but in some ways, more effective since you can pause, rewind, etc.
See the comments on this article about how to do a Fibonacci recursive example (which seems to be well done; the teacher takes it as slow as humanly possible):
http://www.khanacademy.org/video/recursive-fibonacci-example?playlist=Computer+Science http://www.khanacademy.org/video/recursive-fibonacci-example...
The top comments are from people not knowing the difference between the equality and assignment operators:
"Why do I get an error with a single equal, but not with a double? This is what hung me up for a while."
...I don't know the history of this particular user, it's possible he/she skipped a bunch of the basic lessons and decided to learn recursion...but I wonder if there's a better way to somehow make sure people get the basics down, in an online teaching environment.
- non123 15y agoI remember I first bought a Java book to learn to program when I was around 15-16. I tried for days but couldn't figure out why the first example program wouldn't work, it was because it wasn't System.out.print1n but System.out.println. In the font the code was written in, I couldn't tell. Because of that it wasn't until at least a year later that I didn't try again.
- dexy 15y agoExact same thing happened to me when trying to do my first cs problem set. It was some filename that I was sure had a 1 in it but it was an l. It's almost as if courier tries as hard as possible to make the two look the same.
- jleader 15y agoCourier was intended to look like a traditional typewriter font. For many decades, most typewriters didn't have a key for 1 (one), you were supposed to use the lower-case l (ell) instead. Teletypes did have a one key, probably because they were all-uppercase, so there wasn't a lowercase ell available.
- manish_gill 15y agoHappened to me while learning C++. endl or end1...so confused.
- bialecki 15y agoI've wondered this too. I wonder whether "doing" with some hints like Code Academy or watching videos and then doing is more helpful for programming and then how that applies to other disciplines like writing, math, etc. Seems like eventually we'll find a way to converge where I can do both side by side.
- sjwright 15y agoNo matter how you slice the education process, you're always going to have instruction and practice. It seems Khan Academy has a great model for instruction and Code Academy has a great model for practice; it seems reasonable to posit that a combination of the two would be superior to either one on their own. I would further posit that the blend between the two models of instruction and practice would be something that might be tailored to the learning style of each individual student. Some people learn well by understanding before doing, others by doing first then understanding.
- 2arrs2ells 15y agoCode School (i.e. Rails for Zombies) is a combination of the two! It's not quite what you're hoping for, though (it's always Instruction then Practice, rather than giving you the option to mix it up).
- manish_gill 15y ago>I have always wondered how effective video is as a teaching tool for programming? I guess when I think about it, it's the same delivery tool as an in-person lecture, but in some ways, more effective since you can pause, rewind, etc. It's a lot better than some of in-person lectures I've taken, but maybe that's just me. I've been encouraging my peers to use online videos as a source to learn stuff they have a hard time grasping in class for quite a while. They don't listen, but that's another matter... Anyways, I'm glad Khan Academy is coming out with this. I was freaking out when I couldn't solve some project Eular questions, and pretty much lost all of confidence in my programming abilities for a while. Online tutorials helped me a lot, and I think I've become a better programmer because of that. One small nitpick: I haven't seen the videos yet, but it looks like they'll be in python. I'd rather it be C or C++. From what little I know of the language, it's pretty easy to pick up, and doesn't put pressure on the programmer to take care of details like memory management etc. I know for a fact that many algorithms that I've implementer in C++ that take over 100 LOC, I've found solutions online that have the same algorithm in 20-30 LOC. Used to irritate me a lot. :P
- loup-vaillant 15y agoC or C++ are definitely not a good idea. The beginners' brains will be too occupied with curly brackets and semi-colon. There's also the brain-dead notation for types (see function pointers). The poor souls already have a hard time differentiating assignment and comparison, just because of counter-intuitive notation (compared to high school). As experts, syntax doesn't annoy us. We see past the curly brackets (or the parentheses), because we can quickly see the internal AST that derive from them. Beginners can't. Now, it would be wonderful to teach them a systems language that forces them to manage their own memory. I think a good candidate would be to keep most of the semantics of C, but simplifying its syntax (and find a solution to simplify includes).
- manish_gill 15y agoYeah, but I still advocate the use of C++ over Python. Just because of the fact that I can now appreciate what goes on under the hood instead of groaning that why should I learn it when the "language takes care of it". Many classmates of mine really enjoy Java because of they had learned C++ first. It's a harder learning curve, but I think it's worth it.
- JupiterJazz 15y agoI've had a lot of success with the tutorials at thenewboston.com The instructor there explains everything in a very ELI5 (explain like im 5) manner and tone and it works very well for beginners like me.
- capnrefsmmat 15y ago> That said, I have always wondered how effective video is as a teaching tool for programming? I guess when I think about it, it's the same delivery tool as an in-person lecture, but in some ways, more effective since you can pause, rewind, etc. I've dug up a lot of papers on effectiveness of teaching strategies in physics in particular (since I'm a physics student), and it seems in physics that your time spent working practice problems and making predictions about experiments is more important than actual lectures. An example: http://www.sciencemag.org/content/332/6031/862.abstract http://www.sciencemag.org/content/332/6031/862.abstract If anything, I think the Khan Academy is best suited for a mixed approach where students watch lecture videos, then attend a problem session or help session to work examples, get help on exercises, and so on. The Khan Academy's exercise framework is an important step in this direction, and I hope they continue to improve it.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- llimllib 15y ago> The Khan Academy's exercise framework is an important step in this direction, and I hope they continue to improve it. They certainly are: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L_EU6w8iIGQ&feature=channel_video_title http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L_EU6w8iIGQ&feature=chann... If you want to help, it's on github: https://github.com/Khan/khan-exercises/ https://github.com/Khan/khan-exercises/ It's super easy to write new exercises.
- jcampbell1 15y agoKahn makes a big mistake in pronouncing the assignment operator as "equals" in the first video. The assignment operator should be pronounced as "gets".
- llimllib 15y agoWhen I read it in my head, I read it as "let". As in "x = 5" -> "let x be 5".
- pjscott 15y agoIn my head, I reserve the word "let" for immutable bindings. Or at least local bindings that people probably aren't going to mutate. I read it as "x equals five". So, between three of us, we saw that simple line of code in three different ways. I wonder what other people see in more complicated code.
- jcampbell1 15y agoThe point is that if you pronounce if(x=5) and if(x==5) both as "if x equals 5", then you are making things confusing for students. You as the teacher are saying the exact same words, but mean two completely different things. Kahn made this mistake and there are student comments showing the confusion. Not correctly understanding assignment is one of the biggest failure points for beginners learning programming. The '=' operator has little relation to '=' in any form the students have encountered before. It means something like "evaluate the shit on the right hand side, and store it in a variable with the name on the left hand side". That meaning is not really even close to the meaning of the english word "equals". You can personally call it whatever you want, but if you want to be a good teacher to beginning programmers, then you don't call both = and == the same thing. "x gets 5", "set x to 5" or "x is now 5" are all acceptable, but "x equals 5" is not acceptable for teaching purposes.
- loup-vaillant 15y agoI note that the biggest mistake probably comes from C itself. If only it had chosen for assignment a syntax such as : x <- 5; It would be more clear that "the shit on the right" goes to that garbage on the left. But no, they had to use the `=` sign, as if saving one character where more important than not changing the meaning of one of the most used sign of all mathematics. And now nearly all popular language is making the same damn mistake.
- mwidarto 15y agoI found video to be every effective teaching tool for programming. I don't know why, but I can read something 10 times and didn't get it but If I see video covering the same material it clicks. The only thing I don't like about video is that I can't do search for it. Sometime they show you a piece of code and you don't remember exactly where, you can't easily go to that part of the video.
- moreorless 15y agoVideo search is coming along quite nicely. In one of my previous jobs, we employed Everyzing and the results were pretty good.
- hsshah 15y agoGood point. That's why I am big fan of teaching "Computational Thinking" before any specific programming language. Personally used Scratch (from MIT) to teach my nephews and niece. It worked well to cement their core concepts. http://scratch.mit.edu/ http://scratch.mit.edu/ http://info.scratch.mit.edu/sites/infoscratch.media.mit.edu/files/file/ScratchProgrammingConcepts-v14.pdf http://info.scratch.mit.edu/sites/infoscratch.media.mit.edu/...
- pbhjpbhj 15y agoDo you know of a basic introductory course using Scratch so I don't have to ad-hoc it so much? We're supposed to be building a game but I need something, like KhanAcademy, that I can give my primary-aged son space to explore by himself without me hovering over him.
- wiredfool 15y agoI'm pretty much winging it with the Middle Schoolers. Normally I throw a quick demo up on the big screen, talk about it for a couple of minutes pointing out what it does that they were struggling with in the last class. Then they work on doing something interesting while I answer questions and ask "What happens if...".
- hsshah 15y agoIn case you are interested, there is a curriculum that ScratchEd team has developed. http://scratched.media.mit.edu/resources/scratch-curriculum-guide-overview-august-2011-webinar http://scratched.media.mit.edu/resources/scratch-curriculum-... Personally, I also "wing it". I encourage them to come up with ideas for games, animations that implicitly requires them to cover all aspects of "computational thinking". It's implicitly because I don't want them to think of this as too academic; let them have fun while learning (for a change!)
- wiredfool 15y agoLooks interesting -- they posted that a week or two after I was searching. We're heavily into animations and games right now, including one where the student is building up space invaders, one complication at a time.